Jeremy Corbyn
#21
(10-29-2020, 03:04 PM)Fall Out Boy Wrote: I don't think Corbyn himself is a racist, I just think he sticks his head in the sand rather than deal with things he views as an inconvenience.

If you look at the way he dealt with Brexit you can see that; he himself did not have a strong opinion, and so that rubbed off on his party. In or out didn't really matter in his vision for the country, so he didn't pursue either outcome vehemently.

It's the same with this. He didn't want to deal with it, so he ignored it and hoped it would go away.

That's pretty much my reading of it as well FOB, we should never have been at a position where Brexit was allowed to go so far without a real opposition party jemmying open the obvious cracks in the sunlit uplands promises
Reply
#22
(10-29-2020, 03:50 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(10-29-2020, 03:04 PM)Fall Out Boy Wrote: I don't think Corbyn himself is a racist, I just think he sticks his head in the sand rather than deal with things he views as an inconvenience.

If you look at the way he dealt with Brexit you can see that; he himself did not have a strong opinion, and so that rubbed off on his party. In or out didn't really matter in his vision for the country, so he didn't pursue either outcome vehemently.

It's the same with this. He didn't want to deal with it, so he ignored it and hoped it would go away.

That's pretty much my reading of it as well FOB, we should never have been at a position where Brexit was allowed to go so far without a real opposition party jemmying open the obvious cracks in the sunlit uplands promises

The extremists on both sides saw that no rational debate was held r.e. Brexit. 

Those believing in the sunlit uplands didn't want to know, and the LibDem/ChangeUK/#FBPE lot didn't want to engage as if you voted to leave you were a thick racist in their eyes.

On this topic, we should probably spare a thought for Jewish people who at present are having their existence exploited for political gain, on both sides.
Reply
#23
Quote:People in the Midlands and the traditional 'Red Wall' were blinded by Brexit. 

The problem is that the Labour party now essentially have a Tory in charge. Who is representing those, even slightly to the left of centre? It certainly isn't Kier Starmer.




What makes you think that mate, interested know? As I understand it Starmer is from a working class background, with his Mom being a Nurse and his Dad a toolmaker.
Reply
#24
(10-29-2020, 04:00 PM)tiptontown Wrote:
Quote:People in the Midlands and the traditional 'Red Wall' were blinded by Brexit. 

The problem is that the Labour party now essentially have a Tory in charge. Who is representing those, even slightly to the left of centre? It certainly isn't Kier Starmer.




What makes you think that mate, interested know? As I understand it Starmer is from a working class background, with his Mom being a Nurse and his Dad a toolmaker.

Wont dispute his background, but it still remains that he's abstained pretty much every time he's had a chance to oppose the Government (school dinners aside). Appreciate the press is busy with other things at present, but notice the attacks on the Labour leadership have virtually vanished, even the Tories don't bother slagging him off which speaks volumes. 

Starmer will be fine as long as the upper-middle class status quo is maintained and despite my earlier protestations, the very worst Labour Government is still better than the best Tory Government, however narrow the gap might be.
Reply
#25
As someone who joined the Labour party because of Corbyn, saying that Starmer is a Tory is really feeding into the Tory agenda ie 'they're all the same'. If he was running against Blair he would be derided as 'loony left' and is definitely not a Tory. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Keir_Starm..._positions.

Regarding the suspension of Corbyn, I don't personally like it and I think it's the end result of what has been an ongoing character assassination but I recognise that it's probably necessary in order to achieve any kind of electoral success. The UK electorate need to have social democracy drip fed to them whether we like it or not.
Reply
#26
I can see the little pip squeak Owen Jones Stiring the pot for Mr hindsight..... I can see this splitting Labour more than it is now...... They love scoring own goals...... Fair play to starmer outing step toe out but can see an explosion of shit from momentum.
Reply
#27
(10-29-2020, 04:25 PM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: As someone who joined the Labour party because of Corbyn, saying that Starmer is a Tory is really feeding into the Tory agenda ie 'they're all the same'. If he was running against Blair he would be derided as 'loony left' and is definitely not a Tory. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Keir_Starm..._positions.

Regarding the suspension of Corbyn, I don't personally like it and I think it's the end result of what has been an ongoing character assassination but I recognise that it's probably necessary in order to achieve any kind of electoral success. The UK electorate need to have social democracy drip fed to them whether we like it or not.

Also, and aimed a Ted and those that are thinking of leaving the Labour party and setting up a new 'left' party, now is not the time. If the left gets split then the right will most definitely mop up at the next election. If you really want you voice heard or to be represented then stick with the goal of getting Labour into power, once there aim for a restructure of voting along proportional representation lines and then set up your own party. That is the only way you will have any representation and your voice heard. 

We might all be different shades of red here (i'm obviously the pink one) but we need to stick together to get any voice heard.
Reply
#28
(10-29-2020, 04:45 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(10-29-2020, 04:25 PM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: As someone who joined the Labour party because of Corbyn, saying that Starmer is a Tory is really feeding into the Tory agenda ie 'they're all the same'. If he was running against Blair he would be derided as 'loony left' and is definitely not a Tory. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Keir_Starm..._positions.

Regarding the suspension of Corbyn, I don't personally like it and I think it's the end result of what has been an ongoing character assassination but I recognise that it's probably necessary in order to achieve any kind of electoral success. The UK electorate need to have social democracy drip fed to them whether we like it or not.

Also, and aimed a Ted and those that are thinking of leaving the Labour party and setting up a new 'left' party, now is not the time. If the left gets split then the right will most definitely mop up at the next election. If you really want you voice heard or to be represented then stick with the goal of getting Labour into power, once there aim for a restructure of voting along proportional representation lines and then set up your own party. That is the only way you will have any representation and your voice heard. 

We might all be different shades of red here (i'm obviously the pink one) but we need to stick together to get any voice heard.

I'm not quite ready to join the full on revolt (now I've calmed from my earlier tantrum). A new party would just be an exclusive Momentum club and would go the same way as Change UK albeit a slightly slower death. The rest of your post is bang on.
Reply
#29
Corbyn has got what he deserved. I dont understand the fandom over him on Twitter. He has a boring personality and his polices were rejected by the UK twice, He has supported the IRA, Hamas and anti-semites across the board.

This should be the end of him, Sadly i don't think this will happen. The best thing is that he runs as an Independent and gets beat by a Jewish person at the next election/Bi-Election

(10-29-2020, 03:32 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(10-29-2020, 03:24 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-29-2020, 03:05 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(10-29-2020, 02:58 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-29-2020, 02:29 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: Blame Starmer and his mates wanting Brexit Ref 2 for that.


I agree with what he stood for. His biggest mistake is caving into to those wanting a second Brexit vote, and not turfing out those who spent five years trying to undermine him.

There is no way Corbyn was ever going to win an election. Only those enthral to him thought he would. The obsessing by his supporters regarding Israel and Palestine for example meant absolutely feck all to the average electorate but somehow under his leadership he managed to make it a political bomb within the party.

Not sure why supporting Palestine in the face of Israeli war crimes is a big issue, it's just human decency.

I worry for the Labour party now, you only have to look at the swell in membership when Corbyn took leadership.

The swell of supporters means nowt, it was an echo chamber of opinion. Most Corbyn supporters seem to be on Twitter currently shouting it’s a conspiracy. They cannot bring themselves to admit he was a terrible leader whose appeal only stretched to them no one else and certainly not those who could get Labour elected. Ffs Labour lost seats in Sandwell under his stewardship. You could traditionally put a red rosette on a turd and it would be off to Westminster. 

The rights and wrongs of Israel and Palestine are not something your average non member voter cares about or even understands. The fact it was allowed to become an issue within the naval gazing membership is proof they were as out of touch as Corbyn was with the wider electorate. Whether those that like him or not want to admit It, Corbyn was a major reason Labour lost.

People in the Midlands and the traditional 'Red Wall' were blinded by Brexit. 

The problem is that the Labour party now essentially have a Tory in charge. Who is representing those, even slightly to the left of centre? It certainly isn't Kier Starmer.

Please explain how Starmer is a tory?
Reply
#30
Fall Out Boy Wrote:I don't think Corbyn himself is a racist, I just think he sticks his head in the sand rather than deal with things he views as an inconvenience.

If you look at the way he dealt with Brexit you can see that; he himself did not have a strong opinion, and so that rubbed off on his party. In or out didn't really matter in his vision for the country, so he didn't pursue either outcome vehemently.

It's the same with this. He didn't want to deal with it, so he ignored it and hoped it would go away.
Corbyn is  lifelong anti EU as were many on the old left. The fact he chose not to interfere was because his views were different to most of his party. The real irony in this stance is that were he to have stuck with his long held anti EU views, he would not have lost the traditional support base.
Personally I absolutely despise the creep. He deliberately remained unelectable and let down the people who are in most need of an alternative to austerity. Even today he had to argue the point, (right or wrong), thus once again Labour are in the headlines for the wrong reason. He should have just knuckled down as a constituency MP until the next election when he should simply retire.   Inept, stubborn, dull and absolutely out of touch, his leadership wrecked the Labour party (those seats will take some winning back), Corbyn has a lot to answer for and a lot to answer to.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: