Harvey Elliott
#11
(02-11-2021, 12:20 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Sadly I expect the injury to be a pertinent factor in determining the transfer fee.

Remember the original move broke down because of a failed medical.

Surely the fee will be determined by his valuation at the 30th June 2020, not 31st January 2020.

At that date he had had a injury that had prevented a transfer happening, and had been out of action due to injury for 5 months.

Our only silver lining is that despite this injury, Palace still wanted him.

I'd imagine we will argue that he has played first team football for us since that failed transfer and that the medical issues he's now suffering with are down to him refusing to take the advice of our club staff and insisting on following the advice Palace gave.

Think this will be a very messy case to sort out - and we'll probably be the ones who lose out.

Then again, Palace now have a player who's not kicked a ball in over a year, is still suffering from unknown injury complications with rumours going round may never play again, but tied down to a 40k/wk salary for the next 4 years!

Nice work if you can get it.
Reply
#12
(02-11-2021, 11:35 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(02-11-2021, 11:32 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(02-11-2021, 10:40 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: I think there are a couple of differences but agree with a lot of what you’re saying.

Elliot was only 16 when he moved to Liverpool and hadn’t signed a professional contract. Ferguson was older and was a fixture in our first team. We’d also rejected a £10m+ Offer for him from the club in question just 6 months previous.

Elliott was still an untried kid when he moved and his value will have been based on that, not the progress we’ve seen in the last 2 years. Believe Liverpool offered about £700k, so the fact they’ve got over £4m and a record fee for a kid is relatively promising.

I expect Palace will try and screw us on the fitness aspect. “Yeah we agreed £11m but that’s before we discovered he was a crock”, especially if it takes another year and he’s barely kicked a ball for them.

The purpose of the committee is to set a price that reflects his value at the time of the transfer, not what they have learned after committing.

We won’t get £10m+, but I’d imagine we would be very disappointed if we didn’t see a £5-6m award.

Is the transfer fee not subject to a successful medical though?
Reply
#13
(02-11-2021, 12:36 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(02-11-2021, 12:20 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Sadly I expect the injury to be a pertinent factor in determining the transfer fee.

Remember the original move broke down because of a failed medical.

Surely the fee will be determined by his valuation at the 30th June 2020, not 31st January 2020.

At that date he had had a injury that had prevented a transfer happening, and had been out of action due to injury for 5 months.

Our only silver lining is that despite this injury, Palace still wanted him.

I'd imagine we will argue that he has played first team football for us since that failed transfer and that the medical issues he's now suffering with are down to him refusing to take the advice of our club staff and insisting on following the advice Palace gave.

Think this will be a very messy case to sort out - and we'll probably be the ones who lose out.

Then again, Palace now have a player who's not kicked a ball in over a year, is still suffering from unknown injury complications with rumours going round may never play again, but tied down to a 40k/wk salary for the next 4 years!

Nice work if you can get it.
Don't think he played for us after move broke down. Pretty sure last game was Cardiff away and that was before the transfer saga, might be wrong.

Last I heard is that he is currently out with a new injury picked up in training, so if he can't play again, should imagine Palaces insurance will pick up the bill.
Reply
#14
(02-11-2021, 01:48 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(02-11-2021, 12:36 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(02-11-2021, 12:20 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Sadly I expect the injury to be a pertinent factor in determining the transfer fee.

Remember the original move broke down because of a failed medical.

Surely the fee will be determined by his valuation at the 30th June 2020, not 31st January 2020.

At that date he had had a injury that had prevented a transfer happening, and had been out of action due to injury for 5 months.

Our only silver lining is that despite this injury, Palace still wanted him.

I'd imagine we will argue that he has played first team football for us since that failed transfer and that the medical issues he's now suffering with are down to him refusing to take the advice of our club staff and insisting on following the advice Palace gave.

Think this will be a very messy case to sort out - and we'll probably be the ones who lose out.

Then again, Palace now have a player who's not kicked a ball in over a year, is still suffering from unknown injury complications with rumours going round may never play again, but tied down to a 40k/wk salary for the next 4 years!

Nice work if you can get it.
Don't think he played for us after move broke down. Pretty sure last game was Cardiff away and that was before the transfer saga, might be wrong.

Last I heard is that he is currently out with a new injury picked up in training, so if he can't play again, should imagine Palaces insurance will pick up the bill.

Insurance became Palace’s responsibility as soon as I signed god them, and the value will take into what he was worth at the time he signed for them.  If his value is less than that now and he doesn’t play again then that’s for Palace to claim via insurance. 

As we turned down an offer of £11m for him FROM THE SAME CLUB a few months earlier that will massively influenced the tribunal’s valuation figure.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)