Have we improved under Allardyce?
#31
(03-07-2021, 04:40 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(03-07-2021, 04:39 PM)devonstroller Wrote: Yes from me, the major difference being a proper defensive midfielder in the team. Not sure the manager has a direct impact on fitness levels. Would still have rather seen what Bilic did in the January transfer window - it's not like we could be any worse off.

Why?

He fucked the summer one up and was making us worse.

Again, why do fans love that guy? Don't see it.

I don't think he'd have kept us up,  but I think he had as much chance as anyone else, so just didn't think there was much point changing it at the time. I'd like to have seen what he did with the January window. He got Gallagher in, so he recognised the weakness there. Would he have looked for a player like Yokuslu? Would he have gone for someone like Diagne? Would he have got more points from the games we played? The irrefutable undeniable fact is that none of us know. 

We're relegated now (not quite a fact but near enough),  so I'm just not at all convinced that changing the manager (be it slav or anyone else) was a wise decision, unless they had clearly lost the dressing room, which Slav hadn't,  I believe.
Reply
#32
(03-07-2021, 07:49 PM)devonstroller Wrote:
(03-07-2021, 04:40 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(03-07-2021, 04:39 PM)devonstroller Wrote: Yes from me, the major difference being a proper defensive midfielder in the team. Not sure the manager has a direct impact on fitness levels. Would still have rather seen what Bilic did in the January transfer window - it's not like we could be any worse off.

Why?

He fucked the summer one up and was making us worse.

Again, why do fans love that guy? Don't see it.

I don't think he'd have kept us up,  but I think he had as much chance as anyone else, so just didn't think there was much point changing it at the time. I'd like to have seen what he did with the January window. He got Gallagher in, so he recognised the weakness there. Would he have looked for a player like Yokuslu? Would he have gone for someone like Diagne? Would he have got more points from the games we played? The irrefutable undeniable fact is that none of us know. 

We're relegated now (not quite a fact but near enough),  so I'm just not at all convinced that changing the manager (be it slav or anyone else) was a wise decision, unless they had clearly lost the dressing room, which Slav hadn't,  I believe.

Slav ignored those positions in the summer.
Reply
#33
(03-07-2021, 07:58 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(03-07-2021, 07:49 PM)devonstroller Wrote:
(03-07-2021, 04:40 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(03-07-2021, 04:39 PM)devonstroller Wrote: Yes from me, the major difference being a proper defensive midfielder in the team. Not sure the manager has a direct impact on fitness levels. Would still have rather seen what Bilic did in the January transfer window - it's not like we could be any worse off.

Why?

He fucked the summer one up and was making us worse.

Again, why do fans love that guy? Don't see it.

I don't think he'd have kept us up,  but I think he had as much chance as anyone else, so just didn't think there was much point changing it at the time. I'd like to have seen what he did with the January window. He got Gallagher in, so he recognised the weakness there. Would he have looked for a player like Yokuslu? Would he have gone for someone like Diagne? Would he have got more points from the games we played? The irrefutable undeniable fact is that none of us know. 

We're relegated now (not quite a fact but near enough),  so I'm just not at all convinced that changing the manager (be it slav or anyone else) was a wise decision, unless they had clearly lost the dressing room, which Slav hadn't,  I believe.

Slav ignored those positions in the summer.

?
Gallagher...?

He also said at the end of last season that the players deserved a shot at the premier,  which I think is fair enough. Relegation for us this season was not a disastrous outcome, particularly as we had succeeded in signing players with potential resale value
Reply
#34
(03-07-2021, 08:51 PM)devonstroller Wrote:
(03-07-2021, 07:58 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(03-07-2021, 07:49 PM)devonstroller Wrote:
(03-07-2021, 04:40 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(03-07-2021, 04:39 PM)devonstroller Wrote: Yes from me, the major difference being a proper defensive midfielder in the team. Not sure the manager has a direct impact on fitness levels. Would still have rather seen what Bilic did in the January transfer window - it's not like we could be any worse off.

Why?

He fucked the summer one up and was making us worse.

Again, why do fans love that guy? Don't see it.

I don't think he'd have kept us up,  but I think he had as much chance as anyone else, so just didn't think there was much point changing it at the time. I'd like to have seen what he did with the January window. He got Gallagher in, so he recognised the weakness there. Would he have looked for a player like Yokuslu? Would he have gone for someone like Diagne? Would he have got more points from the games we played? The irrefutable undeniable fact is that none of us know. 

We're relegated now (not quite a fact but near enough),  so I'm just not at all convinced that changing the manager (be it slav or anyone else) was a wise decision, unless they had clearly lost the dressing room, which Slav hadn't,  I believe.

Slav ignored those positions in the summer.

?
Gallagher...?

He also said at the end of last season that the players deserved a shot at the premier,  which I think is fair enough. Relegation for us this season was not a disastrous outcome, particularly as we had succeeded in signing players with potential resale value

It is disastrous if we never get promoted again. The Championship is getting ever tougher.

Some better acquisitions in summer and an organised and fit team and we could have stayed up.
Reply
#35
Slaven had clearly let fitness levels go. Players were lightweight and heads went down too easily.

Maybe if Sam had gotten Diagne and Okay on January 1st... we might have had a chance. But I've always felt he didnt trust us to attack. That cost us.

So... on balance... neither of the above.

But I'd rahter either of them than the likes of Pulis.
Reply
#36
(03-07-2021, 08:55 PM)Squid Wrote:
(03-07-2021, 08:51 PM)devonstroller Wrote:
(03-07-2021, 07:58 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(03-07-2021, 07:49 PM)devonstroller Wrote:
(03-07-2021, 04:40 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Why?

He fucked the summer one up and was making us worse.

Again, why do fans love that guy? Don't see it.

I don't think he'd have kept us up,  but I think he had as much chance as anyone else, so just didn't think there was much point changing it at the time. I'd like to have seen what he did with the January window. He got Gallagher in, so he recognised the weakness there. Would he have looked for a player like Yokuslu? Would he have gone for someone like Diagne? Would he have got more points from the games we played? The irrefutable undeniable fact is that none of us know. 

We're relegated now (not quite a fact but near enough),  so I'm just not at all convinced that changing the manager (be it slav or anyone else) was a wise decision, unless they had clearly lost the dressing room, which Slav hadn't,  I believe.

Slav ignored those positions in the summer.

?
Gallagher...?

He also said at the end of last season that the players deserved a shot at the premier,  which I think is fair enough. Relegation for us this season was not a disastrous outcome, particularly as we had succeeded in signing players with potential resale value

It is disastrous if we never get promoted again. The Championship is getting ever tougher.

Some better acquisitions in summer and an organised and fit team and we could have stayed up.

I think it would have been an enormous ask given our budget.
Reply
#37
(03-07-2021, 09:07 PM)devonstroller Wrote:
(03-07-2021, 08:55 PM)Squid Wrote:
(03-07-2021, 08:51 PM)devonstroller Wrote:
(03-07-2021, 07:58 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(03-07-2021, 07:49 PM)devonstroller Wrote: I don't think he'd have kept us up,  but I think he had as much chance as anyone else, so just didn't think there was much point changing it at the time. I'd like to have seen what he did with the January window. He got Gallagher in, so he recognised the weakness there. Would he have looked for a player like Yokuslu? Would he have gone for someone like Diagne? Would he have got more points from the games we played? The irrefutable undeniable fact is that none of us know. 

We're relegated now (not quite a fact but near enough),  so I'm just not at all convinced that changing the manager (be it slav or anyone else) was a wise decision, unless they had clearly lost the dressing room, which Slav hadn't,  I believe.

Slav ignored those positions in the summer.

?
Gallagher...?

He also said at the end of last season that the players deserved a shot at the premier,  which I think is fair enough. Relegation for us this season was not a disastrous outcome, particularly as we had succeeded in signing players with potential resale value

It is disastrous if we never get promoted again. The Championship is getting ever tougher.

Some better acquisitions in summer and an organised and fit team and we could have stayed up.

I think it would have been an enormous ask given our budget.

We've survived comfortably on less, even accounting for inflation. An organised and fit team should be a given, anyway.
Reply
#38
Now, yes. We look fitter, more organised and more competitive now than we have been at any point previously this season. But us getting worse under him initially which lasted for a fair period of time, and compounded by us only picking up 1 point from the Sheffield United and Fulham games, has basically cost us the remote chance of staying up.
Reply
#39
There are a number of measures of improvement. SJ not being compelled to look like a superhero every week, couple of clean sheets, getting into final third far more, fitness markedly improved, defence looking more organised.

But the improvement as said time and time again is too little, too late; and the biggest area lacking is that we are still too goal shy. In fact, after games like today’s, it’s amazing to think some teams are capable of scoring more than one goal in a game, yet we seem to excuse our lot for not doing so every week.

The Grady situation is perplexing and the ignorance of Robinson equally so. HRK always gets the nod first, but when was the last time he made an impact. Periera has gone backwards in recent weeks, Diang doesn’t seem to be as clinical as we’d hope, the final ball and set pieces let us down continuously.

Perhaps the challenge was too great. Perhaps the wrong man. What’s definite is that the shower that started were never good enough, and ‘trusting the players who got us promoted’ was akin to trusting the McCanns to babysit. Particularly after we limped over the line so unconvincingly after making out on social media that we had a squad full of 4-minute-milers.

A season to forget, which many of our first team will when they disappear.
Reply
#40
My heart sank when billic said on the pitch we are sticking with the lads..... I knew we was fucked from that day
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: