Ratings
#1
A little behind as had to watch the 2nd half on catch up tonights

Started OK for me but a little toothless, they got a grip after 20 minutes or so and we were on the back foot, defended well enough but just seemed to get deeper and deeper, looked like a side short of confidence and self belief, their goal was a massive car crash from our perspective, so many errors, none more so than Grady who was piss poor all night

2nd half a lot better, again we controlled the ball without threatening much but the game was played consitently towards their goal and overall the equaliser was deserved, plenty to build on but we could really do with 3 points at Fulham, having seen a lot of them they are decent and play good football but throw a lot of bodies forward, staying compact and playing on the counter is key, Palace created for fun last week with a Sly Old Woy masterclass, be nice to see Slav do the same................if he hasn't had enough by then

SJ 8* - Key saves at key times for me kept us in the game, distribution a little iffy at times but another strong showing
Furlong 7 - Again thought he did well, crossing at times lets him down but so good in the air and full of running and always shows for the ball giving us an outlet
Townsend 7 - Started poorly but grew into the game, some dangerous crosses too but we never looked like getting on the end of them, still Gibbs all day for me but doesn't deserve to be dropped on his last 2 games, be really tested by Lookman if he keeps his place
Semi 8 Very assured display, strong in the air and read the game well
Ivanovic 7 - Born leader and gives his all for the cause, can see winning means so much to him, shaky at times 1st half but never exposed for lack of pace and solid enough
Livermore 6 - Struggled a bit tonight with Brighton's sharp passing but put the yards in and used the ball better than normally in that deeper role
Krov 8 - Close to MOM for me, good touch, clever link up play and incisive ball to Robinson set up the goal, impressive
Gallagher 7 - Great 2nd half, again 1st half thought he picked up where he left off v Burnley, all a bit pedestrian which isn't his game, 2nd half much more like it, full of energy, work rate and drive, unlucky not to score and asked plenty of questions of them
Grady 5 - Such a poor game, capped off with a terrible jump for their goal, just seemed to have no condifence to run at the full back and drive at the opposition in general which is crucial to how we set up and play
Pereira 7 - Again seemed to be the spark when we got in their final third, a little sloppy at times but unlucky not to score and still finds the pass which in transition gets us up the pitch
Grant 7 - Worked his socks off, difficult task in the first half when at times isolated but deserved his goal which would have done him the world of good
Subs
Edwards - 7 - Liked his directness, when he's at his best, exactly what we need from the bench
Robinson 8 - Full of energy and workrate, real impressive cameo and must be pushing for a start at Fulham over the out of sorts Grady
Phillips 6 - One great chance to get in behind late on but didn't have the pace or legs to get there..........Grosicki anyone????
Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Reply
#2
Phillip's such a confidence player. Recall him being put through last season vs Blackburn. Brushed off the defender and scored.
Reply
#3
Fair enough Grady didn't have a good game but I'm disappointed with some of the comments about him on the match thread. I think too many fail to take account of the opposition sometimes and the fact is, tonight, Grady was up against a very rapid RB, the sort he hasn't come up against before very often. He's going to have to work out how cope with those sort. I think we should stick with him.

May I also take the opportunity to say Conor Townsend is proving me wrong. Never let us down in the Chump, but I thought the Prem would be a step too far for him - but he's been very steady. Well done, chap.
Reply
#4
(10-27-2020, 01:00 AM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: Fair enough Grady didn't have a good game but I'm disappointed with some of the comments about him on the match thread. I think too many fail to take account of the opposition sometimes and the fact is, tonight, Grady was up against a very rapid RB, the sort he hasn't come up against before very often. He's going to have to work out how cope with those sort. I think we should stick with him.

May I also take the opportunity to say Conor Townsend is proving me wrong. Never let us down in the Chump, but I thought the Prem would be a step too far for him - but he's been very steady. Well done, chap.

The Grady-Lamptey battle was definitely to blame for Grady being quite reserved first half. He was doing a lot of defensive work and you could see both Slav and Potter were guiding their players when to go and stay. He definitely had to play with one eye over his shoulder.

I think Grady was poor, his chance first half especially showing his lack of a right foot, but in fairness to him he was having to do a lot more defensive work. 

I’d take him out the XI next week Just because he looks a little low on confidence.
Reply
#5
Grady has been off it for a few weeks now. His performance was summed up by being out jumped by Lamptey that ultimately led to Brighton’s goal.

I’d start Robinson next week in his place.
Reply
#6
(10-26-2020, 11:17 PM)Cuzer Wrote: A little behind as had to watch the 2nd half on catch up tonights

Started OK for me but a little toothless, they got a grip after 20 minutes or so and we were on the back foot, defended well enough but just seemed to get deeper and deeper, looked like a side short of confidence and self belief, their goal was a massive car crash from our perspective, so many errors, none more so than Grady who was piss poor all night

2nd half a lot better, again we controlled the ball without threatening much but the game was played consitently towards their goal and overall the equaliser was deserved, plenty to build on but we could really do with 3 points at Fulham, having seen a lot of them they are decent and play good football but throw a lot of bodies forward, staying compact and playing on the counter is key, Palace created for fun last week with a Sly Old Woy masterclass, be nice to see Slav do the same................if he hasn't had enough by then

SJ 8* - Key saves at key times for me kept us in the game, distribution a little iffy at times but another strong showing
Furlong 7 - Again thought he did well, crossing at times lets him down but so good in the air and full of running and always shows for the ball giving us an outlet
Townsend 7 - Started poorly but grew into the game, some dangerous crosses too but we never looked like getting on the end of them, still Gibbs all day for me but doesn't deserve to be dropped on his last 2 games, be really tested by Lookman if he keeps his place
Semi 8 Very assured display, strong in the air and read the game well
Ivanovic 7 - Born leader and gives his all for the cause, can see winning means so much to him, shaky at times 1st half but never exposed for lack of pace and solid enough
Livermore 6 - Struggled a bit tonight with Brighton's sharp passing but put the yards in and used the ball better than normally in that deeper role
Krov 8 - Close to MOM for me, good touch, clever link up play and incisive ball to Robinson set up the goal, impressive
Gallagher 7 - Great 2nd half, again 1st half thought he picked up where he left off v Burnley, all a bit pedestrian which isn't his game, 2nd half much more like it, full of energy, work rate and drive, unlucky not to score and asked plenty of questions of them
Grady 5 - Such a poor game, capped off with a terrible jump for their goal, just seemed to have no condifence to run at the full back and drive at the opposition in general which is crucial to how we set up and play
Pereira 7 - Again seemed to be the spark when we got in their final third, a little sloppy at times but unlucky not to score and still finds the pass which in transition gets us up the pitch
Grant 7 - Worked his socks off, difficult task in the first half when at times isolated but deserved his goal which would have done him the world of good
Subs
Edwards - 7 - Liked his directness, when he's at his best, exactly what we need from the bench
Robinson 8 - Full of energy and workrate, real impressive cameo and must be pushing for a start at Fulham over the out of sorts Grady
Phillips 6 - One great chance to get in behind late on but didn't have the pace or legs to get there..........Grosicki anyone????
Cuzer

Agree with most of your assessment. I think you are being a bit kind to the fullbacks though. They are a huge weakness that will be exploited throughout the season. For me, I'd bring back Gibbs and O'Shea if possible. Diangana is disappointing at the moment. Seems a real confidence player. Doesn't deserve to start over Robinson at the moment.
Reply
#7
SJ 7.5

DF 6.5
BI 7
SA 8
CT 6.5

JL 4

PK 8
MP 7.5
CG 8
GD 5

KG 7.5

SUBS

MP 5
KE 7
CR 7

Need to bin Livermore.

My revised lineup (bit to attacking granted)

Same back 5.

Krov and Gallacher in the middle, Robinson and either Edwards/Ding out wide; Pereira behind Grant.
Reply
#8
Only seen brief highlights but listened to the whole game and it sounded to me like Lamptey was their best player. He's had a cracking season and is lightening quick.

He  won the battle with Grady but I really wouldn't be writing Grady off. He'd start at Fulham for me.
Reply
#9
(10-27-2020, 08:20 AM)Peachy Wrote: Only seen brief highlights but listened to the whole game and it sounded to me like Lamptey was their best player. He's had a cracking season and is lightening quick.

He  won the battle with Grady but I really wouldn't be writing Grady off. He'd start at Fulham for me.

No doubting his talent, but I'd prefer to bring him on against Fulham than hook him off after 65 minutes for another non performance.

6 games so far, was better than ok against Everton, the rest very so so.
Reply
#10
(10-27-2020, 08:27 AM)Slightly Bonkers Wrote:
(10-27-2020, 08:20 AM)Peachy Wrote: Only seen brief highlights but listened to the whole game and it sounded to me like Lamptey was their best player. He's had a cracking season and is lightening quick.

He  won the battle with Grady but I really wouldn't be writing Grady off. He'd start at Fulham for me.

No doubting his talent, but I'd prefer to bring him on against Fulham than hook him off after 65 minutes for another non performance.

6 games so far, was better than ok against Everton, the rest very so so.

Start them both?

Johnstone; Furlong, Ivanović, Ajayi, Gibbs; Gallagher, Krovinović, Pereria; Robinson, Grant, Diangana.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: