Populism bit shit isn’t it?!
#41
What is the motivation of private healthcare providers? To make people well so they don’t need their services? Reduce people doing harmful things like smoking? To inform people to make better health choices?

Another question can those frozen out of affording private healthcare be assured by government that their health provision and lives will be equal to those who go private? If so what is the incentive to pay into private health care?
Reply
#42
(11-17-2020, 12:05 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: What is the motivation of private healthcare providers? To make people well so they don’t need their services? Reduce people doing harmful things like smoking? To inform people to make better health choices?

Another question can those frozen out of affording private healthcare be assured by government that their health provision and lives will be equal to those who go private? If so what is the incentive to pay into private health care?

To offer a service and get paid for offering said service.

In most European countries with a Bismarck Model system instead of the Beveridge Model, as implemented in the UK and the Nordic countries, you have to pay into compulsory health insurance as a proportion of salary akin to a tax so paying for healthcare is functionally the same. In Germany you're allowed to use private health insurance instead of paying into the federal statutory insurance but you get access to the same hospitals and staff. The only exception as far as I know is Switzerland, where you have to get private health insurance.
Reply
#43
(11-17-2020, 12:50 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(11-17-2020, 12:05 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: What is the motivation of private healthcare providers? To make people well so they don’t need their services? Reduce people doing harmful things like smoking? To inform people to make better health choices?

Another question can those frozen out of affording private healthcare be assured by government that their health provision and lives will be equal to those who go private? If so what is the incentive to pay into private health care?

To offer a service and get paid for offering said service.

In most European countries with a Bismarck Model system instead of the Beveridge Model, as implemented in the UK and the Nordic countries, you have to pay into compulsory health insurance as a proportion of salary akin to a tax so paying for healthcare is functionally the same. In Germany you're allowed to use private health insurance instead of paying into the federal statutory insurance but you get access to the same hospitals and staff. The only exception as far as I know is Switzerland, where you have to get private health insurance.

The Bismarck System is a far superior system to our own. If people could actually see how much they're paying for healthcare they would be a lot more demanding for decent service and outcomes. 

I wouldn't countenance not have having private health insurance for my family in the UK after the horrendous heathcare experiences I've witnessed in the last decade. And on a moratorium basis it's relatively inexpensive. Happy to go without other stuff.
Reply
#44
(11-17-2020, 01:30 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(11-17-2020, 12:50 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(11-17-2020, 12:05 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: What is the motivation of private healthcare providers? To make people well so they don’t need their services? Reduce people doing harmful things like smoking? To inform people to make better health choices?

Another question can those frozen out of affording private healthcare be assured by government that their health provision and lives will be equal to those who go private? If so what is the incentive to pay into private health care?

To offer a service and get paid for offering said service.

In most European countries with a Bismarck Model system instead of the Beveridge Model, as implemented in the UK and the Nordic countries, you have to pay into compulsory health insurance as a proportion of salary akin to a tax so paying for healthcare is functionally the same. In Germany you're allowed to use private health insurance instead of paying into the federal statutory insurance but you get access to the same hospitals and staff. The only exception as far as I know is Switzerland, where you have to get private health insurance.

The Bismarck System is a far superior system to our own. If people could actually see how much they're paying for healthcare they would be a lot more demanding for decent service and outcomes. 

I wouldn't countenance not have having private health insurance for my family in the UK after the horrendous heathcare experiences I've witnessed in the last decade. And on a moratorium basis it's relatively inexpensive. Happy to go without other stuff.

I think those are fair points and it would be good to get a government get to grips with what they want from a health service, I have been pleased with the announcement of a mega testing facility (initially for covid) that will be kept for use with analysing the health of the nation and proactively managing it.

And we're lucky to be in a position to have private health insurance without having to go without other stuff, but my concern is if the focus shifts us towards having private care then, as Dekka says, what about those that can't afford it. There needs to be some halfway house whereby everyone has an equal chance of getting as a minimum a 'good' service - there will always be people that can afford the best but we can't head towards a system where those that can't afford anything get a 'poor' service.

I've no definition of good or poor btw
Reply
#45
(11-17-2020, 01:30 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(11-17-2020, 12:50 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(11-17-2020, 12:05 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: What is the motivation of private healthcare providers? To make people well so they don’t need their services? Reduce people doing harmful things like smoking? To inform people to make better health choices?

Another question can those frozen out of affording private healthcare be assured by government that their health provision and lives will be equal to those who go private? If so what is the incentive to pay into private health care?

To offer a service and get paid for offering said service.

In most European countries with a Bismarck Model system instead of the Beveridge Model, as implemented in the UK and the Nordic countries, you have to pay into compulsory health insurance as a proportion of salary akin to a tax so paying for healthcare is functionally the same. In Germany you're allowed to use private health insurance instead of paying into the federal statutory insurance but you get access to the same hospitals and staff. The only exception as far as I know is Switzerland, where you have to get private health insurance.

The Bismarck System is a far superior system to our own. If people could actually see how much they're paying for healthcare they would be a lot more demanding for decent service and outcomes. 

I wouldn't countenance not have having private health insurance for my family in the UK after the horrendous heathcare experiences I've witnessed in the last decade. And on a moratorium basis it's relatively inexpensive. Happy to go without other stuff.

The Bismarck system isn't "far superior". Prior to the formation of the NHS, our healthcare system was based on the Bismarck Model and the NHS is indisputably superior to the healthcare system used prior to 1948. The Bismarck Model and Beveridge Model are both funding models for healthcare, and you can get wildly different outcomes depending on the healthcare structure as a result, the Swedes use the Beveridge Model but it is far more decentralised than the NHS and they have better healthcare outcomes than the German healthcare system despite spending similar amounts as a proportion of GDP. Go back 20 years and the NHS had better healthcare outcomes than Germany despite spending similar amounts as a proportion of GDP. 

It's all well and good saying you want to change the funding model but I have seen absolutely no evidence that shows one model to be superior to the other as they are functionally the same thing, and within Western and Northern Europe (excluding Switzerland where they have the Bismarck Model without universal healthcare) they both are used to provide universal healthcare. All the evidence points to structural changes, number of beds and the number of doctors/GPs/nurses per capita being the defining factors that effect healthcare outcomes in Europe, if we replaced the NHS with social insurance and made no changes to funding or organisation with respect to trusts then I'd be very shocked if there was a change in healthcare outcomes. If people want changes to the system then you need to focus on the organisational structure and how funding is distributed instead of the funding model, and any changes need to be identified in an independent review to depoliticise it as per the Beveridge Report.
Reply
#46
(11-17-2020, 03:33 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(11-17-2020, 01:30 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(11-17-2020, 12:50 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(11-17-2020, 12:05 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: What is the motivation of private healthcare providers? To make people well so they don’t need their services? Reduce people doing harmful things like smoking? To inform people to make better health choices?

Another question can those frozen out of affording private healthcare be assured by government that their health provision and lives will be equal to those who go private? If so what is the incentive to pay into private health care?

To offer a service and get paid for offering said service.

In most European countries with a Bismarck Model system instead of the Beveridge Model, as implemented in the UK and the Nordic countries, you have to pay into compulsory health insurance as a proportion of salary akin to a tax so paying for healthcare is functionally the same. In Germany you're allowed to use private health insurance instead of paying into the federal statutory insurance but you get access to the same hospitals and staff. The only exception as far as I know is Switzerland, where you have to get private health insurance.

The Bismarck System is a far superior system to our own. If people could actually see how much they're paying for healthcare they would be a lot more demanding for decent service and outcomes. 

I wouldn't countenance not have having private health insurance for my family in the UK after the horrendous heathcare experiences I've witnessed in the last decade. And on a moratorium basis it's relatively inexpensive. Happy to go without other stuff.

The Bismarck system isn't "far superior". Prior to the formation of the NHS, our healthcare system was based on the Bismarck Model and the NHS is indisputably superior to the healthcare system used prior to 1948. The Bismarck Model and Beveridge Model are both funding models for healthcare, and you can get wildly different outcomes depending on the healthcare structure as a result, the Swedes use the Beveridge Model but it is far more decentralised than the NHS and they have better healthcare outcomes than the German healthcare system despite spending similar amounts as a proportion of GDP. Go back 20 years and the NHS had better healthcare outcomes than Germany despite spending similar amounts as a proportion of GDP. 

It's all well and good saying you want to change the funding model but I have seen absolutely no evidence that shows one model to be superior to the other as they are functionally the same thing, and within Western and Northern Europe (excluding Switzerland where they have the Bismarck Model without universal healthcare) they both are used to provide universal healthcare. All the evidence points to structural changes, number of beds and the number of doctors/GPs/nurses per capita being the defining factors that effect healthcare outcomes in Europe, if we replaced the NHS with social insurance and made no changes to funding or organisation with respect to trusts then I'd be very shocked if there was a change in healthcare outcomes. If people want changes to the system then you need to focus on the organisational structure and how funding is distributed instead of the funding model, and any changes need to be identified in an independent review to depoliticise it as per the Beveridge Report.

The reason I stated was that you actually see what you paying. If people in this country had any notion of how much they're stiffed for healthcare through their taxes the resulting outcry would ensure improvemements.
Reply
#47
(11-17-2020, 07:52 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(11-17-2020, 03:33 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(11-17-2020, 01:30 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(11-17-2020, 12:50 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(11-17-2020, 12:05 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: What is the motivation of private healthcare providers? To make people well so they don’t need their services? Reduce people doing harmful things like smoking? To inform people to make better health choices?

Another question can those frozen out of affording private healthcare be assured by government that their health provision and lives will be equal to those who go private? If so what is the incentive to pay into private health care?

To offer a service and get paid for offering said service.

In most European countries with a Bismarck Model system instead of the Beveridge Model, as implemented in the UK and the Nordic countries, you have to pay into compulsory health insurance as a proportion of salary akin to a tax so paying for healthcare is functionally the same. In Germany you're allowed to use private health insurance instead of paying into the federal statutory insurance but you get access to the same hospitals and staff. The only exception as far as I know is Switzerland, where you have to get private health insurance.

The Bismarck System is a far superior system to our own. If people could actually see how much they're paying for healthcare they would be a lot more demanding for decent service and outcomes. 

I wouldn't countenance not have having private health insurance for my family in the UK after the horrendous heathcare experiences I've witnessed in the last decade. And on a moratorium basis it's relatively inexpensive. Happy to go without other stuff.

The Bismarck system isn't "far superior". Prior to the formation of the NHS, our healthcare system was based on the Bismarck Model and the NHS is indisputably superior to the healthcare system used prior to 1948. The Bismarck Model and Beveridge Model are both funding models for healthcare, and you can get wildly different outcomes depending on the healthcare structure as a result, the Swedes use the Beveridge Model but it is far more decentralised than the NHS and they have better healthcare outcomes than the German healthcare system despite spending similar amounts as a proportion of GDP. Go back 20 years and the NHS had better healthcare outcomes than Germany despite spending similar amounts as a proportion of GDP. 

It's all well and good saying you want to change the funding model but I have seen absolutely no evidence that shows one model to be superior to the other as they are functionally the same thing, and within Western and Northern Europe (excluding Switzerland where they have the Bismarck Model without universal healthcare) they both are used to provide universal healthcare. All the evidence points to structural changes, number of beds and the number of doctors/GPs/nurses per capita being the defining factors that effect healthcare outcomes in Europe, if we replaced the NHS with social insurance and made no changes to funding or organisation with respect to trusts then I'd be very shocked if there was a change in healthcare outcomes. If people want changes to the system then you need to focus on the organisational structure and how funding is distributed instead of the funding model, and any changes need to be identified in an independent review to depoliticise it as per the Beveridge Report.

The reason I stated was that you actually see what you paying. If people in this country had any notion of how much they're stiffed for healthcare through their taxes the resulting outcry would ensure improvemements.

You don't see what you are paying for, you see some of what you're paying for. Let's use Germany as an example, Germans see how much they're paying for insurance but they don't see how much the government subsidises health insurance by funding publicly run hospitals, research and development, employer contributions, staff training and the proportion of tax surpluses being spent. As for how much we're stiffed for healthcare, the NHS has serious flaws but we spend far less per capita than all of the good healthcare systems in Europe no matter which funding model they implement, we're hardly being stiffed so much as we are paying for what we are getting.

Improvements for the NHS need to be identified by a public inquiry and report, akin to how the Beveridge Report was conducted, and the implementation needs to be apolitical.
Reply
#48
(11-19-2020, 12:45 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(11-17-2020, 07:52 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(11-17-2020, 03:33 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(11-17-2020, 01:30 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(11-17-2020, 12:50 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: To offer a service and get paid for offering said service.

In most European countries with a Bismarck Model system instead of the Beveridge Model, as implemented in the UK and the Nordic countries, you have to pay into compulsory health insurance as a proportion of salary akin to a tax so paying for healthcare is functionally the same. In Germany you're allowed to use private health insurance instead of paying into the federal statutory insurance but you get access to the same hospitals and staff. The only exception as far as I know is Switzerland, where you have to get private health insurance.

The Bismarck System is a far superior system to our own. If people could actually see how much they're paying for healthcare they would be a lot more demanding for decent service and outcomes. 

I wouldn't countenance not have having private health insurance for my family in the UK after the horrendous heathcare experiences I've witnessed in the last decade. And on a moratorium basis it's relatively inexpensive. Happy to go without other stuff.

The Bismarck system isn't "far superior". Prior to the formation of the NHS, our healthcare system was based on the Bismarck Model and the NHS is indisputably superior to the healthcare system used prior to 1948. The Bismarck Model and Beveridge Model are both funding models for healthcare, and you can get wildly different outcomes depending on the healthcare structure as a result, the Swedes use the Beveridge Model but it is far more decentralised than the NHS and they have better healthcare outcomes than the German healthcare system despite spending similar amounts as a proportion of GDP. Go back 20 years and the NHS had better healthcare outcomes than Germany despite spending similar amounts as a proportion of GDP. 

It's all well and good saying you want to change the funding model but I have seen absolutely no evidence that shows one model to be superior to the other as they are functionally the same thing, and within Western and Northern Europe (excluding Switzerland where they have the Bismarck Model without universal healthcare) they both are used to provide universal healthcare. All the evidence points to structural changes, number of beds and the number of doctors/GPs/nurses per capita being the defining factors that effect healthcare outcomes in Europe, if we replaced the NHS with social insurance and made no changes to funding or organisation with respect to trusts then I'd be very shocked if there was a change in healthcare outcomes. If people want changes to the system then you need to focus on the organisational structure and how funding is distributed instead of the funding model, and any changes need to be identified in an independent review to depoliticise it as per the Beveridge Report.

The reason I stated was that you actually see what you paying. If people in this country had any notion of how much they're stiffed for healthcare through their taxes the resulting outcry would ensure improvemements.

You don't see what you are paying for, you see some of what you're paying for. Let's use Germany as an example, Germans see how much they're paying for insurance but they don't see how much the government subsidises health insurance by funding publicly run hospitals, research and development, employer contributions, staff training and the proportion of tax surpluses being spent. As for how much we're stiffed for healthcare, the NHS has serious flaws but we spend far less per capita than all of the good healthcare systems in Europe no matter which funding model they implement, we're hardly being stiffed so much as we are paying for what we are getting.

Improvements for the NHS need to be identified by a public inquiry and report, akin to how the Beveridge Report was conducted, and the implementation needs to be apolitical.

I didn't say "you see what you're paying for" - I said "you see what you are paying", a very different thing.
Reply
#49
(11-19-2020, 01:56 PM)Protheroe Wrote: I didn't say "you see what you're paying for" - I said "you see what you are paying", a very different thing.

I addressed that, you don't see what you're paying. In Germany you see what your ringfenced contributions are to the social insurance scheme out of your pocket but you don't see employer contributions, public hospital funding, research and development, federal budget surplus investments, local budget surplus investments, training investment etc. The money you see going towards healthcare in Germany is only a portion of money.
Reply
#50
(11-19-2020, 05:41 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(11-19-2020, 01:56 PM)Protheroe Wrote: I didn't say "you see what you're paying for" - I said "you see what you are paying", a very different thing.

I addressed that, you don't see what you're paying. In Germany you see what your ringfenced contributions are to the social insurance scheme out of your pocket but you don't see employer contributions, public hospital funding, research and development, federal budget surplus investments, local budget surplus investments, training investment etc. The money you see going towards healthcare in Germany is only a portion of money.

Quite, and it would be the same in the UK in any event. Nevertheless, if taxpayers ever appreciated the size of the chunk taken from their income for this fatted calf they'd soon demand change.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: