Allardyce.
(03-14-2021, 10:14 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(03-14-2021, 10:09 PM)Dumbo Wrote:
(03-14-2021, 10:02 PM)Baggie_Nick Wrote:
(03-14-2021, 08:37 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(03-14-2021, 07:49 PM)Hopalong Wrote: That's the position he played at Hudds when he score 19 last season - left of a front 3.  

You're right though Baggeridge, that is the $64,000 of the season - well one of them.   I can only assume it was felt he could play the lone-striker role which it certainly doesn't look as if he can, not in the Prem anyway, but he's been unlucky on a couple of occasions.  If he' taken those two gilt edged chances against Man City and Fulham it could have made a difference to the results and his confidence.  Sadly he didn't.


Grant scored 14 in 28 for Charlton in the first half of the 2018/19 season earning him a move to the Prem with Hudds in Jan 2019 (when he was 21) and he scored 4 in 13. 

Last season he scored 19 in 43.  

So he scored 23 for Hudds in 18 months.  Not bad.  

As I have mentioned before,  he scored more goals in the last two seasons than Watkins.  

We have potentially overpaid for him (we will only know in the fullness of time) but English players generally come with a premium and with Brexit this is likely to rise.   

Interestingly Benrahma is yet to score for West Ham in 20 appearances and will eventually cost then £30m.    He's two years older than Grant as is Watkins who will cost £33m, so you would think there's potential and development for Grant at 23.

The only season that matters when it comes to Watkins and Grant is this season, and Watkins has looked head and shoulders above Grant.

Benrhama was never going to make the step up. He’s not good enough for a mid table team to give him the freedom he needs to perform, and he’s not good enough to play for a PL side where he could have that level of freedom. 

Grant will be OK next year. He’s a decent enough Champ player who we overpaid for, but we should at least get a fair few goals from him next year.

Watkins
Benhrama
Grant

The hierarchy; you get what you pay for.

Grant will probably be okay or moreso next season but I'd love to get a Gayle in there to make our front line certain.

I’d love us to get Gayle on a free.

But...I watched Newcastle v Villa the other day and Gayle looked a mile off the player that played for us. I know there are a lot of different factors but you have to consider, his successful season here with us was  3 seasons ago. 

I’d still take him in a heart beat though.

Correct.
Gayle has played just over 1000 minutes in two seasons for Newcastle...that’s little over 10 games in 2 years...for the right wages, he’s worth the punt,  but regardless of last time he was here, it would be a punt.

Absolutely.
Reply
(03-14-2021, 10:25 PM)Baggie_Nick Wrote:
(03-14-2021, 10:14 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(03-14-2021, 10:09 PM)Dumbo Wrote:
(03-14-2021, 10:02 PM)Baggie_Nick Wrote:
(03-14-2021, 08:37 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: The only season that matters when it comes to Watkins and Grant is this season, and Watkins has looked head and shoulders above Grant.

Benrhama was never going to make the step up. He’s not good enough for a mid table team to give him the freedom he needs to perform, and he’s not good enough to play for a PL side where he could have that level of freedom. 

Grant will be OK next year. He’s a decent enough Champ player who we overpaid for, but we should at least get a fair few goals from him next year.

Watkins
Benhrama
Grant

The hierarchy; you get what you pay for.

Grant will probably be okay or moreso next season but I'd love to get a Gayle in there to make our front line certain.

I’d love us to get Gayle on a free.

But...I watched Newcastle v Villa the other day and Gayle looked a mile off the player that played for us. I know there are a lot of different factors but you have to consider, his successful season here with us was  3 seasons ago. 

I’d still take him in a heart beat though.

Correct.
Gayle has played just over 1000 minutes in two seasons for Newcastle...that’s little over 10 games in 2 years...for the right wages, he’s worth the punt,  but regardless of last time he was here, it would be a punt.

Absolutely.
Gayle? No thanks. Rather give our loaned out stars to hopefully reveal their potential.  Gayle is not worth the investment given his age and lack of 1st team football.
Reply
The investment comes in getting promoted to the premier league and the financial rewards that come with it. Gayle is more likely to get us there quicker than Callum Morton st this point
Reply
(03-15-2021, 09:06 AM)Sliced Wrote: The investment comes in getting promoted to the premier league and the financial rewards that come with it. Gayle is more likely to get us there quicker than Callum Morton st this point
Agree on the logic.. however he will look for at least a 2 year contract. He will potentially have Premier league suitors so expect 50 to 60k per week. Plus his inactivity and age make him an investment that doesn't cut it IMHO.  
If he were to be signed it would delight me to be proven wrong.
Reply
The only investment that counts over the next two seasons is promotion. Long term projects with an owner who wants to sell are off the agenda. Saying that I’m not sure about Gayle coming back when money could be better spent on a different type of forward who can bring others into play, perhaps an old fashioned target man... I know shockingly regressive
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: