Ratings
#11
(10-27-2020, 08:32 AM)Super_Slav Wrote:
(10-27-2020, 08:27 AM)Slightly Bonkers Wrote:
(10-27-2020, 08:20 AM)Peachy Wrote: Only seen brief highlights but listened to the whole game and it sounded to me like Lamptey was their best player. He's had a cracking season and is lightening quick.

He  won the battle with Grady but I really wouldn't be writing Grady off. He'd start at Fulham for me.

No doubting his talent, but I'd prefer to bring him on against Fulham than hook him off after 65 minutes for another non performance.

6 games so far, was better than ok against Everton, the rest very so so.

Start them both?

Johnstone; Furlong, Ivanović, Ajayi, Gibbs; Gallagher, Krovinović, Pereria; Robinson, Grant, Diangana.

Think we're going to need to be a little more solid against Fulham - we'll have to be patient, break up the middle and get in behind quickly... can't see us being able to do that with such an attacking lineup!

Plenty of pace though!!
Reply
#12
(10-27-2020, 08:32 AM)Super_Slav Wrote:
(10-27-2020, 08:27 AM)Slightly Bonkers Wrote:
(10-27-2020, 08:20 AM)Peachy Wrote: Only seen brief highlights but listened to the whole game and it sounded to me like Lamptey was their best player. He's had a cracking season and is lightening quick.

He  won the battle with Grady but I really wouldn't be writing Grady off. He'd start at Fulham for me.

No doubting his talent, but I'd prefer to bring him on against Fulham than hook him off after 65 minutes for another non performance.

6 games so far, was better than ok against Everton, the rest very so so.

Start them both?

Johnstone; Furlong, Ivanović, Ajayi, Gibbs; Gallagher, Krovinović, Pereria; Robinson, Grant, Diangana.

Yep, why not.

May as well go down swinging as to playing Livermore and/or Sawyers and losing x-nil!!!!
Reply
#13
(10-27-2020, 07:53 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(10-27-2020, 01:00 AM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: Fair enough Grady didn't have a good game but I'm disappointed with some of the comments about him on the match thread. I think too many fail to take account of the opposition sometimes and the fact is, tonight, Grady was up against a very rapid RB, the sort he hasn't come up against before very often. He's going to have to work out how cope with those sort. I think we should stick with him.

May I also take the opportunity to say Conor Townsend is proving me wrong. Never let us down in the Chump, but I thought the Prem would be a step too far for him - but he's been very steady. Well done, chap.

The Grady-Lamptey battle was definitely to blame for Grady being quite reserved first half. He was doing a lot of defensive work and you could see both Slav and Potter were guiding their players when to go and stay. He definitely had to play with one eye over his shoulder.

I think Grady was poor, his chance first half especially showing his lack of a right foot, but in fairness to him he was having to do a lot more defensive work. 

I’d take him out the XI next week Just because he looks a little low on confidence.

I agree, he should be given a breather. Let's just think what's happened to him over the past two months. He had a great loan season and was told by Moyes he was part of his plans. A few days before signing he played and laid on several goals for Haller and looked superb, I watched the highlights and he was the Grady we know, albeit it against Ipswich I think. Then out of the blue he's suddenly told we've sold you to WBA. He must have been as shocked as we were. Then there was a national debate on radio for quite a while about the whys and wherefores. This I believe has put enormous pressure on his young shoulders whilst facing much better and physical opponents and at the moment he hasn't been able to deal with it. I would put him on the bench for a few games and give him a few cameos to build his confidence. He'll come through this but he may have to reinvent himself and beef himself up a little, he's a bit light-weight. A few mackesans might help and raw eggs.
Reply
#14
(10-27-2020, 08:52 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(10-27-2020, 08:32 AM)Super_Slav Wrote:
(10-27-2020, 08:27 AM)Slightly Bonkers Wrote:
(10-27-2020, 08:20 AM)Peachy Wrote: Only seen brief highlights but listened to the whole game and it sounded to me like Lamptey was their best player. He's had a cracking season and is lightening quick.

He  won the battle with Grady but I really wouldn't be writing Grady off. He'd start at Fulham for me.

No doubting his talent, but I'd prefer to bring him on against Fulham than hook him off after 65 minutes for another non performance.

6 games so far, was better than ok against Everton, the rest very so so.

Start them both?

Johnstone; Furlong, Ivanović, Ajayi, Gibbs; Gallagher, Krovinović, Pereria; Robinson, Grant, Diangana.

Think we're going to need to be a little more solid against Fulham - we'll have to be patient, break up the middle and get in behind quickly... can't see us being able to do that with such an attacking lineup!

Plenty of pace though!!

Reckon Gallacher can do the job of Livermore/Sawyers plus a little bit more.
Reply
#15
(10-27-2020, 08:54 AM)Hopalong Wrote:
(10-27-2020, 07:53 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(10-27-2020, 01:00 AM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: Fair enough Grady didn't have a good game but I'm disappointed with some of the comments about him on the match thread. I think too many fail to take account of the opposition sometimes and the fact is, tonight, Grady was up against a very rapid RB, the sort he hasn't come up against before very often. He's going to have to work out how cope with those sort. I think we should stick with him.

May I also take the opportunity to say Conor Townsend is proving me wrong. Never let us down in the Chump, but I thought the Prem would be a step too far for him - but he's been very steady. Well done, chap.

The Grady-Lamptey battle was definitely to blame for Grady being quite reserved first half. He was doing a lot of defensive work and you could see both Slav and Potter were guiding their players when to go and stay. He definitely had to play with one eye over his shoulder.

I think Grady was poor, his chance first half especially showing his lack of a right foot, but in fairness to him he was having to do a lot more defensive work. 

I’d take him out the XI next week Just because he looks a little low on confidence.

I agree, he should be given a breather. Let's just think what's happened to him over the past two months. He had a great loan season and was told by Moyes he was part of his plans. A few days before signing he played and laid on several goals for Haller and looked superb, I watched the highlights and he was the Grady we know, albeit it against Ipswich I think. Then out of the blue he's suddenly told we've sold you to WBA. He must have been as shocked as we were. Then there was a national debate on radio for quite a while about the whys and wherefores. This I believe has put enormous pressure on his young shoulders whilst facing much better and physical opponents and at the moment he hasn't been able to deal with it. I would put him on the bench for a few games and give him a few cameos to build his confidence. He'll come through this but he may have to reinvent himself and beef himself up a little, he's a bit light-weight. A few mackesans might help and raw eggs.

Think that's a really good point Athers.

Grady went from being a player who very few people knew much about to centre stage in the national media almost overnight. He seems a level headed lad, and there's definitely a sense of community here within the group so you'd like to think he was supported through it, but it's hard to believe he won't have been impacted by it.

We all know there's a player who can play at this level in Diangana, but he's 22, and in his first full season at this level. Both the club and he still have a lot of work to do before he's winning games every week for us.

(10-27-2020, 09:00 AM)Slightly Bonkers Wrote:
(10-27-2020, 08:52 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(10-27-2020, 08:32 AM)Super_Slav Wrote:
(10-27-2020, 08:27 AM)Slightly Bonkers Wrote:
(10-27-2020, 08:20 AM)Peachy Wrote: Only seen brief highlights but listened to the whole game and it sounded to me like Lamptey was their best player. He's had a cracking season and is lightening quick.

He  won the battle with Grady but I really wouldn't be writing Grady off. He'd start at Fulham for me.

No doubting his talent, but I'd prefer to bring him on against Fulham than hook him off after 65 minutes for another non performance.

6 games so far, was better than ok against Everton, the rest very so so.

Start them both?

Johnstone; Furlong, Ivanović, Ajayi, Gibbs; Gallagher, Krovinović, Pereria; Robinson, Grant, Diangana.

Think we're going to need to be a little more solid against Fulham - we'll have to be patient, break up the middle and get in behind quickly... can't see us being able to do that with such an attacking lineup!

Plenty of pace though!!

Reckon Gallacher can do the job of Livermore/Sawyers plus a little bit more.

Gallagher's game is about bursting into space and carrying the ball. He needs an anchor alongside him, which is why Livermore will play for the foreseeable future. The only other player we have capable of playing that role is Field but he's injured. If we had Gallagher that deep we'd detract from his natural game.

Krov / Livermore / Gallagher is probably our most balanced midfield... although as has been done to death, not signing an upgrade for that holding role is a real error this summer, but much like fullbacks, there was only so much money to spend!
Reply
#16
It’s a massive step up for Diangana and Pereira. Pereira at least has the experience of the Bundesliga. We can’t expect them to be like they were in the Champ. It will take time.
Reply
#17
(10-27-2020, 09:17 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(10-27-2020, 08:54 AM)Hopalong Wrote:
(10-27-2020, 07:53 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(10-27-2020, 01:00 AM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: Fair enough Grady didn't have a good game but I'm disappointed with some of the comments about him on the match thread. I think too many fail to take account of the opposition sometimes and the fact is, tonight, Grady was up against a very rapid RB, the sort he hasn't come up against before very often. He's going to have to work out how cope with those sort. I think we should stick with him.

May I also take the opportunity to say Conor Townsend is proving me wrong. Never let us down in the Chump, but I thought the Prem would be a step too far for him - but he's been very steady. Well done, chap.

The Grady-Lamptey battle was definitely to blame for Grady being quite reserved first half. He was doing a lot of defensive work and you could see both Slav and Potter were guiding their players when to go and stay. He definitely had to play with one eye over his shoulder.

I think Grady was poor, his chance first half especially showing his lack of a right foot, but in fairness to him he was having to do a lot more defensive work. 

I’d take him out the XI next week Just because he looks a little low on confidence.

I agree, he should be given a breather. Let's just think what's happened to him over the past two months. He had a great loan season and was told by Moyes he was part of his plans. A few days before signing he played and laid on several goals for Haller and looked superb, I watched the highlights and he was the Grady we know, albeit it against Ipswich I think. Then out of the blue he's suddenly told we've sold you to WBA. He must have been as shocked as we were. Then there was a national debate on radio for quite a while about the whys and wherefores. This I believe has put enormous pressure on his young shoulders whilst facing much better and physical opponents and at the moment he hasn't been able to deal with it. I would put him on the bench for a few games and give him a few cameos to build his confidence. He'll come through this but he may have to reinvent himself and beef himself up a little, he's a bit light-weight. A few mackesans might help and raw eggs.

Think that's a really good point Athers.

Grady went from being a player who very few people knew much about to centre stage in the national media almost overnight. He seems a level headed lad, and there's definitely a sense of community here within the group so you'd like to think he was supported through it, but it's hard to believe he won't have been impacted by it.

We all know there's a player who can play at this level in Diangana, but he's 22, and in his first full season at this level. Both the club and he still have a lot of work to do before he's winning games every week for us.

(10-27-2020, 09:00 AM)Slightly Bonkers Wrote:
(10-27-2020, 08:52 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(10-27-2020, 08:32 AM)Super_Slav Wrote:
(10-27-2020, 08:27 AM)Slightly Bonkers Wrote: No doubting his talent, but I'd prefer to bring him on against Fulham than hook him off after 65 minutes for another non performance.

6 games so far, was better than ok against Everton, the rest very so so.

Start them both?

Johnstone; Furlong, Ivanović, Ajayi, Gibbs; Gallagher, Krovinović, Pereria; Robinson, Grant, Diangana.

Think we're going to need to be a little more solid against Fulham - we'll have to be patient, break up the middle and get in behind quickly... can't see us being able to do that with such an attacking lineup!

Plenty of pace though!!

Reckon Gallacher can do the job of Livermore/Sawyers plus a little bit more.

Gallagher's game is about bursting into space and carrying the ball. He needs an anchor alongside him, which is why Livermore will play for the foreseeable future. The only other player we have capable of playing that role is Field but he's injured. If we had Gallagher that deep we'd detract from his natural game.

Krov / Livermore / Gallagher is probably our most balanced midfield... although as has been done to death, not signing an upgrade for that holding role is a real error this summer, but much like fullbacks, there was only so much money to spend!

Totally agree with you regarding Gallacher attributes, but Livermore or Sawyers in the team we will almost certainly lose every game.

Without them, we may lose, but then again we might win.
Reply
#18
Grady is a top, top player and I've no doubt he'll go on and play for England at some point

Form is temporary, class is permanent just at the minute he's a little low on confidence but I'm sure they'll work with him before the Fulham game

Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Reply
#19
Good ratings again Cuzer.

Krov is confirming what quite a few of us thought - better in off in the Prem. Looks a real class act.

We're improving but we've not got much time to click.
Reply
#20
Thought the standouts last night were Johnstone, Gallagher and Krov (his pass to Robinson in the build up for the goal was excellent). As soon as Livermore came off we looked much better. Furlong struggled again I thought , I think its a bit of a myth that he's good going forward, Townsend is much better technically in comparison.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: