Boris
#61
(11-16-2020, 03:18 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(11-16-2020, 03:12 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: Excess deaths is an extremely poor indicator when many are down to incidental risk now mitigated by changes in social behaviour. As a stat, it's pretty worthless.

As a stat its the only one that is accurate. If you can dig deeper and see that we have (as per the govt figures which IMO are understated) over 50k covid deaths and there happens to be around 60k excess deaths you can be pretty certain that they are a good measure.

Of course there are going to be other deaths because of the circumstances, increase in suicides for example, but in theory they will be counterbalanced by other societal factors, less deaths on the road for instance. All in all there is one big difference this year and that can be measured in how  many more people have died this year than last or compared with the 5YA.

Let me word that correctly then. It is a poor indicator if road deaths, occupational deaths, deaths through drink and drugs (maybe), those related to crime... etc. which are all down, are adjusted for. 

Of course it is just as easy to offset this with an increase in deaths due to heart disease, COPD, inactivity/stress, which will all most likely be up. 

So how do you know? It is just an indicator, nothing more, but as a stat alone without any adjustment to take account of the above, I stand by my point. It is like comparing the quality of two wines from two regions over two different years, and trying to pinpoint one factor in that. I'm sorry but I'm not convinced, when we can't even seem to count the two figures that matter most with much accord.

I do agree that a 5YA is a better baseline. For the same reason companies use R12 rather than a snapshot or monthly (or even quarterly) P&L. But it has to be apples with apples. I am happy to be convinced that it is!
Reply
#62
The reason for using it isn’t to compare 2020 with any other year, it is most effective being used to compare nations. It is also a good indicator against years and I would add that currently it will be a good measure but as time goes on less so.
Reply
#63
(11-16-2020, 02:35 PM)LIMABAGGIE Wrote: Its a new virus, ideally coming along at precisely the right time to allow for the implementation of the WEF agenda of the great reset. Ideal again for Big Pharma to make a massive killing in selling billions of vaccines which will of course end up being the first mandatory vaccine in Human History.
We are being manipulated and scare mongered into allowing our freedoms to be taken away for a virus that is survived by 99.95% of all that contact it. That is so debilitating that in most cases you have to have a test to tell if you have it or not. That affects only the elderly, who we blatantly failed to protect. A virus that attacks weakened immune systems and is killed by exposure to sunlight. Our response is to lock people up in their homes, out of the sun and fresh air and therefore further weaken their immune systems.
There is a Globalist Political agenda behind all of the hysterical, fear mongering and  doom laden computer models. The same flawed models which show catastrophic climate change and where the basic facts say otherwise. It is all part of the same plan. This is how freedom dies.

The state of this.  Rolleyes
Reply
#64
(11-16-2020, 08:39 PM)baggy1 Wrote: The reason for using it isn’t to compare 2020 with any other year, it is most effective being used to compare nations. It is also a good indicator against years and I would add that currently it will be a good measure but as time goes on less so.

These nations will have the same variance. I agree though that the greater the sample data when compared to death trends in those respective nations, the more useful it becomes. But snapshots seldom paint a fair picture; without contextualising interference, and fairly-apportioned adjustment to compensate. 

Perhaps I should read about the conditioning of this data to appreciate your POV a little more. But the two largest boundary conditions (infections vs deaths) are highly questionable themselves, and will remain so until reliable testing and reporting on these can be trusted en masse. Which will likely be occluded by vaccination, if we’re lucky!
Reply
#65
(11-16-2020, 11:23 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote:
(11-16-2020, 08:39 PM)baggy1 Wrote: The reason for using it isn’t to compare 2020 with any other year, it is most effective being used to compare nations. It is also a good indicator against years and I would add that currently it will be a good measure but as time goes on less so.

These nations will have the same variance. I agree though that the greater the sample data when compared to death trends in those respective nations, the more useful it becomes. But snapshots seldom paint a fair picture; without contextualising interference, and fairly-apportioned adjustment to compensate. 

Perhaps I should read about the conditioning of this data to appreciate your POV a little more. But the two largest boundary conditions (infections vs deaths) are highly questionable themselves, and will remain so until reliable testing and reporting on these can be trusted en masse. Which will likely be occluded by vaccination, if we’re lucky!

Too many unexpected big words Hawkpip, just give it to us straight. Am we gonna be deed?
Reply
#66
(11-16-2020, 03:14 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(11-16-2020, 01:07 PM)Baggiejacko Wrote: In my opinion it's the tin foil hat virologist experts spreading bogus shite on social media that is part of the problem causing people to be too flippant with the 3 rule regime. I see the latest is advising people not to take a vaccination because you get implanted with a tracking chip ffs

The ironic thing is that the mongs who tend to believe this sort of chip aren’t worth microchipping anyway.

Not worth vaccinating either, now you mention it.
Reply
#67
(11-16-2020, 11:23 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote:
(11-16-2020, 08:39 PM)baggy1 Wrote: The reason for using it isn’t to compare 2020 with any other year, it is most effective being used to compare nations. It is also a good indicator against years and I would add that currently it will be a good measure but as time goes on less so.

These nations will have the same variance. I agree though that the greater the sample data when compared to death trends in those respective nations, the more useful it becomes. But snapshots seldom paint a fair picture; without contextualising interference, and fairly-apportioned adjustment to compensate. 

Perhaps I should read about the conditioning of this data to appreciate your POV a little more. But the two largest boundary conditions (infections vs deaths) are highly questionable themselves, and will remain so until reliable testing and reporting on these can be trusted en masse. Which will likely be occluded by vaccination, if we’re lucky!

Sorry Hawks, I answered that on my phone last night hence it being a bit short.

I tend not to rely on the data for tests or cases (infections) because it really can't be compared with anything (do more tests, get more cases) until we start testing every member of the public on a regular basis (something that isn't going to happen). And even deaths can be subjective, what does someone with a heart condition or cancer who has covid get put on the death cert.

So I rely on two pieces of data - hospital admissions and excess deaths, the two (unfortunately) correlate quite accurately and the hospital admissions are the 1st real point that I can see to identify if things are getting worse.

We've just had the excess death figure for week 44, it was up by 1.5k on normal at the same time we had over 10k people in hospital with covid and because it seems to run parallel we have had 14% excess deaths for the year to date. Now I know these don't correlate exactly but increased hospitalisations lead to excess deaths. So they are indicative data sets rather than definitive.

However, and as mentioned, I used these figures originally to compare how we were doing in the UK compared with other nations (especially similar ones) to show what a shitshow the government were making of it all. It turns out that they can be used as an indicator and confirmatory data sets to show there really is an issue that we need to be careful with.

With every set of data we will be able to find issue or even manipulate to prove our point, these seem the best measures to me and are standing that analysis over time.
Reply
#68
Why is Boris still having to isolate after having a negative test today? How is it any different from the Albion players carrying on when they have been in contact with Pereira and Ivanovic for example?
Reply
#69
(11-17-2020, 10:35 PM)baggiebuckster Wrote: Why is Boris still having to isolate after having a negative test today? How is it any different from the Albion players carrying on when they have been in contact with Pereira and Ivanovic for example?

I think (and I'm not an expert) elite sportsmen have different rules, and also they are tested multiple times each week,at the clubs cost.

Boris is following NHS guidelines, and whilst I'm sure he could have antibody tests and multiple virus tests, if he declared himself to be ok to continue there would be a bigger outcry than the Barnard Castle situation.
Reply
#70
(11-16-2020, 11:37 PM)SausEggBaton Wrote:
(11-16-2020, 11:23 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote:
(11-16-2020, 08:39 PM)baggy1 Wrote: The reason for using it isn’t to compare 2020 with any other year, it is most effective being used to compare nations. It is also a good indicator against years and I would add that currently it will be a good measure but as time goes on less so.

These nations will have the same variance. I agree though that the greater the sample data when compared to death trends in those respective nations, the more useful it becomes. But snapshots seldom paint a fair picture; without contextualising interference, and fairly-apportioned adjustment to compensate. 

Perhaps I should read about the conditioning of this data to appreciate your POV a little more. But the two largest boundary conditions (infections vs deaths) are highly questionable themselves, and will remain so until reliable testing and reporting on these can be trusted en masse. Which will likely be occluded by vaccination, if we’re lucky!

Too many unexpected big words Hawkpip, just give it to us straight. Am we gonna be deed?

In a word? No. In a sound? Oooreroooeerr.

@baggy1 I don’t think this country can be fairly compared to others though. Its population density, propensity to travel, diversity, comparative dependence upon (and age of) infrastructure, healthcare, social habits etc. all vary across nations, the other biggie being the volume of people compelled to cross counties and tier regions into neighbouring towns to pursue livelihoods and even care for relatives. It isn’t fair to say we are better, worse, the same as any of these nations bar the ones that compare closest in all regards.

People are dying, we need controls to prevent that. They will stop dying and we’ll need those controls less, the more obedient we are. That’s the only real certainty; however I am becoming convinced by today’s news that these indicators do bear greater relevance given the observations you make. The stats in Wales published today do support your correlations.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)