Posts: 17,072
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(05-04-2021, 10:19 AM)Mayo Wrote: Allardyce had plenty of time - the squad was good enough to come up, just - it needed more and Allardyce got more but has failed.
It is his relegation - we were not down yet under Bilic and it is hard to imagine we would have had the appalling run under him that we had after Sam took over. It is foolish to ignore this and suggests an agenda. I would have liked to see Bilic have more time after the 1-1 at City and I'd give Sam more time now - we change horses too quickly - but some of the performances under Sam give cause for concern at least.
No it doesn't it suggests the reality of the situation. If the squad isn't good enough it's not good enough it's as simple as that. It is now competing due to the additional players in the squad and as Slice pointed out on another thread the stats point to a marked improvement that would see us safe if those players and current manager were in place at the start of the season.
Posts: 17,072
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(05-04-2021, 10:32 AM)Mayo Wrote: (05-04-2021, 10:25 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (05-04-2021, 10:19 AM)Mayo Wrote: Allardyce had plenty of time - the squad was good enough to come up, just - it needed more and Allardyce got more but has failed.
It is his relegation - we were not down yet under Bilic and it is hard to imagine we would have had the appalling run under him that we had after Sam took over. It is foolish to ignore this and suggests an agenda. I would have liked to see Bilic have more time after the 1-1 at City and I'd give Sam more time now - we change horses too quickly - but some of the performances under Sam give cause for concern at least.
No it doesn't it suggests the reality of the situation. If the squad isn't good enough it's not good enough it's as simple as that. It is now competing due to the additional players in the squad and as Slice pointed out on another thread the stats point to a marked improvement that would see us safe if those players and current manager were in place at the start of the season.
I don't believe we were doomed from the off but we were always going to struggle, as any promoted team does - did Sam say on taking the gig that he could not keep us up because we were not good enough? No - we looked for a new manager bounce and got an appalling slump - it is foolish to ignore this - we may have been better to keep Bilic and get more players for him in January instead of for Sam - Sam failed to keep us up, which was the reason for giving him the appointment - you find it easy to point out Bilic shortcomings but really cannot see any in Sam? I am not for changing horses again but I see his shortcomings alright and won't ignore the reality of his relegation
I didn't criticise Bilic at the start of the season because the squad wasn't good enough and under the daft DoF system it's very difficult to ascertain who was ultimately responsible for that if indeed anyone was given our budget. Sam was imo either desperate to get back in the game or really did underestimate the size of the job he had inherited. Ill judged perhaps but ultimately responsible for our relegation? No.
Posts: 10,272
Threads: 694
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
(05-04-2021, 10:32 AM)Mayo Wrote: (05-04-2021, 10:25 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (05-04-2021, 10:19 AM)Mayo Wrote: Allardyce had plenty of time - the squad was good enough to come up, just - it needed more and Allardyce got more but has failed.
It is his relegation - we were not down yet under Bilic and it is hard to imagine we would have had the appalling run under him that we had after Sam took over. It is foolish to ignore this and suggests an agenda. I would have liked to see Bilic have more time after the 1-1 at City and I'd give Sam more time now - we change horses too quickly - but some of the performances under Sam give cause for concern at least.
No it doesn't it suggests the reality of the situation. If the squad isn't good enough it's not good enough it's as simple as that. It is now competing due to the additional players in the squad and as Slice pointed out on another thread the stats point to a marked improvement that would see us safe if those players and current manager were in place at the start of the season.
I don't believe we were doomed from the off but we were always going to struggle, as any promoted team does - did Sam say on taking the gig that he could not keep us up because we were not good enough? No - we looked for a new manager bounce and got an appalling slump - it is foolish to ignore this - we may have been better to keep Bilic and get more players for him in January instead of for Sam - Sam failed to keep us up, which was the reason for giving him the appointment - you find it easy to point out Bilic shortcomings but really cannot see any in Sam? I am not for changing horses again but I see his shortcomings alright and won't ignore the reality of his relegation
I think you're being very harsh Mayo and being a black and white in apportioning blame. I started the original post saying I'm no fan of Allardyce- I was a fan of Bilic.
Under Bilic we were very poor though. We won one game only and even then we didn't deserve to. Sheff U were proper unfortunate.
Some games were as inept as some of those horror games under Allardyce, but we didn't get pummelled. Southampton away and Leicester home we looked two leagues below them. That just jumps to mind.
It's all hypothetical, but I think most would say given a whole season, and even the half he has had, plus a little more we would have stayed up under Allardyce.
Posts: 974
Threads: 11
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
2
05-04-2021, 11:05 AM
(This post was last modified: 05-04-2021, 11:13 AM by Lillwall's left foot.)
Allardyce has shown he can put together a competitive PL team without spending. A season with the current team would have by no means guaranteed a mid table finish but I have no doubt it would have been in the mix for survival. He has a defensive mindset but this isn't aligned to hoofball, and at the right times the players do try and play through the pitch.
Bottom line is that NONE of the players the management team must have hoped might step up have. Jake, Romaine, Grant, Grady (what we've seen of him) Semi, Gallacher (harsh?) and Furlong have all looked like championship players. Ivanovic was a terrible signing. The only players to really emerge with credit for me are those we probably didn't expect much of in Townsend, SJ, Bartley and even a re-emergent Phillips (I think I've included him as I thought he was finished). Starting a season more in hope than expectation is not a solid strategy!
Would Slav have made the changes in the window that Sam made? Would he have bombed out his captain and big signings? We don't know. But I very much doubt that Sam would have allowed a team to go into the season with a midfield and defensive unit so unfit for purpose. That is again just conjecture but we know it was the focus of his recruitment and he DID bomb out those players.
I tend to find that regardless of tenure most managers leave something positive behind. In Slavs case he left behind a desperately needed promotion and a genuinely PL quality player in Pereira. If Sam does go he will leave behind a blueprint of how to compete at this level following promotion. Strikes me that if it seems a good idea to follow his blueprint then we might as well keep on the man himself to have a go....but only if he wants it enough and only if we agree to back him to his expectations.
Posts: 5,201
Threads: 197
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
14
(05-04-2021, 10:24 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: If true that Bilic was offered Yokuslu and Diagne in the summer and went after Krovinovic and Grant instead then he deserved the sack just for that.
Given we're starting to resemble a functioning football team for the first time in 18 months, it would seem foolish to disrupt all that by changing managers.
It's not, not even close to the truth
Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Posts: 3,075
Threads: 116
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
11
I guess regarding the Sam situation it comes down to the question of who is better and available?
Posts: 5,201
Threads: 197
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
14
Sam wants it, make no bones there, nobody else in the UK will offer him anything like what he has here ,maybe China or Dubai might line his pockets should be need it but in terms of getting a job here nobody else would want him or offer him what we would, both personal package and playing budger for the Chump
As you say depends on whether Dowling and Lai feel better options are available, Lai is desperate to sell as we all know and if he thinks Sam getting us back up is the best option this is how I see us sticking with him, my colours are well and truly nailed to the mast but I'd say the smart money now is on him being here. Wilder is as good as done if we press the button, just not sure we will now
Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Posts: 974
Threads: 11
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
2
05-04-2021, 11:28 AM
(This post was last modified: 05-04-2021, 11:38 AM by Lillwall's left foot.)
(05-04-2021, 11:15 AM)yeoman lai Wrote: I guess regarding the Sam situation it comes down to the question of who is better and available?
How do you define better? If we are talking record and results then I can't imagine who out there could be considered better than SA. This is a manager, much like our Woy, who worked his way up to the national team job and only lost it because he was an arrogant arse.
Of his most recent roles he even did ok at Everton, but their fans (much like Newcastle's) have delusions of grandeur and it just wasn't a fit. I have no such broom up my ass and compared to the Pullis years at times the football under him has been positively free flowing. Given the right club i would presume he has a record of over achieving?
I would imagine out of those other managers available that Wilder has the best record of relative sucess? No doubt a very good manager but his apparent poor judgement in the striking department does bother me (Brewster £24m, McBurnie £18m, Mousset £10m and a certain Mr Burke). Although I'm sure the Everton fans would also point to Cenk Tosun at £27m to balance out the argument.
Posts: 4,002
Threads: 162
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
We were pretty awful at the start of the season and we were pretty awful when BFS took over. Bilic didn't really have any excuses, he had spent time with the players for the previous 12-18 months and signed several of them. We were nowhere near PL standard, quite why January and very little money would have seen Bilic have an epithany I don't know.
BFS made mistakes and took too long to get us going, partly the sitiuation and partly his fault. What is undeniable is that his record at the cliub has seen us improve and on his record over that time we would not be in the bottom 3. Unfortunately the teams who were better than us but under-performing stopped doing so. 17th place could see one of the highest points total in PL hiistory (unless safety sees them slope off for the last few games) and that's what has done for us.
I hated TCITC and celebrated when he went, BFS should have been appointed then instead of Pardew. I was no lover of BFS and my heart sank a little with his appointment but the style has been much better and I've been surpsrised at how well coached the team look, in particular the full backs. Ultimateky Bilic AND BFS are both culpable in the relegation but IMO BFS less so, his fault has been in his inability to stop the shite quick enough. The shite was already in situ when he arrived.
Trump is a Cunt
Posts: 974
Threads: 11
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
2
(05-04-2021, 11:39 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: We were pretty awful at the start of the season and we were pretty awful when BFS took over. Bilic didn't really have any excuses, he had spent time with the players for the previous 12-18 months and signed several of them. We were nowhere near PL standard, quite why January and very little money would have seen Bilic have an epithany I don't know.
BFS made mistakes and took too long to get us going, partly the sitiuation and partly his fault. What is undeniable is that his record at the cliub has seen us improve and on his record over that time we would not be in the bottom 3. Unfortunately the teams who were better than us but under-performing stopped doing so. 17th place could see one of the highest points total in PL hiistory (unless safety sees them slope off for the last few games) and that's what has done for us.
I hated TCITC and celebrated when he went, BFS should have been appointed then instead of Pardew. I was no lover of BFS and my heart sank a little with his appointment but the style has been much better and I've been surpsrised at how well coached the team look, in particular the full backs. Ultimateky Bilic AND BFS are both culpable in the relegation but IMO BFS less so, his fault has been in his inability to stop the shite quick enough. The shite was already in situ when he arrived.
Think that's sums it up nicely.
|