UK Covid death toll
I should have listened to Strawman - the figures that came up in the slides last night for hospitalisations were simply wrong and overstated. Looking at the update that came on late last night of hospitalisations they show the number was about 700 less than the slide showed. So I have updated the figures in my post above and it gives us a much rosier picture.

The figures show that the number of those in hospital appear to have stalled in England for 3 days, it is important to note that this is a net figure (i.e. those in hospital on day 1 plus those arriving on day 2 less those leaving on day 2) and that number has held at around 10.4k for 3 days now. We do have figures for those arriving in hospital which is relatively high (around 1.2k) but we don't know how they are leaving (either recovered or died). Using the death data (which I have tried to avoid because it's potentially subjective and gets updated weeks after in some cases) the figures are around 250 a day which means that around 1k people are leaving hospital as recovered each day - this appears to be good news.

Also with the reduced growth rate the prediction for numbers in hospital is also reduced and, using the increase rate as 1.2 now (this isn't what would normally be used because it isn't a trend, it's just one week) means that the peak of those in hospital will be roughly the same as in April.

I've updated my post above and for comparison of what it was Strawman has quoted the original post. Positive news.
Reply
(11-06-2020, 09:07 AM)baggy1 Wrote: I should have listened to Strawman - the figures that came up in the slides last night for hospitalisations were simply wrong and overstated. Looking at the update that came on late last night of hospitalisations they show the number was about 700 less than the slide showed. So I have updated the figures in my post above and it gives us a much rosier picture.

The figures show that the number of those in hospital appear to have stalled in England for 3 days, it is important to note that this is a net figure (i.e. those in hospital on day 1 plus those arriving on day 2 less those leaving on day 2) and that number has held at around 10.4k for 3 days now. We do have figures for those arriving in hospital which is relatively high (around 1.2k) but we don't know how they are leaving (either recovered or died). Using the death data (which I have tried to avoid because it's potentially subjective and gets updated weeks after in some cases) the figures are around 250 a day which means that around 1k people are leaving hospital as recovered each day - this appears to be good news.

Also with the reduced growth rate the prediction for numbers in hospital is also reduced and, using the increase rate as 1.2 now (this isn't what would normally be used because it isn't a trend, it's just one week) means that the peak of those in hospital will be roughly the same as in April.

I've updated my post above and for comparison of what it was Strawman has quoted the original post. Positive news.

Blimey - normally I'm the last person you should listen to - my kids stopped taking any notice of what I said long ago  Big Grin Big Grin

Well done with keeping the figures up to date B1 - nice and factual with no agenda
Reply
So why were the slides overstating the numbers?

Which figures are the general public most likely to see?

Are these from the slide presented by the NHS chief? The one that he said were based on facts and not projections?
Reply
(11-06-2020, 09:41 AM)strawman Wrote:
(11-06-2020, 09:07 AM)baggy1 Wrote: I should have listened to Strawman - the figures that came up in the slides last night for hospitalisations were simply wrong and overstated. Looking at the update that came on late last night of hospitalisations they show the number was about 700 less than the slide showed. So I have updated the figures in my post above and it gives us a much rosier picture.

The figures show that the number of those in hospital appear to have stalled in England for 3 days, it is important to note that this is a net figure (i.e. those in hospital on day 1 plus those arriving on day 2 less those leaving on day 2) and that number has held at around 10.4k for 3 days now. We do have figures for those arriving in hospital which is relatively high (around 1.2k) but we don't know how they are leaving (either recovered or died). Using the death data (which I have tried to avoid because it's potentially subjective and gets updated weeks after in some cases) the figures are around 250 a day which means that around 1k people are leaving hospital as recovered each day - this appears to be good news.

Also with the reduced growth rate the prediction for numbers in hospital is also reduced and, using the increase rate as 1.2 now (this isn't what would normally be used because it isn't a trend, it's just one week) means that the peak of those in hospital will be roughly the same as in April.

I've updated my post above and for comparison of what it was Strawman has quoted the original post. Positive news.

Blimey - normally I'm the last person you should listen to - my kids stopped taking any notice of what I said long ago  Big Grin Big Grin

Well done with keeping the figures up to date B1 - nice and factual with no agenda

I know that feeling SM, my kids are a bit older now and need me for deposits for houses so I seem to have got back some of that influence for some reason  Big Grin

It's like you say, if you put up too much info, or incorrect info, then it can all get called into question.

For what it's worth I still think that a circuit break was needed and if it was done earlier, either when Johnson had the original advice or when Starmer called him out, then I believe it wouldn't have needed to be for so long. And we would have been near the end of it now giving shops and hospitality the opportunity to make some money over Black Friday and in the run up to Christmas. Once we have got to Christmas, put another circuit break in when workers would be on leave generally and head into the new year with hopefully a test and trace system that can be deployed en masse to control where it is with local lockdowns.

I am concerned that they seem to be indicating a very extended period with the Furlough until March. They keep on making poor decisions and it is becoming more and more apparent. It is unsurprising to some of us how unfit Johnson (and in that case Trump) was to lead the country, this is taking the blinkers off for a lot of people. And maybe, just maybe those of us that were right about Johnson and Trump were right about Brexit as well, who knows, we'll find out soon enough.
Reply
(11-06-2020, 10:52 AM)baggiebuckster Wrote: So why were the slides overstating the numbers?

Which figures are the general public most likely to see?

Are these from the slide presented by the NHS chief? The one that he said were based on facts and not projections?

The one slide that was used last night on the BBC showed 11,047 as those in hospital in England. There was a delay last night in uploading the figures to the gov.uk page, so either i misread the slide or they put a predicted figure in there, it wasn't clear.

This was the slide: https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk...-Final.pdf

I'd misread the 11,037 as 11,047 but I can't see how they have made the number based on the 'in hospital' figures on the gov's own website https://coronavirus.data.gov.uk/details/healthcare



OK I've done some research on the figures and it appears that the numbers I put up each week for those in hospital are just for NHS hospitals:
"Data only include NHS Hospital Acute Trusts with a type 1 A&E department and are reported daily by trusts to NHS England and NHS Improvement."

The figures from the slides appear to include "NHS or independent sector inpatient beds".

Why they don't use a standard set for everything is unclear but it does explain why the slide figure is higher.
Reply
The QE have cancelled all operations there now due to coronavirus in the hospital but hey ho its just the flu.
Reply
(11-06-2020, 12:01 PM)The liquidator Wrote: The QE have cancelled all operations there now due to coronavirus in the hospital but hey ho its just the flu.

Like they did in 2018....for flu.

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2018/01...s-january/
Reply
(11-06-2020, 12:13 PM)baggiebuckster Wrote:
(11-06-2020, 12:01 PM)The liquidator Wrote: The QE have cancelled all operations there now due to coronavirus in the hospital but hey ho its just the flu.

Like they did in 2018....for flu.

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2018/01...s-january/

I've spoken to an MP this morning who tells me the QE made no attempt to catch up on elective surgery during June, July & August either....
Reply
(11-06-2020, 12:19 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(11-06-2020, 12:13 PM)baggiebuckster Wrote:
(11-06-2020, 12:01 PM)The liquidator Wrote: The QE have cancelled all operations there now due to coronavirus in the hospital but hey ho its just the flu.

Like they did in 2018....for flu.

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2018/01...s-january/

I've spoken to an MP this morning who tells me the QE made no attempt to catch up on elective surgery during June, July & August either....

Must be true then
Reply
(11-06-2020, 12:45 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(11-06-2020, 12:19 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(11-06-2020, 12:13 PM)baggiebuckster Wrote:
(11-06-2020, 12:01 PM)The liquidator Wrote: The QE have cancelled all operations there now due to coronavirus in the hospital but hey ho its just the flu.

Like they did in 2018....for flu.

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2018/01...s-january/

I've spoken to an MP this morning who tells me the QE made no attempt to catch up on elective surgery during June, July & August either....

Must be true then

*If* a proper Inquiry is ever made into the instutional handling of Covid 19 I suspect the NHS won't come out of it well.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)