VAR again...
#11
Jota's goal ruled out was ridiculous too. I'm still convinced it was on
Reply
#12
(04-10-2021, 05:00 PM)Sliced Wrote: Jota's goal ruled out was ridiculous too. I'm still convinced it was on

It was worse than last night. Absolutely ridiculous. A joke. We'll be well out of it next season and hopefully they'll have modified it by the time we get promoted the year after.  Smile 
Apparently, the Dutch League has a linesman's call rule, presumably similar to cricket. It seems not many VAR systems in existence would have ruled out either the Wolves goal last night or the Liverpool one today so it can clearly be improved through implementation - and needs to be given it's almost certainly here to stay.
Reply
#13
It's hard to say how you could get VAR wrong?  Unlimited amount of replays, all the help and guidance you need at the click of an earpiece.  But they have.  You see the same incidents over and over with differing outcomes.
 The Dings last night.   Level. His arm may be off but he can't score with it so it should be be ok. Oh wait, no it isn't now.  He's level so the attacker has the advantage, no that wasn't a rule, just an advisory.
 That Chelsea equaliser at ours early season? VAR said it was handball, but it doesn't matter, turned out as it wasn't the last touch before it went in so that's ok.  Does anyone know any more?
Reply
#14
(04-10-2021, 09:00 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: It's hard to say how you could get VAR wrong?  Unlimited amount of replays, all the help and guidance you need at the click of an earpiece.  But they have.  You see the same incidents over and over with differing outcomes.
 The Dings last night.   Level. His arm may be off but he can't score with it so it should be be ok. Oh wait, no it isn't now.  He's level so the attacker has the advantage, no that wasn't a rule, just an advisory.
 That Chelsea equaliser at ours early season? VAR said it was handball, but it doesn't matter, turned out as it wasn't the last touch before it went in so that's ok.  Does anyone know any more?

As I said on another recent thread....

It comes back to decisions being imperfect but that is the same with incidents  looked at a dozen times from loads of angles with VAR and the outcomes are inexplicable or inconsistent.  The match could be "reffed" entirely by VAR and there would still be what look to be clearly wrong calls.

It's bullshit.  Get rid.
Reply
#15
IF VAR had been around in the 60s, 70s and no multi tv cameras at grounds, the existing football records would need to be torn up! Half the defenders would have been sent off, headed goals were often punched in, offsides often weren't... etc,etc, etc. But that was how it was! but then the Football Regulators, and TV companies decided "we shall have to spoil this game the working men love" and here we are today!
Good players on £1million per month, decent players £600k, and downright average players £200k , if you'm a keeper £40k a week for possibly 2 or 3 games a season. The games gone 'kin mad !
Reply
#16
Man United have just had a goal disallowed for something that was completely accidental and not a foul.
Reply
#17
(04-11-2021, 04:11 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Man United have just had a goal disallowed for something that was completely accidental and not a foul.

Ridiculous decision. VAR won't last long if it keeps pissing off the big teams
Reply
#18
(04-11-2021, 04:11 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Man United have just had a goal disallowed for something that was completely accidental and not a foul.
I thought so too.
What is disappointing is that the incident was not replayed to the ref in real time. It always looks worse in slow motion.
Reply
#19
It was and remains a total nonsense in its current form. I was watching the Utd Spurs game, but I've turned it off now. It is all bollox, I'm afraid.
Reply
#20
The game's gone, Tom.     Rolleyes
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: