The license fee
(02-09-2021, 04:52 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
baggy1 Wrote:By commercialising the BBC you will lose tons of unique and groundbreaking content that otherwise would not be made because it isn't commercially viable.

BBC is predominantly the medium I use, both daytime (radio) and evening (TV). But having said that I don't think they can justify not having advertising when they bombard us constantly with adverts for their own stuff. Long term, I think dropping the ban on adverts might be the best option for them.

In a future world where the BBC have commercials and they have to make some budget decisions based on potential falling revenue they would get rid of stations such as Radio 3 and 6 straight away (the latter cutting the route to market for a number of upcoming bands that don't fit into the spotify / apple mindset) and we will be blessed with a Simon Cowell / JayZee world of entertainment.

They'd probably then look at national sporting events, without the proviso that certain events have to be shown to the public via the beeb, they wouldn't be able to compete with Sky, Amazon or BT for the rights therefore cutting the option for a large part of the population that can't afford subscription or pay per view TV. 

Childrens advertising would be very restricted making it unattractive to advertisers therefore Childrens TV would not be seen as revenue generating and slowly disappear.

World service would be on the hit list as well I would imagine.

Niche documentaries would be consigned to Sky Arts, the History Channel or Discovery, again all subscription so cutting out the poorer in society from getting access to.

It would be a long term car crash.

(02-09-2021, 05:03 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(02-09-2021, 04:44 PM)baggy1 Wrote: By commercialising the BBC you will lose tons of unique and groundbreaking content that otherwise would not be made because it isn't commercially viable.

Stuff that next to no-one watches then?

I wouldn't imagine you, Mrs P, Tarquin and Sara would watch it obviously, you are far too highbrow catching up on Tiger King and other such shows.

(02-09-2021, 04:52 PM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(02-09-2021, 04:44 PM)baggy1 Wrote: By commercialising the BBC you will lose tons of unique and groundbreaking content that otherwise would not be made because it isn't commercially viable.

Isn’t commercially viable?  Now we’re getting there. So if it was self funded they wouldn’t be able to spend as much as people wouldn’t want to pay that much to watch it?

As I said before... the BBC should be made available online globally via subscription and their revenue would probably be higher (if they pitched the subscription costs correctly) than what they currently receive from something far outdated and unjust. 

Just a pity we have to wait until 2027 (at the earliest) until this outdated income stream for the BBC is removed.

You've only learned today that pensioners don't have to pay for it so you'll excuse me for not taking too much notice of your in depth knowledge on the subject.
Reply
(02-09-2021, 05:03 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(02-09-2021, 04:44 PM)baggy1 Wrote: By commercialising the BBC you will lose tons of unique and groundbreaking content that otherwise would not be made because it isn't commercially viable.

Stuff that next to no-one watches then?

Well at least we will avoid a contrived outrage over the singing of Rule Britannia at the last night of the proms. Because without the BBC's televising of the whole event, the proms would disappear.
Reply
(02-09-2021, 05:03 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(02-09-2021, 04:52 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
baggy1 Wrote:By commercialising the BBC you will lose tons of unique and groundbreaking content that otherwise would not be made because it isn't commercially viable.

BBC is predominantly the medium I use, both daytime (radio) and evening (TV). But having said that I don't think they can justify not having advertising when they bombard us constantly with adverts for their own stuff. Long term, I think dropping the ban on adverts might be the best option for them.

In a future world where the BBC have commercials and they have to make some budget decisions based on potential falling revenue they would get rid of stations such as Radio 3 and 6 straight away (the latter cutting the route to market for a number of upcoming bands that don't fit into the spotify / apple mindset) and we will be blessed with a Simon Cowell / JayZee world of entertainment.

They'd probably then look at national sporting events, without the proviso that certain events have to be shown to the public via the beeb, they wouldn't be able to compete with Sky, Amazon or BT for the rights therefore cutting the option for a large part of the population that can't afford subscription or pay per view TV. 

Childrens advertising would be very restricted making it unattractive to advertisers therefore Childrens TV would not be seen as revenue generating and slowly disappear.

World service would be on the hit list as well I would imagine.

Niche documentaries would be consigned to Sky Arts, the History Channel or Discovery, again all subscription so cutting out the poorer in society from getting access to.

It would be a long term car crash.

(02-09-2021, 05:03 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(02-09-2021, 04:44 PM)baggy1 Wrote: By commercialising the BBC you will lose tons of unique and groundbreaking content that otherwise would not be made because it isn't commercially viable.

Stuff that next to no-one watches then?

I wouldn't imagine you, Mrs P, Tarquin and Sara would watch it obviously, you are far too highbrow catching up on Tiger King and other such shows.

(02-09-2021, 04:52 PM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(02-09-2021, 04:44 PM)baggy1 Wrote: By commercialising the BBC you will lose tons of unique and groundbreaking content that otherwise would not be made because it isn't commercially viable.

Isn’t commercially viable?  Now we’re getting there. So if it was self funded they wouldn’t be able to spend as much as people wouldn’t want to pay that much to watch it?

As I said before... the BBC should be made available online globally via subscription and their revenue would probably be higher (if they pitched the subscription costs correctly) than what they currently receive from something far outdated and unjust. 

Just a pity we have to wait until 2027 (at the earliest) until this outdated income stream for the BBC is removed.

You've only learned today that pensioners don't have to pay for it so you'll excuse me for not taking too much notice of your in depth knowledge on the subject.

Only pensioners on pension credit or another qualifying benefit don't have to pay for it - the majority of pensioners do have to pay
Reply
(02-09-2021, 05:03 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(02-09-2021, 04:52 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
baggy1 Wrote:By commercialising the BBC you will lose tons of unique and groundbreaking content that otherwise would not be made because it isn't commercially viable.

BBC is predominantly the medium I use, both daytime (radio) and evening (TV). But having said that I don't think they can justify not having advertising when they bombard us constantly with adverts for their own stuff. Long term, I think dropping the ban on adverts might be the best option for them.

In a future world where the BBC have commercials and they have to make some budget decisions based on potential falling revenue they would get rid of stations such as Radio 3 and 6 straight away (the latter cutting the route to market for a number of upcoming bands that don't fit into the spotify / apple mindset) and we will be blessed with a Simon Cowell / JayZee world of entertainment.

They'd probably then look at national sporting events, without the proviso that certain events have to be shown to the public via the beeb, they wouldn't be able to compete with Sky, Amazon or BT for the rights therefore cutting the option for a large part of the population that can't afford subscription or pay per view TV. 

Childrens advertising would be very restricted making it unattractive to advertisers therefore Childrens TV would not be seen as revenue generating and slowly disappear.

World service would be on the hit list as well I would imagine.

Niche documentaries would be consigned to Sky Arts, the History Channel or Discovery, again all subscription so cutting out the poorer in society from getting access to.

It would be a long term car crash.

(02-09-2021, 05:03 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(02-09-2021, 04:44 PM)baggy1 Wrote: By commercialising the BBC you will lose tons of unique and groundbreaking content that otherwise would not be made because it isn't commercially viable.

Stuff that next to no-one watches then?

I wouldn't imagine you, Mrs P, Tarquin and Sara would watch it obviously, you are far too highbrow catching up on Tiger King and other such shows.

(02-09-2021, 04:52 PM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(02-09-2021, 04:44 PM)baggy1 Wrote: By commercialising the BBC you will lose tons of unique and groundbreaking content that otherwise would not be made because it isn't commercially viable.

Isn’t commercially viable?  Now we’re getting there. So if it was self funded they wouldn’t be able to spend as much as people wouldn’t want to pay that much to watch it?

As I said before... the BBC should be made available online globally via subscription and their revenue would probably be higher (if they pitched the subscription costs correctly) than what they currently receive from something far outdated and unjust. 

Just a pity we have to wait until 2027 (at the earliest) until this outdated income stream for the BBC is removed.

You've only learned today that pensioners don't have to pay for it so you'll excuse me for not taking too much notice of your in depth knowledge on the subject.

I’m still waiting for your justification for giving one organisation money to enable you to watch another. 

It’s like paying M&S to be enable you to shop in Sainsburys even though you don’t want to buy anything from M&S.  Think about it!

“Ground breaking” isn’t justification.
Reply
Good point, Baggy 1. I'd prefer the Beeb to stay just the way it is (well, almost!), but these arguments are hard to counter. The one thing that concerns me most is that once it goes, it's gone for good.
Reply
(02-09-2021, 05:18 PM)strawman Wrote: Only pensioners on pension credit or another qualifying benefit don't have to pay for it - the majority of pensioners do have to pay

I know this, there are currently 750k that have applied for the exemption based on their pension credit situation. And also there are a 2.7M that have paid for it. I was pointing out the 1st part was news to FF this morning and yet by this afternoon he is an expert on the matter.
Reply
(02-09-2021, 05:03 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(02-09-2021, 04:52 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
baggy1 Wrote:By commercialising the BBC you will lose tons of unique and groundbreaking content that otherwise would not be made because it isn't commercially viable.

BBC is predominantly the medium I use, both daytime (radio) and evening (TV). But having said that I don't think they can justify not having advertising when they bombard us constantly with adverts for their own stuff. Long term, I think dropping the ban on adverts might be the best option for them.

In a future world where the BBC have commercials and they have to make some budget decisions based on potential falling revenue they would get rid of stations such as Radio 3 and 6 straight away (the latter cutting the route to market for a number of upcoming bands that don't fit into the spotify / apple mindset) and we will be blessed with a Simon Cowell / JayZee world of entertainment.

They'd probably then look at national sporting events, without the proviso that certain events have to be shown to the public via the beeb, they wouldn't be able to compete with Sky, Amazon or BT for the rights therefore cutting the option for a large part of the population that can't afford subscription or pay per view TV. 

Childrens advertising would be very restricted making it unattractive to advertisers therefore Childrens TV would not be seen as revenue generating and slowly disappear.

World service would be on the hit list as well I would imagine.

Niche documentaries would be consigned to Sky Arts, the History Channel or Discovery, again all subscription so cutting out the poorer in society from getting access to.

It would be a long term car crash.

So what's to stop them charging a subscription of £150 a year and those that want to can continue watching, presumeably those you say won't be able to afford other subscription tv, already pay the license fee, so there will be no difference.
Reply
(02-09-2021, 05:03 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(02-09-2021, 05:03 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(02-09-2021, 04:44 PM)baggy1 Wrote: By commercialising the BBC you will lose tons of unique and groundbreaking content that otherwise would not be made because it isn't commercially viable.

Stuff that next to no-one watches then?

I wouldn't imagine you, Mrs P, Tarquin and Sara would watch it obviously, you are far too highbrow catching up on Tiger King and other such shows.

Personal slight aside, I'm not sure what the argument is for a public service broadcaster making content that no-one watches?

You're also implying that nothing unique or groundbreaking is made commercially which is, frankly, bollocks.
Reply
I have no issue with paying £150 a year.
It’s only two months of my Sky, Netflix, Prime, and whatever other crap the wife has subscribed to.

What really annoys me is pensioners having to pay.
Reply
So your basic suggestion is to make it just like the other available stations, which begs the question why have it at all? There won't be an extra layer of advertising funds available all of a sudden, it will be the same amount as there is now just spread a little thinner between ITV, CH4, BBC, CH5, Sky etc, which inevitably means there standard of the existing non-subscription providers will drop (they will get less money), and potentially less choice, some channels will falter completely I would imagine if they have to go lower than some of the advertising on CH5.

Less quality, less choice, less options for the poorer in society, less educational content - sunlit uplands indeed.

And the 'we could make it subscription for the world service' line - of course all of these nations would pay for it when they can have CNN for free. So added to our reduced international aid budget and cutting world service we really are showing our future global influence stripes here.

Fuck me, all this because a few people that can afford Netflix and Sky don't really watch it any more.

(02-09-2021, 05:48 PM)Supamart Wrote: I have no issue with paying £150 a year.
It’s only two months of my Sky, Netflix, Prime, and whatever other crap the wife has subscribed to.

What really annoys me is pensioners having to pay.

The reason pensioners have to pay is because the government have pushed this agenda, the BBC wanted to continue as they are but unfortunately they upset our erstwhile leaders during Brexit who have now shown them who's boss.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)