Policy on school closures
#51
(01-02-2021, 10:32 AM)baggiebuckster Wrote: As with most decisions taken by this Government during this pandemic it boils down to them trying to balance the health of the nation with keeping a semblance of the economy running. In some ways they seem to be trying to remain popular but instead they have annoyed the hell out of a fair majority of people. Every time a decision has to made it gets leaked to the press and then invariably gets changed if the reaction is not to their liking.

With schools I can see the issue - how do parents go to work if they have to be at home to look after their kids? Not everyone is a key worker, not everyone is able to work from home and not everyone is on furlough. How do you deal with that if as suggested schools close until Easter? For a sizeable percentage of people any childcare is provided by grandparents but that is not an option at the moment. Obviously health and safety should be the key driver but unless they sort this issue out then there will be people taken to the brink financially in the next few months.
With schools the answer would be for key workers and vulnerable only and if you can do online for the rest. 
Know of a dad very ill after his son brought the virus back from school. 
Regarding this being political it’s not really. It’s more on health and dealing with an unprecedented situation. There’s complaints at the government but we all realise they are in a tough situation. 
I do wish that the media would focus on the way other nations are reacting more though. Seeing more of the world being in it together would bring more unity. The news has got very parochial.
Reply
#52
(01-02-2021, 10:32 AM)baggiebuckster Wrote: As with most decisions taken by this Government during this pandemic it boils down to them trying to balance the health of the nation with keeping a semblance of the economy running. In some ways they seem to be trying to remain popular but instead they have annoyed the hell out of a fair majority of people. Every time a decision has to made it gets leaked to the press and then invariably gets changed if the reaction is not to their liking.

With schools I can see the issue - how do parents go to work if they have to be at home to look after their kids? Not everyone is a key worker, not everyone is able to work from home and not everyone is on furlough. How do you deal with that if as suggested schools close until Easter? For a sizeable percentage of people any childcare is provided by grandparents but that is not an option at the moment. Obviously health and safety should be the key driver but unless they sort this issue out then there will be people taken to the brink financially in the next few months.

I also see the issue but if they are committed to keeping schools open, if at all possible, it makes not prioritising school staff for the vaccine even more incomprehensible for 2 reasons.
Firstly, a vaccinated workforce means fewer staff off ill or self-isolating. Secondly, it will make the likes of me feel safer to face hundreds of strong vectors every day.
Reply
#53
(01-02-2021, 11:50 AM)Solihull Throstle Wrote:
(01-02-2021, 10:32 AM)baggiebuckster Wrote: As with most decisions taken by this Government during this pandemic it boils down to them trying to balance the health of the nation with keeping a semblance of the economy running. In some ways they seem to be trying to remain popular but instead they have annoyed the hell out of a fair majority of people. Every time a decision has to made it gets leaked to the press and then invariably gets changed if the reaction is not to their liking.

With schools I can see the issue - how do parents go to work if they have to be at home to look after their kids? Not everyone is a key worker, not everyone is able to work from home and not everyone is on furlough. How do you deal with that if as suggested schools close until Easter? For a sizeable percentage of people any childcare is provided by grandparents but that is not an option at the moment. Obviously health and safety should be the key driver but unless they sort this issue out then there will be people taken to the brink financially in the next few months.

I also see the issue but if they are committed to keeping schools open, if at all possible, it makes not prioritising school staff for the vaccine even more incomprehensible for 2 reasons.
Firstly, a vaccinated workforce means fewer staff off ill or self-isolating. Secondly, it will make the likes of me feel safer to face hundreds of strong vectors every day.

+1
Reply
#54
Genuine question, but what is the reason behind Primary schools going back on the 4th and Secondary on the 18th? My partner works in a primary and I'm extremely concerned about the risk she will be exposed to from Monday.

What's the difference between primary and secondary in transmission terms?
Reply
#55
(01-02-2021, 12:17 PM)ericlegrisly Wrote: Genuine question, but what is the reason behind Primary schools going back on the 4th and Secondary on the 18th?  My partner works in a primary and I'm extremely concerned about the risk she will be exposed to from Monday.

What's the difference between primary and secondary in transmission terms?

I think historical data might suggest that the virus rarely affects kids of that age and there is little transmission between them.
This new variant appears to blow a lot of our existing knowledge out of the water.
If I were a primary teacher I would think very carefully about attending when the kids are back.
I have a feeling that the unions might actually force the issue and put the government in a situation where they must see sense..
We must remember that the role of unions is not all about pay but also safety and conditions.
I don't think many of the public, whatever their political persuasion, would be against them on this one.
Reply
#56
(01-02-2021, 11:04 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Seeing more of the world being in it together would bring more unity. The news has got very parochial.

Valid point: the collegiate approach was apparently one of the main reasons behind the rapid progress made in producing multiple vaccines.
Reply
#57
(01-02-2021, 11:50 AM)Solihull Throstle Wrote:
(01-02-2021, 10:32 AM)baggiebuckster Wrote: As with most decisions taken by this Government during this pandemic it boils down to them trying to balance the health of the nation with keeping a semblance of the economy running. In some ways they seem to be trying to remain popular but instead they have annoyed the hell out of a fair majority of people. Every time a decision has to made it gets leaked to the press and then invariably gets changed if the reaction is not to their liking.

With schools I can see the issue - how do parents go to work if they have to be at home to look after their kids? Not everyone is a key worker, not everyone is able to work from home and not everyone is on furlough. How do you deal with that if as suggested schools close until Easter? For a sizeable percentage of people any childcare is provided by grandparents but that is not an option at the moment. Obviously health and safety should be the key driver but unless they sort this issue out then there will be people taken to the brink financially in the next few months.

I also see the issue but if they are committed to keeping schools open, if at all possible, it makes not prioritising school staff for the vaccine even more incomprehensible for 2 reasons.
Firstly, a vaccinated workforce means fewer staff off ill or self-isolating. Secondly, it will make the likes of me feel safer to face hundreds of strong vectors every day.

Absolutely agree.
Reply
#58
(01-02-2021, 12:29 PM)Solihull Throstle Wrote:
(01-02-2021, 12:17 PM)ericlegrisly Wrote: Genuine question, but what is the reason behind Primary schools going back on the 4th and Secondary on the 18th?  My partner works in a primary and I'm extremely concerned about the risk she will be exposed to from Monday.

What's the difference between primary and secondary in transmission terms?

I think historical data might suggest that the virus rarely affects kids of that age and there is little transmission between them.
This new variant appears to blow a lot of our existing knowledge out of the water.
If I were a primary teacher I would think very carefully about attending when the kids are back.
I have a feeling that the unions might actually force the issue and put the government in a situation where they must see sense..
We must remember that the role of unions is not all about pay but also safety and conditions.
I don't think many of the public, whatever their political persuasion, would be against them on this one.

Thanks Soily, appreciate the response. I just fail to see why London (Tier 4) primaries close whilst everywhere else (tier 4) return on the 4th.
Reply
#59
The Education Union has asked for all primary schools to remain shut. As for all Teachers to be vaccinated in the first groups is wrong for me. I understand your concerns as my daughter works in a primary school and yes I’m worried for her health, but the elderly and the vulnerable must still come first as they are the most at danger. It has been proven that the younger adults do not get as severe symptoms as the elderly.
Reply
#60
(01-02-2021, 01:18 PM)wba13 Wrote: The Education Union has asked for all primary schools to remain shut. As for all Teachers to be vaccinated in the first groups is wrong for me. I understand your concerns as my daughter works in a primary school and yes I’m worried for her health, but the elderly and the vulnerable must still come first as they are the most at danger. It has been proven that the younger adults do not get as severe symptoms as the elderly.

Hi mate. I should clarify that. I meant they should be prioritised but not above the aged / vulnerable and frontline health workers, necessarily.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: