VAR
#11
Never a penalty excellent tackle. But should not take so long to confirm or deny.
Reply
#12
(12-13-2020, 05:11 PM)TartanRug Wrote:
(12-13-2020, 05:01 PM)Duffers Wrote: Says a lot when the first two posts offer opposite views on the incident.

Looked a fair challenge in real time, then on the replays it looked a penalty. Either way I wouldn’t call it a “clear and obvious error”.

Strikes me these days that referees are happy to let VAR make the big calls.

The trouble is they're analysing everything to the minutest degree. The ref did well to stick with his decision, normally they cave in when told to look at the screen and are reminded who they have given a decision against...

Fixed...
Reply
#13
(12-13-2020, 05:37 PM)wba13 Wrote: Never a penalty excellent tackle. But should not take so long to confirm or deny.

He did not at any time have any contact with the ball!
The nearest he got was to kick the Fulham players foot on to the ball.
It was a penalty.
Reply
#14
Interesting to see some think that was a stonewall penalty. I was watching live and it wasn't in a million years a pen for me. It's what frustrates me so much about VAR - for decades, a challenge like that has taken place in the box, the player has won the ball and put it out for a corner and the game carries on. Not a single player appealed and the commentators were talking about the importance of getting challenges right in the box and applauding the player for doing so. Then VAR gets involved and it's down to slow motion replays and different angles and suddenly it looks more like a pen and doubt is sown and no-one's sure which way is what way and what way is which (to quote Dr Seuss). So it becomes forensic and boring and time-consuming and frankly a bit ridiculous. Just get on with it lads and play the game. I hate Marriner but credit for not changing his original decision. He would if it was against us, of course, or even the other way round in this game.
Reply
#15
(12-13-2020, 05:47 PM)Swagbaggie Wrote:
(12-13-2020, 05:37 PM)wba13 Wrote: Never a penalty excellent tackle. But should not take so long to confirm or deny.

He did not at any time have any contact with the ball!
The nearest he got was to kick the Fulham players foot on to the ball.
It was a penalty.

Do you want to borrow my glasses even mariner got it right he kicked the ball first.  Fabinho foot went underneath Cavalario. Never a penalty.
Reply
#16
I have just checked a close up video confirming what I said it was not a penalty took the ball it was a great tackle.
Reply
#17
(12-13-2020, 06:10 PM)wba13 Wrote: I have just checked a close up video confirming what I said it was not a penalty took the ball it was a great tackle.

bailey on Twitter: "@SkySportsPL @SkySports Clearly gets his foot first and which stops him from planting his foot https://t.co/zZ60cX0b7z" / Twitter

Clearly takes the left foot of the player first
Reply
#18
(12-13-2020, 05:11 PM)oldun Wrote:
(12-13-2020, 05:01 PM)Duffers Wrote: Says a lot when the first two posts offer opposite views on the incident.

Looked a fair challenge in real time, then on the replays it looked a penalty. Either way I wouldn’t call it a “clear and obvious error”.

Strikes me these days that referees are happy to let VAR make the big calls.
This is the problem, but to fair when Oliver is VAR he takes over anyway
Yep. I suppose that in football refs are under so much pressure to"get it right" they defer to VAR more than necessary.
That's partly the fault of managers, pundits and fans who want "consistency".
There's no such thing. Even with var, as we all know.
I'd get rid.
Reply
#19
VAR or no VAR it hasn't changed much. The elite clubs benefit more often than not.

It's  just another layer of bias.

It reduces the possibility  that a ref will have a brainstorm  and award a pen against
Liverpool, City etc
Reply
#20
(12-13-2020, 06:27 PM)strawman Wrote:
(12-13-2020, 06:10 PM)wba13 Wrote: I have just checked a close up video confirming what I said it was not a penalty took the ball it was a great tackle.

bailey on Twitter: "@SkySportsPL @SkySports Clearly gets his foot first and which stops him from planting his foot https://t.co/zZ60cX0b7z" / Twitter

Clearly takes the left foot of the player first

No he doesn’t, do a close up I did he kicks the ball  and at no time does he kick his foot. We will have to disagree on this  Smile
No falling out.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)