Allardyce is slowly making a difference
I get that Derek, however I think Appleton, with our budget and advantages in that league satisfies short term objectives while giving some sort of long term plan.

I can see him keeping us up if promoted with the usual, non covid backing we give managers. He certainly would have wanted a DM over Krov, and maybe wouldn't gave been so adamant Grant was the only possible answer up front as Bilic did. Those two changes would have changed a lot fir this season.
Reply
(02-28-2021, 10:44 AM)Brentbaggie Wrote:
(02-28-2021, 10:20 AM)TETLEY74 Wrote: I'm no big fan of Alladyce but all these BFS haters who want him gone really haven't cottoned on that we aint going to survive in the prem be this year or any other year pretty pleasing on the eye tippy tappy bollocks unless we get a sugar daddy who is prepared to bank roll us to the tune o £600-700millon, and we now it ain't going to happen, our best and only chance to compete in the prem is the likes ofBfs, uncle Roy, Pearson a pragmatic type of manager., I'd love to see Appleton eventually take over but don't rlthink he is ready yet, if he gets Lincoln up give him a season in the chump it's a bastard of a league to survive in see how he does. Let's stop the bitter infighting and just get behind the manager till end of season see where we are then. We'll that's my onions anyway.

I agree.  Sadly, I'd love to watch us play "the right way" but what's the point?  What I can't bear is the way pundits wax lyrical over Man City as if money has nothing to do with it.  It's the pretence of Sky & Match of the Day that the top clubs are in some way far simply more gifted than the rest of us.  They certainly are gifted shit loads of cash.  Whatever happened to all the checks on expenditure over income - or is Covid just a convenient flag of convenience to protect their power to shit on everyone else?

Even Wet Spam, whose fans were screaming for the Dildo Brothers to do one only four months ago, have suddenly turned a corner and made their way to the top table.  There's little doubt that Moyes has a lot to do with this but his pork barrel porn barons still managed to make funds available to him that most of the rest of the league can barely dream of.

I can barely watch us live now, not because it's simply too depressing to live in the vague hope of a win like yesterday but because the brand of football that has to be played - and I stress "has to", denies so much of what this club was once all about. We can moan about ditching Slav (whom I admired and liked) for Sam, but football in the top tier is no longer the game most of us remember.  For most clubs it is a battle of pragmatism against hope, practicalities against panache, and point clutching v a possible disastrous plunge through the divisions.  We tailor our hopes and dreams to mid-table 'respectability' - whatever that is. We take joy in the rare moments of the improbable - a Pereira touch, an Ajayi/Bartley headed goal, the unearthing of a gem like Yokuslu, Johnstone pulling off another incredible stop, even a grafting journeyman like Townsend defying the naysayers and proving he's not just a First Division full-back but someone with heart, energy and a give-it-all attitude.

Our problem is not that we want what we once know we had - a great club playing a great brand of football - or that any chance of silverware other than the Championship Trophy being in our cupboard is impossible.  It is that we have ended up knowing what we need is what has killed the game, someone with bucketloads of money.  If it happened most of us would be delighted because we might become a club able to play against the big boys and compete.  But by the same token we would lose any right to complain about the dreadful state of the game in this country and the 30 pieces of silver that have attracted so many great players to a fucking freezing island they'd only ever have visited to see the house where the Queen lives otherwise.
Well said bud bloody well said.
Reply
(02-28-2021, 02:12 PM)TETLEY74 Wrote:
(02-28-2021, 10:44 AM)Brentbaggie Wrote:
(02-28-2021, 10:20 AM)TETLEY74 Wrote: I'm no big fan of Alladyce but all these BFS haters who want him gone really haven't cottoned on that we aint going to survive in the prem be this year or any other year pretty pleasing on the eye tippy tappy bollocks unless we get a sugar daddy who is prepared to bank roll us to the tune o £600-700millon, and we now it ain't going to happen, our best and only chance to compete in the prem is the likes ofBfs, uncle Roy, Pearson a pragmatic type of manager., I'd love to see Appleton eventually take over but don't rlthink he is ready yet, if he gets Lincoln up give him a season in the chump it's a bastard of a league to survive in see how he does. Let's stop the bitter infighting and just get behind the manager till end of season see where we are then. We'll that's my onions anyway.

I agree.  Sadly, I'd love to watch us play "the right way" but what's the point?  What I can't bear is the way pundits wax lyrical over Man City as if money has nothing to do with it.  It's the pretence of Sky & Match of the Day that the top clubs are in some way far simply more gifted than the rest of us.  They certainly are gifted shit loads of cash.  Whatever happened to all the checks on expenditure over income - or is Covid just a convenient flag of convenience to protect their power to shit on everyone else?

Even Wet Spam, whose fans were screaming for the Dildo Brothers to do one only four months ago, have suddenly turned a corner and made their way to the top table.  There's little doubt that Moyes has a lot to do with this but his pork barrel porn barons still managed to make funds available to him that most of the rest of the league can barely dream of.

I can barely watch us live now, not because it's simply too depressing to live in the vague hope of a win like yesterday but because the brand of football that has to be played - and I stress "has to", denies so much of what this club was once all about. We can moan about ditching Slav (whom I admired and liked) for Sam, but football in the top tier is no longer the game most of us remember.  For most clubs it is a battle of pragmatism against hope, practicalities against panache, and point clutching v a possible disastrous plunge through the divisions.  We tailor our hopes and dreams to mid-table 'respectability' - whatever that is. We take joy in the rare moments of the improbable - a Pereira touch, an Ajayi/Bartley headed goal, the unearthing of a gem like Yokuslu, Johnstone pulling off another incredible stop, even a grafting journeyman like Townsend defying the naysayers and proving he's not just a First Division full-back but someone with heart, energy and a give-it-all attitude.

Our problem is not that we want what we once know we had - a great club playing a great brand of football - or that any chance of silverware other than the Championship Trophy being in our cupboard is impossible.  It is that we have ended up knowing what we need is what has killed the game, someone with bucketloads of money.  If it happened most of us would be delighted because we might become a club able to play against the big boys and compete.  But by the same token we would lose any right to complain about the dreadful state of the game in this country and the 30 pieces of silver that have attracted so many great players to a fucking freezing island they'd only ever have visited to see the house where the Queen lives otherwise.
Well said bud bloody well said.
Terrific post!
Reply
Birdman1811 Wrote:Appleton is also an extremely well regarded coach which certainly can't be said of Ferguson. He's also achieved pretty amazing results when actually given some time to enact things, his issue has been bad decision making when choosing jobs, however it's meant he knows how to deal with bad times too.

He is also very understanding of modern football and the difference in management now compared to 10-20 years ago. Something important for a club such as ours where the manager doesn't have total control by any means.

He instills discipline and plays, good but sensible football where fitness, work rate and determination are key traits. He improves players and builds strong squad dynamics.

He isn't the only one on my shortlist, but he's probably my favourite should we go for someone different.

This. He ticks the right boxes for me. Similar to when we appointed RDM and further back, Atkinson.  I take Derek's point about bias because he played for Albion but as long as he is a quality coach, that is just to our advantage. We can't simply un know him. I'm open minded for now because a lot of games will happen before May and neither Allardyce nor Appleton or AN Other need be concerned with anything other than doing their jobs for mow.
Reply
(02-28-2021, 04:28 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
Birdman1811 Wrote:Appleton is also an extremely well regarded coach which certainly can't be said of Ferguson. He's also achieved pretty amazing results when actually given some time to enact things, his issue has been bad decision making when choosing jobs, however it's meant he knows how to deal with bad times too.

He is also very understanding of modern football and the difference in management now compared to 10-20 years ago. Something important for a club such as ours where the manager doesn't have total control by any means.

He instills discipline and plays, good but sensible football where fitness, work rate and determination are key traits. He improves players and builds strong squad dynamics.

He isn't the only one on my shortlist, but he's probably my favourite should we go for someone different.

This. He ticks the right boxes for me. Similar to when we appointed RDM and further back, Atkinson.  I take Derek's point about bias because he played for Albion but as long as he is a quality coach, that is just to our advantage. We can't simply un know him. I'm open minded for now because a lot of games will happen before May and neither Allardyce nor Appleton or AN Other need be concerned with anything other than doing their jobs for mow.

Good reply TJ I’m open minded. Any manager that comes in has to get promotion that’s my expectation. Staying in the Championship for any length of time will see us where Blues are now.
Reply
(02-28-2021, 05:18 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(02-28-2021, 04:28 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
Birdman1811 Wrote:Appleton is also an extremely well regarded coach which certainly can't be said of Ferguson. He's also achieved pretty amazing results when actually given some time to enact things, his issue has been bad decision making when choosing jobs, however it's meant he knows how to deal with bad times too.

He is also very understanding of modern football and the difference in management now compared to 10-20 years ago. Something important for a club such as ours where the manager doesn't have total control by any means.

He instills discipline and plays, good but sensible football where fitness, work rate and determination are key traits. He improves players and builds strong squad dynamics.

He isn't the only one on my shortlist, but he's probably my favourite should we go for someone different.

This. He ticks the right boxes for me. Similar to when we appointed RDM and further back, Atkinson.  I take Derek's point about bias because he played for Albion but as long as he is a quality coach, that is just to our advantage. We can't simply un know him. I'm open minded for now because a lot of games will happen before May and neither Allardyce nor Appleton or AN Other need be concerned with anything other than doing their jobs for mow.

Good reply TJ I’m open minded. Any manager that comes in has to get promotion that’s my expectation. Staying in the Championship for any length of time will see us where Blues are now.

Agree there. We can spend an absolute maximum of 2 years down there, and ideally want to go straight back up. No talk of 3 or 4 year projects, they simply don't exist.
Reply
(02-28-2021, 11:35 AM)richbaggie Wrote:
(02-28-2021, 11:33 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(02-28-2021, 10:56 AM)richbaggie Wrote: What is the right way? I don't want to get all Derek here but I never really understand that term.

I personally like to see my teams mix it up a bit. Tippy tippy sideways backwards possession football is just as irritating to me as launching it into channels at every opportunity.

One thing I would say about Sam's football is it's a mixture of playing through the lines as well as hitting long.  We just don't particularly pass it well either way.

Ooh you bitch! 

Everyone has a preference on how they like to see football played but it’s very old argument with no right or wrong answer. The problem occurs when fans put parameters on how you get results and by and large it’s those who want easy on the eye football who set these parameters. I didn’t pluck the cliches I’ve used out the air they are used by fans to romanticise, complicate, set unrealistic measure of success and conversely afford managers they like more time. 

I had written this season off when the summer transfer window shut so my opinion on Allardyce staying is based on who is best to get us back up at the first ask and help build a squad that can compete. I’m not sure you can say any other candidate currently mentioned offers the same potential based on their CV to date. Three year parachute payments do not make long terms plan realistic.

My biggest concern with Allardyce is whether he has the energy and appetite for it. There are very much question marks around that.

Which is exactly my point of wanting him nowhere near the club next season should we go down

The Championship is  unforgiving, it’s a young mans league, playing 2-3 times a week, no rest bite, hours of scouting, Allardyce knows bugger all about the sides in the Championship, say what you want about Bilic but his knowledge of our players and the league when he came for his interview blew Dowling away, he also worked with our youth players, again something I have grave reservations with surrounding Sam

Finally I think a progressive coach with our squad and budget would get us promoted playing attacking football and scoring goals, pre lockdown and despite that December wobble we all enjoyed the football served up by Slav with the likes of Pereira/Grady etc flying I for ne doubt you would see anything similar under Sam

It’s a huge NO from me

Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Reply
(02-28-2021, 05:45 PM)Cuzer Wrote:
(02-28-2021, 11:35 AM)richbaggie Wrote:
(02-28-2021, 11:33 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(02-28-2021, 10:56 AM)richbaggie Wrote: What is the right way? I don't want to get all Derek here but I never really understand that term.

I personally like to see my teams mix it up a bit. Tippy tippy sideways backwards possession football is just as irritating to me as launching it into channels at every opportunity.

One thing I would say about Sam's football is it's a mixture of playing through the lines as well as hitting long.  We just don't particularly pass it well either way.

Ooh you bitch! 

Everyone has a preference on how they like to see football played but it’s very old argument with no right or wrong answer. The problem occurs when fans put parameters on how you get results and by and large it’s those who want easy on the eye football who set these parameters. I didn’t pluck the cliches I’ve used out the air they are used by fans to romanticise, complicate, set unrealistic measure of success and conversely afford managers they like more time. 

I had written this season off when the summer transfer window shut so my opinion on Allardyce staying is based on who is best to get us back up at the first ask and help build a squad that can compete. I’m not sure you can say any other candidate currently mentioned offers the same potential based on their CV to date. Three year parachute payments do not make long terms plan realistic.

My biggest concern with Allardyce is whether he has the energy and appetite for it. There are very much question marks around that.



The Championship is  unforgiving, it’s a young mans league, playing 2-3 times a week, no rest bite,

Cuzer

Is that no meal break?  Hard on Sam, that....agreed.
Reply
If it's a young man's league then 64 must count as young because that's how old Bielsa was when he won it with Leeds.
Reply
(02-28-2021, 06:21 PM)hudds Wrote:
(02-28-2021, 05:45 PM)Cuzer Wrote:
(02-28-2021, 11:35 AM)richbaggie Wrote:
(02-28-2021, 11:33 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(02-28-2021, 10:56 AM)richbaggie Wrote: What is the right way? I don't want to get all Derek here but I never really understand that term.

I personally like to see my teams mix it up a bit. Tippy tippy sideways backwards possession football is just as irritating to me as launching it into channels at every opportunity.

One thing I would say about Sam's football is it's a mixture of playing through the lines as well as hitting long.  We just don't particularly pass it well either way.

Ooh you bitch! 

Everyone has a preference on how they like to see football played but it’s very old argument with no right or wrong answer. The problem occurs when fans put parameters on how you get results and by and large it’s those who want easy on the eye football who set these parameters. I didn’t pluck the cliches I’ve used out the air they are used by fans to romanticise, complicate, set unrealistic measure of success and conversely afford managers they like more time. 

I had written this season off when the summer transfer window shut so my opinion on Allardyce staying is based on who is best to get us back up at the first ask and help build a squad that can compete. I’m not sure you can say any other candidate currently mentioned offers the same potential based on their CV to date. Three year parachute payments do not make long terms plan realistic.

My biggest concern with Allardyce is whether he has the energy and appetite for it. There are very much question marks around that.



The Championship is  unforgiving, it’s a young mans league, playing 2-3 times a week, no rest bite,

Cuzer

Is that no meal break?  Hard on Sam, that....agreed.

That would be a deal breaker tbf
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)