Do you still care about Brexit?
#21
(05-06-2021, 12:36 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(05-06-2021, 11:12 AM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote:
(05-06-2021, 10:54 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: It seems to me that the only people still wound up by Brexit are ardent Remainers who will never find anything else in their life to be so enthralled about.

Edited for you

I like the selective quoting. That I specifically wrote I wouldn't  campaign to re join the EU was missed. Presumably because it undermined the point you wanted to make.

Hardly selective. I changed one word. And you are the one banging on about it. Remainers remind me of Villa fans and 1982.
Reply
#22
(05-06-2021, 01:20 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(05-06-2021, 01:12 PM)Bortolazzi's Barnet Wrote: Why is it only remainers who try to tell leavers that we didn't vote to leave the Single Market, never any leaver saying, "Hang on, I didn't vote for that"?

You mean all of the leave voters knew what they were voting for, fucking hell priceless. For a leaver to say that it would be an admission that they didn't know what they voted for and that's about as likely as us staying up this year.

Do you think the fishermen voted to be in their current position - I will guarantee they are currently saying "Hang on, I didn't vote for that".

Here you go again with your foul-mouth, inferring and arguing a point I never made for the second time today. I'll break it down:

1. I never said that leavers knew everything they voted for. No-one is a clairvoyant
2. I said that we voted to leave the Single Market
3. I said that it is never any leaver who says, "I didn't vote for that," i.e. leaving the Single Market, only remainers who tell us that we didn't
Reply
#23
(05-06-2021, 01:23 PM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote:
(05-06-2021, 12:36 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(05-06-2021, 11:12 AM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote:
(05-06-2021, 10:54 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: It seems to me that the only people still wound up by Brexit are ardent Remainers who will never find anything else in their life to be so enthralled about.

Edited for you

I like the selective quoting. That I specifically wrote I wouldn't  campaign to re join the EU was missed. Presumably because it undermined the point you wanted to make.

Hardly selective. I changed one word. And you are the one banging on about it. Remainers remind me of Villa fans and 1982.

Strangely Leavers remind me of Villa fans deluded that they have actually won anything that benefits them now.

(05-06-2021, 01:28 PM)Bortolazzi's Barnet Wrote:
(05-06-2021, 01:20 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(05-06-2021, 01:12 PM)Bortolazzi's Barnet Wrote: Why is it only remainers who try to tell leavers that we didn't vote to leave the Single Market, never any leaver saying, "Hang on, I didn't vote for that"?

You mean all of the leave voters knew what they were voting for, fucking hell priceless. For a leaver to say that it would be an admission that they didn't know what they voted for and that's about as likely as us staying up this year.

Do you think the fishermen voted to be in their current position - I will guarantee they are currently saying "Hang on, I didn't vote for that".

Here you go again with your foul-mouth, inferring and arguing a point I never made for the second time today. I'll break it down:

1. I never said that leavers knew everything they voted for. No-one is a clairvoyant
2. I said that we voted to leave the Single Market
3. I said that it is never any leaver who says, "I didn't vote for that," i.e. leaving the Single Market, only remainers who tell us that we didn't

So you agree it would have been a good idea to have voted for something that they knew about as no one is a clairvoyant. And they voted to leave the EU not the single market, a large number of them wouldn't know the difference, we agree on that. And you agree Leavers wouldn't admit knot knowing what they voted for.

Glad we agree mate.
Reply
#24
I'm alright with it all. Bumps along the road, but worth it to be out from my perspective. Others will disagree which is what makes democracy what it is. We'll never return.
Reply
#25
I don't recall saying you didn't want to leave the single market, I said that it wasn't a vote to leave the single market. My mum voted to leave and she didn't want to leave the single market, as an anecdote, and I know she wasn't alone.

The purpose of the referendum was to establish whether we should leave the EU or not, it wasn't about the specifics of how we go about that nor that process we follow. The single market in of itself is not exclusive of EU membership, it's perfectly possible to leave the EU and remain within the single market and it would have satisfied both the spirit and the word of the referendum. Membership of the EU involves a significantly deeper integration (such as membership of Euratom, which I didn't bring up specifically as it only applies to EU members). And, as shown by the purpose of membership of the EFTA nations, it is not in any way a transitional arrangement for EU membership. Norway, Switzerland, Iceland and Lichtenstein do not why to join the EU, non-EU members like Ukraine have a stronger desire to join the EU and have a closer relationship with the European Commission than the EFTA nations do.

The referendum was only and solely to do with whether the UK should leave the EU, not the specifics. When you start introducing specifics then you get paradoxes as was the case with the Irish border which to resolve it the government had to retract from a campaign promise of the Leave campaign.

Much as it is with those who claim that the AV referendum was an endorsement of FPTP, to extrapolate the EU referendum to aspects without it's remit is fundamentally dishonest and the fact that we've allowed this to happen has allowed the UK to fall into the trap of the tyranny of the majority, one of the fundamental reasons we have a representative democracy instead of a direct democracy in the first place.

The ultimate fact of the matter is that after the vote any competent government would have either broken down the result into options and reached a compromise position with the electorate, which they didn't. How the hell does leaving Europol, EASA and Erasmus benefit anyone? Why would anyone be pissed off at our continued participation? What practical benefits are there to the UK leaving the single market when there's significant scope within EEA membership to address the key concerns people had? That's what's pissed me off, we've left stuff for no reason other than the sake of it.

That's the biggest issue with referenda and why any country that uses them (Ireland, Switzerland, New Zealand) has extreme restrictions on them that the EU referendum wouldn't have qualified for, you risk setting up an undefined position on a loose premise which fucks shit up.
Reply
#26
(05-06-2021, 10:54 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: It seems to me that the only people still wound up by Brexit are ardent Brexiteers who will never find anything else in their life to be so enthralled about.

My reasons for voting remain were not to do with the economy, and i am still of the view it is a mistake. But it is done and we need to get on and make the best of it. I won't be campaigning to re join, i think that would be hugely disrespectful to those who won the campaign, but even more to the remaining members of the EU who don't constantly need to be concerning themselves with a country who cannot make their mind up on this issue.
This has been written a few times on here now.


Of the last 20 pages of threads on the political board, since early November 2019, there have been:
18 threads with an Anti-Brexit slant
  7 threads of a pro-Brexit stance
  2 threads which were, more or less, neutral.
(This does not include other post which have had mention of Brexit as an excuse for certain events or situations raised in said thread.)

So, of the 25 threads which plumped for either side, that means:
 72% were from the laid back, accepting, democracy loving Remainer types who now just want to get on with things.
28% from those gnarling, angry, selfish, racist Brexit types who aren’t satisfied with attaining what they hoped for and are “still wound up”.   

That’s over two and a half times as many posts  droning on  about ‘how bad’  Brexit is.  I think that small snap shot is sufficient to show which group is still ‘enthralled’ by Brexit.
(I’m willing to gamble that the anti-percentage would be far higher the further back we go.)

I could have sworn the country had "made their mind up" on the issue. What was the referendum and withdrawal agreement about then?
Reply
#27
(05-06-2021, 01:39 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: you risk setting up an undefined position on a loose premise which fucks shit up.

If the Establishment ever considered for one moment that they'd lose the EU Referendum it would never have happened.

I am delighted that I was part of the greatest peoples' democratic disruption this country has seen since 1945.
Reply
#28
(05-06-2021, 01:34 PM)Protheroe Wrote: I'm alright with it all. Bumps along the road, but worth it to be out from my perspective. Others will disagree which is what makes democracy what it is. We'll never return.

I am about to have my first client go under purely down to Brexit.  A bright start for the business even during Covid and less than 12 months later snuffed out by the extra admin and errors causing an insurmountable logistical/tax problem on product being sourced from the Netherlands.  I had tried to get them to switch to a UK supplier, foreseeing the potential problems but no UK supplier was making the same "base" product required.  I cannot begin to convey the hurt to, and bitterness of, these young people.  Still, just collateral damage in the Great Project.

As I have said, I have only one client who I know is pro- Brexit.  The others are making the best of a bad job but for some it is too much.  The train has only just left the station, as well....

(05-06-2021, 01:44 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(05-06-2021, 01:39 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: you risk setting up an undefined position on a loose premise which fucks shit up.

If the Establishment ever considered for one moment that they'd lose the EU Referendum it would never have happened.

I am delighted that I was part of the greatest peoples' democratic disruption this country has seen since 1945.

Great victory for the plutocrat elite.  Congrats!
Reply
#29
baggy1 Wrote:
Cunninghamismagic Wrote:
Shabby Russian Wrote:It seems to me that the only people still wound up by Brexit are ardent Remainers who will never find anything else in their life to be so enthralled about.

Edited for you

Strangely it really is the opposite, it is a fuck up and will get worse over time but the drip drip of it won't be noticed and covid is masking the main problems. To paraphrase, "you won, get over it"

Bortolazzi's Barnet Wrote:Here we go. So easy to dismantle these additional remain lies.

1. Easiest trade deal ih history. Firstly, this was after the referendum on Summer 2017 so how could it have influenced the referendum? Fox actually said that whilet the deal SHOULD be the easiest in history, the reality may well be different: https://www.theguardian.com/politics/201...an-history

2. Control our borders? Well, we could only refuse entry to EU nationals if they posed an imminent risk to public health, public security or public morals, in accordance with Art 27 of Dir 2004/38. Note that Art 27(2) stipulates that a criminal record is not such a reason. Also note the restrictions on expulsion in Art 28, as well. https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/...32004L0038

Not really control, that, is it mate?

3. As for 'forms', again, this was post-referendum so had no effect on the result. I also don't think it was a lie, more a naively optimitsic prediction that should never have been made

4. The border in the Irish Sea was again post-referendum and is there at the insistence of the EU. I shiuld also remind you that Barnier said openly that the issue of Ireland should be leveraged and exploited

5. No freedom of movement - I have no idea what this is supposed to refer to

Be great to see you condemn the remain lies though instead of whataboutery.

Now,

So basically you are saying that there was no actual plan just a vague idea of leaving the EU which can't be shown to be a lie because there was no detail before the referendum. You forget that once we realised all the issues post referendum and there was an opportunity to articulate that to the electorate for their informed decision the Brexiteers moved heaven and hell to make sure that didn't happen.

No whataboutery there "mate"

Remember that the hard line Brexit nutters knew that they could never write down in detail what the post Brexit world might like - the magical 'king's suite of clothes' and 'sunlight uplands' would fall apart just as they have now reality begins to bite. It was all about ignoring facts and experts and believing more!
No Brexit head case had yet given me a tangible list of how it will make my and my families life better ?

We were thinking of maybe retiring to the sunny Med in a few year's time but Brexit has all but put paid to that with all the additional loopholes and costs such as medical care to consider.

In answer to the original question; Yes I really do still care for what individuals have done to this country including giving us this wretched one dimensional government and will keep trying to call out the lies and greed of the main players as they try to back off into the distance.
The likes of Farage, Johnson, Fox, Gove, Leadsom, Hoey, Jenkin, Redwood, Francios, Rees Mogg, Dacre, Hard Man Baker and the ERG, Davis, Banks, Bridgen, Jim Radcliffe. Dyson, the Weatherspoons buffoon  all deserve to be held responsible for the rest of their lives and not be allowed to get away with all the gas lighting and pain they will cause going forward. They need to be monitored by the nation to see if they go against what that advocated (like Rees Moggs' group and Dyson setting up more and more outside the UK post Brexit) or they profit from financial beneficiaries of loose regulation and employee rights.
Never let them off the hook until to show us how it's benefitted the masses...
Reply
#30
(05-06-2021, 01:46 PM)hudds Wrote: The train has only just left the station, as well....

I can sympathise, my business went under in 2009 due to factors beyond my control.

I didn't and still don't blame Ben Bernanke and Gordon Brown for that.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: