Posts: 509
Threads: 19
Joined: Jan 2021
Reputation:
0
(04-24-2021, 11:48 AM)Bortolazzi's Barnet Wrote: The Dyson matter really is a non-issue.
Will the same people complaining also whine about Marcus Rashford's access to power when he had phone conversations with the PM for what was also an altruistic matter?
Nah. Course not.
However, the revelations since the early part of last week may well be much more difficult to defend and, if true put the PM in a very difficult position indeed. And there may well be more to come.
Contrariwise, I am comparing a man who put his time, money and employees into fighting a pandemic to a bloke who campaigns.
Be interested to see if the people who, last year, claimed that Cummings is a total liar who can't ever be believed, suddenly think everyhing he says needs to be believed, now.
I bet they do.
Posts: 13,568
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
(04-24-2021, 04:01 PM)Bortolazzi's Barnet Wrote: Contrariwise, I am comparing a man who put his time, money and employees into war profiteering with a complete disaster of a design that was in no way, shape or form a serious attempt at developing a ventilator.
Fixed that for you. And Rashford had to be contacted by Number 10 after building a campaign which was then voted on by Parliament, he didn't have a direct line to the PM's personal number that he uses for his own benefit. Complete false equivalence.
And Cummings is a nob, we all know he's dishonest after lying about an eye test and retrospectively updating his blog to make it seem like he predicted the pandemic when he didn't. What he is though is someone who knows a lot about Boris Johnson's personal life and it's up to the PM as to whether he wants to get into a fight with someone who has his balls in a vice.
Posts: 17,072
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(04-24-2021, 04:01 PM)Bortolazzi's Barnet Wrote: (04-24-2021, 11:48 AM)Bortolazzi's Barnet Wrote: The Dyson matter really is a non-issue.
Will the same people complaining also whine about Marcus Rashford's access to power when he had phone conversations with the PM for what was also an altruistic matter?
Nah. Course not.
However, the revelations since the early part of last week may well be much more difficult to defend and, if true put the PM in a very difficult position indeed. And there may well be more to come.
Contrariwise, I am comparing a man who put his time, money and employees into fighting a pandemic to a bloke who campaigns.
Be interested to see if the people who, last year, claimed that Cummings is a total liar who can't ever be believed, suddenly think everyhing he says needs to be believed, now.
I bet they do.
I’m waiting to see who those who defended Cummings and Johnson for the last few years are now going to side with... looks like you’ve decided to believe the man who is renowned for being a stranger to the truth. Although that’s up against some pretty stiff competition.
Posts: 5,322
Threads: 356
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
That Johnson was told by civil service advisers that he should change his mobile because too many people were aware of his number is telling.
Heard an anecdote that someone contacted him on his mobile asking him about their UC claim, Johnson passed his details to DWP, who sorted the claimant out.
Possibly the conservatives idea of a replacement for Citizens advice bureau.
Posts: 1,058
Threads: 51
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
3
(04-24-2021, 04:01 PM)Bortolazzi's Barnet Wrote: Contrariwise, I am comparing a man who put his time, money and employees into fighting a pandemic to a bloke who campaigns.
Be interested to see if the people who, last year, claimed that Cummings is a total liar who can't ever be believed, suddenly think everyhing he says needs to be believed, now.
I bet they do.
They will believe the ones who go against the people or organisations they revile the most, as usual. The people who believed those consummate liars, Harry and Megs-it-up because they have a pathological hatred of the royals. Such as the poster who prefers anecdotes and Twatter as mediums from which he forms his opinions and despises and ignores researched, proven facts and statistics when they disprove his pronouncements and then has the effrontery to complain about ‘fake news’. (in fact for someone who adores ‘experts’ he is very dismissive of researched posts!)
The same types who railed at the ‘shortage’ of ventilators and believed the Sunday Times story that the ‘frail and elderly’ were being denied the use of a ventilator when in fact ICU beds never rose above 80% occupation and ventilator use even less during the pandemic. In fact, the story used a triage model for ‘worst case scenario’.
The ones who proffer the line, all that’s brilliant = NHS, all that has been crap = the government, overlooking the facts that in March last year the NHS didn’t actually know how many ventilators it had or that over 25% of those that died with Covid actually contracted it IN hospital, supposedly one of the most sterile places we can enter. Over 450 people a day, in January, contracted Covid in hospital.
Those who did the most shouting about the lack of PPE and ventilators and demanded the situation be swiftly remedied but, after adding to the atmosphere of panic then, are now shouting “where was the tendering process “? Anyone who’s familiar with civil service and local government procurement will know how long that would have taken.
The ones who, currently, to paraphrase a poster’s line, must find their literary gymnastics very painful after insisting for years that neither can be believed. These are the ones who will believe Cummings now.
Posts: 17,072
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
04-26-2021, 08:47 AM
(This post was last modified: 04-26-2021, 11:12 AM by Derek Hardballs.)
I think some are showing their True Blue scarf is a little too tight or possibly tangled given the circumstances. I wish I was as impartial as them  .
Posts: 8,953
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
(04-26-2021, 07:40 AM)JOK Wrote: (04-24-2021, 04:01 PM)Bortolazzi's Barnet Wrote: Contrariwise, I am comparing a man who put his time, money and employees into fighting a pandemic to a bloke who campaigns.
Be interested to see if the people who, last year, claimed that Cummings is a total liar who can't ever be believed, suddenly think everyhing he says needs to be believed, now.
I bet they do.
They will believe the ones who go against the people or organisations they revile the most, as usual. The people who believed those consummate liars, Harry and Megs-it-up because they have a pathological hatred of the royals. Such as the poster who prefers anecdotes and Twatter as mediums from which he forms his opinions and despises and ignores researched, proven facts and statistics when they disprove his pronouncements and then has the effrontery to complain about ‘fake news’. (in fact for someone who adores ‘experts’ he is very dismissive of researched posts!)
The same types who railed at the ‘shortage’ of ventilators and believed the Sunday Times story that the ‘frail and elderly’ were being denied the use of a ventilator when in fact ICU beds never rose above 80% occupation and ventilator use even less during the pandemic. In fact, the story used a triage model for ‘worst case scenario’.
The ones who proffer the line, all that’s brilliant = NHS, all that has been crap = the government, overlooking the facts that in March last year the NHS didn’t actually know how many ventilators it had or that over 25% of those that died with Covid actually contracted it IN hospital, supposedly one of the most sterile places we can enter. Over 450 people a day, in January, contracted Covid in hospital.
Those who did the most shouting about the lack of PPE and ventilators and demanded the situation be swiftly remedied but, after adding to the atmosphere of panic then, are now shouting “where was the tendering process “? Anyone who’s familiar with civil service and local government procurement will know how long that would have taken.
The ones who, currently, to paraphrase a poster’s line, must find their literary gymnastics very painful after insisting for years that neither can be believed. These are the ones who will believe Cummings now.
I have particular issue with this comment, I saw it come up at the time and couldn't believe the stupidity of it and am surprised to see it again. The hospitals were full and an obvious point of infection, it really should be no surprise that where there is a large proliferation of the virus it will spread more, and as for sterilising the areas - this is a respiratory virus which would require sterilisation of the air to stop it moving around. There is no way to stop the spread of this virus in a hospital short of closing the hospital to everyone that didn't need to be there for coronavirus reasons. Plus a number of those 25% (which wasn't an accurate figure btw it was based on a couple of studies and not an accurate view of the full picture) would have been those working in the hospitals.
It was, and appears to still be, being used to downplay the virus when in fact it shows exactly what happens when you get in a close proximity of a large amount of this virus. Everything about this comment is not thought through at all.
Posts: 152
Threads: 8
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
1
(04-26-2021, 07:40 AM)JOK Wrote: (04-24-2021, 04:01 PM)Bortolazzi's Barnet Wrote: Contrariwise, I am comparing a man who put his time, money and employees into fighting a pandemic to a bloke who campaigns.
Be interested to see if the people who, last year, claimed that Cummings is a total liar who can't ever be believed, suddenly think everyhing he says needs to be believed, now.
I bet they do.
They will believe the ones who go against the people or organisations they revile the most, as usual. The people who believed those consummate liars, Harry and Megs-it-up because they have a pathological hatred of the royals. Such as the poster who prefers anecdotes and Twatter as mediums from which he forms his opinions and despises and ignores researched, proven facts and statistics when they disprove his pronouncements and then has the effrontery to complain about ‘fake news’. (in fact for someone who adores ‘experts’ he is very dismissive of researched posts!)
The same types who railed at the ‘shortage’ of ventilators and believed the Sunday Times story that the ‘frail and elderly’ were being denied the use of a ventilator when in fact ICU beds never rose above 80% occupation and ventilator use even less during the pandemic. In fact, the story used a triage model for ‘worst case scenario’.
The ones who proffer the line, all that’s brilliant = NHS, all that has been crap = the government, overlooking the facts that in March last year the NHS didn’t actually know how many ventilators it had or that over 25% of those that died with Covid actually contracted it IN hospital, supposedly one of the most sterile places we can enter. Over 450 people a day, in January, contracted Covid in hospital.
Those who did the most shouting about the lack of PPE and ventilators and demanded the situation be swiftly remedied but, after adding to the atmosphere of panic then, are now shouting “where was the tendering process “? Anyone who’s familiar with civil service and local government procurement will know how long that would have taken.
The ones who, currently, to paraphrase a poster’s line, must find their literary gymnastics very painful after insisting for years that neither can be believed. These are the ones who will believe Cummings now.
You really should read 'Failures of State' by Jonathan Calvert. Hospitals had a scoring mechanism to decide who would and wouldn't be denied treatment. The whole discharging untested patients into care homes thus exponentially killing people was done so that beds were free.
Posts: 1,058
Threads: 51
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
3
(04-26-2021, 05:32 PM)Mish Wrote: (04-26-2021, 07:40 AM)JOK Wrote: The same types who railed at the ‘shortage’ of ventilators and believed the Sunday Times story that the ‘frail and elderly’ were being denied the use of a ventilator when in fact ICU beds never rose above 80% occupation and ventilator use even less during the pandemic. In fact, the story used a triage model for ‘worst case scenario’.
The ones who proffer the line, all that’s brilliant = NHS, all that has been crap = the government, overlooking the facts that in March last year the NHS didn’t actually know how many ventilators it had or that over 25% of those that died with Covid actually contracted it IN hospital, supposedly one of the most sterile places we can enter. Over 450 people a day, in January, contracted Covid in hospital.
You really should read 'Failures of State' by Jonathan Calvert. Hospitals had a scoring mechanism to decide who would and wouldn't be denied treatment. The whole discharging untested patients into care homes thus exponentially killing people was done so that beds were free. From the horse’s mouth.
https://www.england.nhs.uk/2020/10/nhs-a...day-times/
“The Sunday Times’ assertions are simply not borne out by the facts:”
“The NHS repeatedly instructed staff that no patient who could benefit from treatment should be denied it …”
“We were asked to look at the issue of a Covid-19 triage tool, however, it wasn’t needed.”
“The final version, which does not include numerical scoring, was issued for release by the Society on 28 May 2020…”
‘ No intensive care national triage tool was issued by the NHS. Early work on a triage tool was commissioned when modelling suggested two million people here could require hospital treatment’.
Posts: 8,953
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
You seem to be ignoring the bit where you tried to downplay the virus impact by making out that 25% (an inaccurate figure but one used by the covid-deniers) of infections came from within hospitals. You also appear to not be aware that the 80% was for increased ICU beds which is different to ventilator use but you seem to want to merge the stats. You are clearly an intelligent bloke JOK which makes it even more surprising that you will be making out it wasn't as bad as it was. I really do have an issue with the downplay going on here.
|