Posts: 152
Threads: 8
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
1
(04-28-2021, 07:51 AM)JOK Wrote: (04-26-2021, 05:32 PM)Mish Wrote: (04-26-2021, 07:40 AM)JOK Wrote: The same types who railed at the ‘shortage’ of ventilators and believed the Sunday Times story that the ‘frail and elderly’ were being denied the use of a ventilator when in fact ICU beds never rose above 80% occupation and ventilator use even less during the pandemic. In fact, the story used a triage model for ‘worst case scenario’.
The ones who proffer the line, all that’s brilliant = NHS, all that has been crap = the government, overlooking the facts that in March last year the NHS didn’t actually know how many ventilators it had or that over 25% of those that died with Covid actually contracted it IN hospital, supposedly one of the most sterile places we can enter. Over 450 people a day, in January, contracted Covid in hospital.
You really should read 'Failures of State' by Jonathan Calvert. Hospitals had a scoring mechanism to decide who would and wouldn't be denied treatment. The whole discharging untested patients into care homes thus exponentially killing people was done so that beds were free. From the horse’s mouth.
https://www.england.nhs.uk/2020/10/nhs-a...day-times/
“The Sunday Times’ assertions are simply not borne out by the facts:”
“The NHS repeatedly instructed staff that no patient who could benefit from treatment should be denied it …”
“We were asked to look at the issue of a Covid-19 triage tool, however, it wasn’t needed.”
“The final version, which does not include numerical scoring, was issued for release by the Society on 28 May 2020…”
‘No intensive care national triage tool was issued by the NHS. Early work on a triage tool was commissioned when modelling suggested two million people here could require hospital treatment’.
Interesting link JOK. From what I remember, and in the interests of balance, I believe Calvert did quote NHS management officials saying that triage scoring was not the case. I will re-read.
I notice there is no denial of patients being discharged into care homes to free up capacity at the start of the crisis which led to the care homes scandal.
Posts: 1,058
Threads: 51
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
3
(04-28-2021, 08:16 AM)baggy1 Wrote: You seem to be ignoring the bit where you tried to downplay the virus impact by making out that 25% (an inaccurate figure but one used by the covid-deniers) of infections came from within hospitals. You also appear to not be aware that the 80% was for increased ICU beds which is different to ventilator use but you seem to want to merge the stats. You are clearly an intelligent bloke JOK which makes it even more surprising that you will be making out it wasn't as bad as it was. I really do have an issue with the downplay going on here.
Oh, come on B1, where or when have I ever downplayed the pandemic? This thread is about lies (or is that what you’re saying I’m downplaying? Which, again, where have I downplayed that. Pointing out politicians have always lied and the hypocrisy of inferring that it’s just the current lot in power is not ‘downplaying’ whatever shenanigans is going on at present. I didn’t ‘merge’ stats, I said occupancy of ICU beds never outstripped availability and that the use of ventilators was far less than capacity. (See NHS stats below)
‘Throughout the Covid-19 pandemic there has in fact always been ICU capacity available. As the National Audit Office have confirmed, around the peak of Covid-19 hospital admissions on 14 April, NHS providers in England had 6,818 ventilator beds operational, of which: 2,849 (42%) were occupied by Covid-19 patients; 1,031 (15%) were occupied by other patients; and 2,938 (43%) were unoccupied.’
‘Hospital treatment and intensive care has been available to any individual who clinicians determined would benefit from it throughout the pandemic as it normally would be.’
‘A study published in July led by King’s College London estimated that 12.5% of all Covid-19 inpatients had hospital-acquired infections. The study, which looked at 1,500 Covid patients admitted up to 28 April in 10 hospitals in the UK and one in Italy, defined nosocomial patients as those who were diagnosed 15 or more days after admission to hospital.
However, the study said this was a “conservative” estimate, as this definition did not include people who tested positive sooner, hospital workers, or asymptomatic patients who were discharged without a positive test. It said the true proportion of hospital-acquired transmission could be closer to 23%.k
https://fullfact.org/health/coronavirus-transmission-hospitals’
‘Nosocomial covid cases doubled at some trusts including King’s College Hospital FT, where hospital-caught cases rose from 46 in the week to 3 January to 92 in the latest week (13.2 per cent of cases), and at University Hospitals of Leicester Trust, where these cases rose from 30 to 61 in that time (22.2 per cent).’ (Jan. 21st)
https://www.hsj.co.uk/patient-safety/covid-infections-caught-in-hospital-up-by-half-in-a-week/7029320.article
‘More than a fifth of Covid deaths at some hospitals after patients caught virus on wards’
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2021/03/31/exclusive-fifth-covid-deaths-hospitals-infections-caught-ward/ or:
https://www.express.co.uk/news/uk/1417689/covid-news-infections-on-wards-fifth-deaths-latest-ont
https://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/entry/covid-hospitals-nosocomial_uk_6026fae9c5b6741597e1ff12
https://www.theguardian.com/society/2021/mar/26/40600-people-likely-caught-covid-while-hospital-inpatients-in-england
Surely you accept at least one of these reports? The Huffington? The Guardian?
Of course, all the stats on deaths come with the caveat ‘died with Covid’ which I did emphasize in my previous post and of which I have always been a little suspect.
n.b. As someone who has followed all lockdown rules religiously, with much gnashing of my teeth at the selfish cretins who haven’t and critical of Covid deniers, anti vacs types and the anti-lockdown nutters, I am a bit perplexed at being accused of downplaying the whole tragedy (if I am).
Posts: 8,953
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
All good points JOK, my issue was with the throw away comment that is being used by 'downplayers' as a reason to reduce lockdown measure quicker as a large proportion get it in hospital. Apologies for grouping you with them - I have a particular dislike of that stat because used in isolation it can make people think that its not as bad as is being described.
Even the data you use only highlights half of the number used and that for a very limited study 1,500 across 11 hospitals (that is 0.3% of the UK hospitalisations and includes an Italian hospital which we don't have total numbers for) and the 23% (not 25% quoted) is an estimate. And each one of those newspaper reports have used the worst case to make the story more tantalising. The figure you quoted (25%) is very much a misrepresentation of any fact.
I've pointed out on here many times that using 'died with', 'died from', or just having covid on the death cert can be used to muddy the waters (and has been) when the facts are that excess deaths tell the story without all the doubt as to the cost of covid.
And the ICU beds stat being at 80% - this ignores two big points. ICU beds have been increased for covid (on previous capacity the % would have been much higher and other wards had to close to accommodate the reallocation to ICU not to comment on the nightingales that counted as ICU and were never used). By saying ICU beds "never rose above 80% and ventilators even less" again it is saying "it wasn't that bad".
And 80% represents the whole country when the virus wasn't consistently attacking the whole country. There were areas that would have been at full capacity and others at 60% (both examples) and it wasn't as if you could just take the patient 100s of miles to where the free beds were.
My issue is anyone who uses, directly or indirectly, comments that imply 'it wasn't that bad' - It was and could be again if we drop our guard.
Posts: 1,058
Threads: 51
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
3
04-29-2021, 09:58 AM
(This post was last modified: 04-29-2021, 10:28 AM by JOK.
Edit Reason: explain
)
(04-29-2021, 07:35 AM)Mish Wrote: (04-28-2021, 07:51 AM)JOK Wrote: (04-26-2021, 05:32 PM)Mish Wrote: (04-26-2021, 07:40 AM)JOK Wrote: The same types who railed at the ‘shortage’ of ventilators and believed the Sunday Times story that the ‘frail and elderly’ were being denied the use of a ventilator when in fact ICU beds never rose above 80% occupation and ventilator use even less during the pandemic. In fact, the story used a triage model for ‘worst case scenario’.
The ones who proffer the line, all that’s brilliant = NHS, all that has been crap = the government, overlooking the facts that in March last year the NHS didn’t actually know how many ventilators it had or that over 25% of those that died with Covid actually contracted it IN hospital, supposedly one of the most sterile places we can enter. Over 450 people a day, in January, contracted Covid in hospital.
You really should read 'Failures of State' by Jonathan Calvert. Hospitals had a scoring mechanism to decide who would and wouldn't be denied treatment. The whole discharging untested patients into care homes thus exponentially killing people was done so that beds were free. From the horse’s mouth.
https://www.england.nhs.uk/2020/10/nhs-a...day-times/
“The Sunday Times’ assertions are simply not borne out by the facts:”
“The NHS repeatedly instructed staff that no patient who could benefit from treatment should be denied it …”
“We were asked to look at the issue of a Covid-19 triage tool, however, it wasn’t needed.”
“The final version, which does not include numerical scoring, was issued for release by the Society on 28 May 2020…”
‘No intensive care national triage tool was issued by the NHS. Early work on a triage tool was commissioned when modelling suggested two million people here could require hospital treatment’.
Interesting link JOK. From what I remember, and in the interests of balance, I believe Calvert did quote NHS management officials saying that triage scoring was not the case. I will re-read.
I notice there is no denial of patients being discharged into care homes to free up capacity at the start of the crisis which led to the care homes scandal. Why would I deny that? A, it’s a fact. One I have personal experience with as my mother’s home ended up with nine cases after one resident returned from hospital with it. And B, I never mentioned it. If anything, it corroborates the lie I alluded to that ‘all things bad are the government’s fault’ and the NHS is all wonderful. It is NHS hospital managers that coerce clinicians into the too early discharge of patients.
And before some poster gets the notion that my pointing out that the NHS is not infallible, I do believe, strongly, that we should maintain the NHS in full public control / ownership and publicly funded.
(soz, I tried to remove the previous posts for brevity but for some reason it wouldn't let me this time.)
(04-29-2021, 08:49 AM)baggy1 Wrote: All good points JOK, my issue was with the throw away comment that is being used by 'downplayers' as a reason to reduce lockdown measure quicker as a large proportion get it in hospital. Apologies for grouping you with them - I have a particular dislike of that stat because used in isolation it can make people think that its not as bad as is being described.
Even the data you use only highlights half of the number used and that for a very limited study 1,500 across 11 hospitals (that is 0.3% of the UK hospitalisations and includes an Italian hospital which we don't have total numbers for) and the 23% (not 25% quoted) is an estimate. And each one of those newspaper reports have used the worst case to make the story more tantalising. The figure you quoted (25%) is very much a misrepresentation of any fact.
I've pointed out on here many times that using 'died with', 'died from', or just having covid on the death cert can be used to muddy the waters (and has been) when the facts are that excess deaths tell the story without all the doubt as to the cost of covid.
And the ICU beds stat being at 80% - this ignores two big points. ICU beds have been increased for covid (on previous capacity the % would have been much higher and other wards had to close to accommodate the reallocation to ICU not to comment on the nightingales that counted as ICU and were never used). By saying ICU beds "never rose above 80% and ventilators even less" again it is saying "it wasn't that bad".
And 80% represents the whole country when the virus wasn't consistently attacking the whole country. There were areas that would have been at full capacity and others at 60% (both examples) and it wasn't as if you could just take the patient 100s of miles to where the free beds were.
My issue is anyone who uses, directly or indirectly, comments that imply 'it wasn't that bad' - It was and could be again if we drop our guard.
No worries, B1. Believe me, I am defo not a “downplayer” and would prefer overkill as regards the length of lockdown to ending it too soon. However, some public acceptance for that seems too far gone for that. Even though I will have my second jab on Saturday I will continue with the precautions I have been doing for the last 14 months.
I do bow down to your forensic study of the stats and I am aware I am, perhaps, not as diligent with their interpretation but I do try and study as many sources as reasonably possible to get an overall picture.
I certainly didn’t intend to infer that the situation “wasn’t that bad” just trying to disprove the ‘lie’ of the Times article that the NHS were ‘selecting’ certain patients for treatment refusal. (although, over the last 15 months I have been asked 3 times to agree to a DNR for my mother)
Just an observation, though; saying a thing wasn’t as bad as predicted isn’t the same as saying ‘it wasn’t that bad’ ! A cyclist being hit by an artic. doing 70mph isn’t as bad as a cyclist being hit by a train doing 100mph but the outcome is still tragically devastating.
Posts: 8,953
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
All fair again JOK, I came across this 1st sometime last September on Twitter and the line being pushed that it's not that bad because a large proportion originates in hospital therefore go about your business. The fact that people couldn't understand it was so high in hospital because it was a high concentration and therefore if you keep the hospitalisations down then they won't 'increase further from within'.
And i think that we all agree that news outlets have gone for the dramatic throughout which may not have helped as we became saturated by it whilst we weren't necessarily suffering from covid directly.
However I do feel we are nearly there and hopefully have learned a lot from the past year.
Posts: 152
Threads: 8
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
1
(04-29-2021, 09:58 AM)JOK Wrote: (04-29-2021, 07:35 AM)Mish Wrote: (04-28-2021, 07:51 AM)JOK Wrote: (04-26-2021, 05:32 PM)Mish Wrote: (04-26-2021, 07:40 AM)JOK Wrote: The same types who railed at the ‘shortage’ of ventilators and believed the Sunday Times story that the ‘frail and elderly’ were being denied the use of a ventilator when in fact ICU beds never rose above 80% occupation and ventilator use even less during the pandemic. In fact, the story used a triage model for ‘worst case scenario’.
The ones who proffer the line, all that’s brilliant = NHS, all that has been crap = the government, overlooking the facts that in March last year the NHS didn’t actually know how many ventilators it had or that over 25% of those that died with Covid actually contracted it IN hospital, supposedly one of the most sterile places we can enter. Over 450 people a day, in January, contracted Covid in hospital.
You really should read 'Failures of State' by Jonathan Calvert. Hospitals had a scoring mechanism to decide who would and wouldn't be denied treatment. The whole discharging untested patients into care homes thus exponentially killing people was done so that beds were free. From the horse’s mouth.
https://www.england.nhs.uk/2020/10/nhs-a...day-times/
“The Sunday Times’ assertions are simply not borne out by the facts:”
“The NHS repeatedly instructed staff that no patient who could benefit from treatment should be denied it …”
“We were asked to look at the issue of a Covid-19 triage tool, however, it wasn’t needed.”
“The final version, which does not include numerical scoring, was issued for release by the Society on 28 May 2020…”
‘No intensive care national triage tool was issued by the NHS. Early work on a triage tool was commissioned when modelling suggested two million people here could require hospital treatment’.
Interesting link JOK. From what I remember, and in the interests of balance, I believe Calvert did quote NHS management officials saying that triage scoring was not the case. I will re-read.
I notice there is no denial of patients being discharged into care homes to free up capacity at the start of the crisis which led to the care homes scandal. Why would I deny that? A, it’s a fact. One I have personal experience with as my mother’s home ended up with nine cases after one resident returned from hospital with it. And B, I never mentioned it. If anything, it corroborates the lie I alluded to that ‘all things bad are the government’s fault’ and the NHS is all wonderful. It is NHS hospital managers that coerce clinicians into the too early discharge of patients.
And before some poster gets the notion that my pointing out that the NHS is not infallible, I do believe, strongly, that we should maintain the NHS in full public control / ownership and publicly funded.
(soz, I tried to remove the previous posts for brevity but for some reason it wouldn't let me this time.)
(04-29-2021, 08:49 AM)baggy1 Wrote: All good points JOK, my issue was with the throw away comment that is being used by 'downplayers' as a reason to reduce lockdown measure quicker as a large proportion get it in hospital. Apologies for grouping you with them - I have a particular dislike of that stat because used in isolation it can make people think that its not as bad as is being described.
Even the data you use only highlights half of the number used and that for a very limited study 1,500 across 11 hospitals (that is 0.3% of the UK hospitalisations and includes an Italian hospital which we don't have total numbers for) and the 23% (not 25% quoted) is an estimate. And each one of those newspaper reports have used the worst case to make the story more tantalising. The figure you quoted (25%) is very much a misrepresentation of any fact.
I've pointed out on here many times that using 'died with', 'died from', or just having covid on the death cert can be used to muddy the waters (and has been) when the facts are that excess deaths tell the story without all the doubt as to the cost of covid.
And the ICU beds stat being at 80% - this ignores two big points. ICU beds have been increased for covid (on previous capacity the % would have been much higher and other wards had to close to accommodate the reallocation to ICU not to comment on the nightingales that counted as ICU and were never used). By saying ICU beds "never rose above 80% and ventilators even less" again it is saying "it wasn't that bad".
And 80% represents the whole country when the virus wasn't consistently attacking the whole country. There were areas that would have been at full capacity and others at 60% (both examples) and it wasn't as if you could just take the patient 100s of miles to where the free beds were.
My issue is anyone who uses, directly or indirectly, comments that imply 'it wasn't that bad' - It was and could be again if we drop our guard.
No worries, B1. Believe me, I am defo not a “downplayer” and would prefer overkill as regards the length of lockdown to ending it too soon. However, some public acceptance for that seems too far gone for that. Even though I will have my second jab on Saturday I will continue with the precautions I have been doing for the last 14 months.
I do bow down to your forensic study of the stats and I am aware I am, perhaps, not as diligent with their interpretation but I do try and study as many sources as reasonably possible to get an overall picture.
I certainly didn’t intend to infer that the situation “wasn’t that bad” just trying to disprove the ‘lie’ of the Times article that the NHS were ‘selecting’ certain patients for treatment refusal. (although, over the last 15 months I have been asked 3 times to agree to a DNR for my mother)
Just an observation, though; saying a thing wasn’t as bad as predicted isn’t the same as saying ‘it wasn’t that bad’ ! A cyclist being hit by an artic. doing 70mph isn’t as bad as a cyclist being hit by a train doing 100mph but the outcome is still tragically devastating.
I meant denial on the link that you provided, not from you.
Posts: 1,058
Threads: 51
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
3
(04-29-2021, 02:57 PM)Mish Wrote: (04-29-2021, 09:58 AM)JOK Wrote: Interesting link JOK. From what I remember, and in the interests of balance, I believe Calvert did quote NHS management officials saying that triage scoring was not the case. I will re-read.
I notice there is no denial of patients being discharged into care homes to free up capacity at the start of the crisis which led to the care homes scandal.
Why would I deny that? A, it’s a fact. One I have personal experience with as my mother’s home ended up with nine cases after one resident returned from hospital with it. And B, I never mentioned it. If anything, it corroborates the lie I alluded to that ‘all things bad are the government’s fault’ and the NHS is all wonderful. It is NHS hospital managers that coerce clinicians into the too early discharge of patients.
And before some poster gets the notion that my pointing out that the NHS is not infallible, I do believe, strongly, that we should maintain the NHS in full public control / ownership and publicly funded.
(soz, I tried to remove the previous posts for brevity but for some reason it wouldn't let me this time.)
I meant denial on the link that you provided, not from you. Oh, I see now, sorry.
|