The Third Test
(02-25-2021, 10:24 PM)MancBaggie Wrote:
(02-25-2021, 10:15 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(02-25-2021, 10:00 PM)MancBaggie Wrote:
(02-25-2021, 09:56 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(02-25-2021, 09:49 PM)MancBaggie Wrote: Arf - I was at a cricket lunch hosted by Fat Gatt that was on that. Everyone regrets it now and at least him and Imran agreed that neutral umpires were the future. 

There’s a good book on the subject - It’s Not Cricket by Simon Rae
I was at a dinner with Gatting at New Road and spoke with him about it afterwards. He said the biggest shame was they were good enough not to need such tactics to win.

A Manchester property guy I know is big mates with Imran.

Who’s your property man in Manc?

I know plenty. This one is Manchester's largest private landlord. He owns Halfpenny Green Airport now.

If it’s Mcr Property Group - I’ve come across them
That would be them. I used to do alot with them. I'm "the other side of the fence" these days, though.
Reply
Well what a shitshow it turned out to be. England's strengths on a good day and a suitable wicket are definitely weaknesses when things don't work out.

Anderson and Broad - legends without doubt, but do they need to be treated with such deference? Woakes might have been more use than either of them with bat and ball in the last couple of tests. If he isn't picked we'll never know what he can do. And let's mention the elephant in the room - the establishment are absolutely desperate for Jimmy and Stuart to set more records. Which isn't helping the team.

Archer - they worked so hard to get him playing for England. He's rewarded them with a few good performances and a lot of mediocrity, a tendency towards the hissy fit and a breakout from the bubble which cost him a Test appearance. Fair enough, but when he trots up and bowls at less than 85mph, I wonder why Mark Wood isn't playing. The arrogant assumption that Anderson, Broad and Archer would skittle the Indians was overtaken by events, but it was still very wrong. 

Bairstow and Stokes - players who can turn a game, any format of the game, in just a few overs, Stokes with either bat or ball. But they are both 125% unreliable, with a Pieterson-like "this is what I do" attitude. They were both pretty poor in this match - maybe cut Stokes a bit of slack for top-scoring in the second innings.

Wicket-keeping all-rounders - Foakes is better than Buttler and very much better than Bairstow behind the stumps. But we've got so used to having batsmen keeping wicket that we persevere with an unbalanced line-up. With Foakes in the gloves, Stokes has to bowl more than the paltry and poor 3 overs he managed to earn his place as an all-rounder.

All of the "elder statesmen" in the batting line-up are the flamboyant type, with the exception of Root. Will any of the youngsters grow into the steady batsman role? Cook and Strauss were in the commentary box on C4. I'm remembering Vaughan, Trescothick, Thorpe, Trott - are we even looking for that type of player, or encouraging young players to develop that kind of staying power?

And finally - I would never pick Jonny Bairstow for England again, in any form of cricket. Playing that sweep to his first ball in that situation was beyond disgraceful. End of International career, enjoy playing for Yorkshire if they'll have you.
Reply
(02-25-2021, 10:42 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Well what a shitshow it turned out to be. England's strengths on a good day and a suitable wicket are definitely weaknesses when things don't work out.

Anderson and Broad - legends without doubt, but do they need to be treated with such deference? Woakes might have been more use than either of them with bat and ball in the last couple of tests. If he isn't picked we'll never know what he can do. And let's mention the elephant in the room - the establishment are absolutely desperate for Jimmy and Stuart to set more records. Which isn't helping the team.

Archer - they worked so hard to get him playing for England. He's rewarded them with a few good performances and a lot of mediocrity, a tendency towards the hissy fit and a breakout from the bubble which cost him a Test appearance. Fair enough, but when he trots up and bowls at less than 85mph, I wonder why Mark Wood isn't playing. The arrogant assumption that Anderson, Broad and Archer would skittle the Indians was overtaken by events, but it was still very wrong. 

Bairstow and Stokes - players who can turn a game, any format of the game, in just a few overs, Stokes with either bat or ball. But they are both 125% unreliable, with a Pieterson-like "this is what I do" attitude. They were both pretty poor in this match - maybe cut Stokes a bit of slack for top-scoring in the second innings.

Wicket-keeping all-rounders - Foakes is better than Buttler and very much better than Bairstow behind the stumps. But we've got so used to having batsmen keeping wicket that we persevere with an unbalanced line-up. With Foakes in the gloves, Stokes has to bowl more than the paltry and poor 3 overs he managed to earn his place as an all-rounder.

All of the "elder statesmen" in the batting line-up are the flamboyant type, with the exception of Root. Will any of the youngsters grow into the steady batsman role? Cook and Strauss were in the commentary box on C4. I'm remembering Vaughan, Trescothick, Thorpe, Trott - are we even looking for that type of player, or encouraging young players to develop that kind of staying power?

And finally - I would never pick Jonny Bairstow for England again, in any form of cricket. Playing that sweep to his first ball in that situation was beyond disgraceful. End of International career, enjoy playing for Yorkshire if they'll have you.

Was listening to a few experts on TV and radio yesterday who were all in praise of how stokes tried to play yesterday. Said he was the one player who realised the situation and tried to keep the Indian attack guessing to stem the tide.
Reply
India are just a better test team than England at the moment - don't forget that India are missing half of their bowling line-up. Shami, Yadav and Jadeja (in particular) are outstanding. Outstanding as they are, I think England could play Ashwin and Azar a bit differently - as an off-spinner myself, the thing you crave more than anything is a batsman who plays you from the crease and allows you to settle. Bowling at somebody who uses their feet against you makes it so much harder, and I think by and large our batsman have just let Patel settle into his line & once you do that on a turner you're going to get out eventually.

When you look at the umpiring - it's really easy to call it cheating because they're home umpires. I'd say that the standard of on-field umpiring has been excellent, it's just the 3rd umpire that has been inconsistent. Other than the Rahane decision in the second test, I would say the right decision has been reached on all of their calls - it's just how they're making those decisions that needs to be questioned.

I've seen Stokes called a cheat for claiming that as a catch - I'm telling you that in real time, he will have genuinely thought he caught that, you honestly can't tell. I would also say RE Stokes - go back through the archives and look at some of the times he's walked when edging behind. Old Trafford in the 2019 Ashes the Australians hardly appealed and he walked off, he's many things, but a cheat isn't one of them. I think some of the criticism of Bairstow is harsh - that shot was awful, but walking out to bat when the ball is turning, the pressure is on and men are around the bat is SO hard. Add in the fact he's not played any cricket for a month, and on a pair. I think he can be cut some slack.

The pitches in the 2nd and 3rd tests have been poor - the sad thing is that India don't need to prepare such awful wickets to win. I think they just panicked after the 1st test, and I think they should be sanctioned by the ICC because it's not good for cricket. I hope that we don't return the favour in the summer - I want to see a fair contest on good wickets.
Reply
The thing that bugs me with these home umpires is when it’s umpires call. We get trapped in front the umpire always seem to give it out, so if it’s close on review it’s umpires call and given out. Now when it’s the Indians get trapped in front they give it not out so on review it’s umpires call and not out. Yet both were hitting the stump in exactly the same place.no consistently just biase. It’s the same with the stumping both times we’re out yet both given not out. You can bet your last £ if it had been an England player both would have been given out. They even missed a catch on review because they don’t do there job properly. I said at the end of the 1st test we had no chance of winning this series and you can bet your life that the last test wicket will be a batters paradise.
Reply
(02-26-2021, 04:02 PM)wba13 Wrote: The thing that bugs me with these home umpires is when it’s umpires call. We get trapped in front the umpire always seem to give it out, so if it’s close on review  it’s umpires call and given out. Now when it’s the Indians get trapped in front they give it not out so on review it’s umpires call and not out. Yet both were hitting the stump in exactly the same place.no consistently just biase. It’s the same with the stumping both times we’re out yet both given not out. You can bet your last £ if it had been an England player both would have been given out. They even missed a catch on review because they don’t do there job properly. I said at the end of the 1st test we had no chance of winning this series and you can bet your life that the last test wicket will be a batters paradise.

You wouldn't be suggesting they are cheats, would you? Heaven forbid  Tongue
Reply
(02-26-2021, 05:50 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(02-26-2021, 04:02 PM)wba13 Wrote: The thing that bugs me with these home umpires is when it’s umpires call. We get trapped in front the umpire always seem to give it out, so if it’s close on review  it’s umpires call and given out. Now when it’s the Indians get trapped in front they give it not out so on review it’s umpires call and not out. Yet both were hitting the stump in exactly the same place.no consistently just biase. It’s the same with the stumping both times we’re out yet both given not out. You can bet your last £ if it had been an England player both would have been given out. They even missed a catch on review because they don’t do there job properly. I said at the end of the 1st test we had no chance of winning this series and you can bet your life that the last test wicket will be a batters paradise.

You wouldn't be suggesting they are cheats, would you? Heaven forbid  Tongue
No of course not.  He leaves that to others.  Peace.
Reply
(02-25-2021, 10:42 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Well what a shitshow it turned out to be. England's strengths on a good day and a suitable wicket are definitely weaknesses when things don't work out.

Anderson and Broad - legends without doubt, but do they need to be treated with such deference? Woakes might have been more use than either of them with bat and ball in the last couple of tests. If he isn't picked we'll never know what he can do. And let's mention the elephant in the room - the establishment are absolutely desperate for Jimmy and Stuart to set more records. Which isn't helping the team.

Archer - they worked so hard to get him playing for England. He's rewarded them with a few good performances and a lot of mediocrity, a tendency towards the hissy fit and a breakout from the bubble which cost him a Test appearance. Fair enough, but when he trots up and bowls at less than 85mph, I wonder why Mark Wood isn't playing. The arrogant assumption that Anderson, Broad and Archer would skittle the Indians was overtaken by events, but it was still very wrong. 

Bairstow and Stokes - players who can turn a game, any format of the game, in just a few overs, Stokes with either bat or ball. But they are both 125% unreliable, with a Pieterson-like "this is what I do" attitude. They were both pretty poor in this match - maybe cut Stokes a bit of slack for top-scoring in the second innings.

Wicket-keeping all-rounders - Foakes is better than Buttler and very much better than Bairstow behind the stumps. But we've got so used to having batsmen keeping wicket that we persevere with an unbalanced line-up. With Foakes in the gloves, Stokes has to bowl more than the paltry and poor 3 overs he managed to earn his place as an all-rounder.

All of the "elder statesmen" in the batting line-up are the flamboyant type, with the exception of Root. Will any of the youngsters grow into the steady batsman role? Cook and Strauss were in the commentary box on C4. I'm remembering Vaughan, Trescothick, Thorpe, Trott - are we even looking for that type of player, or encouraging young players to develop that kind of staying power?

And finally - I would never pick Jonny Bairstow for England again, in any form of cricket. Playing that sweep to his first ball in that situation was beyond disgraceful. End of International career, enjoy playing for Yorkshire if they'll have you.

Good post and spot on about Archer, I’m a huge Ollie Stone fan and he shows exactly what Archer should be doing, running in full pelt and bowling as fast as you can

Do a 6 over stint, have a breather and be ready for the captain next time he calls upon you

Archer ambles in as a rule, that’s fine but this 82mph bollocks is not what we want at all, even more so on these pitches the Indians have served up, got to be faster than the rest and keep the batsmen guessing. The hierarchy need a long stern word with him

I’ve no issue with Stokes or Bairstow, the approach was be positive, we couldn’t just sit in the crease like The Indians and we did in the first innings. Bairstow was in great nick in Sri Lanka then we send him home, Moeen takes wickets and is improving, he goes home, planning is all wrong but the Ashes are clearly our priority, India need to win this series at all costs for this ICC Test Championship bollocks

As for Broad how was he picked over Wood, Woakes or Stone? Always go with Jimmy he can be a threat on any pitch anywhere with his skill set but Broad is way behind Jimmy and the others carry more of a threat on these docile pitches for pace

India in home conditions are a serious side but starting in day 4 pitches has hardly helped anyone!

Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Reply
(02-26-2021, 04:02 PM)wba13 Wrote: The thing that bugs me with these home umpires is when it’s umpires call. We get trapped in front the umpire always seem to give it out, so if it’s close on review  it’s umpires call and given out. Now when it’s the Indians get trapped in front they give it not out so on review it’s umpires call and not out. Yet both were hitting the stump in exactly the same place.no consistently just biase. It’s the same with the stumping both times we’re out yet both given not out. You can bet your last £ if it had been an England player both would have been given out. They even missed a catch on review because they don’t do there job properly. I said at the end of the 1st test we had no chance of winning this series and you can bet your life that the last test wicket will be a batters paradise.

I think the one that annoyed me in this Test was the stumping chance. It was absolutely clear as they rolled the video back and forward that the batsman's toe pushed down an inch or more after the wicket was broken. The pitch isn't that soft, and they could have looked at different angles to see what was going on. The two lbws were different - for the early Root call, there seemed to be a deflection from bat in towards pad, for the later one (Stokes or Foakes, can't remember?) it was impossible to see which was hit first, so umpire's call. It's the air of bewilderment and general lack of clarity that winds up the viewers. But if you've ever been to India you'll realise that's how it is over there.

Noticing that Woakes has been sent home on pre-arranged rotation. Despite not being picked at all in the first three Tests. I sometimes wonder what the seal did to be so routinely overlooked. Saints Jimmy and Stuart and SuperJof had better get some wickets next time out. Is it too early to say that those three won't win us the Ashes?
Reply
(02-26-2021, 06:34 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:
(02-26-2021, 05:50 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(02-26-2021, 04:02 PM)wba13 Wrote: The thing that bugs me with these home umpires is when it’s umpires call. We get trapped in front the umpire always seem to give it out, so if it’s close on review  it’s umpires call and given out. Now when it’s the Indians get trapped in front they give it not out so on review it’s umpires call and not out. Yet both were hitting the stump in exactly the same place.no consistently just biase. It’s the same with the stumping both times we’re out yet both given not out. You can bet your last £ if it had been an England player both would have been given out. They even missed a catch on review because they don’t do there job properly. I said at the end of the 1st test we had no chance of winning this series and you can bet your life that the last test wicket will be a batters paradise.

You wouldn't be suggesting they are cheats, would you? Heaven forbid  Tongue
No of course not.  He leaves that to others.  Peace.

I’m not saying there cheats but through my glasses I can see the correct decision, do the Indian umpires wish to borrow them. There not cheats hmmmm they just see what they won’t to see. Angel
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 5 Guest(s)