Here we go again
#41
(07-17-2020, 01:13 PM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(07-17-2020, 01:03 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: What you are describing is Anarchy, and we had that in the 1970's.

There is no place for unlawfulness in a modern civilised society.

Not sure about the 70's bit. There's been plenty of riots since. So I'm guessing we've never lived in a modern civilised society?

So, in your modern, civilised society, how would you go about getting rid of a statue of a slave trader (Assuming you think they should)? How would it be different to the methods that were used unsuccessfully for 30 years? I'm willing to bet they were all done and they all failed. As I said, I'm no supporter of direct action, but unlike you, I see serious failings in a system that couldn't find a lawful solution after 30 years. If that hadn't happened there would be no direct action victory.

What would you have done?

Well I wouldn't have assembled an illegal mob, and unilaterally decided to vandalise it, and chuck it in the dock, that's for sure.

You have to have rules, and live by them, otherwise you end up with the very riots you have described.

Not in my name, thank you.
Reply
#42
(07-17-2020, 01:45 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(07-17-2020, 01:13 PM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(07-17-2020, 01:03 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: What you are describing is Anarchy, and we had that in the 1970's.

There is no place for unlawfulness in a modern civilised society.

Not sure about the 70's bit. There's been plenty of riots since. So I'm guessing we've never lived in a modern civilised society?

So, in your modern, civilised society, how would you go about getting rid of a statue of a slave trader (Assuming you think they should)? How would it be different to the methods that were used unsuccessfully for 30 years? I'm willing to bet they were all done and they all failed. As I said, I'm no supporter of direct action, but unlike you, I see serious failings in a system that couldn't find a lawful solution after 30 years. If that hadn't happened there would be no direct action victory.

What would you have done?

Well I wouldn't have assembled an illegal mob, and unilaterally decided to vandalise it, and chuck it in the dock, that's for sure.

You have to have rules, and live by them, otherwise you end up with the very riots you have described.

Not in my name, thank you.

Agreed.

So the council own the land, but not the statue? Seems a bit odd? Surely whoever owns the statue will be paying ground rent or similar? I'd have got the council to increase ground rent to a silly amount so that they then agreed to move it.

Until it happened I had never even heard of it, nor have I ever been to Brizzle, so I don't know all the ins and outs. It does seem a strange situation though.

Had the above not worked I'd have petitioned the council to erect advertising hoarding all the way around the statue and then allowed charities free use of them. or they could have organised hoarding that depicted anti-slave trade history and artworks and provided teaching and something positive for all of the community... When visitors saw it then they would be able to learn about it. However, i would caveat the materials with all of the good that Coulston had done with the money, and maybe add a poll at the end of the installation asking if the visitors thought it should be removed or left as the historical teaching section of the square? Actually that does sound like a great compromise and one that is actually positive, even if I do say so myself. Context from both sides for people to learn and judge afterwards.

In no scenario would I have organised a mob to pull it down.

As for the things I would have done, they are hypothetical since I don't much care about the statue, I'm more annoyed about what happened to it than the actual object.
Reply
#43
(07-17-2020, 01:51 PM)MassDebater Wrote:
(07-17-2020, 01:45 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: Well I wouldn't have assembled an illegal mob, and unilaterally decided to vandalise it, and chuck it in the dock, that's for sure.

You have to have rules, and live by them, otherwise you end up with the very riots you have described.

Not in my name, thank you.

Agreed.

So the council own the land, but not the statue? Seems a bit odd? Surely whoever owns the statue will be paying ground rent or similar? I'd have got the council to increase ground rent to a silly amount so that they then agreed to move it.



As for the things I would have done, they are hypothetical since I don't much care about the statue, I'm more annoyed about what happened to it than the actual object.

KitKat, you know I didn't say that. Quite the opposite. I actually said I don't agree with direct action.

What I asked is what would you have done to get a statue removed? Your answer shows that you weren't aware of the problems and why it was such an issue (and why would you?!)

The council was behind the removal, the local populace was behind the removal and I would have thought in this case (although it's not a given) it was morally unambiguous as he was an out and out slave trader .

Ultimately nobody had the answer, the 'The Society of Merchant Venturers' were the trustees and wanted it to remain and so it did.

If you believe in law and order - which as a lawyer for 30 years I have every reason to do so - it's frustrating when it fails and hands victory to direct action. Which is ultimately what happened here, whether you like it or not.

Didn't the cynic in you wonder, why this statue, amongst all the statues in the UK was chosen? It was deliberate.
Reply
#44
(07-17-2020, 11:51 AM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(07-17-2020, 08:06 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: I agree on the criminal justice point 

Those that vandalised the original statue, and those that illegally erected the new one must be held to account.

If you did that, what do you think would happen?

Do we really need this to go on and on? Do you really want to make them into martyrs? Leaving aside the morality of having a statue of a slave trader up in 2020, I'm sad that 30 years of peaceful protest couldn't achieve what direct action could. But let's move on. Arresting them now would do actually what I imagine you don't want. They would love it!

(07-17-2020, 01:13 PM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(07-17-2020, 01:03 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: What you are describing is Anarchy, and we had that in the 1970's.

There is no place for unlawfulness in a modern civilised society.

Not sure about the 70's bit. There's been plenty of riots since. So I'm guessing we've never lived in a modern civilised society?

So, in your modern, civilised society, how would you go about getting rid of a statue of a slave trader (Assuming you think they should)? How would it be different to the methods that were used unsuccessfully for 30 years? I'm willing to bet they were all done and they all failed. As I said, I'm no supporter of direct action, but unlike you, I see serious failings in a system that couldn't find a lawful solution after 30 years. If that hadn't happened there would be no direct action victory.

What would you have done?

How many protests and how large were they? How many petitions and how many signatures? How many Bristolian's were asked if they would prefer it stay?

People protest against all sorts of things, but it doesn't prevent them happen the majority of the time. If people protest against a development over countryside, when that goes ahead anyway does that mean those protesters are free to go and demolish the work carried out?

The people involved in the tearing down of that statue should be held to account. They won't be 'martyred', however not charging them will lead to further problems and likely escalations of racial tensions somewhere down the line almost certainly.
Reply
#45
(07-17-2020, 02:03 PM)Ampadu\s Left Boot Wrote:
(07-17-2020, 11:51 AM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(07-17-2020, 08:06 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: I agree on the criminal justice point 

Those that vandalised the original statue, and those that illegally erected the new one must be held to account.

If you did that, what do you think would happen?

Do we really need this to go on and on? Do you really want to make them into martyrs? Leaving aside the morality of having a statue of a slave trader up in 2020, I'm sad that 30 years of peaceful protest couldn't achieve what direct action could. But let's move on. Arresting them now would do actually what I imagine you don't want. They would love it!

(07-17-2020, 01:13 PM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(07-17-2020, 01:03 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: What you are describing is Anarchy, and we had that in the 1970's.

There is no place for unlawfulness in a modern civilised society.

Not sure about the 70's bit. There's been plenty of riots since. So I'm guessing we've never lived in a modern civilised society?

So, in your modern, civilised society, how would you go about getting rid of a statue of a slave trader (Assuming you think they should)? How would it be different to the methods that were used unsuccessfully for 30 years? I'm willing to bet they were all done and they all failed. As I said, I'm no supporter of direct action, but unlike you, I see serious failings in a system that couldn't find a lawful solution after 30 years. If that hadn't happened there would be no direct action victory.

What would you have done?

How many protests and how large were they? How many petitions and how many signatures? How many Bristolian's were asked if they would prefer it stay?

People protest against all sorts of things, but it doesn't prevent them happen the majority of the time. If people protest against a development over countryside, when that goes ahead anyway does that mean those protesters are free to go and demolish the work carried out?

The people involved in the tearing down of that statue should be held to account. They won't be 'martyred', however not charging them will lead to further problems and likely escalations of racial tensions somewhere down the line almost certainly.
+1

(07-17-2020, 01:57 PM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(07-17-2020, 01:51 PM)MassDebater Wrote:
(07-17-2020, 01:45 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: Well I wouldn't have assembled an illegal mob, and unilaterally decided to vandalise it, and chuck it in the dock, that's for sure.

You have to have rules, and live by them, otherwise you end up with the very riots you have described.

Not in my name, thank you.

Agreed.

So the council own the land, but not the statue? Seems a bit odd? Surely whoever owns the statue will be paying ground rent or similar? I'd have got the council to increase ground rent to a silly amount so that they then agreed to move it.



As for the things I would have done, they are hypothetical since I don't much care about the statue, I'm more annoyed about what happened to it than the actual object.

KitKat, you know I didn't say that. Quite the opposite. I actually said I don't agree with direct action.

What I asked is what would you have done to get a statue removed? Your answer shows that you weren't aware of the problems and why it was such an issue (and why would you?!)

The council was behind the removal, the local populace was behind the removal and I would have thought in this case (although it's not a given) it was morally unambiguous as he was an out and out slave trader .

Ultimately nobody had the answer, the 'The Society of Merchant Venturers' were the trustees and wanted it to remain and so it did.

If you believe in law and order - which as a lawyer for 30 years I have every reason to do so - it's frustrating when it fails and hands victory to direct action. Which is ultimately what happened here, whether you like it or not.

Didn't the cynic in you wonder, why this statue, amongst all the statues in the UK was chosen? It was deliberate.

I believe it was a matter for Bristol to resolve. Local elections are held on local matters. The democracy should have worked. I wonder how many people in the angry mob had actually even been to Bristol before the organised violence took place on that day?
Reply
#46
"I believe it was a matter for Bristol to resolve. Local elections are held on local matters. The democracy should have worked."

I must have badly explained my position because that's my point. Surveys were for taking it down, the council tried to help them take it down. But the trustees refused

Having said that 'grass roots' democracy is a poor way to solve things like this (even though in polls most wanted it taken down),

Using the planning analogy you brought up there is a legal procedure you use in planning. (Which would incorporate local opinion)

Ultimately, If you wanted to put up a statue of slave trader now, you wouldn't be allowed. Yet there is no legal procedure that provides for that exact statue of a slave trader to be taken down.

Doesn't that strike you as an anomaly? Wouldn't you think the reasons for both would be the same? 

You could even decide NOT to take it down, if there was a legal procedure that decided that.

But at present, there's nothing.

It's this gap in legislation is what has been exploited so effectively. Black Lives Matter knew it and they knew the history of this particular case, that's why they chose it. They chose one they could 'win' because there was evidence of local support and a failed attempt to get it legally taken down.

What I am suggesting is that if you closed this legal contradiction this would have stopped a lot of BLM's machinations and they wouldn't have been half as successful. Which believe it or not, I would have been more than happy with.



Arrest them, don't arrest them I don't care. But bear in mind if you do, you're choosing to do exactly what they want. But that's up to you - You'll both be very happy!
Reply
#47
(07-17-2020, 02:54 PM)fuzzbox Wrote: "I believe it was a matter for Bristol to resolve. Local elections are held on local matters. The democracy should have worked."

I must have badly explained my position because that's my point. Surveys were for taking it down, the council tried to help them take it down. But the trustees refused

Having said that 'grass roots' democracy is a poor way to solve things like this (even though in polls most wanted it taken down),

Using the planning analogy you brought up there is a legal procedure you use in planning. (Which would incorporate local opinion)

Ultimately, If you wanted to put up a statue of slave trader now, you wouldn't be allowed. Yet there is no legal procedure that provides for that exact statue of a slave trader to be taken down.

Doesn't that strike you as an anomaly? Wouldn't you think the reasons for both would be the same? 

You could even decide NOT to take it down, if there was a legal procedure that decided that.

But at present, there's nothing.

It's this gap in legislation is what has been exploited so effectively. Black Lives Matter knew it and they knew the history of this particular case, that's why they chose it. They chose one they could 'win' because there was evidence of local support and a failed attempt to get it legally taken down.

What I am suggesting is that if you closed this legal contradiction this would have stopped a lot of BLM's machinations and they wouldn't have been half as successful. Which believe it or not, I would have been more than happy with.



Arrest them, don't arrest them I don't care. But bear in mind if you do, you're choosing to do exactly what they want. But that's up to you - You'll both be very happy!

When you've closed all of the loopholes you can then start working on the gaps in Stamp Duty Land Tax. 

Where do you draw the line? Lawyers have made a living for centuries in making and exploiting loopholes in law. It's what they do. 

For my part I would rather try to be a law abiding citizen than a member of out of control mob imposing it's will on others. I really don't give two fucks whether it stays or goes, but I do care about law enforcement.
Reply
#48
This is an opportunity for advancement yet it is being held back by squabbling. It really doesn't matter that some old slave traders statue got chucked in the harbour. It should have been moved to a museum years ago. It doesn't matter that sportsmen take the knee before an event, it costs neither me, nor anyone else, nothing. It may do some good, it may not.
Those advancing their own cause over this need to think again. (And I mean in general, not us few on this bored). We have a real chance to improve things yet it will more likely than not, come to nothing, mainly due to a few that will always look for offence and more than a few who think virtue signalling is the same as simply doing things right.
Reply
#49
(07-17-2020, 03:25 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: When you've closed all of the loopholes you can then start working on the gaps in Stamp Duty Land Tax. 

Where do you draw the line? Lawyers have made a living for centuries in making and exploiting loopholes in law. It's what they do. 

For my part I would rather try to be a law abiding citizen than a member of out of control mob imposing it's will on others. I really don't give two fucks whether it stays or goes, but I do care about law enforcement.

So now you're arguing against introducing law that would solve this problem? You don't want them to take the law into the hands, whilst at the same time you don't want there to be a legal remedy! Can't you see the flaw in your argument?!

It's not a 'loophole' there is simply no legislation, which means that it can't be decided by law! There isn't a law because statues from previous eras were never a problem before. It obviously is now. That's why there should be law. And you know why? Because it prevents an angry mob imposing it's will on others!

For the fourth time, I don't agree with direct action either, so that argument is moot. 

Unlike you, I do want these types of statues gone, which is why I'd like a law to provide a mechanism to enable this to happen (or not) LEGALLY. At present there isn't, so there's nothing I can do, regardless of us living in a democracy.

You don't 'give two fucks' which I understand. A stunning lack of compassion - I'm sure I would have more if it was your ancestors and not mine - but I understand. However, it made me realise that you didn't know there's no legal recourse, or the efforts that were made by the democratically elected council. I can understand that now, why would you if you don't give two fucks? What's a shame is I think you're too pig-headed to admit you didn't know. This is exactly why BLM are running rings around everyone. They're not as stupid as people think. You let them choose the perfect battle ground to fight and you obliged. That's why they're winning.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: