Last night & Ratings
#1
Before the Bilic news took over there was actually a very decent performance that has been overlooked & hardly discussed on here. 

I will give it a shot with my ratings on an excellent, disciplined, defensively sound performance. 

SJ - 9 - MOTM. What a transformation this season, like a different keeper

Furlong 7 - Disciplined & held his position better than I thought he could
Gibbs 7 Gives us better balance. 
Ajayi 9 A rock. Headed & cleared everything 
O’Shea 8 Fantastic reading of the game 

Sawyers 7 Much improved on Newcastle 
Livermore 7 Tired but stuck to his task
Gallagher 7 Kept shape & was always involved 

Diangana 7 At fault for their goal but improved 
Phillips 8 Defended brilliantly against Sterling 
Grant 5 Can’t play lone striker. Doesn’t hold it up, doesn’t work hard enough 

Austin 6 At least he tries but legs have gone
Krov 7 Busy
Peltier 6 He exists then
Reply
#2
Bit low on Sawyers and Gallagher for me. I’d go 8 for both. Sawyers would have been a 9 had he not given away a couple of free kicks in dangerous areas.

Agree with your comments on Grant - he’d be advised to spend the rest of the week watching videos of Rondon.
Reply
#3
Johnstone - 9

Furlong - 7
Ajayi - 9
O'Shea - 10 (motm)
Gibbs - 7

Phillips - 8
Sawyers - 9
Gallagher - 7
Livermore - 6
Diangana - 7

Grant - 6
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#4
A game to be endured not enjoyed.

We had to play a certain way o get anything from the game, and we did it brilliantly.

Thought Ajayi was absolutely outstanding and a deserved man of the match.. But i was particularly pleased for Dara O'Shea, a real coming of age performance . The kind of performance which makes me think he does have a good premiership career in front of him. Time now for him to be considered a central defender and not a full back?
Reply
#5
Totally agree re O’Shea, Shabs. This season he has only played in the centre though. He is full of guts and balls and we don’t have many of those. He actually makes less mistakes than Bartley and Ivanovic but I’d much prefer to watch him every week and let him develop even if it does mean the odd error.

Funny how our two most gutsy players are the youngest....
Reply
#6
I predicted a 1-2 win so am a bit disappointed not to have seen us sneak the 3 points.

Some super performances. Who changed the batteries in Phillips?
Reply
#7
Still wondering how the Amazon commentator got Sawyers and Gallagher confused.
Reply
#8
(12-16-2020, 06:24 AM)B36baggie Wrote: Before the Bilic news took over there was actually a very decent performance that has been overlooked & hardly discussed on here.

I will give it a shot with my ratings on an excellent, disciplined, defensively sound performance. 

SJ - 9 - MOTM. What a transformation this season, like a different keeper

Furlong 7 - Disciplined & held his position better than I thought he could
Gibbs 7 Gives us better balance. 
Ajayi 9 A rock. Headed & cleared everything 
O’Shea 8 Fantastic reading of the game 

Sawyers 7 Much improved on Newcastle 
Livermore 7 Tired but stuck to his task
Gallagher 7 Kept shape & was always involved 

Diangana 7 At fault for their goal but improved 
Phillips 8 Defended brilliantly against Sterling 
Grant 5 Can’t play lone striker. Doesn’t hold it up, doesn’t work hard enough 

Austin 6 At least he tries but legs have gone
Krov 7 Busy
Peltier 6 He exists then

Not quite true as there were a lot of posts full of praise for the team effort and individual performances. 

I wouldn’t give Ajayi a 9 as he needlessly gave the ball away a couple of times which meant we had to defend for our lives once more.

I’d give Furlomg less points,  maybe 4 due to celebrating black lives matter by going on his knee before city took a free kick Big Grin
Reply
#9
(12-16-2020, 07:42 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: A game to be endured not enjoyed.

We had to play a certain way o get anything from the game, and we did it brilliantly.

Thought Ajayi was absolutely outstanding and a deserved man of the match.. But i was particularly pleased for Dara O'Shea, a real coming of age performance .  The kind of performance which makes me think he does have a good premiership career in front of him. Time now for him to be considered a central defender and not a full back?

Agree its time for him and Semi tp be given time to form a partnership and play both in the best positions .
Reply
#10
An excellent performance that raise a lot of questions in lieu of the expected announcement today.

We showed last night all the facets that have been missing from our game since Slav arrived... there was defensive organisation, competence at set pieces and a clear plan which everyone bought into and knew their jobs. Can’t help but think if we’d shown a bit more of that this season Slav would be contacted up for the next few years. Unfortunately it’s too little, too late, and whilst I doubt we’ll find another manager with his charisma, charm and likeability, we can certainly find one who will bring more solidity, nous and organisation. Yes the players may have showed last night that they like Slav, but the manager’s job isn’t to be liked by players and fans, it’s to get results with what he has and Slav hasn’t been doing that for 8-9 months.

Johnstone - 9 - fabulous saves at the death, really impressing this season.

Furlong - 8 - probably his best defensive display since joining.
O’Shea - 9 - some excellent blocks, spot on positioning, may well save us some money this January!
Ajayi - 9 - colossal tonight, close to a 10 but made his customary howler under no pressure which should have been punished.
Gibbs - 8 - excellent defensively, and whilst Townsend tries hard, he doesn’t have the class Gibbs does

Livermore - 7.5 - stuck to his task well, was a little surprised to see him subbed so early

Phillips - 8.5 - the type of game you want Phillips playing in. Defensively protected Furlong well, did the donkey work many wingers won’t, and carried a threat breaking into space.
Gallagher - 8.5 - again his engine is so impressive - imagine he went for a run after the game just to relax. Wins so many second balls around our box and always ensures he finds another Baggies player or gets the foul.
Sawyers - 7.5 - did so much brilliantly last night, but in the final 15 minutes he was ghosted past several times, and gave away a couple very silly free kicks. Had City scored a winner chances are it would have come from one of his errors. Expected Krov to come on for him, not JL.
Diangana - 8.5 - Looked like the player who first arrived early last season... defensively excellent, pressed his man, won the ball high up the pitch and carried a threat when given permission to gamble.

Grant - 6 - jury still out. Felt he pressed a lot more than in previous games but went missing after 30 mins. Robinson still our first choice for me, and for a striker who is in the team because he can finish that miss early doors was terrible!

Austin - 6 - shocked it was him and not Robinson but did his defensive work well
Krov - 7 - neat and tidy
Peltier - n/a - I had absolutely no idea who it was coming on...
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: