Question regarding the disparity of the Prem?
#1
Being old enough to remember before 1992, I recall the likes of Forest winning the League straight from Promotion and many a promoted side giving it a real go the first season up, such as Watford. 
The gap between the top two divisions were very close and Div 2, as it was then, was very much still in the spotlight with more than the occasional match from it on the likes of Match of the Day/Star Soccer.
Now though, we know there's a chasm between the divisions due to money flowing into the top clubs that have left all bar a handful of clubs with little hope of winning the league or even a cup. The Championship/old Div 2 has no profile whatsoever and the ignorance of pundits demonstrates this.
I recall the points distribution of the top division was much more even and the disparity of now is demonstrated by the fact that Leeds number of points in the Championship per game, would have seen them six points behind Man C in 3rd place in the Prem in a like for like points per game average over 46 games. 
Equally Villa would have been bottom by 3 points in the Championship averaging what they did, yet they survived.
Just wondering has anyone ever seen an article/graph or just how uneven the Prem is to illustrate how non-competitive it is, because it's often cited without in-depth evidence?
By the way, these rough maths by me should help some of you who have forgot after 2 seasons just what type of division this is. We can still be gash and stop us as Villa showed, and we also did in 2005. There's hope so long as there's 3 other rubbish teams at least.
Reply
#2
Only seven teams have won the Premiership in 28 years....

A rough quick count suggests 9 teams won the First Division in the 28 years prior to the Premier league.

So not as much difference as I was expecting.
Reply
#3
(09-14-2020, 01:51 PM)MassDebater Wrote: Only seven teams have won the Premiership in 28 years....

A rough quick count suggests 9 teams won the First Division in the 28 years prior to the Premier league.

So not as much difference as I was expecting.

Think that’s a decent stat but it papers over the disparity. Wait until the Prem is around 50 years and still the same clubs have won it. 
There’s barely any fluidity in the top 6 and it’s all but a cartel now. More years of this lopsided hype will prove this to those who actually like sport to be competitive.
Reply
#4
(09-14-2020, 01:57 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(09-14-2020, 01:51 PM)MassDebater Wrote: Only seven teams have won the Premiership in 28 years....

A rough quick count suggests 9 teams won the First Division in the 28 years prior to the Premier league.

So not as much difference as I was expecting.

Think that’s a decent stat but it papers over the disparity. Wait until the Prem is around 50 years and still the same clubs have won it. 
There’s barely any fluidity in the top 6 and it’s all but a cartel now. More years of this lopsided hype will prove this to those who actually like sport to be competitive.

It's not so much the difference between the prem and championship that bothers me, I think decent sides getting promoted can and often do compete with the lower sides in the Prem. It's more the top few who have such a ridiculous level of resources compared to the rest that means it's all but impossible for most to compete, you could take a reserve team for the top few sides and it could beat most in the division.
Reply
#5
(09-14-2020, 01:57 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(09-14-2020, 01:51 PM)MassDebater Wrote: Only seven teams have won the Premiership in 28 years....

A rough quick count suggests 9 teams won the First Division in the 28 years prior to the Premier league.

So not as much difference as I was expecting.

Think that’s a decent stat but it papers over the disparity. Wait until the Prem is around 50 years and still the same clubs have won it. 
There’s barely any fluidity in the top 6 and it’s all but a cartel now. More years of this lopsided hype will prove this to those who actually like sport to be competitive.

I think it's pretty much worse in all other top leagues though. Spain's La Liga has only ever had NINE different winners for example (Real 34 times Barca 26), since 1929. SIX different winners since 1992 season. 6 different runners up since 92.

I think Italy's Serie A has only been won by ten different teams in its history (since 1929/30). Six different winners since 1992 (however they had a season of scandal and relegations and such like). Six different teams in second.

I think the Bundesliga has been won by nine different teams since 1963 (they've had 43 different champions, but what with East German leagues being counted it's trickier to work out). SIX different champions since 1992. 9 Different runners up.

So it turns out the winner spread for the Premiership is comparable to other top leagues. There have been 8 different Premiership runners up.

So what it proves is what we all know, the Premiership can be bought and frequently is, just like the other top leagues. The real disparity is money as usual.

P.S. for a laugh i checked Scotland, 2 different winners since 1992 will surprise nobody. they've had 5 different teams finish second in that time.

Oh the First Division in the previous 28 years had 12 different runners up, so that more goes with where you are heading with your thinking.

Interestingly there have been 10 different teams that have finished third in the Premiership. However, in the last 10 years there have been 5, with 6 different teams in second, and 5 different winners.

ALL of the last ten seasons, Leicester excepted, have had a combination of the teams who finished first, second or third ONLY, no other team has broken into the top three in the last ten years.

The last ten seasons of the Premiership has only had a mix of eight teams in the top 3, and it would be seven if Leicester hadn't done what they did.

The last ten years of the First Division had 5 different teams in third, 5 in second and 4 different champions. A total of ten teams made up the top 3 in the last ten years of the First Division.

So again, the stats suggest it's not that different, just that before premiership more teams had a chance of finishing second or third.
Reply
#6
You've only got to read this recent article by Swiss Ramble to see why theres such disparity

https://twitter.com/SwissRamble/status/1...77984?s=19

The £27m non noted dividend payment we made to the owner in 2015-16 is interesting. And Villas finances are incredibly dodgy

In fact it's amazing we can compete with Leeds and Fulham when you look at the owner financing they've have over the years. Plus the 1.3bn Man City have been given is incredible
Reply
#7
(09-14-2020, 03:03 PM)billybassett Wrote: You've only got to read this recent article by Swiss Ramble to see why theres such disparity

https://twitter.com/SwissRamble/status/1...77984?s=19

The £27m non noted dividend payment we made to the owner in 2015-16 is interesting. And Villas finances are incredibly dodgy

In fact it's amazing we can compete with Leeds and Fulham when you look at the owner financing they've have over the years. Plus the 1.3bn Man City have been given is incredible

Must admit I don't fully understand these sort of figures...anyone able to explain them in non accountancy speak?
Reply
#8
(09-14-2020, 03:03 PM)billybassett Wrote: You've only got to read this recent article by Swiss Ramble to see why theres such disparity

https://twitter.com/SwissRamble/status/1...77984?s=19

The £27m non noted dividend payment we made to the owner in 2015-16 is interesting. And Villas finances are incredibly dodgy

In fact it's amazing we can compete with Leeds and Fulham when you look at the owner financing they've have over the years. Plus the 1.3bn Man City have been given is incredible

Apparently that £27m was bounced from one account to the other to avoid corp tax.

That aside, I'm happy we're a self-sustaining club, I think sugar daddy stuff that some clubs do, plus the sportwashing that Man City are engaged in is not how football should be.
This afternoon, Kyle Edwards tweeted about being disappointed with the result, but pleased to make his PL debut after 16 years at Albion. That is an achievement the club should be proud of. I just wish the rich kids would go off and form their own league.
Reply
#9
(09-14-2020, 03:19 PM)Squid Wrote:
(09-14-2020, 03:03 PM)billybassett Wrote: You've only got to read this recent article by Swiss Ramble to see why theres such disparity

https://twitter.com/SwissRamble/status/1...77984?s=19

The £27m non noted dividend payment we made to the owner in 2015-16 is interesting. And Villas finances are incredibly dodgy

In fact it's amazing we can compete with Leeds and Fulham when you look at the owner financing they've have over the years. Plus the 1.3bn Man City have been given is incredible

Apparently that £27m was bounced from one account to the other to avoid corp tax.

That aside, I'm happy we're a self-sustaining club, I think sugar daddy stuff that some clubs do, plus the sportwashing that Man City are engaged in is not how football should be.
This afternoon, Kyle Edwards tweeted about being disappointed with the result, but pleased to make his PL debut after 16 years at Albion. That is an achievement the club should be proud of. I just wish the rich kids would go off and form their own league.

They did and we got promoted to it.
Reply
#10
(09-14-2020, 02:16 PM)MassDebater Wrote:
(09-14-2020, 01:57 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(09-14-2020, 01:51 PM)MassDebater Wrote: Only seven teams have won the Premiership in 28 years....

A rough quick count suggests 9 teams won the First Division in the 28 years prior to the Premier league.

So not as much difference as I was expecting.

Think that’s a decent stat but it papers over the disparity. Wait until the Prem is around 50 years and still the same clubs have won it. 
There’s barely any fluidity in the top 6 and it’s all but a cartel now. More years of this lopsided hype will prove this to those who actually like sport to be competitive.

I think it's pretty much worse in all other top leagues though. Spain's La Liga has only ever had NINE different winners for example (Real 34 times Barca 26), since 1929. SIX different winners since 1992 season. 6 different runners up since 92.

I think Italy's Serie A has only been won by ten different teams in its history (since 1929/30). Six different winners since 1992 (however they had a season of scandal and relegations and such like). Six different teams in second.

I think the Bundesliga has been won by nine different teams since 1963 (they've had 43 different champions, but what with East German leagues being counted it's trickier to work out). SIX different champions since 1992. 9 Different runners up.

So it turns out the winner spread for the Premiership is comparable to other top leagues. There have been 8 different Premiership runners up.

So what it proves is what we all know, the Premiership can be bought and frequently is, just like the other top leagues. The real disparity is money as usual.

P.S. for a laugh i checked Scotland, 2 different winners since 1992 will surprise nobody. they've had 5 different teams finish second in that time.

Oh the First Division in the previous 28 years had 12 different runners up, so that more goes with where you are heading with your thinking.

Interestingly there have been 10 different teams that have finished third in the Premiership. However, in the last 10 years there have been 5, with 6 different teams in second, and 5 different winners.

ALL of the last ten seasons, Leicester excepted, have had a combination of the teams who finished first, second or third ONLY, no other team has broken into the top three in the last ten years.

The last ten seasons of the Premiership has only had a mix of eight teams in the top 3, and it would be seven if Leicester hadn't done what they did.

The last ten years of the First Division had 5 different teams in third, 5 in second and 4 different champions. A total of ten teams made up the top 3 in the last ten years of the First Division.

So again, the stats suggest it's not that different, just that before premiership more teams had a chance of finishing second or third.

I think it depends what stats you want to look at. its utterly clear that the disparity in football is getting wider. Add the FA Cup and you will see that the same old faces have it utterly sewn up now, with appearances by non big clubs getting rarer.
No room for Cov, Wimbledon, Southampton, Ipswich winning the cup now like in the 70s and 80s. Wigan the last ones to do it several years ago.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)