The Return of Brexit
I think if we were absenting ourselves from the EU because of the racist nature of some of it's members that would be a moral stance to be proud of. I doubt very much that was the basis for anything this govt. has done. A country like Hungary having a leader like Orban is a tragedy rather than an exemplar - but I have no doubt that Hungary's membership of the EU acts as a restraint on some of his wilder and more autocratic desires if not his present excesses. Outwith the EU the pressure upon such man would be far more difficult to exert.

We are leaving/have left the EU and there is no going back, but for me the idea that our sovereignty equals an ability to decide our own future has more to do with a petty nationalism that harks back to an age and a country that no longer exists, voted for primarily by an age group many of which will not live to be in it for very much longer. It is for me the kind of obsessive and petty nationalism that resulted in two world wars and which was one of the essential reasons for the beginnings of the project that eventually led to the EU. It can be argued, quite rightly, that the EU has come a long way and moved a long way from the moral imperative that part lay behind its instigation. What seems clear to me however is that specious platitudes about sovereignty are simply a camouflage to assuage the rather more undesirable elements of a political party held hostage by a group of obsessive, single issue complainants who have finally got their way and thus prevented Farage from dismembering the Tory party and exiling them from power.

I am highly fortunate in that my wife and children now have Irish passports thanks to their mother's parents' country of origin - the first thing we did when we knew the UK was leaving the EU. They can as a result continue to go anywhere in Europe, work, live and and stay as long they like - but I can't. The economic arguments for and against EU membership have much going for them and I can well understand why people remain so passionate about both sides. The reason I quoted Johnson's dictum about Patriotism being the last refuge of a scoundrel however is because he knew only too well that an appeal to nationalism was the action of a person who had lost most if not all other reasoned arguments in a debate. This country is not better than any other; it varies in degree and substance regarding race, morality, faith, and determination - but I am greatly saddened that so many have chosen to embrace a nationalist rhetoric that historically only ever leads to a deeply unpleasant and costly endgame.
Reply
'He rang you as well?'

[Image: 4awmks.jpg]
Reply
(12-12-2020, 01:11 PM)bradesbaggie Wrote: 'He rang you as well?'

[Image: 4awmks.jpg]

Yes he said something about the English are exceptional.
Reply
What an embarrassment we are. Still, you put a clown in charge and you get a circus.
Reply
(12-12-2020, 01:04 PM)Brentbaggie Wrote: I think if we were absenting ourselves from the EU because of the racist nature of some of it's members that would be a moral stance to be proud of.  I doubt very much that was the basis for anything this govt. has done.  A country like Hungary having a leader like Orban is a tragedy rather than an exemplar - but I have no doubt that Hungary's membership of the EU acts as a restraint on some of his wilder and more autocratic desires if not his present excesses.  Outwith the EU the pressure upon such man would be far more difficult to exert. 

We are leaving/have left the EU and there is no going back, but for me the idea that our sovereignty equals an ability to decide our own future has more to do with a petty nationalism that harks back to an age and a country that no longer exists, voted for primarily by an age group many of which will not live to be in it for very much longer.  It is for me the kind of obsessive and petty nationalism that resulted in two world wars and which was one of the essential reasons for the beginnings of the project that eventually led to the EU.  It can be argued, quite rightly, that the EU has come a long way and moved a long way from the moral imperative that part lay behind its instigation.  What seems clear to me however is that specious platitudes about sovereignty are simply a camouflage to assuage the rather more undesirable elements of a political party held hostage by a group of obsessive, single issue complainants who have finally got their way and thus prevented Farage from dismembering the Tory party and exiling them from power.

I am highly fortunate in that my wife and children now have Irish passports thanks to their mother's parents' country of origin - the first thing we did when we knew the UK was leaving the EU. They can as a result continue to go anywhere in Europe, work, live and and stay as long they like - but I can't.  The economic arguments for and against EU membership have much going for them and I can well understand why people remain so passionate about both sides.  The reason I quoted Johnson's dictum about Patriotism being the last refuge of a scoundrel however is because he knew only too well that an appeal to nationalism was the action of a person who had lost most if not all other reasoned arguments in a debate.  This country is not better than any other; it varies in degree and substance regarding race, morality, faith, and determination - but I am greatly saddened that so many have chosen to embrace a nationalist rhetoric that historically only ever leads to a deeply unpleasant and costly endgame.

Great post BB
Reply
(12-12-2020, 11:31 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: b) Unilateral free trade is flat-out stupid and the only reason to want it is if you personally stand to gain from the collapse of the UK's economy.

It's this sort of insulting and catastrophising response to a perfectly reasaonable position that serves to polarise positions.

The UK has a massive net trade deficit in goods with the EU. Tariff barriers are simply self harm.

In the event of zero tarifffs the economy will not "collapse" and it's ridiculous to suggest it would. We sell into major international markets (like the US) where we have no trade deal and US businesses & consumers face tariff barriers. We still manage to sell there. We will still sell into the EU, even if we face tariff barriers - let the EU punish its consumers.

There seems to be this ridiculous idea that if the EU puts a 30% tariff on a British carrot then British carrots will cost consumers 30% more in the EU. They won't. If the misunderstanding of tariffs is so great no wonder there are folk going round suggesting the economy will collapse. Of course it won't.

Let me be clear, I would prefer a 'thin' trade deal and I still think we'll get one. But suggesting that a policy of zero tariffs is flat-out stupid when the greatest beneficiaries will be consumers like you and me is.....flat out stupid.
Reply
(12-12-2020, 05:32 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(12-12-2020, 11:31 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: b) Unilateral free trade is flat-out stupid and the only reason to want it is if you personally stand to gain from the collapse of the UK's economy.

It's this sort of insulting and catastrophising response to a perfectly reasaonable position that serves to polarise positions.

The UK has a massive net trade deficit in goods with the EU. Tariff barriers are simply self harm.

In the event of zero tarifffs the economy will not "collapse" and it's ridiculous to suggest it would. We sell into major international markets (like the US) where we have no trade deal and US businesses & consumers face tariff barriers. We still manage to sell there. We will still sell into the EU, even if we face tariff barriers - let the EU punish its consumers.

There seems to be this ridiculous idea that if the EU puts a 30% tariff on a British carrot then British carrots will cost consumers 30% more in the EU. They won't. If the misunderstanding of tariffs is so great no wonder there are folk going round suggesting the economy will collapse. Of course it won't.

Let me be clear, I would prefer a 'thin' trade deal and I still think we'll get one. But suggesting that a policy of zero tariffs is flat-out stupid when the greatest beneficiaries will be consumers like you and me is.....flat out stupid.

No, Proth. Unilateral free trade is the absolute dumbest thing this country could do and the only people advocating it don't know what they are on about or stand to gain from destroying the domestic economy.

1. Food prices will go up domestically, not go down. Domestic producers won't be able to compete on exports due to them having a one-sided artificial barrier on trade and though tariffs on food from Africa and Europe won't increase they will be subject to non-tariff barriers which add cost that wasn't there due to the EU customs union and single market removing that red tape. Imports from the US and South America aren't cheaper when transport costs are factored in as they're barely cheaper than EU sourced produce as is and things like NZ lamb are already imported tariff free due to EU quotas so they won't be any cheaper, in fact they will also go up due to the aforementioned non-tariff barriers. The belief that consumables will be cheaper is based on absolute nonsense and misunderstanding on how we trade goods. The thing that is getting in the way of cheaper prices is standards which, I'm sure you agree, should not be diminished as they're based on welfare, health and environmental impact.

2. Manufacturing will be directly exposed to market dumping. This isn't a free market and is fundamentally illiberal, it also risks the viability of companies that are critical for national security. And if we counter-dump, we will be exposed to punitive measures which will be an even bigger barrier to export.

3. The UK won't be seen as a sensible place for modern supply chains as though imports won't be subject to new tariffs, exports will be and given how many big manufacturing plants rely on goods crossing the channel multiple times this will add costs to UK manufactured components, making domestic industry uncompetitive.

4. We are not a city state. The UK needs a diversified economy, we don't have the advantage of Hong Kong and Macau which are able to solely focus on a single service to prop up their economies as we don't have China next door to cover any issues.

5. We won't have any leverage for free trade agreements. Why would a company need a free trade agreement with the UK? Unless we're willing to make a customs union with them to remove non-tariff barriers but then that was already a huge point of contention so that's realistically not going to be on the table. So those issues won't be adressed.

6. Fewer jobs due to artificially uncompetitive industries collapsing needlessly, no decrease in cost of consumable items, how would things be better for consumers? Electronics might be cheaper but they'd also be scarcer due to red tape at ports and no forwarding available at EU ports and consumers would have less choice in the market with which where to buy them from.

And we need a comprehensive free trade agreement with the EU, not a thin one. Any other scenario puts us into a position of weakness whenever we're forced back to the table. The UK isn't just London and thinking we can be a client state to China like Hong Kong or Macau is daft, not even London is as reliant on a single service than those two countries are.
Reply
Cornwall...

Must be a mistake
Reply
(12-12-2020, 08:01 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Cornwall...

Must be a mistake

Similar promises have been made to some farming sectors (not all) with regard to replacing their CAP subsidies; not something I necessarily agree with but, that aside, those promises have been made. Grouse moors will be an interesting one: they presently receive agricultural subsidy (we might wonder why, but they do); it's because moorland is often suitable for grazing and that's all that's needed. The land doesn't actually have to be grazed to qualify.

It will be interesting to see how a powerful lobby group - one which consistently appears to be granted carte blanche to operate outside the law - fares under the new arrangements.
Reply
(12-12-2020, 11:07 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: So what would these gun boats do? Shout stop it? Board the boats and arrest them? Or is this just pointless posturing to play to the populist core?

They aren't sending gunboats, they're sending offshore patrol vessels that are already used to inspect fishing vessels in the UK EEZ and the Navy is doing it because we don't have a civil coastguard.

Complete non-story
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)