Greed ?
#1
Why do people who have so much (multiple tens of millions say) always want so much more and also want to deny society money by avoiding their share of taxes ? 
These are the people who inherit or build up immense wealth on the backs of ordinary folk yet do everything to hoard more wealth and everything to deny their workers or fellow citizens a fair standard of living or a decent society.
They benefit from our infrastructure like roads and eduction ( to enable their workers, offices, factories etc) yet try everything to avoid paying a fair proportion in relation to the rest of us?
I have no problem with people being fairly rewarded very well but their has to be some limit to extreme surely ?
I’m certainly no communist but billionaires should not exist in this enlightened day and age.
Reply
#2
(02-12-2021, 03:06 PM)EastMidsBaggie Wrote: Why do people who have so much (multiple tens of millions say) always want so much more and also want to deny society money by avoiding their share of taxes ? 
These are the people who inherit or build up immense wealth on the backs of ordinary folk yet do everything to hoard more wealth and everything to deny their workers or fellow citizens a fair standard of living or a decent society.
They benefit from our infrastructure like roads and eduction ( to enable their workers, offices, factories etc) yet try everything to avoid paying a fair proportion in relation to the rest of us?
I have no problem with people being fairly rewarded very well but their has to be some limit to extreme surely ?
I’m certainly no communist but billionaires should not exist in this enlightened day and age.

I suppose if you're driven to make money and by little else then it becomes a question of when is enough, enough? From there it's probably easy to cross that threshold beyond which there's no such thing as enough. A couple of the most resentful people I've ever known were substantially wealthy.
Reply
#3
Good post EMB. What happened to the benevolent industrialists? Lever Bros, Cadburys and many more. Where the wealthy, realising they have more money than they realistically need, spread some wealth around to benefit the general population. There is a lot to be said for the Buddhist idea of compassion = personal happiness. Some of the most miserable folks I know are wealthy and some of the happiest don't have a pot.
Reply
#4
I do find this compulsion to want more and more money a vacuous pursuit. In some cases immoral given the way they acquired it and how hard they try to avoid putting it back into society. I have never understood those who use money as fluffer for their flaccid ego.
Reply
#5
Cadbury were Quakers and driven by their religious beliefs. The village was built booze-free and their workers were well looked after, which is also good for productivity.
Levers were slightly odder. Built Port Sunlight in a similar fashion to Bournville and took care of their staff here, but were known to use forced labour in Africa. Can't for the life of me remember where and too tired to check.
Studied 19th century public health during my degree and found it fascinating.

Anyway...eat the fucking rich.
Reply
#6
(02-12-2021, 03:06 PM)EastMidsBaggie Wrote: Why do people who have so much (multiple tens of millions say) always want so much more and also want to deny society money by avoiding their share of taxes ? 
These are the people who inherit or build up immense wealth on the backs of ordinary folk yet do everything to hoard more wealth and everything to deny their workers or fellow citizens a fair standard of living or a decent society.
They benefit from our infrastructure like roads and eduction ( to enable their workers, offices, factories etc) yet try everything to avoid paying a fair proportion in relation to the rest of us?
I have no problem with people being fairly rewarded very well but their has to be some limit to extreme surely ?
I’m certainly no communist but billionaires should not exist in this enlightened day and age.

I could name hundreds of multi millionaires or billionaires who've not only paid all the taxes due but have made huge philanthropic contributuions too. History is littered with them. But in modern times:

How about Tom Hunter who's given away £1 billion? Lord Sainsbury? Peter Cruddas? My mate Bob Edmiston? The list is endless.

Jim Ratcliffe of Ineos donated £100 million to create a new institute to fight antimicrobial resistance at Oxford University and £25 million to build a new prosthetics wing at the defence medical rehabilitation centre for wounded soldiers? Amongst hundreds of other donations in the UK and overseas.

On a wholly different scale Bil Gates has given over $50 billion to causes since 1994.

Warren Buffett $14.7 billion over 5 years, Michael Bloomberg $3 billion over 5 years, Walton Family (Walmart) $2.3 billion over 5 years - even Julian Robinson one of those nasty hedge fund types has given away $881 million - some 20% of his total wealth.

Without the products, services, innovations and productivity gains driven by the entrepreneurial spirit we would all be worse off. No one is "denying" anyone anything. If anything, they're enabling it.

To be quite honest, I don't think you know what you're talking about.
Reply
#7
Protheroe Wrote:
EastMidsBaggie Wrote:Why do people who have so much (multiple tens of millions say) always want so much more and also want to deny society money by avoiding their share of taxes ? 
These are the people who inherit or build up immense wealth on the backs of ordinary folk yet do everything to hoard more wealth and everything to deny their workers or fellow citizens a fair standard of living or a decent society.
They benefit from our infrastructure like roads and eduction ( to enable their workers, offices, factories etc) yet try everything to avoid paying a fair proportion in relation to the rest of us?
I have no problem with people being fairly rewarded very well but their has to be some limit to extreme surely ?
I’m certainly no communist but billionaires should not exist in this enlightened day and age.

I could name hundreds of multi millionaires or billionaires who've not only paid all the taxes due but have made huge philanthropic contributuions too. History is littered with them. But in modern times:

How about Tom Hunter who's given away £1 billion? Lord Sainsbury? Peter Cruddas? My mate Bob Edmiston? The list is endless.

Jim Ratcliffe of Ineos donated £100 million to create a new institute to fight antimicrobial resistance at Oxford University and £25 million to build a new prosthetics wing at the defence medical rehabilitation centre for wounded soldiers? Amongst hundreds of other donations in the UK and overseas.

On a wholly different scale Bil Gates has given over $50 billion to causes since 1994.

Warren Buffett $14.7 billion over 5 years, Michael Bloomberg $3 billion over 5 years, Walton Family (Walmart) $2.3 billion over 5 years - even Julian Robinson one of those nasty hedge fund types has given away $881 million - some 20% of his total wealth.

Without the products, services, innovations and productivity gains driven by the entrepreneurial spirit we would all be worse off. No one is "denying" anyone anything. If anything, they're enabling it.

To be quite honest, I don't think you know what you're talking about.

With respect, I know exactly what I'm talking about but except those laudable examples to quote.

However, I accept that it's complicated and we would have to analyse how that immense wealth had been accumulated:

[ul]
[li]Have they paid an appropriate proportion of tax for that wealth ? Most ordinary folk get taxed between 35-60% of income on earnings (tax/NI)[/li]
[li]Have they paid their workers a decent wage ?[/li]
[li]Have they hollowed out companies / starved ongoing concerns of real investment in order to grab wealth / raid the balance sheets ?[/li]
[li]What effects of their actions in the countries or communities where they have harvested their wealth ? Have they switched work around the globe with the tick of a pen regardless of the impacts ? [/li]
[li]Have they hidden wealth to avoid appropriate scrutiny and fair taxation ?[/li]
[li]Have they taken cheap money (loans etc) that is not accessable to the 'ordinary' man to access ? Have they then loaded the balance sheet of companies with that debt ?[/li]
[li]Have they behaved ethically / paid governments/authorities for influence and lobbied for favourable rules and regulations ?[/li]
[li]Have they just inherited the vast wealth and never really contributed to society ?[/li]
[/ul]

Most of all my point is that such vast wealth and 'never enough' attitude is the real problem.
And, who are they to amass that wealth and then 'play God' with where they decide who should benefit from their philanthropic contributions ? 

Nothing here is simple as I think you'd agree but much of the outcomes should be looked at when so few people can amass such crazy sums.
Reply
#8
I've heard that Phillip Green is a lovely chap too. ….. Oh, wait. No I haven't.
Reply
#9
(02-13-2021, 10:14 AM)Protheroe Wrote: Jim Ratcliffe

Hahahaha.

Imagine thinking Ratliffe is a philanthropist. He and his company are scum.
Reply
#10
(02-13-2021, 01:17 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(02-13-2021, 10:14 AM)Protheroe Wrote: Jim Ratcliffe

Hahahaha.

Imagine thinking Ratliffe is a philanthropist. He and his company are scum.

He has an exceptionally high opinion of you too. Whatever the ad hominem it doesn't change the fact that Ratcliffe and his firms have made huge donations over many many years.

(02-13-2021, 10:56 AM)EastMidsBaggie Wrote: With respect, etc

With respect, if you mess with the profit motive you'll just end up with lower tax receipts and zero philanthropy. And since when did the state know how to spend your money better than you do?

Markets - not governments - have raised, and will continue to raise billions of people out of abject poverty around the world. That is all that matters IMO, the rest just stinks of the politics of envy - which has always been an exceptionally strong stench on this board.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: