Big Sam poll.....
#41
(04-05-2021, 10:30 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(04-05-2021, 08:22 PM)Peachy Wrote:
(04-05-2021, 07:53 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(04-05-2021, 07:51 PM)Duffers Wrote: Wilder and Allardyce are about to have the same number of PL relegations on their CVs.

That’s the best you’ve got?  Big Grin

Wilder

Oxford - Won Promotion from Confrence to Div 2 in 18 months

Northampton - Won promotion from Div 2 despite huge financial problems and players and staff not being paid.

Sheffield Utd (First Season) - Won Promotion from Div 1 to Championship with 100 points.

Sheffield Utd (second season) Won promotion to Premier League.

Sheffield Utd (third season) Finished 9th in Premier league despite lowest budget. 

Sheffield Utd (fourth season) Relegated after a poor season. 

Big Sam

Notts County 1997 - Promoted from Div 3

Bolton 2000 2000 - Promoted via play offs

West Ham 2012 - Promoted via play offs

West Brom - Relegated

Wilder already has more promotions than Big Sam in a much shorter career. Impressive CV if you ask me. Certainly no risk in giving Wilder the gig if you want automatic promotion.

So basically Sam has got promoted at every club he's ever managed that wasn't in the top flight. Were all those at the first time of asking as well? Im asking cause I genuinely don't know.

In that case, why are you seemingly so against it? From your post above it seems both Wilder or Allardyce would be good options. Personally I'd prefer Wilder but both have cracking records in getting teams promoted

I'm not so against it totally. You'll see from my posts on other threads I can see some merit in it but still feel he's been an anticlimax and we've pissed loads of points away in "must win games" (his words) when the team have been too conservative in their approach. Wilders CV is the same if not better than Sam's in terms of promotion. And a much more recent history of the championship too.

The reason I'd want Sam to stay is if he can persuade Okay to stay and try and keep some of the group together. Seeing as the chances of that are slim I think Wilder might be the better bet. There will be plenty of othe managers out there too. Just look at the list of managers that have recently been promoted out of the championship. Hardly any had any experience of the division before being promoted.

The arguement for Sam by some seems to be he'd be a safe pair of hands. I'm just not as convinced that would be the case. As a separate issue I don't think he's got the drive for it either. That's just a gut feeling.

It's all options Slice.
Reply
#42
(04-06-2021, 06:43 AM)Peachy Wrote:
(04-05-2021, 10:30 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(04-05-2021, 08:22 PM)Peachy Wrote:
(04-05-2021, 07:53 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(04-05-2021, 07:51 PM)Duffers Wrote: Wilder and Allardyce are about to have the same number of PL relegations on their CVs.

That’s the best you’ve got?  Big Grin

Wilder

Oxford - Won Promotion from Confrence to Div 2 in 18 months

Northampton - Won promotion from Div 2 despite huge financial problems and players and staff not being paid.

Sheffield Utd (First Season) - Won Promotion from Div 1 to Championship with 100 points.

Sheffield Utd (second season) Won promotion to Premier League.

Sheffield Utd (third season) Finished 9th in Premier league despite lowest budget. 

Sheffield Utd (fourth season) Relegated after a poor season. 

Big Sam

Notts County 1997 - Promoted from Div 3

Bolton 2000 2000 - Promoted via play offs

West Ham 2012 - Promoted via play offs

West Brom - Relegated

Wilder already has more promotions than Big Sam in a much shorter career. Impressive CV if you ask me. Certainly no risk in giving Wilder the gig if you want automatic promotion.

So basically Sam has got promoted at every club he's ever managed that wasn't in the top flight. Were all those at the first time of asking as well? Im asking cause I genuinely don't know.

In that case, why are you seemingly so against it? From your post above it seems both Wilder or Allardyce would be good options. Personally I'd prefer Wilder but both have cracking records in getting teams promoted

I'm not so against it totally. You'll see from my posts on other threads I can see some merit in it but still feel he's been an anticlimax and we've pissed loads of points away in "must win games" (his words) when the team have been too conservative in their approach. Wilders CV is the same if not better than Sam's in terms of promotion. And a much more recent history of the championship too.

The reason I'd want Sam to stay is if he can persuade Okay to stay and try and keep some of the group together. Seeing as the chances of that are slim I think Wilder might be the better bet. There will be plenty of othe managers out there too. Just look at the list of managers that have recently been promoted out of the championship. Hardly any had any experience of the division before being promoted.

The arguement for Sam by some seems to be he'd be a safe pair of hands. I'm just not as convinced that would be the case. As a separate issue I don't think he's got the drive for it either. That's just a gut feeling.

It's all options Slice.

It’s not just about promotion though. Once you’ve got up you need to stay up and that is far more difficult than getting a team up who have better players, more money and a larger wage bill than most of the division. Allardyce record of being competitive in the Prem is far better / longer than Wilder’s. We have to a manager that can do both and given the choice between a one hit wonder at Prem level and someone who has had a number of hits i’m choosing the latter. 

I never expected anyone to keep the Summer squad up because it wasn’t good enough. It’s only since the glaring and long standing deficiencies have been addressed have we looked capable of competing. That was down to the current manager. 

I have no idea if he will want to stay on but a motivated and backed Allardyce with all the advantages that parachute payments bring is a very decent combination that most neutrals would say would make us favourites to get promotion. 

Two, three year projects with, ‘progressive’ coaches is not where we are as a club currently. If it were I would be looking at those types of managers but it’s about who is best given our circumstances nit who I would like because he plays the way I like the game played etc. This seems what some are basing their opinion on but that’s different from what we need imo. The last paragraph wasn’t about you Peachy just a an observation.
Reply
#43
(04-06-2021, 06:43 AM)Peachy Wrote:
(04-05-2021, 10:30 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(04-05-2021, 08:22 PM)Peachy Wrote:
(04-05-2021, 07:53 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(04-05-2021, 07:51 PM)Duffers Wrote: Wilder and Allardyce are about to have the same number of PL relegations on their CVs.

That’s the best you’ve got?  Big Grin

Wilder

Oxford - Won Promotion from Confrence to Div 2 in 18 months

Northampton - Won promotion from Div 2 despite huge financial problems and players and staff not being paid.

Sheffield Utd (First Season) - Won Promotion from Div 1 to Championship with 100 points.

Sheffield Utd (second season) Won promotion to Premier League.

Sheffield Utd (third season) Finished 9th in Premier league despite lowest budget. 

Sheffield Utd (fourth season) Relegated after a poor season. 

Big Sam

Notts County 1997 - Promoted from Div 3

Bolton 2000 2000 - Promoted via play offs

West Ham 2012 - Promoted via play offs

West Brom - Relegated

Wilder already has more promotions than Big Sam in a much shorter career. Impressive CV if you ask me. Certainly no risk in giving Wilder the gig if you want automatic promotion.

So basically Sam has got promoted at every club he's ever managed that wasn't in the top flight. Were all those at the first time of asking as well? Im asking cause I genuinely don't know.

In that case, why are you seemingly so against it? From your post above it seems both Wilder or Allardyce would be good options. Personally I'd prefer Wilder but both have cracking records in getting teams promoted

I'm not so against it totally. You'll see from my posts on other threads I can see some merit in it but still feel he's been an anticlimax and we've pissed loads of points away in "must win games" (his words) when the team have been too conservative in their approach. Wilders CV is the same if not better than Sam's in terms of promotion. And a much more recent history of the championship too.

The reason I'd want Sam to stay is if he can persuade Okay to stay and try and keep some of the group together. Seeing as the chances of that are slim I think Wilder might be the better bet. There will be plenty of othe managers out there too. Just look at the list of managers that have recently been promoted out of the championship. Hardly any had any experience of the division before being promoted.

The arguement for Sam by some seems to be he'd be a safe pair of hands. I'm just not as convinced that would be the case. As a separate issue I don't think he's got the drive for it either. That's just a gut feeling.

It's all options Slice.

Fair enough really. Good post
Reply
#44
Comparing BFS and Wilder is impossible. Even within the game BFS has 20 years more experience. He has spent many more seasons successfully managing at top level. BFS is now generally seen as the guy you go to if your club is struggling. Chris has done great things at SU but is now languishing below BFS's side. Wilders swapping Robinson for Burke was crazy and that alone must give BFS the edge on manager of choice
Reply
#45
(04-06-2021, 08:21 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Comparing BFS and Wilder is impossible. Even within the game BFS has 20 years more experience. He has spent many more seasons successfully managing at top level. BFS is now generally seen as the guy you go to if your club is struggling. Chris has done great things at SU but is now languishing below BFS's side. Wilders swapping Robinson for Burke was crazy and that alone must give BFS the edge on manager of choice

Made me loff on a SU board at the weekend about Robinson’s first goal which stated “I can’t imagine our swapee doing that”
Reply
#46
(04-06-2021, 08:21 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Comparing BFS and Wilder is impossible. Even within the game BFS has 20 years more experience. He has spent many more seasons successfully managing at top level. BFS is now generally seen as the guy you go to if your club is struggling. Chris has done great things at SU but is now languishing below BFS's side. Wilders swapping Robinson for Burke was crazy and that alone must give BFS the edge on manager of choice

Allardyce for me, though if that were not possible for any reason then I would be happy to settle for Wilder. However, Wilders' record of total management of a premiership club does give me cause for concern, not least his buying record. The Robinson/Burke swap is the obvious one but paying £23+m for Brewster and then not getting a tune out of a player that IMHO is much better than any forward at the club smacks of ineptitude or obstinacy. Furthermore, if the Sheffield United owners comments are correct then his greed is no less than Allardyces', but he is not alone in that.
Reply
#47
There appears to be a lot of gooin round in circles, and not many names forth coming. Wilder, Cowley (again) Hughton, seems all the old gang, Brucie, Warnock et al are in situ somewhere, if you saw the lads faces coming off the field at Chelsea, they looked like dogs with 2 dicks, at last the penny had dropped! 10 men or not they had murdered Chelsea !.  IMO, leave it all as is, see the season out, sort out the loanees contracts with BS in charge and start in the Champ ( if thats where we are) running!  To be fair I'd be more worried if I was a Geordie  Tongue
Reply
#48
(04-06-2021, 06:43 AM)Peachy Wrote:
(04-05-2021, 10:30 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(04-05-2021, 08:22 PM)Peachy Wrote:
(04-05-2021, 07:53 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(04-05-2021, 07:51 PM)Duffers Wrote: Wilder and Allardyce are about to have the same number of PL relegations on their CVs.

That’s the best you’ve got?  Big Grin

Wilder

Oxford - Won Promotion from Confrence to Div 2 in 18 months

Northampton - Won promotion from Div 2 despite huge financial problems and players and staff not being paid.

Sheffield Utd (First Season) - Won Promotion from Div 1 to Championship with 100 points.

Sheffield Utd (second season) Won promotion to Premier League.

Sheffield Utd (third season) Finished 9th in Premier league despite lowest budget. 

Sheffield Utd (fourth season) Relegated after a poor season. 

Big Sam

Notts County 1997 - Promoted from Div 3

Bolton 2000 2000 - Promoted via play offs

West Ham 2012 - Promoted via play offs

West Brom - Relegated

Wilder already has more promotions than Big Sam in a much shorter career. Impressive CV if you ask me. Certainly no risk in giving Wilder the gig if you want automatic promotion.

So basically Sam has got promoted at every club he's ever managed that wasn't in the top flight. Were all those at the first time of asking as well? Im asking cause I genuinely don't know.

In that case, why are you seemingly so against it? From your post above it seems both Wilder or Allardyce would be good options. Personally I'd prefer Wilder but both have cracking records in getting teams promoted

I'm not so against it totally. You'll see from my posts on other threads I can see some merit in it but still feel he's been an anticlimax and we've pissed loads of points away in "must win games" (his words) when the team have been too conservative in their approach. Wilders CV is the same if not better than Sam's in terms of promotion. And a much more recent history of the championship too.

The reason I'd want Sam to stay is if he can persuade Okay to stay and try and keep some of the group together. Seeing as the chances of that are slim I think Wilder might be the better bet. There will be plenty of othe managers out there too. Just look at the list of managers that have recently been promoted out of the championship. Hardly any had any experience of the division before being promoted.

The arguement for Sam by some seems to be he'd be a safe pair of hands. I'm just not as convinced that would be the case. As a separate issue I don't think he's got the drive for it either. That's just a gut feeling.

It's all options Slice.

Exactly where I'm at Peachy.

I'm more excited by Wilder as he has a recent record of winning promotion and that's what we need. Sam is the perfect appointment if we need to survive in the PL but winning promotion requires a very different motivation and skill-set and I'm not sure I'm comfortable gambling our best chance of promotion on a man who's only managed in that division / been expected to win more than 1 in 3 to be a success once in 20 years.
Reply
#49
(04-06-2021, 09:28 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(04-06-2021, 06:43 AM)Peachy Wrote:
(04-05-2021, 10:30 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(04-05-2021, 08:22 PM)Peachy Wrote:
(04-05-2021, 07:53 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: That’s the best you’ve got?  Big Grin

Wilder

Oxford - Won Promotion from Confrence to Div 2 in 18 months

Northampton - Won promotion from Div 2 despite huge financial problems and players and staff not being paid.

Sheffield Utd (First Season) - Won Promotion from Div 1 to Championship with 100 points.

Sheffield Utd (second season) Won promotion to Premier League.

Sheffield Utd (third season) Finished 9th in Premier league despite lowest budget. 

Sheffield Utd (fourth season) Relegated after a poor season. 

Big Sam

Notts County 1997 - Promoted from Div 3

Bolton 2000 2000 - Promoted via play offs

West Ham 2012 - Promoted via play offs

West Brom - Relegated

Wilder already has more promotions than Big Sam in a much shorter career. Impressive CV if you ask me. Certainly no risk in giving Wilder the gig if you want automatic promotion.

So basically Sam has got promoted at every club he's ever managed that wasn't in the top flight. Were all those at the first time of asking as well? Im asking cause I genuinely don't know.

In that case, why are you seemingly so against it? From your post above it seems both Wilder or Allardyce would be good options. Personally I'd prefer Wilder but both have cracking records in getting teams promoted

I'm not so against it totally. You'll see from my posts on other threads I can see some merit in it but still feel he's been an anticlimax and we've pissed loads of points away in "must win games" (his words) when the team have been too conservative in their approach. Wilders CV is the same if not better than Sam's in terms of promotion. And a much more recent history of the championship too.

The reason I'd want Sam to stay is if he can persuade Okay to stay and try and keep some of the group together. Seeing as the chances of that are slim I think Wilder might be the better bet. There will be plenty of othe managers out there too. Just look at the list of managers that have recently been promoted out of the championship. Hardly any had any experience of the division before being promoted.

The arguement for Sam by some seems to be he'd be a safe pair of hands. I'm just not as convinced that would be the case. As a separate issue I don't think he's got the drive for it either. That's just a gut feeling.

It's all options Slice.

Exactly where I'm at Peachy.

I'm more excited by Wilder as he has a recent record of winning promotion and that's what we need. Sam is the perfect appointment if we need to survive in the PL but winning promotion requires a very different motivation and skill-set and I'm not sure I'm comfortable gambling our best chance of promotion on a man who's only managed in that division / been expected to win more than 1 in 3 to be a success once in 20 years.

Playing devil's advocate, surely it's the other way around? Of promotion and survival, promotion is the easier (we've never finished outside the top 6, regardless of manager) therefore Sam would be the pick, as, once promotion is achieved, we would have the "perfect" man for survival.

Finding a manager to get us up, with our budget, is relatively easy, finding one to keep us, with our budget, is far more difficult.
Reply
#50
(04-07-2021, 11:00 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(04-06-2021, 09:28 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(04-06-2021, 06:43 AM)Peachy Wrote:
(04-05-2021, 10:30 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(04-05-2021, 08:22 PM)Peachy Wrote: Wilder

Oxford - Won Promotion from Confrence to Div 2 in 18 months

Northampton - Won promotion from Div 2 despite huge financial problems and players and staff not being paid.

Sheffield Utd (First Season) - Won Promotion from Div 1 to Championship with 100 points.

Sheffield Utd (second season) Won promotion to Premier League.

Sheffield Utd (third season) Finished 9th in Premier league despite lowest budget. 

Sheffield Utd (fourth season) Relegated after a poor season. 

Big Sam

Notts County 1997 - Promoted from Div 3

Bolton 2000 2000 - Promoted via play offs

West Ham 2012 - Promoted via play offs

West Brom - Relegated

Wilder already has more promotions than Big Sam in a much shorter career. Impressive CV if you ask me. Certainly no risk in giving Wilder the gig if you want automatic promotion.

So basically Sam has got promoted at every club he's ever managed that wasn't in the top flight. Were all those at the first time of asking as well? Im asking cause I genuinely don't know.

In that case, why are you seemingly so against it? From your post above it seems both Wilder or Allardyce would be good options. Personally I'd prefer Wilder but both have cracking records in getting teams promoted

I'm not so against it totally. You'll see from my posts on other threads I can see some merit in it but still feel he's been an anticlimax and we've pissed loads of points away in "must win games" (his words) when the team have been too conservative in their approach. Wilders CV is the same if not better than Sam's in terms of promotion. And a much more recent history of the championship too.

The reason I'd want Sam to stay is if he can persuade Okay to stay and try and keep some of the group together. Seeing as the chances of that are slim I think Wilder might be the better bet. There will be plenty of othe managers out there too. Just look at the list of managers that have recently been promoted out of the championship. Hardly any had any experience of the division before being promoted.

The arguement for Sam by some seems to be he'd be a safe pair of hands. I'm just not as convinced that would be the case. As a separate issue I don't think he's got the drive for it either. That's just a gut feeling.

It's all options Slice.

Exactly where I'm at Peachy.

I'm more excited by Wilder as he has a recent record of winning promotion and that's what we need. Sam is the perfect appointment if we need to survive in the PL but winning promotion requires a very different motivation and skill-set and I'm not sure I'm comfortable gambling our best chance of promotion on a man who's only managed in that division / been expected to win more than 1 in 3 to be a success once in 20 years.

Playing devil's advocate, surely it's the other way around? Of promotion and survival, promotion is the easier (we've never finished outside the top 6, regardless of manager) therefore Sam would be the pick, as, once promotion is achieved, we would have the "perfect" man for survival.

Finding a manager to get us up, with our budget, is relatively easy, finding one to keep us, with our budget, is far more difficult.
I wonder whether that last paragraph will come to haunt you and others who seem to think that promotion is a foregone conclusion next season?
Bilic did a great job last season with a squad that was far from nailed on at the beginning of the season.
Plenty of clubs languishing in the lower championship thought they'd be up long before now. Plenty of them will provide stiff competition next season.
Whoever our manager is, I hope they'll be given time and patience.
I'm not holding my breath though.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)