Spam vs Vile
#41
I was reading that in Holland they have a 10cm buffer where the linesman decision stands if within it. I think I would welcome that here. If the linesman doesn’t flag the close ones offside then more goals would stand. Ironically the Watkins one last night still wouldn’t have stood as was longer than 10cm.
Reply
#42
(12-01-2020, 08:11 AM)Olympic Wrote: I was reading that in Holland they have a 10cm buffer where the linesman decision stands if within it. I think I would welcome that here. If the linesman doesn’t flag the close ones offside then more goals would stand. Ironically the Watkins one last night still wouldn’t have stood as was longer than 10cm.

But they’d still be measuring to the millimetre.  10.1cm would be offside so you’d still have lines made.

In every version of offside there would be a line drawn whether you’re looking at feet, daylight between players, 10cms or any part of the body ahead.

The alternate is to give a 10 second still review with the naked eye and if they can’t tell with that then the on-field decision stands.

They’re so focused on trying to get the right decision there’s no allowance.  In cricket they go with the whole ball hitting wicket (or not) for lbw. If there’s less than a full ball then they go with umpires call.

I’d you can’t see the on/offside within a few seconds then go with the on field decision, put it on the big screen and mic everyone up whilst talking through it.

Give us transparency.
Reply
#43
(12-01-2020, 08:29 AM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(12-01-2020, 08:11 AM)Olympic Wrote: I was reading that in Holland they have a 10cm buffer where the linesman decision stands if within it. I think I would welcome that here. If the linesman doesn’t flag the close ones offside then more goals would stand. Ironically the Watkins one last night still wouldn’t have stood as was longer than 10cm.

But they’d still be measuring to the millimetre.  10.1cm would be offside so you’d still have lines made.

In every version of offside there would be a line drawn whether you’re looking at feet, daylight between players, 10cms or any part of the body ahead.

The alternate is to give a 10 second still review with the naked eye and if they can’t tell with that then the on-field decision stands.

They’re so focused on trying to get the right decision there’s no allowance.  In cricket they go with the whole ball hitting wicket (or not) for lbw. If there’s less than a full ball then they go with umpires call.

I’d you can’t see the on/offside within a few seconds then go with the on field decision, put it on the big screen and mic everyone up whilst talking through it.

Give us transparency.

This has always been my view on offside decisions referred to var. If the offside isn't obvious leave it with the on field decision.
Reply
#44
(12-01-2020, 08:11 AM)Olympic Wrote: I was reading that in Holland they have a 10cm buffer where the linesman decision stands if within it. I think I would welcome that here. If the linesman doesn’t flag the close ones offside then more goals would stand. Ironically the Watkins one last night still wouldn’t have stood as was longer than 10cm.

Suarez and Earnshaw would be fucked with their teeth.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: