An Outsider's View
#31
Could have done with a bit of Villa jam with the VAR decision yesterday. Shame the monitors were turned on for us......
Reply
#32
(09-20-2020, 02:19 PM)Peachy Wrote: Could have done with a bit of Villa jam with the VAR decision yesterday. Shame the monitors were turned on for us......

Yep, that certainly did help us, equally the goal we scored against Palace which was disallowed hurt us.
Reply
#33
FAO Begley.

Great post.

Quick question - as an outsider looking in what are your thoughts on Sam Johnstone? I really hope Ivanovic is the Terry moment he had at Villa, as I recall he struggled initially but became a fans favourite in your run to the final when you lost to Fulham.

Are we overly critical as we compare him to Foster?

Intrigued to know.
Reply
#34
(09-20-2020, 02:06 PM)Begley Wrote:
(09-20-2020, 01:40 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(09-20-2020, 01:11 PM)Baggie_Nick Wrote:
(09-20-2020, 01:08 PM)ericlegrisly Wrote: Is it just me that finds the opening post just a tiny bit patronising?

Nope.

Particularly the last paragraph.

I nearly spat my beer out with the bit about defending set pieces. The comfort I draw is that the seals defended set pieces that badly all last season, with a comic goal keeper for half of it, and survived.

They also spunked billions on non-scoring goal scorers, and relied on a talisman to survive.

If Pereira can add Olymoic diving to his game then we should survive and pick up the points at the end of the season when everyone else is on the beach.

I too would take Villa's defending of set pieces last season as comfort. We were absolutely dire at it and it still shocks me that a defender as good as JT (I did say a 'defender' and not a person, I am not keen on the guy) could let a back 4 look so much like Sunday league. So it is possible to stay up with crap defending.

I think you will be 12th-15th, Begley, surviving comfortably.

Your bigger problem will be next season. Whilst I wish we had supportive owners like you, and FFP will allow owners to cover Covid shortfalls, you won't have much room to manoeuvre on accumulated losses. You are gambling that this next batch of expensive signings will develop over the next few seasons. FWIW I think they will.
Reply
#35
(09-20-2020, 02:27 PM)Super_Slav Wrote: FAO Begley.

Great post.

Quick question - as an outsider looking in what are your thoughts on Sam Johnstone? I really hope Ivanovic is the Terry moment he had at Villa, as I recall he struggled initially but became a fans favourite in your run to the final when you lost to Fulham.

Are we overly critical as we compare him to Foster?

Intrigued to know.
I liked Sam when he was at Villa and I was majorly pissed off we could not afford to keep him and even more pissed off when you guys took him. I felt he was our keeper (although a Man U GK) and we needed him and he was suddenly a Baggie. He is not a spectacular GK but I do think he is competent. Like most GKs he needs a decent 4 in front of him and he just doesn't have that now so it is very easy to jump on his back and blame him. A defense needs a leader who will marshal the back 4 and constantly tell them where they should be. In our year before promotion when JT was in the back 4 he was brilliant and he covered up a lot of the cracks in the defense as he managed the back 4. The next season when we lost his influence during a game we fell apart and Mings did not step up. So we had poor and inexperienced defenders who did not know what to do. Ivanovic is real quality and if age was not considered a factor he would be Baggies best player. He is at a level above every other player u have imo. I think the issue is his age and fitness. If he keeps fit he could turn out to be the best signing u have made in years. He is absolutely worth the risk of whatever wages u are paying him. I think he will be key to your survival chances. I do hope he works out for u and takes on the responsibility to manage the back 4.
Reply
#36
(09-20-2020, 03:23 PM)Begley Wrote:
(09-20-2020, 02:27 PM)Super_Slav Wrote: FAO Begley.

Great post.

Quick question - as an outsider looking in what are your thoughts on Sam Johnstone? I really hope Ivanovic is the Terry moment he had at Villa, as I recall he struggled initially but became a fans favourite in your run to the final when you lost to Fulham.

Are we overly critical as we compare him to Foster?

Intrigued to know.
I liked Sam when he was at Villa and I was majorly pissed off we could not afford to keep him and even more pissed off when you guys took him. I felt he was our keeper (although a Man U GK) and we needed him and he was suddenly a Baggie. He is not a spectacular GK but I do think he is competent. Like most GKs he needs a decent 4 in front of him and he just doesn't have that now so it is very easy to jump on his back and blame him. A defense needs a leader who will marshal the back 4 and constantly tell them where they should be. In our year before promotion when JT was in the back 4 he was brilliant and he covered up a lot of the cracks in the defense as he managed the back 4. The next season when we lost his influence during a game we fell apart and Mings did not step up. So we had poor and inexperienced defenders who did not know what to do. Ivanovic is real quality and if age was not considered a factor he would be Baggies best player. He is at a level above every other player u have imo. I think the issue is his age and fitness. If he keeps fit he could turn out to be the best signing u have made in years. He is absolutely worth the risk of whatever wages u are paying him. I think he will be key to your survival chances. I do hope he works out for u and takes on the responsibility to manage the back 4.

Thanks Begley. 

We hope so too.
Reply
#37
(09-20-2020, 02:32 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(09-20-2020, 02:06 PM)Begley Wrote:
(09-20-2020, 01:40 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(09-20-2020, 01:11 PM)Baggie_Nick Wrote:
(09-20-2020, 01:08 PM)ericlegrisly Wrote: Is it just me that finds the opening post just a tiny bit patronising?

Nope.

Particularly the last paragraph.

I nearly spat my beer out with the bit about defending set pieces. The comfort I draw is that the seals defended set pieces that badly all last season, with a comic goal keeper for half of it, and survived.

They also spunked billions on non-scoring goal scorers, and relied on a talisman to survive.

If Pereira can add Olymoic diving to his game then we should survive and pick up the points at the end of the season when everyone else is on the beach.

I too would take Villa's defending of set pieces last season as comfort. We were absolutely dire at it and it still shocks me that a defender as good as JT (I did say a 'defender' and not a person, I am not keen on the guy) could let a back 4 look so much like Sunday league. So it is possible to stay up with crap defending.

I think you will be 12th-15th, Begley, surviving comfortably.

Your bigger problem will be next season. Whilst I wish we had supportive owners like you, and FFP will allow owners to cover Covid shortfalls, you won't have much room to manoeuvre on accumulated losses. You are gambling that this next batch of expensive signings will develop over the next few seasons. FWIW I think they will.

Yeah, completely agree, next season will be tough. We simply can't continue this level of spending and the more we spend now the less we can spend next summer, so the team we are building really needs to for the spine of a long term team that only needs slight improvement each year. 40m / 50m a year on one or 2 players should be well within spending power of any PL team that is confident of staying in the PL. I think Villa's strategy at the moment is to try and consolidate as a PL team. There are no delusions of making top 6 or 8 or anything like that. PL means 150m revenue every year, if we can stay in the PL for 4 years then the spending spree is covered. Then in 4 years time strategy can be reassessed and owners can decide if they really want to roll the dice and try and break into top half.
Reply
#38
This is a weird thread
Reply
#39
It is. Come back DK!!
Reply
#40
(09-20-2020, 03:42 PM)Mr vertical Wrote: It is. Come back DK!!

Agree, come back Dingle Don.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)