Biggest disappointing signings of all time
#1
So as an Albion career that failed to get going, despite a huge fee, I wonder where Burke sits in the list of biggest big fee disappointments?
To me, a fan since 1975, I'd place him alongside Luke Moore, but still behind David Mills. No one else really jumps out, but sure there are a good few.
One thing I'm glad about though, as someone who recalls both well, with the constant social media chatter and Talkshite being invented since David Mills days, is that we didn't have social media then.
Reading jibes and general negative stuff based on underwhelming footballers who for some reason don't gel at the club is draining.
We've had very few failures past decade or more, which says much about our general progression as a club.
Reply
#2
Krychowiak, still convinced there's a hell of a player there but obviously playing for TTITC made him about as motivated as a hungover student.
In the form of his life.
Reply
#3
Ideye - one of our first big out of the blue signings, came with a good record in Europe and was absolutely shit... aside from a month where he turned into Pele, then shit again.

Krychowiak - was an absolute monster at Sevilla, moved to PSG and couldn't get in the side. Thought we were getting one of the best midfielders outside the top four. In reality what we got was an overweight tourist who only ever made one decent pass. I remember him smashing a 15 yard pass into the stand at Brighton and thinking "oh fuck"

Sturridge - we all knew what was going to happen. Didn't make it any less frustrating when it inevitably did.
Reply
#4
(09-09-2020, 01:27 PM)Midget In A Pinstripe Suit Wrote: Krychowiak, still convinced there's a hell of a player there but obviously playing for TTITC made him about as motivated as a hungover student.
Good one, how did I forget him, which says it all. Reputation as a world class performer, as high profile as they come, and then nothing!
Reply
#5
Chadli - had a good start. Scored and assisted a few then was never seen again. Our record signing until recently.

Lambert - although he was at the tail end of his career, he just left Liverpool and was on the cusp of the England squad. Woeful
Reply
#6
Scott Sinclair - Thought he’s be brilliant for us. How wrong I was!
Reply
#7
(09-09-2020, 01:33 PM)Dumbo Wrote: Chadli - had a good start. Scored and assisted a few then was never seen again. Our record signing until recently.

Lambert - although he was at the tail end of his career, he just left Liverpool and was on the cusp of the England squad. Woeful

I was never positive about Lambert, felt the writing was on the wall for that one.

Burke, Krychowiak Chadli were really exciting signings - just a shame the time when we've been our biggest draw and had our strongest budget was when we had Pulis in the chair. 

Chadli could have been an absolute star here, but his flair was gradually trained out of him and Krychowiak must have had 2 or 3 training sessions and thought "what the hell am I doing here"

To a lesser extent, I was really excited when Rondon arrived... he was a big player who had a hell of a reputation. Realise he didn't fail anywhere near as much as the above, but he just wasn't what we, or indeed Pulis, thought we were getting.
Reply
#8
Scott Sinclair
Reply
#9
I was buzzing when we signed Burke....
Reply
#10
Ellington
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: