Fighting Talk
#21
(12-19-2020, 12:52 PM)Cuzer Wrote:
(12-19-2020, 12:09 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Colin Murray joins the ranks of sporting media nob-heads who can't recognise a disastrous run of form - that's if he's even looked at the stats or watched any of our matches at all. "He's been sacked for getting them promoted a year early. Ridiculous!" No, Colin, that's not why he was sacked.

However he’s correct

Slav clearly was told by the club there was a 2 year plan to get promoted, even talk of a 3rd season if necessary and promoting academy prospects into first team regulars

He gets up in one season, integrates Edwards and to a degree Harper, sees players excel on loan, brings down the average age of the side dramatically, pre Ivanovic and gets the boot for his troubles

Fucking joke decision but no surprise as Lai desperately wants out, best chance of selling is were a Prem club so no long term plan, structure or thought process just stop up at all costs so I can sell up

I’d rather do a Farke at Naaaarge personally, I’ve only just got over the Pulisnyears and here we fucking go again.........

Cuzer

This is right. We've taken a massive backwards step and the idea that only non-Albion fans see it this way because they lack some sort of insider insight is as laughable as it is depressingly bewildering. 
Sam Allardyce will not save us from relegation, so we've swapped a progressive manager and a plan for a dinosaur manager with no plan,  and made us a much less attractive club to play for at the same time.
Reply
#22
Bilic wasn't likely to sign another contract, so he wasn't likely to be here next season anyway.

And how was he progressive? Setting teams up to be beaten easily and unfit is a new form of progressive I didn't know about.

No team should ever concede 5 to Crystal fucking Palace ffs.
Reply
#23
(12-19-2020, 04:31 PM)devonstroller Wrote:
(12-19-2020, 12:52 PM)Cuzer Wrote:
(12-19-2020, 12:09 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Colin Murray joins the ranks of sporting media nob-heads who can't recognise a disastrous run of form - that's if he's even looked at the stats or watched any of our matches at all. "He's been sacked for getting them promoted a year early. Ridiculous!" No, Colin, that's not why he was sacked.

However he’s correct

Slav clearly was told by the club there was a 2 year plan to get promoted, even talk of a 3rd season if necessary and promoting academy prospects into first team regulars

He gets up in one season, integrates Edwards and to a degree Harper, sees players excel on loan, brings down the average age of the side dramatically, pre Ivanovic and gets the boot for his troubles

Fucking joke decision but no surprise as Lai desperately wants out, best chance of selling is were a Prem club so no long term plan, structure or thought process just stop up at all costs so I can sell up

I’d rather do a Farke at Naaaarge personally, I’ve only just got over the Pulisnyears and here we fucking go again.........

Cuzer

This is right. We've taken a massive backwards step and the idea that only non-Albion fans see it this way because they lack some sort of insider insight is as laughable as it is depressingly bewildering. 
Sam Allardyce will not save us from relegation, so we've swapped a progressive manager and a plan for a dinosaur manager with no plan,  and made us a much less attractive club to play for at the same time.

You've made some massive statements there:

1 - Allardyce will not save us from relegation
2 - Bilic is a progressive manager
3 - Allardyce is a dinosaur
4 - We are less attractive for players we try to sign

So I would say:

1 - I hope you're wrong - neither of us knows at the moment
2 - I couldn't see any style or even game plan from Bilic this season
3 - Cheap lazy opinion. Don't forget he was appointed as England manager at one stage and he's known for a technical approach to the game
4 - Pure surmise, unless of course you are Willie McKay with a loyal clientele of top players keeping you close to the grapevine

Onions, innit?
Reply
#24
(12-19-2020, 04:43 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(12-19-2020, 04:31 PM)devonstroller Wrote:
(12-19-2020, 12:52 PM)Cuzer Wrote:
(12-19-2020, 12:09 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Colin Murray joins the ranks of sporting media nob-heads who can't recognise a disastrous run of form - that's if he's even looked at the stats or watched any of our matches at all. "He's been sacked for getting them promoted a year early. Ridiculous!" No, Colin, that's not why he was sacked.

However he’s correct

Slav clearly was told by the club there was a 2 year plan to get promoted, even talk of a 3rd season if necessary and promoting academy prospects into first team regulars

He gets up in one season, integrates Edwards and to a degree Harper, sees players excel on loan, brings down the average age of the side dramatically, pre Ivanovic and gets the boot for his troubles

Fucking joke decision but no surprise as Lai desperately wants out, best chance of selling is were a Prem club so no long term plan, structure or thought process just stop up at all costs so I can sell up

I’d rather do a Farke at Naaaarge personally, I’ve only just got over the Pulisnyears and here we fucking go again.........

Cuzer

This is right. We've taken a massive backwards step and the idea that only non-Albion fans see it this way because they lack some sort of insider insight is as laughable as it is depressingly bewildering. 
Sam Allardyce will not save us from relegation, so we've swapped a progressive manager and a plan for a dinosaur manager with no plan,  and made us a much less attractive club to play for at the same time.

You've made some massive statements there:

1 - Allardyce will not save us from relegation
2 - Bilic is a progressive manager
3 - Allardyce is a dinosaur
4 - We are less attractive for players we try to sign

So I would say:

1 - I hope you're wrong - neither of us knows at the moment
2 - I couldn't see any style or even game plan from Bilic this season
3 - Cheap lazy opinion. Don't forget he was appointed as England manager at one stage and he's known for a technical approach to the game
4 - Pure surmise, unless of course you are Willie McKay with a loyal clientele of top players keeping you close to the grapevine

Onions, innit?
Does "progressive" mean "ordinary"? If so, I concur.
Reply
#25
(12-19-2020, 12:52 PM)Cuzer Wrote:
(12-19-2020, 12:09 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Colin Murray joins the ranks of sporting media nob-heads who can't recognise a disastrous run of form - that's if he's even looked at the stats or watched any of our matches at all. "He's been sacked for getting them promoted a year early. Ridiculous!" No, Colin, that's not why he was sacked.

However he’s correct

Slav clearly was told by the club there was a 2 year plan to get promoted, even talk of a 3rd season if necessary and promoting academy prospects into first team regulars

He gets up in one season, integrates Edwards and to a degree Harper, sees players excel on loan, brings down the average age of the side dramatically, pre Ivanovic and gets the boot for his troubles

Fucking joke decision but no surprise as Lai desperately wants out, best chance of selling is were a Prem club so no long term plan, structure or thought process just stop up at all costs so I can sell up

I’d rather do a Farke at Naaaarge personally, I’ve only just got over the Pulisnyears and here we fucking go again.........

Cuzer

Slav won 4 out his last 22 games. I'd be sacked from coaching my daughters team if I had that record.
Reply
#26
There are a definite 2 camps forming here, along with all the shite slinging that accompanies this. I can't speak for everyone that didn't want Big Sam but I'm sure my opinion won't be hugely different from theirs.
First, Slav's relationship with Dowling had clearly broken  down. But,this was almost certainly behind the "no intention of signing a new deal". He absolutely did get us up first year into the 2 years he was given. He hasn't been given any serious backing (almost certainly due to Covid). Never mind the line about being serious favourites for promotion, he replaced numerous players last season and got them to click immediately. Let's not forget the other directive. reduce the age of the squad which he did amazingly well with the regular playing of O'Shea, Edwards, Ajayi, Ferguson, Harper and arguably, Townsend.
OK, the minuses. Results and a lack of defensive cohesion coupled with the cardinal sin (in the EPL), of being crap at set pieces. I can't argue with that. So he has to go because now, EPL survival is the only aim. Replacing Slav with, let's say the Swansea guy or Paul Cook, it turns out, is no good to us. Now this is what disappoints me. We are making an about turn something akin to when we let a Pulis side (strict on defensive ideas),  be managed by Pardew, (no fucking ideas). We had a clear forward plan, younger players with sell on value and Championship proficiency.  Now we have a 4 month plan.
Yes. I will be shouting for Big Sam's team. I'd support Albion if we were owned by the Arabian Headchoppers and managed by Charles Manson. But I'm understandably miffed we are less likely to be seeing many Perieras and Dianganas arriving on the East Stand car park. And that, is simply that. Come on you Baggies!
Reply
#27
(12-19-2020, 06:18 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: There are a definite 2 camps forming here, along with all the shite slinging that accompanies this. I can't speak for everyone that didn't want Big Sam but I'm sure my opinion won't be hugely different from theirs.
First, Slav's relationship with Dowling had clearly broken  down. But,this was almost certainly behind the "no intention of signing a new deal". He absolutely did get us up first year into the 2 years he was given. He hasn't been given any serious backing (almost certainly due to Covid). Never mind the line about being serious favourites for promotion, he replaced numerous players last season and got them to click immediately. Let's not forget the other directive. reduce the age of the squad which he did amazingly well with the regular playing of O'Shea, Edwards, Ajayi, Ferguson, Harper and arguably, Townsend.
OK, the minuses. Results and a lack of defensive cohesion coupled with the cardinal sin (in the EPL), of being crap at set pieces. I can't argue with that. So he has to go because now, EPL survival is the only aim. Replacing Slav with, let's say the Swansea guy or Paul Cook, it turns out, is no good to us. Now this is what disappoints me. We are making an about turn something akin to when we let a Pulis side (strict on defensive ideas),  be managed by Pardew, (no fucking ideas). We had a clear forward plan, younger players with sell on value and Championship proficiency.  Now we have a 4 month plan.
Yes. I will be shouting for Big Sam's team. I'd support Albion if we were owned by the Arabian Headchoppers and managed by Charles Manson. But I'm understandably miffed we are less likely to be seeing many Perieras and Dianganas arriving on the East Stand car park. And that, is simply that. Come on you Baggies!
I am delighted withAllardyce for Bilic but what you say is all very fair.
Reply
#28
devonstroller Wrote:
Cuzer Wrote:
Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:Colin Murray joins the ranks of sporting media nob-heads who can't recognise a disastrous run of form - that's if he's even looked at the stats or watched any of our matches at all. "He's been sacked for getting them promoted a year early. Ridiculous!" No, Colin, that's not why he was sacked.

However he’s correct

Slav clearly was told by the club there was a 2 year plan to get promoted, even talk of a 3rd season if necessary and promoting academy prospects into first team regulars

He gets up in one season, integrates Edwards and to a degree Harper, sees players excel on loan, brings down the average age of the side dramatically, pre Ivanovic and gets the boot for his troubles

Fucking joke decision but no surprise as Lai desperately wants out, best chance of selling is were a Prem club so no long term plan, structure or thought process just stop up at all costs so I can sell up

I’d rather do a Farke at Naaaarge personally, I’ve only just got over the Pulisnyears and here we fucking go again.........

Cuzer

This is right. We've taken a massive backwards step and the idea that only non-Albion fans see it this way because they lack some sort of insider insight is as laughable as it is depressingly bewildering. 
Sam Allardyce will not save us from relegation, so we've swapped a progressive manager and a plan for a dinosaur manager with no plan,  and made us a much less attractive club to play for at the same time.

I haven't seen any comments from "non-Albion fans" saying that appointing Allardyce is a backwards step, only that sacking Bilic was harsh in the extreme considering what he had achieved and what squad he had post-transfer window.
Reply
#29
(12-19-2020, 12:52 PM)Cuzer Wrote:
(12-19-2020, 12:09 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Colin Murray joins the ranks of sporting media nob-heads who can't recognise a disastrous run of form - that's if he's even looked at the stats or watched any of our matches at all. "He's been sacked for getting them promoted a year early. Ridiculous!" No, Colin, that's not why he was sacked.

However he’s correct

Slav clearly was told by the club there was a 2 year plan to get promoted, even talk of a 3rd season if necessary and promoting academy prospects into first team regulars

He gets up in one season, integrates Edwards and to a degree Harper, sees players excel on loan, brings down the average age of the side dramatically, pre Ivanovic and gets the boot for his troubles

Fucking joke decision but no surprise as Lai desperately wants out, best chance of selling is were a Prem club so no long term plan, structure or thought process just stop up at all costs so I can sell up

I’d rather do a Farke at Naaaarge personally, I’ve only just got over the Pulisnyears and here we fucking go again.........

Cuzer

I’m with you on this Cuzer.

I’d be far more critical of Slav if he’d been backed more by the Club.

I don’t like Fat Sam and I’ve spoken to quite a few people this week who’ve had dealings with him and not one has anything positive to say.

It will be interesting to see how this pans out. Reverting to signing players like Tompkins ( who was pony when he came on against Liverpool today) is going back in time.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)