Posts: 3,161
Threads: 162
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
11
(02-01-2019, 07:59 AM)Duffers Wrote: It’s easier to develop a long term strategy when you’re in the PL rather than when you’re trying to get there. Those three players would have cost £20m+ had we tried to sign them permanently, then had we not gone up we’d have been saddled with them. This is us making a push for promotion but still staying within our means.
Football in general has become a short term concern, it’s not just us.
I’m not so sure that it’s any easier in the Prem, because that also breeds short term thinking in the scrap for survival.
I’m struggling to think of any club now which builds with a longer term view. A club like Brentford has been superb at scouting and developing young players which get sold for big money, which denies Brentford the chance to retain a strong team capable of promotion because they cannot hold onto them once bigger clubs come along who can pay them far bigger wages. Southampton have found this as well with their superb academy producing endless players for the big 6 to pick off whenever it suits them. If Saints produce top players who can be sold for £40-£50m, those players will know that they can earn £100k+/week from a move, and Saints because of FFP and STCC rules would never be able to pay more than £70k/week. All part of the master plan of the big 6 by using the FFP rules to prevent any other club breaking up their cosy clique, which got even tighter after Leicester’s year to make sure that it can’t happen again. All of the other 14 PL clubs know that they can’t keep any player which a big 6 club really wants. It all works against building a great team and keeping it together. No club from the 14 can easily say that no player is for sale. Agents and players have too much power now to force a move.
This all needs short-termism. Really quite pointless to plan beyond the next 12 months. A great example would be if we had brought Harvey Barnes through our ranks. Retaining him as “ours” would be impossible once he’d got to the point where he could command £100k/week. Sure, we’d get a huge transfer fee which we could use to buy good replacements, but then would be fighting to retain those replacements or pay them the wages that they could get elsewhere. It’s the law of the jungle and it ends up with the question of what’s the real point of the Premier League other than for the big 6 clubs? Everyone else is simply existing as a support act so that they can keep earning the PL millions which all goes out on wages and agents fees anyway. That’s sadly what the Premier League has become.
Posts: 1,674
Threads: 93
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
8
From the players perspective how many of these signings would have agreed to come to the Championship on a permanent move? Its a risk for them as it is us. There is an incentive to get us up, prove a point and earn a move.
Posts: 10,859
Threads: 497
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
23
(02-01-2019, 08:14 AM)albion_pigeon Wrote: (02-01-2019, 07:59 AM)Duffers Wrote: It’s easier to develop a long term strategy when you’re in the PL rather than when you’re trying to get there. Those three players would have cost £20m+ had we tried to sign them permanently, then had we not gone up we’d have been saddled with them. This is us making a push for promotion but still staying within our means.
Football in general has become a short term concern, it’s not just us.
Spot on there mon
Yep spot on. Also if we do go up who's to say Johansen and Murphy won't want to stay with us and permanent deals can be sorted.
I'd like to see the stats on this January window in terms of Perms and loans. My guess would be 80% loans.
It's just the way it works nowadays.
We've done very good business imo. Hats off to Dowling. Better than that useless fucking Hammond. What an organ he was...
Posts: 5,322
Threads: 356
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
02-01-2019, 08:46 AM
(This post was last modified: 02-01-2019, 08:52 AM by Shabby Russian.)
(02-01-2019, 08:13 AM)ColliersWoodBaggie Wrote: It makes sense for the reasons outlined above. I'd like more permanent signings, but it isn't that simple. And anyway, whose to say all of these will need to be replaced? We could well sign most of them if we went up (or even if we stay down).
Agree with this.
There is a scenario where everything goes tits up in the summer, We don't go up, none of the loanee players want to stay and we need to replace the mid 30s club. Leading to a situation where we are looking at bringing in over 10 signings in the summer, far from easy. But that is the worst case scenario.
I think we are slightly stronger at the end of January than we were at the beginning - hard to believe considering Barnes left. But the defence has a really solid look about it and the midfield has a better balance to it (especially if we continue to play a 3 and we utilise Harper and Field)
We may not score so many goals, but I think we are likely not to concede as many. Generally a bit more optimistic.
I do hope - with one eye looking to the future - that Harper, Field and Leko/Edwards are not totally frozen out of first team championship games. They have shown they can make positive contributions. Certainly in midfield I wouldn't want us to keep repeating the situation where on the subs bench we had a combination of 3 from Barry, Morrison, Brunt and Hoolihan.
Posts: 27,980
Threads: 1,168
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
64
(02-01-2019, 08:23 AM)Pragmatist Wrote: (02-01-2019, 07:59 AM)Duffers Wrote: It’s easier to develop a long term strategy when you’re in the PL rather than when you’re trying to get there. Those three players would have cost £20m+ had we tried to sign them permanently, then had we not gone up we’d have been saddled with them. This is us making a push for promotion but still staying within our means.
Football in general has become a short term concern, it’s not just us.
I’m not so sure that it’s any easier in the Prem, because that also breeds short term thinking in the scrap for survival.
I’m struggling to think of any club now which builds with a longer term view. A club like Brentford has been superb at scouting and developing young players which get sold for big money, which denies Brentford the chance to retain a strong team capable of promotion because they cannot hold onto them once bigger clubs come along who can pay them far bigger wages. Southampton have found this as well with their superb academy producing endless players for the big 6 to pick off whenever it suits them. If Saints produce top players who can be sold for £40-£50m, those players will know that they can earn £100k+/week from a move, and Saints because of FFP and STCC rules would never be able to pay more than £70k/week. All part of the master plan of the big 6 by using the FFP rules to prevent any other club breaking up their cosy clique, which got even tighter after Leicester’s year to make sure that it can’t happen again. All of the other 14 PL clubs know that they can’t keep any player which a big 6 club really wants. It all works against building a great team and keeping it together. No club from the 14 can easily say that no player is for sale. Agents and players have too much power now to force a move.
This all needs short-termism. Really quite pointless to plan beyond the next 12 months. A great example would be if we had brought Harvey Barnes through our ranks. Retaining him as “ours” would be impossible once he’d got to the point where he could command £100k/week. Sure, we’d get a huge transfer fee which we could use to buy good replacements, but then would be fighting to retain those replacements or pay them the wages that they could get elsewhere. It’s the law of the jungle and it ends up with the question of what’s the real point of the Premier League other than for the big 6 clubs? Everyone else is simply existing as a support act so that they can keep earning the PL millions which all goes out on wages and agents fees anyway. That’s sadly what the Premier League has become.
We had a long term system under Dashworth that was successful for a number of years, but so did the likes of Charlton, Swansea and a few others languishing in the lower leagues. Most plans and systems are only as good as the people implementing them, you’re only a couple of bad decisions or appointments away from having it all come crashing down. Something Southampton came very close to finding out. The other problem is that when you’re plan becomes successful other teams will copy and eventually will work out how’s to do things better than you.
Posts: 698
Threads: 42
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
1
I seem to remember that someone posted a while ago about there being a limit to the number of loan players named in a match day squad. Anyone know if that’s true and if so, what the number is?
Posts: 27,980
Threads: 1,168
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
64
(02-01-2019, 08:50 AM)lesley Wrote: I seem to remember that someone posted a while ago about there being a limit to the number of loan players named in a match day squad. Anyone know if that’s true and if so, what the number is?
It’s five, and we have six.
Posts: 698
Threads: 42
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
1
(02-01-2019, 08:51 AM)Duffers Wrote: (02-01-2019, 08:50 AM)lesley Wrote: I seem to remember that someone posted a while ago about there being a limit to the number of loan players named in a match day squad. Anyone know if that’s true and if so, what the number is?
It’s five, and we have six.
Thanks.
Posts: 4,322
Threads: 139
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
11
(02-01-2019, 08:46 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: I do hope - with one eye looking to the future - that Harper, Field and Leko/Edwards are not totally frozen out of first team championship games.
This is the only down side to the business we have done. If they dont get a chance in the Championship, it will be even harder to break through should we go up.
We have a lot of games coming up even without injuries, we will need to rotate, especially Barry/Brunt.
Posts: 3,109
Threads: 184
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
And Brunt is injured , isn't he? Went off at Bolton. How long for?
|