Ivan Toney
#21
The amount of money being paid for a League 1 player by a Championship club is ridiculous. Emphasises how important it was to go up last season as there's no way that we'd be able to justify that fee now let alone as a Championship club no matter how good a player he is.
Reply
#22
(09-01-2020, 10:03 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: The amount of money being paid for a League 1 player by a Championship club is ridiculous. Emphasises how important it was to go up last season as there's no way that we'd be able to justify that fee now let alone as a Championship club no matter how good a player he is.

I guess the know they will recoup the money with the sales of Watkins and Benrahma
Reply
#23
(08-31-2020, 12:41 PM)Dumbo Wrote: Watkins look like he’s going to Villa.

Brilliant signing for Brentford. Even better one for Villa, if it happens.

There's no guarantee he'll be a success or fare any better than Wesley, or Samatta (should have signed his brother Wots instead).  

Look at Pukki, absolute class at Champ level and scored 30 last season in Champ.  11 last. 

Can anyone name anyone who has moved from the Championship in recent years for big money and been a real success?  

McBurnie was last season's flavour of the month after scoring 24 goals last season and has scored 6 in 36 for Sheff U.    Robinson scored 1.  

As long as Villa keep signing non-proven Premier League/Championship players they ain't going anywhere fast.
Reply
#24
(09-01-2020, 10:47 AM)Hopalong Wrote:
(08-31-2020, 12:41 PM)Dumbo Wrote: Watkins look like he’s going to Villa.

Brilliant signing for Brentford. Even better one for Villa, if it happens.

There's no guarantee he'll be a success or fare any better than Wesley, or Samatta (should have signed his brother Wots instead).  

Look at Pukki, absolute class at Champ level and scored 30 last season in Champ.  11 last. 

Can anyone name anyone who has moved from the Championship in recent years for big money and been a real success?  

McBurnie was last season's flavour of the month after scoring 24 goals last season and has scored 6 in 36 for Sheff U.    Robinson scored 1.  

As long as Villa keep signing non-proven Premier League/Championship players they ain't going anywhere fast.

I was pondering this. I thought Che Adams would do well at Saints, but he's hardly set them on fire either.
Reply
#25
(09-01-2020, 10:47 AM)Hopalong Wrote:
(08-31-2020, 12:41 PM)Dumbo Wrote: Watkins look like he’s going to Villa.

Brilliant signing for Brentford. Even better one for Villa, if it happens.

There's no guarantee he'll be a success or fare any better than Wesley, or Samatta (should have signed his brother Wots instead).  

Look at Pukki, absolute class at Champ level and scored 30 last season in Champ.  11 last. 

Can anyone name anyone who has moved from the Championship in recent years for big money and been a real success?  

McBurnie was last season's flavour of the month after scoring 24 goals last season and has scored 6 in 36 for Sheff U.    Robinson scored 1.  

As long as Villa keep signing non-proven Premier League/Championship players they ain't going anywhere fast.

I was pondering this. I thought Che Adams would do well at Saints, but he's hardly set them on fire either.
Reply
#26
You miss Maupay

How many strikers have moved from the Championship to the Premier League (suspect not that many) most have done well with teams they played for in the Championship (e.g. Wilson, King and Murray)

How many clubs have got promoted from the Championship with poor strikers? One springs to mind!!!!
Reply
#27
(09-01-2020, 12:36 PM)Gzbaggy Wrote: You miss Maupay

How many strikers have moved from the Championship to the Premier League (suspect not that many) most have done well with teams they played for in the Championship (e.g. Wilson, King and Murray)

How many clubs have got promoted from the Championship with poor strikers? One springs to mind!!!!

It's a very good point. I'm struggling to think of strikers that have been signed from the Championship to a Premier league club and done really well. Like you say the ones that have done the best have already been promoted with their clubs including our own Charlie Austin who bagged 18 for QPR in their relegation season. 

I really am struggling to think of any championship striker thats been signed and done really well. 

It just goes to show the gulf between the two divisions in terms of chances created/taken. Like someone said earlier Watkins has a conversion rate of 25% of chances created. Now that's great when your team create a lot of chances like Brentford did in the Chump. I think they created more than anybody. Villa created fuck all last season and Samatta and Wesley before his injury lived off scraps. When your only getting a couple of decent chances a game the pressure really ramps up. 

God how I'd love us to find another Odemwingie for a couple of mill!
Reply
#28
(09-01-2020, 12:36 PM)Gzbaggy Wrote: You miss Maupay

How many strikers have moved from the Championship to the Premier League (suspect not that many) most have done well with teams they played for in the Championship (e.g. Wilson, King and Murray)

How many clubs have got promoted from the Championship with poor strikers? One springs to mind!!!!

Depends what you determine as a success... I'd say anyone who comes into the PL and scores 10+ goals is a success?

Maupay got 10 in a side that barely scores
Chris Wood has scored double figures at Burnley
Gray did well at Burnley but plummetted at Watford
Pukki getting 11 in that Norwich side is an achievement!

It does seem that teams that get promoted with a decent striker do better than those that are purchased, and it also seems big units who can hold the ball up seem to do better than other types... Deeney, Wilson, King, Holt, Lambert, Vardy, JRod, Ulloa, Murray...  over half of those are "target men"

Whilst we do need a striker, maybe we need a younger Deeney... someone who is an effective battering ram, and who can create space for Pereira and hopefully Kov.  We also need to bring in someone with decent delivery from set pieces and get back to working on actually scoring from corners again.
Reply
#29
(09-01-2020, 12:54 PM)Peachy Wrote:
(09-01-2020, 12:36 PM)Gzbaggy Wrote: You miss Maupay

How many strikers have moved from the Championship to the Premier League (suspect not that many) most have done well with teams they played for in the Championship (e.g. Wilson, King and Murray)

How many clubs have got promoted from the Championship with poor strikers? One springs to mind!!!!

It's a very good point. I'm struggling to think of strikers that have been signed from the Championship to a Premier league club and done really well. Like you say the ones that have done the best have already been promoted with their clubs including our own Charlie Austin who bagged 18 for QPR in their relegation season. 

I really am struggling to think of any championship striker thats been signed and done really well. 

It just goes to show the gulf between the two divisions in terms of chances created/taken. Like someone said earlier Watkins has a conversion rate of 25% of chances created. Now that's great when your team create a lot of chances like Brentford did in the Chump. I think they created more than anybody. Villa created fuck all last season and Samatta and Wesley before his injury lived off scraps. When your only getting a couple of decent chances a game the pressure really ramps up. 

God how I'd love us to find another Odemwingie for a couple of mill!

Spot on
Reply
#30
(09-01-2020, 12:59 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(09-01-2020, 12:36 PM)Gzbaggy Wrote: You miss Maupay

How many strikers have moved from the Championship to the Premier League (suspect not that many) most have done well with teams they played for in the Championship (e.g. Wilson, King and Murray)

How many clubs have got promoted from the Championship with poor strikers? One springs to mind!!!!

Depends what you determine as a success... I'd say anyone who comes into the PL and scores 10+ goals is a success?

Maupay got 10 in a side that barely scores
Chris Wood has scored double figures at Burnley
Gray did well at Burnley but plummetted at Watford
Pukki getting 11 in that Norwich side is an achievement!

It does seem that teams that get promoted with a decent striker do better than those that are purchased, and it also seems big units who can hold the ball up seem to do better than other types... Deeney, Wilson, King, Holt, Lambert, Vardy, JRod, Ulloa, Murray...  over half of those are "target men"

Whilst we do need a striker, maybe we need a younger Deeney... someone who is an effective battering ram, and who can create space for Pereira and hopefully Kov.  We also need to bring in someone with decent delivery from set pieces and get back to working on actually scoring from corners again.

The younger Deeney could be Muriqi who hasn't signed for anyone yet but can't see us paying 18m (and not one penny less!) up front as their Presidento has stated.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: