(10-21-2020, 06:46 PM)baggy1 Wrote: (10-21-2020, 05:16 PM)billybassett Wrote: (10-21-2020, 03:52 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Thanks Proth, and all good points tbh despite Dr. Billy's pointing out of the dubious medical knowledge that wasn't really the point of the article.
It actually makes a lot of sense and, if I'm reading it correctly, the focus should be on preparing the NHS for the inevitable. It does sum up where i am because my gut feeling is to have a short lockdown to bring the numbers down so that they don't multiply exponentially, but I also feel that there is no real end game to this approach until we get a vaccine of which there is no sight of. It would probably help if the politicians stopped giving the 'it's close' and it will be 'world beating' and just gave us how long each stage will go if it all goes perfectly, honest, answer. And based on my views above I have taken a side based on figures that are predictions.
Billy appears to have all bases covered though and if he's wrong he can just blame misinformation and any further excess deaths being down to non-covid reasons which will reinforce his views he is right.
Good article and has given me some for for though - appreciated
That's very unfair in all honesty.
Bit like me holding you to account for all future deaths due to lack of other treatments and general health impacts
It was a bit more tongue in cheek, but I do get frustrated with the conspiracy theory (all the figures are made up) approach that you take. The article spells out basically what is fact - we don't know what is best and are all guessing.
I've never said the figures are made up.
Firstly, I've said consistently that the PCR test is flawed with the way they thermo-cycle the RNA way above the nr of cycles that they should be thus you get a very high false positive percentage. I wrote to my MP asking why Mat Hancock won't publish the false positive rate given they seem to be able to publish every other number. He tells me that the only numbers he has are on the ONS site.
Secondly, why won't the govt publish comparisons of respiratory illness hospital admissions/deaths etc with last year. NHS trusts have been asked not to publish. The Manchester Evening News asked for the data through FOI during the last few days with all this Burnham flag waving and bin burning. All areas refused to provide.
There's no conspiracy. There is no second wave.
And also I see of you dig deep enough in all this stuff and links you'll find
https://www.gov.uk/government/publicatio...troduction
People/cases are now being counted across multiple reporting periods.
Perhaps someone can explain to me how this is not inflating the cases?
Posts: 8,953
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
(10-22-2020, 07:10 AM)billybassett Wrote: (10-21-2020, 06:46 PM)baggy1 Wrote: (10-21-2020, 05:16 PM)billybassett Wrote: (10-21-2020, 03:52 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Thanks Proth, and all good points tbh despite Dr. Billy's pointing out of the dubious medical knowledge that wasn't really the point of the article.
It actually makes a lot of sense and, if I'm reading it correctly, the focus should be on preparing the NHS for the inevitable. It does sum up where i am because my gut feeling is to have a short lockdown to bring the numbers down so that they don't multiply exponentially, but I also feel that there is no real end game to this approach until we get a vaccine of which there is no sight of. It would probably help if the politicians stopped giving the 'it's close' and it will be 'world beating' and just gave us how long each stage will go if it all goes perfectly, honest, answer. And based on my views above I have taken a side based on figures that are predictions.
Billy appears to have all bases covered though and if he's wrong he can just blame misinformation and any further excess deaths being down to non-covid reasons which will reinforce his views he is right.
Good article and has given me some for for though - appreciated
That's very unfair in all honesty.
Bit like me holding you to account for all future deaths due to lack of other treatments and general health impacts
It was a bit more tongue in cheek, but I do get frustrated with the conspiracy theory (all the figures are made up) approach that you take. The article spells out basically what is fact - we don't know what is best and are all guessing.
I've never said the figures are made up.
Firstly, I've said consistently that the PCR test is flawed with the way they thermo-cycle the RNA way above the nr of cycles that they should be thus you get a very high false positive percentage. I wrote to my MP asking why Mat Hancock won't publish the false positive rate given they seem to be able to publish every other number. He tells me that the only numbers he has are on the ONS site.
Secondly, why won't the govt publish comparisons of respiratory illness hospital admissions/deaths etc with last year. NHS trusts have been asked not to publish. The Manchester Evening News asked for the data through FOI during the last few days with all this Burnham flag waving and bin burning. All areas refused to provide.
There's no conspiracy. There is no second wave.
It's too early to say that Billy, I've shown through the weekly hospital admissions, people in hospital and those on ventilators that they are increasing at 1.5x each week and this week we have gone above the numbers in hospital when we locked down in March. We also know there is a two week delay between that information and excess deaths rising. I'll update tomorrow when todays figures come in to keep a consistent comparison but I predicted weeks ago that we would be at 6.75k in hospital by the end of this week and yesterday we went over 6k. At that same rate it will be 10k next week and in April the peak was 17k.
(10-22-2020, 07:42 AM)baggy1 Wrote: (10-22-2020, 07:10 AM)billybassett Wrote: (10-21-2020, 06:46 PM)baggy1 Wrote: (10-21-2020, 05:16 PM)billybassett Wrote: (10-21-2020, 03:52 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Thanks Proth, and all good points tbh despite Dr. Billy's pointing out of the dubious medical knowledge that wasn't really the point of the article.
It actually makes a lot of sense and, if I'm reading it correctly, the focus should be on preparing the NHS for the inevitable. It does sum up where i am because my gut feeling is to have a short lockdown to bring the numbers down so that they don't multiply exponentially, but I also feel that there is no real end game to this approach until we get a vaccine of which there is no sight of. It would probably help if the politicians stopped giving the 'it's close' and it will be 'world beating' and just gave us how long each stage will go if it all goes perfectly, honest, answer. And based on my views above I have taken a side based on figures that are predictions.
Billy appears to have all bases covered though and if he's wrong he can just blame misinformation and any further excess deaths being down to non-covid reasons which will reinforce his views he is right.
Good article and has given me some for for though - appreciated
That's very unfair in all honesty.
Bit like me holding you to account for all future deaths due to lack of other treatments and general health impacts
It was a bit more tongue in cheek, but I do get frustrated with the conspiracy theory (all the figures are made up) approach that you take. The article spells out basically what is fact - we don't know what is best and are all guessing.
I've never said the figures are made up.
Firstly, I've said consistently that the PCR test is flawed with the way they thermo-cycle the RNA way above the nr of cycles that they should be thus you get a very high false positive percentage. I wrote to my MP asking why Mat Hancock won't publish the false positive rate given they seem to be able to publish every other number. He tells me that the only numbers he has are on the ONS site.
Secondly, why won't the govt publish comparisons of respiratory illness hospital admissions/deaths etc with last year. NHS trusts have been asked not to publish. The Manchester Evening News asked for the data through FOI during the last few days with all this Burnham flag waving and bin burning. All areas refused to provide.
There's no conspiracy. There is no second wave.
It's too early to say that Billy, I've shown through the weekly hospital admissions, people in hospital and those on ventilators that they are increasing at 1.5x each week and this week we have gone above the numbers in hospital when we locked down in March. We also know there is a two week delay between that information and excess deaths rising. I'll update tomorrow when todays figures come in to keep a consistent comparison but I predicted weeks ago that we would be at 6.75k in hospital by the end of this week and yesterday we went over 6k. At that same rate it will be 10k next week and in April the peak was 17k.
But not above those figures for this time last year.
Posts: 8,953
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
10-22-2020, 08:35 AM
(This post was last modified: 10-22-2020, 08:36 AM by baggy1.)
(10-22-2020, 08:21 AM)billybassett Wrote: But not above those figures for this time last year.
Last year we didn't have a virus that caused death in the same way that covid does, and we had more staff to deal with the numbers as this time our NHS Staff are having to isolate on a regular basis.
Now there are a couple of points that need to be raised to add to Billy's points - the excess death rate this time is unlikely to match the one from earlier in the year because of three key points, they are not planning on decanting the virus from the hospital into the most vulnerable age group like they did in March; we have better treatment for the virus this time from what we learned the 1st time, and generally the population is more aware and taking appropriate precautions.
And it is correct that the hospitals have always had a capacity problem at this time of year (exacerbated by a decade of cuts) but covid just adds to that problem, it doesn't replace last years problems.
So my point still stands that it is too early to say one way or the other.
I think I'll leave it a this as I'll just repeat myself and we won't agree.
Covid deaths Ioannidis WHO report under 70s 0.05% for all 0.23% (news is it will be revised down to 0.12-0.2%). So it's no more deadly than a bad seasonal flu.
Covid doesn't add to the problem because it's flu and as a whole respiratory illness admissions are actually below this time last year.
A second wave of cases is not a second wave.
Posts: 8,953
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
(10-22-2020, 08:51 AM)billybassett Wrote: I think I'll leave it a this as I'll just repeat myself and we won't agree.
Covid deaths Ioannidis WHO report under 70s 0.05% for all 0.23% (news is it will be revised down to 0.12-0.2%). So it's no more deadly than a bad seasonal flu.
Covid doesn't add to the problem because it's flu and as a whole respiratory illness admissions are actually below this time last year.
A second wave of cases is not a second wave.
All fair points but please stop confusing cases with hospital admissions and ventilator usage.
(10-22-2020, 08:53 AM)baggy1 Wrote: (10-22-2020, 08:51 AM)billybassett Wrote: I think I'll leave it a this as I'll just repeat myself and we won't agree.
Covid deaths Ioannidis WHO report under 70s 0.05% for all 0.23% (news is it will be revised down to 0.12-0.2%). So it's no more deadly than a bad seasonal flu.
Covid doesn't add to the problem because it's flu and as a whole respiratory illness admissions are actually below this time last year.
A second wave of cases is not a second wave.
All fair points but please stop confusing cases with hospital admissions and ventilator usage.
Trying not to
Govt won't post this year's for some reason.
October 2016 had around 24,500 admissions, which is an average of 790 per day. Covid admissions this month up to the 18th are 10,503 with 13 days to go. The month started at around 370 per day and reached about 800 as of October 18th, so is currently running about average.
We will also expect a rise through Nov and Dec. So this hysteria about reducing cases is nothing new for a regular year but if I remember correctly 2016 didn't see a tier system to lock people down or mask wearing or social distancing.
We've got to be really careful about what we're chasing here. We're putting our future health at risk for what is now looking like a normal flu season.
Posts: 8,953
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
The article that you picked that up from in the Spectator is so misleading and obviously answer driven it's painful. The figures you quote from that are around 700 unplanned admissions per day (for all respiratory conditions) to compare that with 300 covid per day. It doesn't expand on what the total respiratory admission were which would give a like for like comparison. And then it talks about the winter deaths figure for 2017 / 2018 without acknowledging we haven't been through a winter phase of this virus.
Stats can be used to show what the writer wants, it's up to the reader to understand the details and not just believe every word because it fits their story.
(10-22-2020, 09:30 AM)baggy1 Wrote: The article that you picked that up from in the Spectator is so misleading and obviously answer driven it's painful. The figures you quote from that are around 700 unplanned admissions per day (for all respiratory conditions) to compare that with 300 covid per day. It doesn't expand on what the total respiratory admission were which would give a like for like comparison. And then it talks about the winter deaths figure for 2017 / 2018 without acknowledging we haven't been through a winter phase of this virus.
Stats can be used to show what the writer wants, it's up to the reader to understand the details and not just believe every word because it fits their story.
I don't think I follow any of that. We expect a rise Sep-Dec that's what we're getting. Covid or no covid.
Easiest way of course is for Hancock to publish the figures in context with other years and also to publish the FPR.
I see no reason for them not to - do you?
You can keep posting the latest figures, and I thank you for that and all your commentary because it really does make me think, but without context they are generally meaningless. How can you possibly take the right actions if you don't actually know if hospital admissions are in line with previous demand led years. Counter to that is of course they do know and hence why they are locking people down... but then if that was the case they'd publish the figures wouldn't they as it would be clear evidence to do such a thing.
|