Posts: 289
Threads: 28
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
2
(10-08-2020, 11:59 AM)billybassett Wrote: (10-08-2020, 10:05 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Anyone who thinks that if we just let the virus run unheeded through the population and we can trust the British people to do the right thing is not living n the real world. I’m not a fan of this government to put it mildly but they have to try no matter how incompetently to manage the risk to health and the economy which is never going to please everyone. At either end of the spectrum you have fruit loops demanding complete lockdown or open everything up it’s no worse than the flu types. As ever the answer will be somewhere in the middle. Lobbying for extreme positions is why this and the US are such clusterfucks culturally and politically now.
It already is running through the population unheeded that's the point. It's respiratory disease it can be stopped and latest figures show that those places with local lockdown saw an increase in cases specifically because of that point. You've only got to look at London as an example of this and the herd immunity threshold.
The reason the figures were so high in Mar/Apr is because old and vulnerable people with the disease went back to care homes - notwithstanding the science probably suggests a full lockdown was probably the right thing to do although the epidemic ended end of May and the casedemic began early July when testing came more fully on line.
The cost to health and wellbeing in the country due to non-Covid matters will far outweigh the number of deaths due to Covid over the next 10 years. No doubt the media and those with interests elsewhere will keep peddling this sensational nonsense around cases and mortality (0.06%)
That guy Prof Ferguson who's advising the govt...PhD is in theoretical physics & has no qualifications in any biologically related field. Vallance has financial interests in pushing the case for vaccines, as does Ferguson. He sits on the managing board of the global vaccine prediction unit at Imperial, an entity financed by the Gates Foundation, around $11M? I’m sure there’s no conflict there.
i don't believe Ferguson is advising the government any longer due to his bed hopping antics during lockdown which pretty much sums up why we have no chance of controlling this as, has already been stated, lots of people from the top down to the bottom don't think the rules apply to them.
Posts: 17,072
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(10-08-2020, 11:59 AM)billybassett Wrote: (10-08-2020, 10:05 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Anyone who thinks that if we just let the virus run unheeded through the population and we can trust the British people to do the right thing is not living n the real world. I’m not a fan of this government to put it mildly but they have to try no matter how incompetently to manage the risk to health and the economy which is never going to please everyone. At either end of the spectrum you have fruit loops demanding complete lockdown or open everything up it’s no worse than the flu types. As ever the answer will be somewhere in the middle. Lobbying for extreme positions is why this and the US are such clusterfucks culturally and politically now.
It already is running through the population unheeded that's the point. It's respiratory disease it can be stopped and latest figures show that those places with local lockdown saw an increase in cases specifically because of that point. You've only got to look at London as an example of this and the herd immunity threshold.
The reason the figures were so high in Mar/Apr is because old and vulnerable people with the disease went back to care homes - notwithstanding the science probably suggests a full lockdown was probably the right thing to do although the epidemic ended end of May and the casedemic began early July when testing came more fully on line.
The cost to health and wellbeing in the country due to non-Covid matters will far outweigh the number of deaths due to Covid over the next 10 years. No doubt the media and those with interests elsewhere will keep peddling this sensational nonsense around cases and mortality (0.06%)
That guy Prof Ferguson who's advising the govt...PhD is in theoretical physics & has no qualifications in any biologically related field. Vallance has financial interests in pushing the case for vaccines, as does Ferguson. He sits on the managing board of the global vaccine prediction unit at Imperial, an entity financed by the Gates Foundation, around $11M? I’m sure there’s no conflict there.
It wasn’t just because of Care Homes there are currently over 600 deaths of NHS staff and social care linked to Covid. Source the Independant.
42 Transport for London workers died by May this year alone.
I want more than just your word that more people will die as a result of what are pretty lax lockdown rules currently in place across the country. Why the arbitrary ten years? What about the next twelve months?
The ONS figures debunk the Flu death argument.
How do you think those who are vulnerable (no not just the elderly although it shouldn’t matter either way) and their families health and wellbeing will be if people just go back to normal which you have advocated? Are they to be locked away whilst everyone does wtf they like? I will do some guesswork and suggest they will suffer the most from lockdown, financially, emotionally and with regards to their health .
The R rate in London is higher than the West Mids and the North West and we are miles off herd immunity anywhere in the country. In August just 6% of the country were estimated to have had the virus and that figure would apparently need to be nearer 80%. I suspect London s not locked down because it’s London and they would be loathe to close the capital down with more punitive restrictions.
Posts: 13,568
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
(10-08-2020, 09:14 AM)hudds Wrote: (10-08-2020, 12:10 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (10-07-2020, 05:30 PM)hudds Wrote: (10-07-2020, 02:43 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Isn't it cheaper to buy a shit tonne of vodka and a shit tonne of sugar free Red Bull now with the minimum alcohol pricing they've got in Scotland?
?
I would have thought Bucky would be more expensive now with the minimum price increase.
A quick Google though suggests I'm wrong as hilariously the most problematic drink in Scotland owing to being a cheap tonic wine is exempt. Nope, lid - it's not exempt. Amazingly, for a pretty low strength product (15% abv) it is selling at £7.99 which means that the Minimum Unit Pricing doesn't kick in. It is an expensive product in relative terms. For some reason it has garnered a reputation in parts of Scotland as some sort of potent elixir but it's just a fortified wine. You may as well buy a bottle of cheap "British sherry"* for half the price and the same strength (but the MUP would raise the base price a bit).
*You can't call the stuff British Sherry any more due the "Spanish Agreement" (which took in more than that issue) but we all know what the muck is.
People buy it because it's 15% abv and it's got a shittonne of caffeine in it so you get shit faced quickly with a big caffeine buzz, same reason people buy Jaegerbombs.
(10-08-2020, 02:52 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (10-08-2020, 11:59 AM)billybassett Wrote: (10-08-2020, 10:05 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Anyone who thinks that if we just let the virus run unheeded through the population and we can trust the British people to do the right thing is not living n the real world. I’m not a fan of this government to put it mildly but they have to try no matter how incompetently to manage the risk to health and the economy which is never going to please everyone. At either end of the spectrum you have fruit loops demanding complete lockdown or open everything up it’s no worse than the flu types. As ever the answer will be somewhere in the middle. Lobbying for extreme positions is why this and the US are such clusterfucks culturally and politically now.
It already is running through the population unheeded that's the point. It's respiratory disease it can be stopped and latest figures show that those places with local lockdown saw an increase in cases specifically because of that point. You've only got to look at London as an example of this and the herd immunity threshold.
The reason the figures were so high in Mar/Apr is because old and vulnerable people with the disease went back to care homes - notwithstanding the science probably suggests a full lockdown was probably the right thing to do although the epidemic ended end of May and the casedemic began early July when testing came more fully on line.
The cost to health and wellbeing in the country due to non-Covid matters will far outweigh the number of deaths due to Covid over the next 10 years. No doubt the media and those with interests elsewhere will keep peddling this sensational nonsense around cases and mortality (0.06%)
That guy Prof Ferguson who's advising the govt...PhD is in theoretical physics & has no qualifications in any biologically related field. Vallance has financial interests in pushing the case for vaccines, as does Ferguson. He sits on the managing board of the global vaccine prediction unit at Imperial, an entity financed by the Gates Foundation, around $11M? I’m sure there’s no conflict there.
It wasn’t just because of Care Homes there are currently over 600 deaths of NHS staff and social care linked to Covid. Source the Independant.
42 Transport for London workers died by May this year alone.
I want more than just your word that more people will die as a result of what are pretty lax lockdown rules currently in place across the country. Why the arbitrary ten years? What about the next twelve months?
The ONS figures debunk the Flu death argument.
How do you think those who are vulnerable (no not just the elderly although it shouldn’t matter either way) and their families health and wellbeing will be if people just go back to normal which you have advocated? Are they to be locked away whilst everyone does wtf they like? I will do some guesswork and suggest they will suffer the most from lockdown, financially, emotionally and with regards to their health .
The R rate in London is higher than the West Mids and the North West and we are miles off herd immunity anywhere in the country. In August just 6% of the country were estimated to have had the virus and that figure would apparently need to be nearer 80%. I suspect London s not locked down because it’s London and they would be loathe to close the capital down with more punitive restrictions.
Again you're misinterpreting my perceived lack of concern for the vulnerable. They are vulnerable every year in the yearly flu that we get. In 2018 lots of those people unfortunately died. Never heard a peep from anyone then.
Your final para quotes so many numbers that are counter to your need to see "I want more than just your word ".
Quoting Yeardon: "In spring it was the epicentre of an intense outbreak. Many hundreds were dying daily in hospitals in the wider London area. Now it isn’t. What else? Well, such outbreaks as occur would be much more likely to expand selectively in areas which had fewer casualties in spring. It’s not a surprise to me that the deaths now are disproportionately in the NE, MW & parts of the midlands. But there’s something else you’d expect to see if we were close to the HIT. It’s that the apparent rate of transmission will be markedly lower than in spring. We in U.K. don’t have as much data on the deaths aspect (which is great) but if you look for a moment at ‘cases’ not just in U.K. but cases & deaths in France & Spain as well. As soon as you see this, you cannot ‘unsee’ it. If you want to check this for yourself, go to OWID covid19, select one of these countries, select cases & importantly, select ‘log’ depictions. It’s unmistakable. The slope of the log transformed data is almost a straight line, but it’s gradient today is roughly 20% of what it was during the rapid phase in March & April. It may be argued that the lower slope is a sign of how effective our measures are being. I disagree, for two main reasons. Firstly, there’s no evidence of reduction in transmission of other respiratory viruses like ‘flu & of course common colds. So that’s not what’s made the slope much flatter. The other reason is that the slopes are reduced in every country, despite there being measures of differing timing & severity. No, Occam’s Razor tells us that the simplest explanation not only fits the data, but it requires no unlikely coincidence of other events. The clearly lower slope of the plots now vs spring not only tells us that we’re in the vicinity of the HIT, but it also tells us that this is going to self-limiting, just as it was in spring. Ferguson was wrong in March & he and SAGE are wrong now. He’s overestimated by over 10-fold. Easily done, but I hear nothing but arrogance from him. He’s sticking to his predictions, even though they’re impossible now to be correct."
Posts: 776
Threads: 7
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
0
"The ONS figures debunk the Flu death argument"
would it be reasonable to think that covid killed some people earlier who would have died anyway through the flu?
we had a year not so long ago where there were 50k flu deaths and the country just operated as normal.
we cant hide forever from covid. if we had a definitive date on a vaccine id think differently
protect the elderly and the vulnerable and let everyone else get on with life.
i think most people are being sensible and have adhered well to the measures that have been asked of them.
Posts: 4,043
Threads: 149
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
10
(10-08-2020, 03:13 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (10-08-2020, 09:14 AM)hudds Wrote: (10-08-2020, 12:10 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (10-07-2020, 05:30 PM)hudds Wrote: (10-07-2020, 02:43 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Isn't it cheaper to buy a shit tonne of vodka and a shit tonne of sugar free Red Bull now with the minimum alcohol pricing they've got in Scotland?
?
I would have thought Bucky would be more expensive now with the minimum price increase.
A quick Google though suggests I'm wrong as hilariously the most problematic drink in Scotland owing to being a cheap tonic wine is exempt. Nope, lid - it's not exempt. Amazingly, for a pretty low strength product (15% abv) it is selling at £7.99 which means that the Minimum Unit Pricing doesn't kick in. It is an expensive product in relative terms. For some reason it has garnered a reputation in parts of Scotland as some sort of potent elixir but it's just a fortified wine. You may as well buy a bottle of cheap "British sherry"* for half the price and the same strength (but the MUP would raise the base price a bit).
*You can't call the stuff British Sherry any more due the "Spanish Agreement" (which took in more than that issue) but we all know what the muck is.
People buy it because it's 15% abv and it's got a shittonne of caffeine in it so you get shit faced quickly with a big caffeine buzz, same reason people buy Jaegerbombs.
British sherry is miles cheaper and the same strength to get shitfaced - Buckfast has just got a bad boy rep that is bonkers. I had to explain this to a minister for Scottish matters about 25 year ago when in HMCE HQ (as was).
Posts: 13,568
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
(10-08-2020, 05:29 PM)hudds Wrote: (10-08-2020, 03:13 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (10-08-2020, 09:14 AM)hudds Wrote: (10-08-2020, 12:10 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (10-07-2020, 05:30 PM)hudds Wrote: ?
I would have thought Bucky would be more expensive now with the minimum price increase.
A quick Google though suggests I'm wrong as hilariously the most problematic drink in Scotland owing to being a cheap tonic wine is exempt. Nope, lid - it's not exempt. Amazingly, for a pretty low strength product (15% abv) it is selling at £7.99 which means that the Minimum Unit Pricing doesn't kick in. It is an expensive product in relative terms. For some reason it has garnered a reputation in parts of Scotland as some sort of potent elixir but it's just a fortified wine. You may as well buy a bottle of cheap "British sherry"* for half the price and the same strength (but the MUP would raise the base price a bit).
*You can't call the stuff British Sherry any more due the "Spanish Agreement" (which took in more than that issue) but we all know what the muck is.
People buy it because it's 15% abv and it's got a shittonne of caffeine in it so you get shit faced quickly with a big caffeine buzz, same reason people buy Jaegerbombs.
British sherry is miles cheaper and the same strength to get shitfaced - Buckfast has just got a bad boy rep that is bonkers. I had to explain this to a minister for Scottish matters about 25 year ago when in HMCE HQ (as was).
Sherry doesn't have caffeine in it though unlike Buckfast. You can get shitfaced but you won't get that buzz.
It's not just the alcohol content, hence why I brought up Jaegerbombs.
Posts: 4,043
Threads: 149
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
10
(10-08-2020, 05:37 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (10-08-2020, 05:29 PM)hudds Wrote: (10-08-2020, 03:13 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (10-08-2020, 09:14 AM)hudds Wrote: (10-08-2020, 12:10 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: I would have thought Bucky would be more expensive now with the minimum price increase.
A quick Google though suggests I'm wrong as hilariously the most problematic drink in Scotland owing to being a cheap tonic wine is exempt. Nope, lid - it's not exempt. Amazingly, for a pretty low strength product (15% abv) it is selling at £7.99 which means that the Minimum Unit Pricing doesn't kick in. It is an expensive product in relative terms. For some reason it has garnered a reputation in parts of Scotland as some sort of potent elixir but it's just a fortified wine. You may as well buy a bottle of cheap "British sherry"* for half the price and the same strength (but the MUP would raise the base price a bit).
*You can't call the stuff British Sherry any more due the "Spanish Agreement" (which took in more than that issue) but we all know what the muck is.
People buy it because it's 15% abv and it's got a shittonne of caffeine in it so you get shit faced quickly with a big caffeine buzz, same reason people buy Jaegerbombs.
British sherry is miles cheaper and the same strength to get shitfaced - Buckfast has just got a bad boy rep that is bonkers. I had to explain this to a minister for Scottish matters about 25 year ago when in HMCE HQ (as was).
Sherry doesn't have caffeine in it though unlike Buckfast. You can get shitfaced but you won't get that buzz.
It's not just the alcohol content, hence why I brought up Jaegerbombs. Well, per what you said about vodka and Red Bull mixing, I suppose you could hit the QC and ProPlus...
You can get a full litre of British sherry for £5.50 instead of £7.99 for 75 cl Buckfast!! How much are caffeine tabs?
See you, Jimmy
Posts: 13,568
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
(10-08-2020, 05:49 PM)hudds Wrote: (10-08-2020, 05:37 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (10-08-2020, 05:29 PM)hudds Wrote: (10-08-2020, 03:13 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (10-08-2020, 09:14 AM)hudds Wrote: Nope, lid - it's not exempt. Amazingly, for a pretty low strength product (15% abv) it is selling at £7.99 which means that the Minimum Unit Pricing doesn't kick in. It is an expensive product in relative terms. For some reason it has garnered a reputation in parts of Scotland as some sort of potent elixir but it's just a fortified wine. You may as well buy a bottle of cheap "British sherry"* for half the price and the same strength (but the MUP would raise the base price a bit).
*You can't call the stuff British Sherry any more due the "Spanish Agreement" (which took in more than that issue) but we all know what the muck is.
People buy it because it's 15% abv and it's got a shittonne of caffeine in it so you get shit faced quickly with a big caffeine buzz, same reason people buy Jaegerbombs.
British sherry is miles cheaper and the same strength to get shitfaced - Buckfast has just got a bad boy rep that is bonkers. I had to explain this to a minister for Scottish matters about 25 year ago when in HMCE HQ (as was).
Sherry doesn't have caffeine in it though unlike Buckfast. You can get shitfaced but you won't get that buzz.
It's not just the alcohol content, hence why I brought up Jaegerbombs. Well, per what you said about vodka and Red Bull mixing, I suppose you could hit the QC and ProPlus...
You can get a full litre of British sherry for £5.50 instead of £7.99 for 75 cl Buckfast!! How much are caffeine tabs?
See you, Jimmy
Yeah, but the people who drink Buckfast are hardly the most intelligent or care about sensible budgeting.
Posts: 17,072
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(10-08-2020, 03:17 PM)billybassett Wrote: (10-08-2020, 02:52 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (10-08-2020, 11:59 AM)billybassett Wrote: (10-08-2020, 10:05 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Anyone who thinks that if we just let the virus run unheeded through the population and we can trust the British people to do the right thing is not living n the real world. I’m not a fan of this government to put it mildly but they have to try no matter how incompetently to manage the risk to health and the economy which is never going to please everyone. At either end of the spectrum you have fruit loops demanding complete lockdown or open everything up it’s no worse than the flu types. As ever the answer will be somewhere in the middle. Lobbying for extreme positions is why this and the US are such clusterfucks culturally and politically now.
It already is running through the population unheeded that's the point. It's respiratory disease it can be stopped and latest figures show that those places with local lockdown saw an increase in cases specifically because of that point. You've only got to look at London as an example of this and the herd immunity threshold.
The reason the figures were so high in Mar/Apr is because old and vulnerable people with the disease went back to care homes - notwithstanding the science probably suggests a full lockdown was probably the right thing to do although the epidemic ended end of May and the casedemic began early July when testing came more fully on line.
The cost to health and wellbeing in the country due to non-Covid matters will far outweigh the number of deaths due to Covid over the next 10 years. No doubt the media and those with interests elsewhere will keep peddling this sensational nonsense around cases and mortality (0.06%)
That guy Prof Ferguson who's advising the govt...PhD is in theoretical physics & has no qualifications in any biologically related field. Vallance has financial interests in pushing the case for vaccines, as does Ferguson. He sits on the managing board of the global vaccine prediction unit at Imperial, an entity financed by the Gates Foundation, around $11M? I’m sure there’s no conflict there.
It wasn’t just because of Care Homes there are currently over 600 deaths of NHS staff and social care linked to Covid. Source the Independant.
42 Transport for London workers died by May this year alone.
I want more than just your word that more people will die as a result of what are pretty lax lockdown rules currently in place across the country. Why the arbitrary ten years? What about the next twelve months?
The ONS figures debunk the Flu death argument.
How do you think those who are vulnerable (no not just the elderly although it shouldn’t matter either way) and their families health and wellbeing will be if people just go back to normal which you have advocated? Are they to be locked away whilst everyone does wtf they like? I will do some guesswork and suggest they will suffer the most from lockdown, financially, emotionally and with regards to their health .
The R rate in London is higher than the West Mids and the North West and we are miles off herd immunity anywhere in the country. In August just 6% of the country were estimated to have had the virus and that figure would apparently need to be nearer 80%. I suspect London s not locked down because it’s London and they would be loathe to close the capital down with more punitive restrictions.
Again you're misinterpreting my perceived lack of concern for the vulnerable. They are vulnerable every year in the yearly flu that we get. In 2018 lots of those people unfortunately died. Never heard a peep from anyone then.
Your final para quotes so many numbers that are counter to your need to see "I want more than just your word ".
Quoting Yeardon: "In spring it was the epicentre of an intense outbreak. Many hundreds were dying daily in hospitals in the wider London area. Now it isn’t. What else? Well, such outbreaks as occur would be much more likely to expand selectively in areas which had fewer casualties in spring. It’s not a surprise to me that the deaths now are disproportionately in the NE, MW & parts of the midlands. But there’s something else you’d expect to see if we were close to the HIT. It’s that the apparent rate of transmission will be markedly lower than in spring. We in U.K. don’t have as much data on the deaths aspect (which is great) but if you look for a moment at ‘cases’ not just in U.K. but cases & deaths in France & Spain as well. As soon as you see this, you cannot ‘unsee’ it. If you want to check this for yourself, go to OWID covid19, select one of these countries, select cases & importantly, select ‘log’ depictions. It’s unmistakable. The slope of the log transformed data is almost a straight line, but it’s gradient today is roughly 20% of what it was during the rapid phase in March & April. It may be argued that the lower slope is a sign of how effective our measures are being. I disagree, for two main reasons. Firstly, there’s no evidence of reduction in transmission of other respiratory viruses like ‘flu & of course common colds. So that’s not what’s made the slope much flatter. The other reason is that the slopes are reduced in every country, despite there being measures of differing timing & severity. No, Occam’s Razor tells us that the simplest explanation not only fits the data, but it requires no unlikely coincidence of other events. The clearly lower slope of the plots now vs spring not only tells us that we’re in the vicinity of the HIT, but it also tells us that this is going to self-limiting, just as it was in spring. Ferguson was wrong in March & he and SAGE are wrong now. He’s overestimated by over 10-fold. Easily done, but I hear nothing but arrogance from him. He’s sticking to his predictions, even though they’re impossible now to be correct."
Measuring Covid 19 with the Flu is a flawed comparison as the ONS figures demonstrate. Flu does pose a risk if you are vulnerable but compared to Covid 19 it poses significantly less.
I am interpreting your opinion as opening everything back up as normal. Which you mention on the politics board. This will further isolate those who are vulnerable, their families and carers. I haven’t read any solution / measures put in place for them to live with the freedoms you want for others. Without some compromise on people’s liberties vulnerable people will have no liberty at all. We as a society are better than that aren’t we? People had to stop smoking for other people’s health in public buildings, shops and pubs etc so society does adapt to think of others and normal isn’t static it changes with the needs of the time. Hopefully compromise will be relatively short lived but without compromise you will hurt the most vulnerable disproportionately. I’m not saying if your sympathetic or not I’m just drawing conclusions of what will happen given the argument to ‘get back to normal’.
My last paragraph was pretty clear those who have had the virus is approx 6% in Aug so possibly now it’s in the teens. To develop herd immunity you need approximately 70-80% and preferably a vaccine. We are nowhere near that figure and who knows where we are with a vaccine.
Them’s my onions anyway...
|