Better than 3-5 at Old Trafford?
#1
I've always said that the proudest I've been at a game was at Old Trafford watching Cantello et al. Yesterday's performance 
comes a very close second.
Reply
#2
(04-04-2021, 07:35 PM)chipper Wrote: I've always said that the proudest I've been at a game was at Old Trafford watching Cantello et al. Yesterday's performance 
comes a very close second.

That 3-5 win was amazing but not as impressive as yesterday and several other away wins over the past 40 years.  United were very average in 78 and had even been relegated a couple of years earlier. They were very much a midtable side and we finished above them several times in that era.  The spending power gulf between us and Chelsea by comparison is enormous, and their recent form exceptionally good, so I would rank yesterday's win as better.
Reply
#3
As I said it’s the best win in the Prem era and as we’d left the first division in 86, by all reckoning the best for over 35 years.
Difference is with the United win in 78 it was a fantastic team who saw off Valencia that year and finished 3rd in the League.
Yesterday was like a total logic defying game which no commentator can put in perspective unless we stop up.
If we do stay up the legend of yesterday will grow into something special. If we don’t it’ll be remembered fondly but nothing else.
Reply
#4
The 1978 3-5 Man United game endorsed the coming of age of a quality side that needed real recognition and respect.
Yesterday was all about what potential a demoralised team could achieve if they played to their absolute limits against quality opposition.
Yesterday was a greater achievement, but they would have lost against the class of 78.
However, if they could have played each other on yesterday's form , I would like to have seen that game!
Reply
#5
(04-04-2021, 08:11 PM)Llandudno Baggie Wrote: The 1978 3-5 Man United game endorsed the coming of age of a quality side that needed real recognition and respect.
Yesterday was all about what potential a demoralised team could achieve if they played to their absolute limits against quality opposition.
Yesterday was a greater achievement, but they would have lost against the class of 78.
However, if they could have played each other on yesterday's form , I would like to have seen that game!

Football is a completely different game to 40 odd years ago. Better pitches and fitter players and softer  rules meaning the team of 78 would be down to 9 players in the first 15 minutes. 
You can only be the best of your era.
Reply
#6
For me, no. Not even close
Reply
#7
As has been said before on here it's not just performances but results. And what the result means whether it's a scrappy one nil or a nil nil that makes something special happen.

For me, and having thought this through, the game against Bradford away to gain promotion, the performance to get that result though not brilliant was poignant in the club's history. Second was at home against Swansea - great atmosphere and pushed us a bit further on.

Yesterday was good. Don't get me wrong.
Reply
#8
(04-04-2021, 10:03 PM)Bristolbion Wrote: For me, no. Not even close

Explain yourself? 

Im 55. I recall that date in Dec 78 well, 30th Dec. We had to put in perspective the might of them, we walloped United 4-0 twice at home in previous seasons. They hadn't won the league in over a decade and been relegated once in the meantime. They were nothing as a footballing force, but only in name for those a generation older who recall the Busby Babes. They were a faded star.

Televised games were rare then. We had 3 games on ITV Star Soccer and about 2, maybe 3 on MoTD. Some of the games were from Div 2.

Half of games were missed. Thousands of wonderful games galore just stuck in our memories.

We just so happened to be on telly that day. Just before then we supposedly were amazing in a 2-1 win at Highbury.

Yesterday was astonishing, but might be a one hit wonder. It's like saying Baker St(I know Gerry Rafferty had more than that) is better than anything the Beatles ever did. It's subjective.

Yesterday, was unbelievable. It was wondrous and joyous. It wasn't though a do or die moment, which is why it falls well short of things like the Palace win in 2002, Pompey 2005 etc. However a curt comment like that lacks depth.
Reply
#9
To be honest that was probably the best football to score goals since 78. Every goal was excellent and 2 were exceptional I cannot decide wether the 3rd or 4th was better.I’m going for the 4th because the football from start to finish was superb. It reminds me of 78 because then the goals were excellent and 2 were exceptional. The 78 side were a side to behold they were playing brilliant football most of that season, where as yesterday was a one off which was most unexpected.but wonderful to watch.
Reply
#10
My post referred to my being proud. I was at Old Trafford and we played the best I have seen. Our black players were booed. I know times were different. I was also at Bradford and Oldham and Wembley 68 and other great days. We won those matches too but didn't play anywhere near as well as at Old Trafford that day. My greatest day was Wembley 68 with my Dad. A day I'll never forget but I have to say we didn't play that well. Pride isn't just about our team winning.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)