Johnstone
#61
(09-26-2020, 09:42 PM)The liquidator Wrote: What a bunch of wankers on here blaming  SJ

No attempt for number 1 
Piss poor attempt at a punch just before number 3.
Its not his fault as such , imo i blame Bilic for being blind towards him .
Reply
#62
(09-26-2020, 10:11 PM)Crossbar11 Wrote:
(09-26-2020, 09:42 PM)The liquidator Wrote: What a bunch of wankers on here blaming  SJ

No attempt for number 1 
Piss poor attempt at a punch just before number 3.
Its not his fault as such , imo i blame Bilic for being blind towards him .

He just isn't good enough, sadly.

We are seeing the same mistakes from him time and again.

Spandau makes an excellent point on another thread though, that when he played with the FKW at Villa, he looked a lot better. Here's hoping Ivanovic can add some organisation to the defence and help SJ.
Reply
#63
Can anyone actually say he’s improved since we signed him?
He’s played pretty much every game since the day he arrived and we’re still having these same arguments on here.
You would think with the amount of minutes you’d some signs of improvement.
That’s exactly my issue with him and why I don’t believe he’s anywhere near good enough
Reply
#64
I didn't think he had a bad game today. Clearly there's mixed feelings regarding the first goal. I think he'll be disappointed that he didn't make an attempt to save it, as he wasn't that far away from it, so could have stopped it.
Reply
#65
My vile friends said he started shaky but really improved with time.i havnt seen it here.maybe its not him but the defence in front of him thats making him play with no   confidence but like i said earlier good 1st half catching ball shot stopping but im not a fan of him. But i know its what weve gotta work with.but for people to come on here and say he shouldnt be criticised is nonsense. Any of our players all across the park are open to.it.he.s had more than some because of his performances.i think.6 is a correct score.room for improvement. Adequate game.
Reply
#66
Genuine observation here. Do goalkeepers get there eyes checked? I genuinely think he sees things very late and that may be down to his vision?

I really don’t want to always get embroiled in these debates but it will be IMO be the running theme until we eventually replace him. I think back to when we had Scott Carson and it was the recurring theme - week in and week out. We conceded 71 goals with Carson in goal and if we do survive this season I think we will concede a similar amount.

I actually wanted to know who people rated higher. Carson or Johnstone?
Reply
#67
If we keep conceding at the same rate, we will concede 140 goals this season.

Carson was woeful, but he won England caps playing for us, and had played over 110 Prem games, before he joined us aged 25. He has England caps, and played in Europe.

SJ is 28 in March (he isnt a kid anymore) and made his Prem debut a few weeks ago. I never thought I would say this, but I think Carson (as bad as he was) was a better keeper.
Reply
#68
(09-26-2020, 11:29 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: If we keep conceding at the same rate, we will concede 140 goals this season.

Carson was woeful, but he won England caps playing for us, and had played over 110 Prem games, before he joined us aged 25. He has England caps, and played in Europe.

SJ is 28 in March (he isnt a kid anymore) and made his Prem debut a few weeks ago. I never thought I would say this, but I think Carson (as bad as he was) was a better keeper.

It’s disheartening to actually keep discussing the same thing over and over again.

He signed a 4 year deal in 2018. So he’s out of contract in 2022. We will stay up in spite of him rather than because of him. I genuinely believe Josh Griffiths is the real deal and hope he gets 40+ games under his belt at Cheltenham this year. It’s one of the reasons IMO the club hasn’t spend big this Summer. I believe Griffiths could be ready next Summer. He’s that good IMO
Reply
#69
(09-26-2020, 11:34 PM)Super_Slav Wrote:
(09-26-2020, 11:29 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: If we keep conceding at the same rate, we will concede 140 goals this season.

Carson was woeful, but he won England caps playing for us, and had played over 110 Prem games, before he joined us aged 25. He has England caps, and played in Europe.

SJ is 28 in March (he isnt a kid anymore) and made his Prem debut a few weeks ago. I never thought I would say this, but I think Carson (as bad as he was) was a better keeper.

It’s disheartening to actually keep discussing the same thing over and over again.

He signed a 4 year deal in 2018. So he’s out of contract in 2022. We will stay up in spite of him rather than because of him. I genuinely believe Josh Griffiths is the real deal and hope he gets 40+ games under his belt at Cheltenham this year

if Palmer has a good year, he could step up next season.
Reply
#70
Super slav not joking someone else actually said that to me earlier this evening.has he got something wrong with his sight
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: