Ratings
#11
(09-16-2020, 07:39 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(09-16-2020, 07:23 PM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote: Field deserves a 7. He's the sort of defensive midfielder we will need in the Prem. Proved under Meggo he can do it at this level.

You mean he did well in two games?

Jury is still out for me.

Did exceptionally well in both. Meggo could spot a player.
Reply
#12
(09-16-2020, 07:48 PM)Artist Wrote:
Quote:Grosicki 6 - tonight's scapegoat? nowhere near as bad as some are suggesting


He was fine, a bit wasteful.

I thought he was piss poor. I have always been quite critical of him though so it may be through those glasses i judge. 

Hes a slightly better Cal McManaman for me.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#13
Button 7

Peltier 6
Kipre. 7
O'Shea. 7
Townsend. 7

Grosicki 4
Harper 7
Field. 7
Edwards. 8

Austin 4
HRK. 5

Subs:

Sawyers. 6
Phillips. 6
Robinson. 7
Reply
#14
Field can pass, tackle, seemingly shoot too but posotiinally he needs a lot of work.

Having said that we were all over the shop at the weekend
Reply
#15
Slightly off topic but remember when Big Dave thought he could turn Field into a centre half.

Tonight was boring as sin, Harrogate an absolute waste of a space in the competition. We learn literally nothing.
Reply
#16
(09-16-2020, 07:59 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: Slightly off topic but remember when Big Dave thought he could turn Field into a centre half.

Tonight was boring as sin, Harrogate an absolute waste of a space in the competition. We learn literally nothing.

Good fitness and valuable minutes for our fringe players. Some staked a claim and we got some goals and confidence. 

Tonight was a decent night for us.
Reply
#17
Interesting how people see a game so differently, well documented I doubt Fields ability to play at our level but tonight I thought he did very well

Button 7 Decent distribution, came off his line a couple of times which made a pleasant change. Looked solid and one good save

Peltier 6 - Smaller than I remember - or seemed it on TV - OK, still struggle to see why we've gave him a year with the cover we have at RB with Ivanovic also signing

Townsend 7 - Good distribution, 90 minutes will do him good, always decent enough on the ball, his lack of pace at top level will find him out but not tested tonight

Kipre 6 - Solid, a bit shakey at times but showed glimpses of the player we know he is, strong, not slow and decent ball to HRK for the second

O Shea 7 - Thought he was very good first half when they asked their questions, always gives 100% and tonight no different

Harper 6 - Close to a 7, great goal, some real good stuff and then some woeful stuff both in and out of possession, still think he needs a full season in the Chump to see how he shapes up, will hurt us if plays in the Prem

Field 7 - As per opening line, impressed me in all honesty, good use of ball, kept us ticking over, works hard off the ball, suited better in a three but did little wrong for me tonight and clearly the Charlton loan has done him some good

HRK 6 - Great goal some good link up play but played well below the level he showed last year and the level we need him to be at this season

Austin 4 - Sorry just not for me, finished at this level and the Chump for me, effort is there but way too slow and sloppy in and out of possession to offer anything, As mentioned Austin of 2 years ago would have got a hat-trick tonight, if we need him in any capcity in the Prem we are fucked!

Krosicki 5 - I think he has a lot to offer us, even if it's from the bench when chasing a game but underwhelmed a bit tonight, pace to burn and didn't use it enough

Edwards 7* Great skill for the goal and came to life in 2nd half, a bit quiet for me in 1st half when he really should be tearing sides like these a new one but plenty of potential as we know

Subs

Phillips 5 - Get the impression Slav has a bit of time for him but again well passed it for me and be good to move him on if possible, should have scored and one good change laid on for Chaz who fluffed his lines

Sawyers 5 - Stroll around midfield, not much shown but will no doubt get the nod Saturday given our limited options, lets hope for more

Robinson 6 - Some decent movement, goal will do him good

Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Reply
#18
(09-16-2020, 08:38 PM)Cuzer Wrote: Interesting how people see a game so differently, well documented I doubt Fields ability to play at our level but tonight I thought he did very well

Button 7 Decent distribution, came off his line a couple of times which made a pleasant change. Looked solid and one good save

Peltier 6 - Smaller than I remember - or seemed it on TV - OK, still struggle to see why we've gave him a year with the cover we have at RB with Ivanovic also signing

Townsend 7 - Good distribution, 90 minutes will do him good, always decent enough on the ball, his lack of pace at top level will find him out but not tested tonight

Kipre 6 - Solid, a bit shakey at times but showed glimpses of the player we know he is, strong, not slow and decent ball to HRK for the second

O Shea 7 - Thought he was very good first half when they asked their questions, always gives 100% and tonight no different

Harper 6 - Close to a 7, great goal, some real good stuff and then some woeful stuff both in and out of possession, still think he needs a full season in the Chump to see how he shapes up, will hurt us if plays in the Prem

Field 7 - As per opening line, impressed me in all honesty, good use of ball, kept us ticking over, works hard off the ball, suited better in a three but did little wrong for me tonight and clearly the Charlton loan has done him some good

HRK 6 - Great goal some good link up play but played well below the level he showed last year and the level we need him to be at this season

Austin 4 - Sorry just not for me, finished at this level and the Chump for me, effort is there but way too slow and sloppy in and out of possession to offer anything, As mentioned Austin of 2 years ago would have got a hat-trick tonight, if we need him in any capcity in the Prem we are fucked!

Krosicki 5 - I think he has a lot to offer us, even if it's from the bench when chasing a game but underwhelmed a bit tonight, pace to burn and didn't use it enough

Edwards 7* Great skill for the goal and came to life in 2nd half, a bit quiet for me in 1st half when he really should be tearing sides like these a new one but plenty of potential as we know

Subs

Phillips 5 - Get the impression Slav has a bit of time for him but again well passed it for me and be good to move him on if possible, should have scored and one good change laid on for Chaz who fluffed his lines

Sawyers 5 - Stroll around midfield, not much shown but will no doubt get the nod Saturday given our limited options, lets hope for more

Robinson 6 - Some decent movement, goal will do him good

Cuzer

Agree with this Cuz
Thought Field was better than Harper - he showed more maturity and composure off the ball... It’s a shame Field and Harper don’t have a few of each others attributes as there’d be a hell of a player if you combined them!

HRK and Austin showed once again they are not PL players.

Last season we were a decent striker away from being a top Championship side... unfortunately we are still a decent striker away from being a top Championship side, and we’re in the PL.
Reply
#19
Good marketh Cuz lad. I'd give Button one extra for the strength of that right-hand save into the danger-free zone; top-class 'keeping.

Agree on Austin, he's shot. Brain still there but body no longer obeys. Bags else to be happy about on the grass tonight though; also a clean sheet for the new boy in pink and 10 unfamiliar faces. No injuries too and extra time avoided. I'm happy.
Reply
#20
Good marks Cuzer. Agree with all apart from Sawyers. I’d mark him 4. He was anonymous after coming on. I’d be mightily worried about him if I was Bilic.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: