Sheff Wed
#21
(08-02-2020, 06:41 PM)Begley Wrote:
(08-01-2020, 06:02 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(07-31-2020, 11:11 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(07-31-2020, 10:52 PM)Pipkins Wrote: Funny that Villa never got punished

Villa have never been charged - remarkably

(07-31-2020, 10:52 PM)Pipkins Wrote: Funny that Villa never got punished

Villa have never been charged - remarkably

You can say that again!

Villa probably didn't get charged as they didn't break P&S rules. There isn't a single suggestion from any source to say that Villa did similar to Sheffield Wed, similar too to Derby. Neither club have done what Wed have been found guilty of.

Exactly.

Unfortunately Villa “broke” the rules, but found a work around by selling their training ground land, and also seemingly massively increasing their academy spend. As has been mooted, they were on the brink financially before Safawis and Edens came in, and I imagine Purslow ensured a few favours would be called in to save the league the embarrassment of Villa going under due to their rules.

Villa also sold their ground at a fair market rate, unlike Derby, and accounted for it appropriately, unlike Wednesday. 

I would love the arrogantdeludedfisheatingsealcunts to come unstuck but their owners played a blinder in bringing Purslow and his little black book in.
Reply
#22
(08-02-2020, 06:46 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(08-02-2020, 06:41 PM)Begley Wrote:
(08-01-2020, 06:02 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(07-31-2020, 11:11 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(07-31-2020, 10:52 PM)Pipkins Wrote: Funny that Villa never got punished

Villa have never been charged - remarkably

(07-31-2020, 10:52 PM)Pipkins Wrote: Funny that Villa never got punished

Villa have never been charged - remarkably

You can say that again!

Villa probably didn't get charged as they didn't break P&S rules. There isn't a single suggestion from any source to say that Villa did similar to Sheffield Wed, similar too to Derby. Neither club have done what Wed have been found guilty of.

Exactly.

Unfortunately Villa “broke” the rules, but found a work around by selling their training ground land, and also seemingly massively increasing their academy spend. As has been mooted, they were on the brink financially before Safawis and Edens came in, and I imagine Purslow ensured a few favours would be called in to save the league the embarrassment of Villa going under due to their rules.

Villa also sold their ground at a fair market rate, unlike Derby, and accounted for it appropriately, unlike Wednesday. 

I would love the arrogantdeludedfisheatingsealcunts to come unstuck but their owners played a blinder in bringing Purslow and his little black book in.

They didn't break the rules, the rules permitted for sale of assets at a profit. Villa Park was sold, which is a loophole which should be closed, but it is not against P&S. The sale of training ground was for HS2, it was not through choice or looking for a loophole. All businesses and residential properties along the HS2 line did similarly. It also afforded Villa the ability to spend significant funds on redeveloping their training ground as these monies do not count towards P&S. The idea that Purslow has people in his pocket is rediculous imo, everything is accounted for and in the public domain and it is nearly impossible to hide things. Villa's owners are clever and clever people tend to employ clever and very capable people. That is just smart business, unlike the stupidity that is going on at Wednesday. An A level Accounting student would know the implications of recording the sale of their ground in the wrong calendar year.

As for Derby, it will be very difficult to prove the ground was not sold at fair market value. It is not like there are many like properties for comparison and they did get an 'independent' valuation which DCFC can and no doubt will claim that they acted in upmost good-faith with this. I fully expect DCFC to get no punishment.
Reply
#23
(08-02-2020, 07:04 PM)Begley Wrote:
(08-02-2020, 06:46 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(08-02-2020, 06:41 PM)Begley Wrote:
(08-01-2020, 06:02 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(07-31-2020, 11:11 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: Villa have never been charged - remarkably


Villa have never been charged - remarkably

You can say that again!

Villa probably didn't get charged as they didn't break P&S rules. There isn't a single suggestion from any source to say that Villa did similar to Sheffield Wed, similar too to Derby. Neither club have done what Wed have been found guilty of.

Exactly.

Unfortunately Villa “broke” the rules, but found a work around by selling their training ground land, and also seemingly massively increasing their academy spend. As has been mooted, they were on the brink financially before Safawis and Edens came in, and I imagine Purslow ensured a few favours would be called in to save the league the embarrassment of Villa going under due to their rules.

Villa also sold their ground at a fair market rate, unlike Derby, and accounted for it appropriately, unlike Wednesday. 

I would love the arrogantdeludedfisheatingsealcunts to come unstuck but their owners played a blinder in bringing Purslow and his little black book in.

They didn't break the rules, the rules permitted for sale of assets at a profit. Villa Park was sold, which is a loophole which should be closed, but it is not against P&S. The sale of training ground was for HS2, it was not through choice or looking for a loophole. All businesses and residential properties along the HS2 line did similarly. It also afforded Villa the ability to spend significant funds on redeveloping their training ground as these monies do not count towards P&S. The idea that Purslow has people in his pocket is rediculous imo, everything is accounted for and in the public domain and it is nearly impossible to hide things. Villa's owners are clever and clever people tend to employ clever and very capable people. That is just smart business, unlike the stupidity that is going on at Wednesday. An A level Accounting student would know the implications of recording the sale of their ground in the wrong calendar year.

As for Derby, it will be very difficult to prove the ground was not sold at fair market value. It is not like there are many like properties for comparison and they did get an 'independent' valuation which DCFC can and no doubt will claim that they acted in upmost good-faith with this. I fully expect DCFC to get no punishment.
This is how I see it, too.

Not sure if they would have passed FFP for season18-19 or 19-20 if they had not flunked promotion though. Parachutes were running out, and the wage bill was monumental. I think they would have had to sell Sealish to balance the books.
Reply
#24
(08-02-2020, 07:04 PM)Begley Wrote:
(08-02-2020, 06:46 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(08-02-2020, 06:41 PM)Begley Wrote:
(08-01-2020, 06:02 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(07-31-2020, 11:11 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: Villa have never been charged - remarkably


Villa have never been charged - remarkably

You can say that again!

Villa probably didn't get charged as they didn't break P&S rules. There isn't a single suggestion from any source to say that Villa did similar to Sheffield Wed, similar too to Derby. Neither club have done what Wed have been found guilty of.

Exactly.

Unfortunately Villa “broke” the rules, but found a work around by selling their training ground land, and also seemingly massively increasing their academy spend. As has been mooted, they were on the brink financially before Safawis and Edens came in, and I imagine Purslow ensured a few favours would be called in to save the league the embarrassment of Villa going under due to their rules.

Villa also sold their ground at a fair market rate, unlike Derby, and accounted for it appropriately, unlike Wednesday. 

I would love the arrogantdeludedfisheatingsealcunts to come unstuck but their owners played a blinder in bringing Purslow and his little black book in.

They didn't break the rules, the rules permitted for sale of assets at a profit. Villa Park was sold, which is a loophole which should be closed, but it is not against P&S. The sale of training ground was for HS2, it was not through choice or looking for a loophole. All businesses and residential properties along the HS2 line did similarly. It also afforded Villa the ability to spend significant funds on redeveloping their training ground as these monies do not count towards P&S. The idea that Purslow has people in his pocket is rediculous imo, everything is accounted for and in the public domain and it is nearly impossible to hide things. Villa's owners are clever and clever people tend to employ clever and very capable people. That is just smart business, unlike the stupidity that is going on at Wednesday. An A level Accounting student would know the implications of recording the sale of their ground in the wrong calendar year.

As for Derby, it will be very difficult to prove the ground was not sold at fair market value. It is not like there are many like properties for comparison and they did get an 'independent' valuation which DCFC can and no doubt will claim that they acted in upmost good-faith with this. I fully expect DCFC to get no punishment.

I'm not so sure with Derby. £80m when West Ham's went for £40m, with property in Derby nowhere near comparable to London... Heck even Villa only sold theirs for £57m, again with property being massivley more expensive in Birmingham than in Derby.... They can have all the 'independent' valuations they like, there's no way on Earth it was worth £80m.
Reply
#25
(08-02-2020, 07:59 PM)MassDebater Wrote:
(08-02-2020, 07:04 PM)Begley Wrote:
(08-02-2020, 06:46 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(08-02-2020, 06:41 PM)Begley Wrote:
(08-01-2020, 06:02 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote: You can say that again!

Villa probably didn't get charged as they didn't break P&S rules. There isn't a single suggestion from any source to say that Villa did similar to Sheffield Wed, similar too to Derby. Neither club have done what Wed have been found guilty of.

Exactly.

Unfortunately Villa “broke” the rules, but found a work around by selling their training ground land, and also seemingly massively increasing their academy spend. As has been mooted, they were on the brink financially before Safawis and Edens came in, and I imagine Purslow ensured a few favours would be called in to save the league the embarrassment of Villa going under due to their rules.

Villa also sold their ground at a fair market rate, unlike Derby, and accounted for it appropriately, unlike Wednesday. 

I would love the arrogantdeludedfisheatingsealcunts to come unstuck but their owners played a blinder in bringing Purslow and his little black book in.

They didn't break the rules, the rules permitted for sale of assets at a profit. Villa Park was sold, which is a loophole which should be closed, but it is not against P&S. The sale of training ground was for HS2, it was not through choice or looking for a loophole. All businesses and residential properties along the HS2 line did similarly. It also afforded Villa the ability to spend significant funds on redeveloping their training ground as these monies do not count towards P&S. The idea that Purslow has people in his pocket is rediculous imo, everything is accounted for and in the public domain and it is nearly impossible to hide things. Villa's owners are clever and clever people tend to employ clever and very capable people. That is just smart business, unlike the stupidity that is going on at Wednesday. An A level Accounting student would know the implications of recording the sale of their ground in the wrong calendar year.

As for Derby, it will be very difficult to prove the ground was not sold at fair market value. It is not like there are many like properties for comparison and they did get an 'independent' valuation which DCFC can and no doubt will claim that they acted in upmost good-faith with this. I fully expect DCFC to get no punishment.

I'm not so sure with Derby. £80m when West Ham's went for £40m, with property in Derby nowhere near comparable to London... Heck even Villa only sold theirs for £57m, again with property being massivley more expensive in Birmingham than in Derby.... They can have all the 'independent' valuations they like, there's no way on Earth it was worth £80m.

I'm not a valuer, but I would guess this will need to go through some sort of RICS arbitration process to determine the value. The EFL will have employed a valuer, who I'm guessing will have come up with a different value.
Reply
#26
(08-02-2020, 07:59 PM)MassDebater Wrote:
(08-02-2020, 07:04 PM)Begley Wrote:
(08-02-2020, 06:46 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(08-02-2020, 06:41 PM)Begley Wrote:
(08-01-2020, 06:02 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote: You can say that again!

Villa probably didn't get charged as they didn't break P&S rules. There isn't a single suggestion from any source to say that Villa did similar to Sheffield Wed, similar too to Derby. Neither club have done what Wed have been found guilty of.

Exactly.

Unfortunately Villa “broke” the rules, but found a work around by selling their training ground land, and also seemingly massively increasing their academy spend. As has been mooted, they were on the brink financially before Safawis and Edens came in, and I imagine Purslow ensured a few favours would be called in to save the league the embarrassment of Villa going under due to their rules.

Villa also sold their ground at a fair market rate, unlike Derby, and accounted for it appropriately, unlike Wednesday. 

I would love the arrogantdeludedfisheatingsealcunts to come unstuck but their owners played a blinder in bringing Purslow and his little black book in.

They didn't break the rules, the rules permitted for sale of assets at a profit. Villa Park was sold, which is a loophole which should be closed, but it is not against P&S. The sale of training ground was for HS2, it was not through choice or looking for a loophole. All businesses and residential properties along the HS2 line did similarly. It also afforded Villa the ability to spend significant funds on redeveloping their training ground as these monies do not count towards P&S. The idea that Purslow has people in his pocket is rediculous imo, everything is accounted for and in the public domain and it is nearly impossible to hide things. Villa's owners are clever and clever people tend to employ clever and very capable people. That is just smart business, unlike the stupidity that is going on at Wednesday. An A level Accounting student would know the implications of recording the sale of their ground in the wrong calendar year.

As for Derby, it will be very difficult to prove the ground was not sold at fair market value. It is not like there are many like properties for comparison and they did get an 'independent' valuation which DCFC can and no doubt will claim that they acted in upmost good-faith with this. I fully expect DCFC to get no punishment.

I'm not so sure with Derby. £80m when West Ham's went for £40m, with property in Derby nowhere near comparable to London... Heck even Villa only sold theirs for £57m, again with property being massivley more expensive in Birmingham than in Derby.... They can have all the 'independent' valuations they like, there's no way on Earth it was worth £80m.

There are so many factors to be considered. Isn't Villa Park some sort of protected building? That would seriously devalue it as you can't simply level it and build a commercial property. It will be very difficult to prove a building was not worth within plus or minus 20m of the actual sale price. I agree DCFC's ground looks very overvalued but I believe it will be very difficult to prove this. And the fact that they got an independent valuation will surely help them. The can simply say they acted in good faith. If the EFL want to challenge this then they will have to prove that the valuer was either corrupt or incompetent. This is again, very difficult to prove
Reply
#27
(08-02-2020, 09:15 PM)Begley Wrote:
(08-02-2020, 07:59 PM)MassDebater Wrote:
(08-02-2020, 07:04 PM)Begley Wrote:
(08-02-2020, 06:46 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(08-02-2020, 06:41 PM)Begley Wrote: Villa probably didn't get charged as they didn't break P&S rules. There isn't a single suggestion from any source to say that Villa did similar to Sheffield Wed, similar too to Derby. Neither club have done what Wed have been found guilty of.

Exactly.

Unfortunately Villa “broke” the rules, but found a work around by selling their training ground land, and also seemingly massively increasing their academy spend. As has been mooted, they were on the brink financially before Safawis and Edens came in, and I imagine Purslow ensured a few favours would be called in to save the league the embarrassment of Villa going under due to their rules.

Villa also sold their ground at a fair market rate, unlike Derby, and accounted for it appropriately, unlike Wednesday. 

I would love the arrogantdeludedfisheatingsealcunts to come unstuck but their owners played a blinder in bringing Purslow and his little black book in.

They didn't break the rules, the rules permitted for sale of assets at a profit. Villa Park was sold, which is a loophole which should be closed, but it is not against P&S. The sale of training ground was for HS2, it was not through choice or looking for a loophole. All businesses and residential properties along the HS2 line did similarly. It also afforded Villa the ability to spend significant funds on redeveloping their training ground as these monies do not count towards P&S. The idea that Purslow has people in his pocket is rediculous imo, everything is accounted for and in the public domain and it is nearly impossible to hide things. Villa's owners are clever and clever people tend to employ clever and very capable people. That is just smart business, unlike the stupidity that is going on at Wednesday. An A level Accounting student would know the implications of recording the sale of their ground in the wrong calendar year.

As for Derby, it will be very difficult to prove the ground was not sold at fair market value. It is not like there are many like properties for comparison and they did get an 'independent' valuation which DCFC can and no doubt will claim that they acted in upmost good-faith with this. I fully expect DCFC to get no punishment.

I'm not so sure with Derby. £80m when West Ham's went for £40m, with property in Derby nowhere near comparable to London... Heck even Villa only sold theirs for £57m, again with property being massivley more expensive in Birmingham than in Derby.... They can have all the 'independent' valuations they like, there's no way on Earth it was worth £80m.

There are so many factors to be considered. Isn't Villa Park some sort of protected building? That would seriously devalue it as you can't simply level it and build a commercial property. It will be very difficult to prove a building was not worth within plus or minus 20m of the actual sale price. I agree DCFC's ground looks very overvalued but I believe it will be very difficult to prove this. And the fact that they got an independent valuation will surely help them. The can simply say they acted in good faith. If the EFL want to challenge this then they will have to prove that the valuer was either corrupt or incompetent. This is again, very difficult to prove

I bet the PI insurers for the Derby valuation are shitting it, because Derby could go for the insurers if they have relied on a report, and this report costs Derby points, and therefore money.
Reply
#28
The cost of relocating the wild life would cause a hike in the price of Vile Park. Rocks to sit on don't come cheap
Reply
#29
(08-02-2020, 09:15 PM)Begley Wrote:
(08-02-2020, 07:59 PM)MassDebater Wrote:
(08-02-2020, 07:04 PM)Begley Wrote:
(08-02-2020, 06:46 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(08-02-2020, 06:41 PM)Begley Wrote: Villa probably didn't get charged as they didn't break P&S rules. There isn't a single suggestion from any source to say that Villa did similar to Sheffield Wed, similar too to Derby. Neither club have done what Wed have been found guilty of.

Exactly.

Unfortunately Villa “broke” the rules, but found a work around by selling their training ground land, and also seemingly massively increasing their academy spend. As has been mooted, they were on the brink financially before Safawis and Edens came in, and I imagine Purslow ensured a few favours would be called in to save the league the embarrassment of Villa going under due to their rules.

Villa also sold their ground at a fair market rate, unlike Derby, and accounted for it appropriately, unlike Wednesday. 

I would love the arrogantdeludedfisheatingsealcunts to come unstuck but their owners played a blinder in bringing Purslow and his little black book in.

They didn't break the rules, the rules permitted for sale of assets at a profit. Villa Park was sold, which is a loophole which should be closed, but it is not against P&S. The sale of training ground was for HS2, it was not through choice or looking for a loophole. All businesses and residential properties along the HS2 line did similarly. It also afforded Villa the ability to spend significant funds on redeveloping their training ground as these monies do not count towards P&S. The idea that Purslow has people in his pocket is rediculous imo, everything is accounted for and in the public domain and it is nearly impossible to hide things. Villa's owners are clever and clever people tend to employ clever and very capable people. That is just smart business, unlike the stupidity that is going on at Wednesday. An A level Accounting student would know the implications of recording the sale of their ground in the wrong calendar year.

As for Derby, it will be very difficult to prove the ground was not sold at fair market value. It is not like there are many like properties for comparison and they did get an 'independent' valuation which DCFC can and no doubt will claim that they acted in upmost good-faith with this. I fully expect DCFC to get no punishment.

I'm not so sure with Derby. £80m when West Ham's went for £40m, with property in Derby nowhere near comparable to London... Heck even Villa only sold theirs for £57m, again with property being massivley more expensive in Birmingham than in Derby.... They can have all the 'independent' valuations they like, there's no way on Earth it was worth £80m.

There are so many factors to be considered. Isn't Villa Park some sort of protected building? That would seriously devalue it as you can't simply level it and build a commercial property. It will be very difficult to prove a building was not worth within plus or minus 20m of the actual sale price. I agree DCFC's ground looks very overvalued but I believe it will be very difficult to prove this. And the fact that they got an independent valuation will surely help them. The can simply say they acted in good faith. If the EFL want to challenge this then they will have to prove that the valuer was either corrupt or incompetent. This is again, very difficult to prove


Didn't the valuations used by both Detby and Villa coincedentally just about cover the losses they incurred?  Dodgy
Reply
#30
(08-02-2020, 10:09 PM)chasetownbaggie Wrote:
(08-02-2020, 09:15 PM)Begley Wrote:
(08-02-2020, 07:59 PM)MassDebater Wrote:
(08-02-2020, 07:04 PM)Begley Wrote:
(08-02-2020, 06:46 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Exactly.

Unfortunately Villa “broke” the rules, but found a work around by selling their training ground land, and also seemingly massively increasing their academy spend. As has been mooted, they were on the brink financially before Safawis and Edens came in, and I imagine Purslow ensured a few favours would be called in to save the league the embarrassment of Villa going under due to their rules.

Villa also sold their ground at a fair market rate, unlike Derby, and accounted for it appropriately, unlike Wednesday. 

I would love the arrogantdeludedfisheatingsealcunts to come unstuck but their owners played a blinder in bringing Purslow and his little black book in.

They didn't break the rules, the rules permitted for sale of assets at a profit. Villa Park was sold, which is a loophole which should be closed, but it is not against P&S. The sale of training ground was for HS2, it was not through choice or looking for a loophole. All businesses and residential properties along the HS2 line did similarly. It also afforded Villa the ability to spend significant funds on redeveloping their training ground as these monies do not count towards P&S. The idea that Purslow has people in his pocket is rediculous imo, everything is accounted for and in the public domain and it is nearly impossible to hide things. Villa's owners are clever and clever people tend to employ clever and very capable people. That is just smart business, unlike the stupidity that is going on at Wednesday. An A level Accounting student would know the implications of recording the sale of their ground in the wrong calendar year.

As for Derby, it will be very difficult to prove the ground was not sold at fair market value. It is not like there are many like properties for comparison and they did get an 'independent' valuation which DCFC can and no doubt will claim that they acted in upmost good-faith with this. I fully expect DCFC to get no punishment.

I'm not so sure with Derby. £80m when West Ham's went for £40m, with property in Derby nowhere near comparable to London... Heck even Villa only sold theirs for £57m, again with property being massivley more expensive in Birmingham than in Derby.... They can have all the 'independent' valuations they like, there's no way on Earth it was worth £80m.

There are so many factors to be considered. Isn't Villa Park some sort of protected building? That would seriously devalue it as you can't simply level it and build a commercial property. It will be very difficult to prove a building was not worth within plus or minus 20m of the actual sale price. I agree DCFC's ground looks very overvalued but I believe it will be very difficult to prove this. And the fact that they got an independent valuation will surely help them. The can simply say they acted in good faith. If the EFL want to challenge this then they will have to prove that the valuer was either corrupt or incompetent. This is again, very difficult to prove


Didn't the valuations used by both Detby and Villa coincedentally just about cover the losses they incurred?  Dodgy

Villa hasn't released its accounts for that season yet, they are not due for publication until 2021, I am not sure but I believe DCFC is the same so we don't know. Wednesday's valuation was within 3m of the required amount they needed. Well, that is if they had of sold the ground in the previous financial year and reported honestly  Wink
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: