Posts: 1,058
Threads: 51
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
3
(10-22-2020, 08:36 AM)Sliced Wrote: The issue is apparently the wording which is "must be completed by 17.30". It was completed at 17.30 and 21 seconds so the Forest lawyers are arguing that the time was still 17.30 until it ticks over until 31 minutes past, and therefore it was done in time.
Then their lawyers would be wrong.
Posts: 10,700
Threads: 674
Joined: Feb 2020
(10-22-2020, 08:52 AM)JOK Wrote: (10-22-2020, 08:36 AM)Sliced Wrote: The issue is apparently the wording which is "must be completed by 17.30". It was completed at 17.30 and 21 seconds so the Forest lawyers are arguing that the time was still 17.30 until it ticks over until 31 minutes past, and therefore it was done in time.
Then their lawyers would be wrong.
They do have a very strong case as here’s the relevant wording from the EFL website re transfers.
[font="Open Sans", Helvetica, Arial, sans-serif]42.2A.2in respect of applications to register a Player who does not require clearance as described in Regulation 46.2, at 5pm on 16 October 2020.[/font]
So 17:00:21 is stil 5pm
Posts: 10,860
Threads: 497
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
23
10-22-2020, 08:56 AM
(This post was last modified: 10-22-2020, 08:57 AM by Peachy.)
(10-22-2020, 08:52 AM)JOK Wrote: (10-22-2020, 08:36 AM)Sliced Wrote: The issue is apparently the wording which is "must be completed by 17.30". It was completed at 17.30 and 21 seconds so the Forest lawyers are arguing that the time was still 17.30 until it ticks over until 31 minutes past, and therefore it was done in time.
Then their lawyers would be wrong.
Not really. 17.30 is Hr/Min.
Now if it had been Hr/Min/Sec and said the cut off was 17:30.00 then they wouldn't have a leg to stand on.
By stipulating it only in hours and minutes then it can quite rightly be argued.
I rest my case your honour......
Posts: 4,043
Threads: 149
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
10
10-22-2020, 09:02 AM
(This post was last modified: 10-22-2020, 09:03 AM by hudds.)
(10-22-2020, 08:56 AM)Peachy Wrote: (10-22-2020, 08:52 AM)JOK Wrote: (10-22-2020, 08:36 AM)Sliced Wrote: The issue is apparently the wording which is "must be completed by 17.30". It was completed at 17.30 and 21 seconds so the Forest lawyers are arguing that the time was still 17.30 until it ticks over until 31 minutes past, and therefore it was done in time.
Then their lawyers would be wrong.
Not really. 17.30 is Hr/Min.
Now if it had been Hr/Min/Sec and said the cut off was 17:30.00 then they wouldn't have a leg to stand on.
By stipulating it only in hours and minutes then it can quite rightly be argued.
I rest my case your honour...... 
This is the detail and why wording of the requirement has to be precise. Mostly, normal people would work to 17.30 and then finito. It's when this sort of actual situation occurs that the lawyers can nit pick. That is, the regs ought to have said eg 17.30.59 or summat. Mebbees there's some legal authority/precedent an' all.
Posts: 4,768
Threads: 3
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
27
17:30hrs is 17:30hrs, there's no need to stipulate seconds as it clearly states 17:30hrs.
Not 17:29.59, not 17:30.01, but 17:30hrs because the deadline was 17:30hrs and no seconds.
The thirtieth minute after 17:00hrs was completed, at 17:30hrs.
Posts: 18,398
Threads: 256
Joined: Jan 2019
(10-22-2020, 09:13 AM)GunsOfNavarone Wrote: 17:30hrs is 17:30hrs, there's no need to stipulate seconds as it clearly states 17:30hrs.
Not 17:29.59, not 17:30.01, but 17:30hrs because the deadline was 17:30hrs and no seconds.
The thirtieth minute after 17:00hrs was completed, at 17:30hrs.
Do we need to get down to thousandths of seconds, like F1 qualifying??
Posts: 10,700
Threads: 674
Joined: Feb 2020
(10-22-2020, 09:13 AM)GunsOfNavarone Wrote: 17:30hrs is 17:30hrs, there's no need to stipulate seconds as it clearly states 17:30hrs.
Not 17:29.59, not 17:30.01, but 17:30hrs because the deadline was 17:30hrs and no seconds.
The thirtieth minute after 17:00hrs was completed, at 17:30hrs.
They only need to add the word “before” and then state the cutoff time. i.e. before 5pm on 16th October.
So 16:59:59 would be the cut off time. Simples.
Posts: 1,058
Threads: 51
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
3
(10-22-2020, 08:56 AM)Peachy Wrote: (10-22-2020, 08:52 AM)JOK Wrote: (10-22-2020, 08:36 AM)Sliced Wrote: The issue is apparently the wording which is "must be completed by 17.30". It was completed at 17.30 and 21 seconds so the Forest lawyers are arguing that the time was still 17.30 until it ticks over until 31 minutes past, and therefore it was done in time.
Then their lawyers would be wrong.
Not really. 17.30 is Hr/Min.
Now if it had been Hr/Min/Sec and said the cut off was 17:30.00 then they wouldn't have a leg to stand on.
By stipulating it only in hours and minutes then it can quite rightly be argued.
I rest my case your honour......  I'm sorry my learned friend and to the witness FF but 'technically' it is no longer 5.00 pm of 17:30 as soon as the second ticks on.
It's actually all a bit petty by the EFL. It's a pity that common sense isn't a little more common than we think. So thousands of squid will be wasted over 21 seconds when the registration owning club want him to go, the destination club want him to go and presumably the player is content to move.
Posts: 10,700
Threads: 674
Joined: Feb 2020
10-22-2020, 09:22 AM
(This post was last modified: 10-22-2020, 09:43 AM by Fulham Fallout.)
(10-22-2020, 09:18 AM)JOK Wrote: (10-22-2020, 08:56 AM)Peachy Wrote: (10-22-2020, 08:52 AM)JOK Wrote: (10-22-2020, 08:36 AM)Sliced Wrote: The issue is apparently the wording which is "must be completed by 17.30". It was completed at 17.30 and 21 seconds so the Forest lawyers are arguing that the time was still 17.30 until it ticks over until 31 minutes past, and therefore it was done in time.
Then their lawyers would be wrong.
Not really. 17.30 is Hr/Min.
Now if it had been Hr/Min/Sec and said the cut off was 17:30.00 then they wouldn't have a leg to stand on.
By stipulating it only in hours and minutes then it can quite rightly be argued.
I rest my case your honour......  I'm sorry my learned friend and to the witness FF but 'technically' it is no longer 5.00 pm of 17:30 as soon as the second ticks on.
It's actually all a bit petty by the EFL. It's a pity that common sense isn't a little more common than we think. So thousands of squid will be wasted over 21 seconds when the registration owning club want him to go, the destination club want him to go and presumably the player is content to move.
How have we got to 17:30 when the cut off is 5pm?!!!?
Anyhow, 17:00:21 is not one minute past 5. If you look at it at the other end of the hour 17:59:01 is not 6pm.
Posts: 13,256
Threads: 468
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
45
I meant to say 17.00. Clearly if I'd been in charge of the paperwork it would've been half an hour late
|