Big Sam (Match on Match)
#11
(05-05-2021, 09:34 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(05-05-2021, 08:14 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: This 1 year ahead of an has to stop. He had a max of 2 years, we wanted it ASAP. He also almost blew it with the worst run of form since Pardew.

After Covid, it was that year or never.

This 2 seasons stuff is nonsense, Moore was said to have been given 2 seasons as well, didn't even get a full season.

Truth is with Bilic, is he got of to a great start, over 50 points and only 1 defeat in the first half of a season is going some, but sadly we didn't build on that start, in fact we went backwards.

The great unanswered question of Bilic’s reign is what the fuck happened during lockdown?

Unstoppable up until Christmas. Big wobble in January, picked up again in February (5 wins out of 6 or something like that) and had evened out again going into March... Then lockdown happened and everything just went to shit.
Reply
#12
(05-05-2021, 09:40 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(05-05-2021, 09:34 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(05-05-2021, 08:14 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: This 1 year ahead of an has to stop. He had a max of 2 years, we wanted it ASAP. He also almost blew it with the worst run of form since Pardew.

After Covid, it was that year or never.

This 2 seasons stuff is nonsense, Moore was said to have been given 2 seasons as well, didn't even get a full season.

Truth is with Bilic, is he got of to a great start, over 50 points and only 1 defeat in the first half of a season is going some, but sadly we didn't build on that start, in fact we went backwards.

The great unanswered question of Bilic’s reign is what the fuck happened during lockdown?

Unstoppable up until Christmas. Big wobble in January, picked up again in February (5 wins out of 6 or something like that) and had evened out again going into March... Then lockdown happened and everything just went to shit.

Well if we had bothered to ask this question, the very day we were promoted, we might have had a better chance this season of avoiding relegation this season, although in fairness it was always going to be a difficult goal to achieve.
Reply
#13
I like the commentary and caveats. Spurs away being a match we should have targeted. arf.

We all know that BFS didn't have a great start, with Bilic's players, no pre-season and very little time on the training ground he only worked on a par with St Slaven. Since bringing a few players in and having more time with the squad he's turned us into a mid-table side, except the damage was already done.

He's not the Messiah and yet neither is he a very naughty boy. He's the best fit for right now with the owners we have and we'd better hope that Lai would rather us be a PL club to try and sell rather than just sell of what he can and take the money and run.
Trump is a Cunt
Reply
#14
Bilic was running a boys club. He got lucky with some decent players hitting a purple patch at the same time and we were basically promoted at Christmas. As WHU fans predicted once the slide started he was absolutely clueless in halting it, I would have sacked him last July.

We were unfit, unable to defend a set piece, made dreadful signings at Bilic's behest and wasted half a season in what the OP has said is the weakest bottom eight there's been for years in the PL.

The first few weeks under Allardyce with the Bilic team were dreadful. Since he's had chance to bring some of his own players and spend some time on the training ground we've been far from the worst team in the league. If we'd have appointed Allardyce last August, we wouldn't be in the position we are in now.
Reply
#15
(05-05-2021, 08:12 AM)Madness Wrote: Since his reign & the myth that we are suddenly a decent side and its all Slav's fault


This is a weak Premier League (Bottom 8 certainly) and we have missed the opportunity to close the gap even with our signings, Damage was done in the first few weeks. Big Sam has ultimately failed as manager and while he will be staying we have rewarded failure while some of you were delighted at Slav was sacked for achieving promotion 1 year ahead of the plan. 

We will learn as fans
Toto Wolfe takes over at Mercedes F1 in 2013. Realises the drivers aren’t good enough, the aerodynamics are not as good as they could be and the engines are not powerful enough. He had to work with what he had then. They did not win the championship that year because the whole team was not good enough. But he immediately started to recruit better technicians and engineers and for the following season he changed a driver. Result, seven world titles.

Until the end of the mid-season window Allardyce had to work with the players he had. He was not responsible for their technical abilities, their fitness or, more importantly, their mentality. He cannot wave a magic wand and get players to perform above their technical abilities. Fitness cannot be improved overnight. And, again, most importantly, he can’t instantaneously change their mindset. If the players were unwilling to accept changes, unable to grasp tactical alterations, unable to increase their understanding of their positional role, were going to sulk at greater discipline and the requirement of a greater work ethic, I don’t think the majority of the blame for the results of his first month or two can be laid at his feet. The lack of ‘bounce’ is mainly, in my opinion, the responsibility of the players and as of a result of the previous coaching staff. We have "rewarded failure" by some of the players for nearly a season and a half.
Reply
#16
(05-05-2021, 08:12 AM)Madness Wrote: Since his reign & the myth that we are suddenly a decent side and its all Slav's fault


Aston Villa (L 0-3)- Poor performance and was a massive let down after the draw at Man City
Liverpool (D 1-1)- A good performance against a side who declined after this, well worked point
Leeds (L 0-5)- Absolutely shambolic, worst performance in the PL. But Big Sam escapes criticism from many
Arsenal (L 0-4)- Dreadful, Arsenal played well but alarm bells are ringing 
Wolves (W 3-2)- Wolves were their for the taking and we put in a fantastic performance. 2nd best of the season
West Ham (L 1-2)- Looked better and you can argue we could have come away with a draw
Man City (L 0-5)- Man City were too good, We deserve to lose by this much....moving on 
Fulham (D 2-2)- 2 points dropped, Hangover from Man City but 2nd half we were the better side and should have won 
Sheff United (L 1-2)- Deserved to lose, New Players begin to come in but its too late the rot set in with 4 weeks of madness from Big Sam
Tottenham (L 0-2)- 2 offside goals. But Spurs dominated and this was a match we could have targeted
Man United (D 1-1)- Played really well, Again 2 points dropped
Burnley (D 0-0)- We was very good even with 10 men, Again 2 points dropped
Brighton (W 1-0)- On balance we didn't deserve to win, but the last few performances perhaps told us we deserved a win from somewhere
Everton (L 1-0)- VAR stopped us from getting a draw, which i didn't think we deserved 
Newcastle (D 0-0)- Defensive tactics against an awful side, clearly 2 points dropped
Crystal Palace (L 0-1)- Awful simply Awful. No Desire and poor tactics
Chelsea (W 5-2)- Simply awesome performance, But it took Ivanovic to get injured before Big Sam realised that Robinson could do some damage
Southampton (W 3-0)- Southampton didn't turn up and we were very good, finished well- superb
Leicester (L 0-3)- Leicester for 20 mins were excellent and it was enough. But it was an alarming performance
Aston Villa (D 2-2)- We played ok, But Villa deserved something out the game i felt 
Wolves (D 1-1)- Wolves had key players out but we didn't capitalise on this 



Conclusion- We have improved since signing the loanees but we have dropped points against Burnley, Man United, Fulham and Newcastle & Didn't turn up against Crystal Palace 

This is a weak Premier League (Bottom 8 certainly) and we have missed the opportunity to close the gap even with our signings, Damage was done in the first few weeks. Big Sam has ultimately failed as manager and while he will be staying we have rewarded failure while some of you were delighted at Slav was sacked for achieving promotion 1 year ahead of the plan. 

We will learn as fans

What is quite clear is that before you composed your message you had already convinced yourself that it would one to demonise Sam with and mitigate the damage done by Bilic over the last 12 months of his managership. So with that mindset you have found reasons to fit your agenda.
Reply
#17
(05-05-2021, 10:39 AM)Mayo Wrote: Not sure which of the similar threads to reply to!

Bilic was tasked with bringing us up and he succeeded - doesn't really matter to me if the best work was early or late in the season - it was an odd season. He was then tasked with keeping us in the prem and got sacked when the bosses thought this looked unlikely - I would have liked him to have the season myself, but that's by the by - so a failure there.

The decision to sack was to bring someone in to keep us up who said they could - Allardyce - and the immediate impact was a devastating run of awful performances which probably sealed our fate the other way. It has since improved, but Allardyce has had time and signings and there were not enough good performances to keep us up, bar a late miracle. That is his failure.

Ultimately the bosses above are responsible for budgets and managerial appointments and to what degree on signings I am never sure, so both successes and failures are theirs too.
I am not for continually changing managers, certainly not without giving them a good run at it, so I would not be calling for Allardyce to go, but to lay all the blame on his predecessor  and ignore the success of his predecessor is wrong for me.

Disappointed how the season started under Bilic but more so with the failure afterwards having changed to secure survival and then endure some of the performances trotted out. Are we fitter now? We always look fitter when we win - but we are still relegated and have not won enough. It may be good if Allardyce stays or not, I don't know, but he does not merit praise for our relegation. Bilic no doubt deserves some of the stick but must get credit for promotion too.

My onions - which matter not a jot of course.

Your onions are reasonable and this is what the cut and thrust of this place is about.

We've had a season where the games have come thicker and faster than ever and the sheer number of fixtures before Allardyce was able to get his grip on it might be a contributing factor too.

I don't think Allardyce deserves great back slaps for what he's done as he's leading us to relegation, but he has improved us and turned around a downward spiral since the start of 2020.

I think most on here are measured enough to weigh up the pros and cons, but the likes of Madness's post , we are replying to, is pure one eyed subjective ranting based on an agenda against Allardyce. It's not that many are even big fans of Allardyce, they just neutrally accept what has happened of late.
Reply
#18
I have only liked two managers and they were GM and Hodgson not that it should matter whether you like a manager or not. It’s about who is the best fit for the circumstances and at the moment Allardyce is the best fit.
Reply
#19
Don't think there is really need for blame? Club with limited budget gets relegated!! is no headline.

Slav did his bit in getting us promoted. We had a really fanrastic half a season and he attracted some good players to the club. Good times were had! However the run in was poor and it was evident he was struggling to turn things around even then, but hope springs eternal. Did he look like he would put together a competitive PL side? No, is the simple answer. Unlucky maybe, but at times we were desperate and the signings of Grant, Krov and Ivanovic range from poor to disastrous.....he does however leave ud with Pereira.

Sam has failed to keep us in the PL, so has failed in his primary goal. However, he addressed weaknesses in the team all the fans were aware of and has now shaped a competitive PL team, without spending a penny in transfer fees, that still includes a defensive unit of Townsend, Bartley, Semi/O'shea and Furlong!! But no longer looks like it might concede at will.

Slav got us up, and although Sam has taken us down it's with a confidence that if he stays not only should we be in the mix for promotion but also have a much better chance of staying up next time.

I was a huge fan of Slav, a charismatic and likeable manager and although I didn't like or want Sam I had respect for his record of over achieving in the PL with limited resources. Nothing has really changed.
Reply
#20
I'm not a fan of Bilic. He's a smoke and mirrors manager with no substance.

I like managers to be strong coaches, to have a strong understanding of how to improve and make the most of the players you have and to spot where the squad needs new blood.

Irvine was a better manager in my mind than Bilic, I was very critical of him, but Dawson and Berahino both took massive steps under his coaching.

My favourite managers, like Derek are Roy and Megson. I wish the Steve Clarke and Ashworth period could have lasted longer, that was as close to 'the next level' as we'll ever get.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: