Go on then just do one
#31
(10-20-2020, 04:53 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(10-20-2020, 04:47 PM)HeavyWoollenBaggie Wrote: Given that this is American money, and in the case of Liverpool/Utd, American owners, I think this will, if it happens, play out on a conference based-system like all US sports.  It may start with 4 x 6 or 6 x 4 conferences, but present your successful business case and your suitcase of cash and, hey you're in.  Would expect a 48-team league within 10 years-including Middle East, Asian, N/S American  conferences as long-distance games will be limited.    Gives the likes of the sleeping giants/inventors of the game/whatever in Witton the chance to join the party if they can demonstrate that they are, for once, genuinely a big club.

For the rest of us it really is a fork in the road.  Only England and Germany has a culture of mass fan-driven club loyalty with large attendances outside the top half of the top league and into the second tier.  In France, Italy etc, those attendances look pretty non-league very quickly.    JohnnyKayeEngland is bang on the money-if this is to work for the rest of us then it has to be a one-way door.  Go and you're gone.  No reserve teams, U21 teams, feeder teams, fancy surreptitious investments-just fuck off and don't come back.  Then, and only then might, and I don't think it's a given, the two levels of football develop a permanently different indentity that fans can relate to.  Oddly enough in the way that many identify with non-league football now as being "different" to the professional game.

Excellent post, especially the second paragraph.

+2

Unfortunately reserve teams, loans, B-teams, academy tie ups etc will very quickly become the norm. There are an awful lot of people who’ve invested a lot of money into clubs outside the big 6 to try and get a chunk of their profits/glory.

If those clubs leave, TV revenues, merchandise, sponsorship will completely dwindle and clubs will have to refocus and become self sustaining very quickly. The gulf in wages between a player moving from the ESL to a national division won’t be sustainable so there will have to be tie ups between local and European clubs - much like how the MLS works with MLS2 teams in the NSL in the US.
Reply
#32
(10-20-2020, 04:53 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(10-20-2020, 04:47 PM)HeavyWoollenBaggie Wrote: Given that this is American money, and in the case of Liverpool/Utd, American owners, I think this will, if it happens, play out on a conference based-system like all US sports.  It may start with 4 x 6 or 6 x 4 conferences, but present your successful business case and your suitcase of cash and, hey you're in.  Would expect a 48-team league within 10 years-including Middle East, Asian, N/S American  conferences as long-distance games will be limited.    Gives the likes of the sleeping giants/inventors of the game/whatever in Witton the chance to join the party if they can demonstrate that they are, for once, genuinely a big club.

For the rest of us it really is a fork in the road.  Only England and Germany has a culture of mass fan-driven club loyalty with large attendances outside the top half of the top league and into the second tier.  In France, Italy etc, those attendances look pretty non-league very quickly.    JohnnyKayeEngland is bang on the money-if this is to work for the rest of us then it has to be a one-way door.  Go and you're gone.  No reserve teams, U21 teams, feeder teams, fancy surreptitious investments-just fuck off and don't come back.  Then, and only then might, and I don't think it's a given, the two levels of football develop a permanently different indentity that fans can relate to.  Oddly enough in the way that many identify with non-league football now as being "different" to the professional game.

Excellent post, especially the second paragraph.

+2

Unfortunately reserve teams, loans, B-teams, academy tie ups etc will very quickly become the norm. There are an awful lot of people who’ve invested a lot of money into clubs outside the big 6 to try and get a chunk of their profits/glory.

If those clubs leave, TV revenues, merchandise, sponsorship will completely dwindle and clubs will have to refocus and become self sustaining very quickly. The gulf in wages between a player moving from the ESL to a national division won’t be sustainable so there will have to be tie ups between local and European clubs - much like how the MLS works with MLS2 teams in the NSL in the US.
Reply
#33
If you read the article it very much looks like a replacement to the Champions League. The clubs won't be leaving us, just earning hundreds of millions£ more from this league whilst the TV rights to the PL drop significantly. It even mentions taking games to Asia and other continents. They want their cake and to eat it.

Explains why they wanted to hijack the ownership of the PL - cut the teams to 18 so they can fit the Euro game in, pass a much smaller domestic TV deal and make qualification to this league a non-starter for those outside the top 6.

When they eventually go to this league they need to go at every level as HeavyWoollen says. It should also be covered by a different Governing body so no players can be loaned in\out of this league to any domestic level.

They can take VAR with them as well.
Reply
#34
(10-20-2020, 05:09 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: If you read the article it very much looks like a replacement to the Champions League.  The clubs won't be leaving us, just earning hundreds of millions£ more from this league whilst the TV rights to the PL drop significantly.  It even mentions taking games to Asia and other continents. They want their cake and to eat it.

Explains why they wanted to hijack the ownership of the PL - cut the teams to 18 so they can fit the Euro game in, pass a much smaller domestic TV deal and make qualification to this league a non-starter for those outside the top 6.

When they eventually go to this league they need to go at every level as HeavyWoollen says. It should also be covered by a different Governing body so no players can be loaned in\out of this league to any domestic level.

They can take VAR with them as well.

Agreed you cannot have it both ways, get the riches of the Champions League, but blood your younger players in the domestic league. You may aswell rename the prem the English Football combination league.
Reply
#35
(10-20-2020, 05:09 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: If you read the article it very much looks like a replacement to the Champions League.  The clubs won't be leaving us, just earning hundreds of millions£ more from this league whilst the TV rights to the PL drop significantly.  It even mentions taking games to Asia and other continents. They want their cake and to eat it.

Explains why they wanted to hijack the ownership of the PL - cut the teams to 18 so they can fit the Euro game in, pass a much smaller domestic TV deal and make qualification to this league a non-starter for those outside the top 6.

When they eventually go to this league they need to go at every level as HeavyWoollen says. It should also be covered by a different Governing body so no players can be loaned in\out of this league to any domestic level.

They can take VAR with them as well.

+10000%
Reply
#36
I agree with most of what HWB writes, but disagree on the lack of support claimed. Clubs in Scandinavia and Holland also have mass bases, esp. in proportion to population. Also, in Scandinavia most clubs were, until recently, mass member-owned rather than corporate toys. Think what you write mostly applies to France and maybe Italy.
Reply
#37
Let them go, but......
Expel any teams joining this league from the Premier League and EFL;
Ban any players registered for an ESL team from playing in the PL/EFL (no buying all the best young players and loaning them out);
Only PL/EFL players eligible to play for England.

Sadly, as ever the big clubs will be allowed to do what they want and it wouldn’t be long before the next tier of clubs clamoured to form an ESL second division.

I really hate what football has become.
Reply
#38
(10-20-2020, 05:48 PM)Babel Wrote: I agree with most of what HWB writes, but disagree on the lack of support claimed. Clubs in Scandinavia and Holland also have mass bases, esp. in proportion to population. Also, in Scandinavia most clubs were, until recently, mass member-owned rather than corporate toys. Think what you write mostly applies to France and maybe Italy.

I really hope you are right mate, and pardon my ignorance if I'm wrong.   Fan resistance is the only defence going forwards.
Reply
#39
And what will UEFA have to say about all this?! Ooooh - pant wetting gone mad I suspect. Then they’ll tip up and ask to organise it all no doubt.
Reply
#40
(10-20-2020, 06:23 PM)Brentbaggie Wrote: And what will UEFA have to say about all this?! Ooooh - pant wetting gone mad I suspect. Then they’ll tip up and ask to organise it all no doubt.

UEFA will protest, threaten court action etc, then come on board anyway when the $ signs are flashed. Their moneymaker is the 'Champions' League. Without the big clubs the competition is a worthless one that nobody watches, bit like the Europa League.

I for one long for the day that the big uns feck off and take their corporations with them. Hopefully then player wages will come down to a reasonable level domestically, clubs that operate within their means will be in a healthy position and success or failure will depend on the quality of your manager, your players' commitment, the money you generate through gate receipts and the quality of your youth system. Not which corporation/arab country wants to outspend the other.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: