European super League
(04-19-2021, 10:52 AM)Swagbaggie Wrote: Anyone who thinks that telling these 6 clubs to clear off and form their league, and it will not have a devastating impact on the rest of football, is delusional.

The current format is massively flawed but allows mid range clubs like ourselves, Norwich, Fulham, SheffU etc etc etc to survive by slotting in promotions/ Cup runs that allow the club to survive. The trickle down the leagues from the EPL is not as generous, or even as fair as it should be, but again it provides unattainable income for many many clubs.

The fallout from this will devastate the club structure in this country if it is allowed to go ahead.
I would even fear for our stability and of course the National game that was starting to look so promising for the first time in many years.

I disagree. There'd be short term issues, I'd agree with that much, but if clubs could get through that, wages (clubs biggest outgoing) would simply re-adjust over a few years in all 4 divisions.
Reply
This could be the start of the fight back - any number of people on here, including me, are looking forward to next season in the Championship - its a better "product" for us. It's easy to see the reason why so many Championship Clubs have got into severe financial difficulties, they have gambled for the premier dollar. If there is a levelling down that "incentive" will be removed we can return to competition on the pitch not the bank. Big clubs won't be able to stockpile youth players so more opportunity to bring on our own. I will not watch a minute of the Mid week friendly league, very rarely watch European football now, the uniqueness went when they ceased knockout football. Perhaps we can have our FA cup back as well. Big 6 can go to hell. What's not to like.
Reply
(04-19-2021, 10:52 AM)Swagbaggie Wrote: Anyone who thinks that telling these 6 clubs to clear off and form their league, and it will not have a devastating impact on the rest of football, is delusional.

The current format is massively flawed but allows mid range clubs like ourselves, Norwich, Fulham, SheffU etc etc etc to survive by slotting in promotions/ Cup runs that allow the club to survive. The trickle down the leagues from the EPL is not as generous, or even as fair as it should be, but again it provides unattainable income for many many clubs.

The fallout from this will devastate the club structure in this country if it is allowed to go ahead.
I would even fear for our stability and of course the National game that was starting to look so promising for the first time in many years.

Unfortunately this is absolutely true

IMO the Premier league will cave. They'll allow the teams to compete in both the super league and the Prem, which those clubs will do. Despite it being such a poorly thought out idea after massive legal battles the clubs in the ESL will make it work for them and it will result in the complete destruction of the Champions League......and along with that completely screw over national football and any history associated with it. Honestly, its so bad, so so bad
Reply
(04-19-2021, 10:52 AM)Swagbaggie Wrote: Anyone who thinks that telling these 6 clubs to clear off and form their league, and it will not have a devastating impact on the rest of football, is delusional.

The current format is massively flawed but allows mid range clubs like ourselves, Norwich, Fulham, SheffU etc etc etc to survive by slotting in promotions/ Cup runs that allow the club to survive. The trickle down the leagues from the EPL is not as generous, or even as fair as it should be, but again it provides unattainable income for many many clubs.

The fallout from this will devastate the club structure in this country if it is allowed to go ahead.
I would even fear for our stability and of course the National game that was starting to look so promising for the first time in many years.

Didn't 'mid range' clubs survive before? Was there not 4 divisions before Sheik Woshisname and Oligarchovic got involved? Of course their was. The biggest outlay is player wages. There would be some short term difficulties, but wages would reduce naturally to more manageable levels very quickly. Without such a massive difference in financial rewards clubs wont need to risk their future in an attempt to get there.
Reply
I am a bit miffed at the likes of Neville ranting about it. I agree with what he said but he has got very rich off the same sort of elitist attitude, the ESL is merely that attitude and approach reaching its natural conclusion.
Reply
(04-19-2021, 11:11 AM)MrFizz Wrote:
(04-19-2021, 10:52 AM)Swagbaggie Wrote: Anyone who thinks that telling these 6 clubs to clear off and form their league, and it will not have a devastating impact on the rest of football, is delusional.

The current format is massively flawed but allows mid range clubs like ourselves, Norwich, Fulham, SheffU etc etc etc to survive by slotting in promotions/ Cup runs that allow the club to survive. The trickle down the leagues from the EPL is not as generous, or even as fair as it should be, but again it provides unattainable income for many many clubs.

The fallout from this will devastate the club structure in this country if it is allowed to go ahead.
I would even fear for our stability and of course the National game that was starting to look so promising for the first time in many years.

Didn't 'mid range' clubs survive before? Was there not 4 divisions before Sheik Woshisname and Oligarchovic got involved? Of course their was. The biggest outlay is player wages. There would be some short term difficulties, but wages would reduce naturally to more manageable levels very quickly. Without such a massive difference in financial rewards clubs wont need to risk their future in an attempt to get there.

Totally agree, it would simply mean over a few years the salaries would drop by a percentage in each division.
Reply
(04-19-2021, 10:56 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(04-19-2021, 10:52 AM)Swagbaggie Wrote: Anyone who thinks that telling these 6 clubs to clear off and form their league, and it will not have a devastating impact on the rest of football, is delusional.

The current format is massively flawed but allows mid range clubs like ourselves, Norwich, Fulham, SheffU etc etc etc to survive by slotting in promotions/ Cup runs that allow the club to survive. The trickle down the leagues from the EPL is not as generous, or even as fair as it should be, but again it provides unattainable income for many many clubs.

The fallout from this will devastate the club structure in this country if it is allowed to go ahead.
I would even fear for our stability and of course the National game that was starting to look so promising for the first time in many years.

I disagree. There'd be short term issues, I'd agree with that much, but if clubs could get through that, wages (clubs biggest outgoing) would simply re-adjust over a few years in all 4 divisions.

Problem is that it would take years to readjust, as I said above you still have bang average (by PL standards) players earning huge sums. Too many clubs would go under while we waited for the finances to sort themselves out.

(04-19-2021, 11:20 AM)Bortolazzi's Barnet Wrote: I am a bit miffed at the likes of Neville ranting about it. I agree with what he said but he has got very rich off the same sort of elitist attitude, the ESL is merely that attitude and approach reaching its natural conclusion.

If you watch the video of his comments he does acknowledge that he has made a lot of money out of football down the years and as someone who has money invested in Salford he does have a vested interest. He doesn’t try to hide it. Yes he’s paid by Sky, but he’s also using the platform they’ve given him to preach from.
Reply
He spoke sense and I was surprised and pleased that he even attacked Manchester United.
Reply
(04-19-2021, 11:22 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(04-19-2021, 10:56 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(04-19-2021, 10:52 AM)Swagbaggie Wrote: Anyone who thinks that telling these 6 clubs to clear off and form their league, and it will not have a devastating impact on the rest of football, is delusional.

The current format is massively flawed but allows mid range clubs like ourselves, Norwich, Fulham, SheffU etc etc etc to survive by slotting in promotions/ Cup runs that allow the club to survive. The trickle down the leagues from the EPL is not as generous, or even as fair as it should be, but again it provides unattainable income for many many clubs.

The fallout from this will devastate the club structure in this country if it is allowed to go ahead.
I would even fear for our stability and of course the National game that was starting to look so promising for the first time in many years.

I disagree. There'd be short term issues, I'd agree with that much, but if clubs could get through that, wages (clubs biggest outgoing) would simply re-adjust over a few years in all 4 divisions.

Problem is that it would take years to readjust, as I said above you still have bang average (by PL standards) players earning huge sums. Too many clubs would go under while we waited for the finances to sort themselves out.

(04-19-2021, 11:20 AM)Bortolazzi's Barnet Wrote: I am a bit miffed at the likes of Neville ranting about it. I agree with what he said but he has got very rich off the same sort of elitist attitude, the ESL is merely that attitude and approach reaching its natural conclusion.

If you watch the video of his comments he does acknowledge that he has made a lot of money out of football down the years and as someone who has money invested in Salford he does have a vested interest. He doesn’t try to hide it. Yes he’s paid by Sky, but he’s also using the platform they’ve given him to preach from.

I agree its a problem with player contracts that are longer than the current tv deal. When that drops (as it inevitably would with the rich 6 gone) there'd be a difficult couple of years I agree. But if there's a way to get over that, it would be fine long term. Otherwise we're in a situation where the strong just get stronger, and that really is killing the game.

I do agree with you that the short term is the issue though.
Reply
(04-19-2021, 11:22 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(04-19-2021, 10:56 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(04-19-2021, 10:52 AM)Swagbaggie Wrote: Anyone who thinks that telling these 6 clubs to clear off and form their league, and it will not have a devastating impact on the rest of football, is delusional.

The current format is massively flawed but allows mid range clubs like ourselves, Norwich, Fulham, SheffU etc etc etc to survive by slotting in promotions/ Cup runs that allow the club to survive. The trickle down the leagues from the EPL is not as generous, or even as fair as it should be, but again it provides unattainable income for many many clubs.

The fallout from this will devastate the club structure in this country if it is allowed to go ahead.
I would even fear for our stability and of course the National game that was starting to look so promising for the first time in many years.

I disagree. There'd be short term issues, I'd agree with that much, but if clubs could get through that, wages (clubs biggest outgoing) would simply re-adjust over a few years in all 4 divisions.

Problem is that it would take years to readjust, as I said above you still have bang average (by PL standards) players earning huge sums. Too many clubs would go under while we waited for the finances to sort themselves out.

(04-19-2021, 11:20 AM)Bortolazzi's Barnet Wrote: I am a bit miffed at the likes of Neville ranting about it. I agree with what he said but he has got very rich off the same sort of elitist attitude, the ESL is merely that attitude and approach reaching its natural conclusion.

If you watch the video of his comments he does acknowledge that he has made a lot of money out of football down the years and as someone who has money invested in Salford he does have a vested interest. He doesn’t try to hide it. Yes he’s paid by Sky, but he’s also using the platform they’ve given him to preach from.

Contracts would be re-negotiated fairly quickly Duffers. Players would have a stark choice. Either accept a new contract at a 50% reduction, or don't get anything at all because we'll go bust. Or we can cancel the contract and you're a free agent.

There would be some pain yes, some clubs will suffer. But it might be just what the game as a whole needs.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)