Gibbs
#71
(03-23-2021, 05:09 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(03-23-2021, 05:04 PM)ElbowGrease1973 Wrote:
(03-23-2021, 04:24 PM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote:
(03-23-2021, 03:35 PM)TartanRug Wrote:
(03-23-2021, 03:19 PM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote: Silly (if entirely predictable) comment. He was one of our better players when relegated in 2018. And was excellent in the Play Off season 2018/19. Also started last seasons promotion season on form. Gibbs and Diangana were unstoppable at one point down the left flank. 33 games in his first season. 36 games in the next. Yes he has tailed off but I prefer to look at his 4 years with us as a whole rather than simply dwell on his injury plagued last 12 months.

+1
 
Some of the negative comments are way over the top, apart from the last 15 months odd he's been a good player for us. There's been plenty of players you could chuck into the waste of space category ahead of Gibbs.

Having said that we're definitely right to get rid now, agree the injuries have taken their toll and his attitude doesn't seem right any more.

Spot on. His time is now up. But for £6m we got far better value out of Gibbs than we have from some far more expensive players.
You're right, but that doesn't mean that Gibbs has been value for money, particularly when you factor in wages, or is beyond reproach.

As one of our experienced players, you'd have thought he'd have been a key component this season, and would have shown leadership skills, but it all went downhill after the stupid sending off at Everton. I'd like to think that we'll be able to find a replacement on a fraction of the wages that can comfortably give us more than Gibbs has contributed this season.

We already have found him, Conor Townsend!
Townsend has earned the right to be considered first choice left back now, but we'll need cover for him, which effectively is what Gibbs has now become. Another Townsend type buy from the lower leagues would be ideal.
Reply
#72
(03-23-2021, 06:19 PM)MrFizz Wrote: Townsend has improved every game he's played and is now a solid, reliable top of Champ/lower Prem full back. It is to his credit that he bided his time, got his head down and made himself into the player he is now. Just shows what can happen if you buy potential, and give them time.

Yep his attitude and application has been first class imho.
Reply
#73
(03-23-2021, 09:11 PM)TETLEY74 Wrote:
(03-23-2021, 06:19 PM)MrFizz Wrote: Townsend has improved every game he's played and is now a solid, reliable top of Champ/lower Prem full back. It is to his credit that he bided his time, got his head down and made himself into the player he is now. Just shows what can happen if you buy potential, and give them time.

Yep his attitude and application has been first class imho.

+1
Reply
#74
For me it's Townsend as first choice over Gibbs all day long now, Gibbs is maybe the better technical footballer but playing the style we do we need someone in that position who will also create some chances and Townsend at least sends the ball into the box when we go, on the rare occasion, forward. Gibb's too often is slow in receiving the ball doesn't get the ball forward and turns back to pass inside. Fair play to Townsend as he just seems to get better and better in a season where too many have failed to deliver up step up their game.
Reply
#75
We've had all sorts of left back troubles in recent years. Never properly replaced Robbo and the much-maligned Ridgewell. We had Brunt, Chester, Lescott and even Evans turning out there. Gibbs seemed to solve the problem for a while.

But recently, when we've been under pressure, when players needed to show their strength, Gibbs has been a constant sick note. When he has played he's done all the little things that full backs can do wrong to put their side in trouble. Weak in the air for far post crosses, getting caught for pace, drifting inside, playing attackers onside etc etc. We've lambasted Furlong, O'Shea and Townsend for some of their performances at full back, we've consigned Peltier to the scrap heap without seeing him play much at all and we've bemoaned the continuing absence of our saviour Kieran Gibbs. Yet he's been as bad as any of them.

I've tagged him in the category of "bad signing" alongside Gareth Barry. Unlike say Darren Fletcher, these two have not delivered what was needed from them when we needed it most.
Reply
#76
Gibbs has been a luxury player for 4 years, and one that we certainly cannot afford in the team when in the PL.

His best season was as a wingback under Moore where his defensive duties were limited. Whilst he can play the defensive side of the game, he just makes too many silly mistakes which are punished at this level.

Was completely the wrong player for a club like us to buy - ageing, high wages, chequered injury background and big fee - and completely the wrong player for Pulis to buy - an actual fullback. I’m not sure he deserves any real ill-will as for the most part he’s done as much as those around him, but he certainly won’t be missed or looked back on with any fondness. Definitely one for the “meh” category.

Fair play to him and his agent for securing a final payday in the sun. Meanwhile, Townsend has earned the right to be first choice next season, but we will need another LB to compete with him.
Reply
#77
Wouldn’t say he was “ageing” SW4. He was 27 when he signed, the four years he has spent here should have been his prime.
Reply
#78
(03-24-2021, 10:49 AM)Duffers Wrote: Wouldn’t say he was “ageing” SW4. He was 27 when he signed, the four years he has spent here should have been his prime.

Fair point Duffers.

Suppose what I meant to say was that his value was more likely to drop than go up whilst with us. A club in our financial position can’t afford to be investing £7m + 50k/wk on players who will be in their 30s come the end of the deal.

With all the associated costs and bonuses I imagine Gibbs has cost us close to £20m over 4 years. We can’t invest that into a player with no realistic opportunity to make a return.
Reply
#79
(03-24-2021, 11:04 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(03-24-2021, 10:49 AM)Duffers Wrote: Wouldn’t say he was “ageing” SW4. He was 27 when he signed, the four years he has spent here should have been his prime.

Fair point Duffers.

Suppose what I meant to say was that his value was more likely to drop than go up whilst with us. A club in our financial position can’t afford to be investing £7m + 50k/wk on players who will be in their 30s come the end of the deal.

With all the associated costs and bonuses I imagine Gibbs has cost us close to £20m over 4 years. We can’t invest that into a player with no realistic opportunity to make a return.

I think if he’d given us four years’ worth of performances to justify that cost then it wouldn’t be much of a problem. But he simply hasn’t.
Reply
#80
(03-24-2021, 11:16 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(03-24-2021, 11:04 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(03-24-2021, 10:49 AM)Duffers Wrote: Wouldn’t say he was “ageing” SW4. He was 27 when he signed, the four years he has spent here should have been his prime.

Fair point Duffers.

Suppose what I meant to say was that his value was more likely to drop than go up whilst with us. A club in our financial position can’t afford to be investing £7m + 50k/wk on players who will be in their 30s come the end of the deal.

With all the associated costs and bonuses I imagine Gibbs has cost us close to £20m over 4 years. We can’t invest that into a player with no realistic opportunity to make a return.

I think if he’d given us four years’ worth of performances to justify that cost then it wouldn’t be much of a problem. But he simply hasn’t.

I think the other issue is that majority of us knew this would be the case  when he signed!
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: