Poll: Sack or Back
You do not have permission to vote in this poll.
Sack im!
45.65%
63 45.65%
Back im!
54.35%
75 54.35%
Total 138 vote(s) 100%
* You voted for this item. [Show Results]

Back or Sack? (But not crack)
#61
He has to go. This has gone on too long now.
Great bloke, but it has to be goodbye for the sake of OUR club.
Reply
#62
He’s still in credit with me...just. If he’s lost interest and lost trust of players then I’ve no doubt he will be gone. However as a newly promoted team without a pot to piss in it was obvious there would be a struggle. I just can’t see who is a reasonable alternative
Reply
#63
(11-02-2020, 08:16 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(11-02-2020, 08:11 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(11-02-2020, 08:05 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Sack.

Poor form end of last season, in fact, more of the season was spent out of form than in.

Yes he's been dealt a rough hand, but can anyone honestly say he is making the most of a bad situation? His contract ends this season, he's hardly impressing any suitors at the moment either.  I am fed up of seeing a team that can't do the basics of defending properly, that have no desire, that are unfit compared to their opposition every game. These are the basics I expect any manager of our club, due to our constraints, to satisfy, Bilic is failing every one of them.

I'd sack him tonight.

Sits back and awaits the usual suspects demanding free flowing football on a shoestring budget plus results if we change managers. Hissy fits at the boring pragmatic football aots!

Best football we've ever played in the Prem was spread over two periods, a short run under Roy, starting with the 5-1 demolition of Wolves. Second was the first part of Clarkes season, both built on counter attacking, defensively strong football. When you have less resources than opponents, it will ALWAYS be the best way to play, anyone clamouring for possession heavy, technical football is honestly clueless.

The squad is built all wrong, but a good coach and tactician can help with that short term. Motivation can help a lot, which is something sorely lacking.

Agree with that last para pal. 

Our best football in the Prem was actually the same season - 2010-11 - RDM at the start (including the win at arsenal) and Roy at the end when he played 4231 with PO up front. Not bothered about possession etc

Clarke had the best side - being Roy’s base and adding Rom/Yacob and Gera returning from injury (who was like a new signing).
Reply
#64
Back.

Although he does look broken.

The alternatives to replace him and our incompetent board are why I’d stick. For now.
Reply
#65
(11-02-2020, 08:47 PM)Dumbo Wrote: Back.

Although he does look broken.

The alternatives to replace him and our incompetent board are why I’d stick. For now.

+1
Reply
#66
(11-02-2020, 08:22 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(11-02-2020, 07:55 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The idea that our Championship squad is good enough to stay up is an interesting concept. Look at our squad and show another that is weaker?

Sack him or back him it’s a forlorn exercise in hope over reality that things will change results wise. Clem mentioned would Roy Hodgson do better? If we had a more resilient squad possibly but not this nice but weak one. Even if Roy came in we would still have twonks demanding we ‘played the right way’ and moaning it’s boring. It happened before it would happen again.

But you know that football isn't exclusively about the quality of the playing staff. Other than ourselves today Sheff United have been the worst team I've seen this season but they finished 9th last season with basically the same team. I would say that this years position is a better reflection of the individual quality of their players.

The idea that no manager can keep us up just isn't true. However, I would suggest that Bilic won't

I appreciate that Slice but we had a far better squad to play a more disciplined counter attacking game under Roy and a far better squad under Clarke (thanks Roy) in general. If I’m honest I don’t really care if he stays or goes bit I’m not convinced it’s going to make a huge difference. I don’t see players that can grind out results or hold out for 1-0 wins. Put it this way Foster, Brunt, Morrison, Long and Odemwingie in their prime or the players we have now to play in a Hodgson type team?
Reply
#67
(11-02-2020, 07:51 PM)clem4england Wrote: I would actually have sacked him in the summer if I'd known the budget was so little as we have been shit since November 2019 and, with so little funds, you need a motivator and organiser who will get the players super-fit and drilled.

You are a fool.
Reply
#68
(11-02-2020, 08:42 PM)clem4england Wrote:
(11-02-2020, 08:40 PM)Fido Wrote:
(11-02-2020, 08:35 PM)Sliced Wrote: Once it starts going downhill he's always had an issue pulling it back. Clearly it's just not going to happen. A great bloke, but we need something different

This seems to be evident. A side brimming with confidence before Xmas and then as soon as the slide started the whole team looked nervy in most games thereafter. I know he’s not had great backing but at least pick a side that has worked to some degree and get them working FFS sake. Needs to go.
When the heads dropped after conceding against Leicester in the first game that was a really worrying sign IMO.

Absolutely Clem - my main reason to post a thread titled big problems. We looked like a lower league team playing an FA Cup tie against a premiership, who had huffed and puffed for 60 mins, but knew the game was up once they went behind.
Reply
#69
(11-02-2020, 07:35 PM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote: The only trouble is we will either go for a cheap option like Atherton. Or a Pulis type to bore the fuggin arises off us.

To be fair, he was a great opening bat.
Reply
#70
Back him, mainly because I dont think we will, get better. Worst case, he will get us up again and we wil; be stronger after a boing boing.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 3 Guest(s)