Ratings...
#11
(07-05-2020, 04:10 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: What an odd side we are... we’ve looked solid as a rock at the back for the last 7 or 8 games, yet have struggled going forward, whereas today some of our attacking play was sublime but our defending shambolic... still fair play to the lads, Brentford again laid down the gauntlet but we didn’t panic and put the points in the board.

Johnstone - 6 - not to blame for either goal but failed to inspire any confidence. Hull targeted that space just in front of him with every dead ball.

OShea - 7.5 - Improves every time I see him, looked better going forward and isn’t afraid to take a man on or have a pop.
Bartley - 6 - Couple wobbles, but did OK in a game where few players come out well at the back.
Hegazi - 7 - cracking header for the goal and saved a certain goal... silly booking got him sent off but otherwise solid. Comes back in after his suspension.
Gibbs - 6 - good delivery, good attacking outlet but we looked better at the back after his injury, at fault for their second.

Sawyers - 5 - needs a rest... has looked sloppy since restart and today probably his worst game since joining. To blame for the opener and let them in several times. Toral  must have been gutted to see him go off. 
Harper - 6.5 - Better than Sawyers, but part of the problem in midfield that saw us get overrun too easily. Should have scored.
Krov - 7 - linked the play well, was at the heat of most of our good work going forward.

Periera - 10 - 3 assists and a constant thorn in their side. Quite what this lad is worth I’ve no idea. 
Austin - 8.5 - one of his best games for us. Linked the ball up well, looked fresh and hungry, settled nerves with the early goal we needed. Starts again Weds for me even if he only lasts 45 Mins or so. 
Grosicki - 8.5 - Wonderful finish and could have had more. Would have been higher but was greedy when a pass would have seen us score more.

Townsend - 7 - we looked more solid after he came on. 
Brunt - 7.5 - invaluable nous, use the ball very well and got us over the line 
Livermore - 7 - added the bite in the middle we were lacking, the right sub at the right time 
HRK - 6 - not sure he did an awful lot with the ball but his runs opened up space.
Diangana - 7.5 - lovely finish, and a bag of tricks. Looked a lot sharper.

EDIT- thought Townsend game on sooner than he did!
Basically my thoughts too. Hard for me to give high ratings to the defence considering we gave up 2 goals to Hull at home, and were under pressure numerous other times
Reply
#12
(07-05-2020, 05:18 PM)scotbaggie Wrote:
(07-05-2020, 04:10 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: What an odd side we are... we’ve looked solid as a rock at the back for the last 7 or 8 games, yet have struggled going forward, whereas today some of our attacking play was sublime but our defending shambolic... still fair play to the lads, Brentford again laid down the gauntlet but we didn’t panic and put the points in the board.

Johnstone - 6 - not to blame for either goal but failed to inspire any confidence. Hull targeted that space just in front of him with every dead ball.

OShea - 7.5 - Improves every time I see him, looked better going forward and isn’t afraid to take a man on or have a pop.
Bartley - 6 - Couple wobbles, but did OK in a game where few players come out well at the back.
Hegazi - 7 - cracking header for the goal and saved a certain goal... silly booking got him sent off but otherwise solid. Comes back in after his suspension.
Gibbs - 6 - good delivery, good attacking outlet but we looked better at the back after his injury, at fault for their second.

Sawyers - 5 - needs a rest... has looked sloppy since restart and today probably his worst game since joining. To blame for the opener and let them in several times. Toral  must have been gutted to see him go off. 
Harper - 6.5 - Better than Sawyers, but part of the problem in midfield that saw us get overrun too easily. Should have scored.
Krov - 7 - linked the play well, was at the heat of most of our good work going forward.

Periera - 10 - 3 assists and a constant thorn in their side. Quite what this lad is worth I’ve no idea. 
Austin - 8.5 - one of his best games for us. Linked the ball up well, looked fresh and hungry, settled nerves with the early goal we needed. Starts again Weds for me even if he only lasts 45 Mins or so. 
Grosicki - 8.5 - Wonderful finish and could have had more. Would have been higher but was greedy when a pass would have seen us score more.

Townsend - 7 - we looked more solid after he came on. 
Brunt - 7.5 - invaluable nous, use the ball very well and got us over the line 
Livermore - 7 - added the bite in the middle we were lacking, the right sub at the right time 
HRK - 6 - not sure he did an awful lot with the ball but his runs opened up space.
Diangana - 7.5 - lovely finish, and a bag of tricks. Looked a lot sharper.

EDIT- thought Townsend game on sooner than he did!
Basically my thoughts too. Hard for me to give high ratings to the defence considering we gave up 2 goals to Hull at home, and were under pressure numerous other times

Not completely the defence’s fault tbf. Had no cover from the midfield until Livermore and Brunt came on.
Reply
#13
(07-05-2020, 05:24 PM)Dumbo Wrote:
(07-05-2020, 05:18 PM)scotbaggie Wrote:
(07-05-2020, 04:10 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: What an odd side we are... we’ve looked solid as a rock at the back for the last 7 or 8 games, yet have struggled going forward, whereas today some of our attacking play was sublime but our defending shambolic... still fair play to the lads, Brentford again laid down the gauntlet but we didn’t panic and put the points in the board.

Johnstone - 6 - not to blame for either goal but failed to inspire any confidence. Hull targeted that space just in front of him with every dead ball.

OShea - 7.5 - Improves every time I see him, looked better going forward and isn’t afraid to take a man on or have a pop.
Bartley - 6 - Couple wobbles, but did OK in a game where few players come out well at the back.
Hegazi - 7 - cracking header for the goal and saved a certain goal... silly booking got him sent off but otherwise solid. Comes back in after his suspension.
Gibbs - 6 - good delivery, good attacking outlet but we looked better at the back after his injury, at fault for their second.

Sawyers - 5 - needs a rest... has looked sloppy since restart and today probably his worst game since joining. To blame for the opener and let them in several times. Toral  must have been gutted to see him go off. 
Harper - 6.5 - Better than Sawyers, but part of the problem in midfield that saw us get overrun too easily. Should have scored.
Krov - 7 - linked the play well, was at the heat of most of our good work going forward.

Periera - 10 - 3 assists and a constant thorn in their side. Quite what this lad is worth I’ve no idea. 
Austin - 8.5 - one of his best games for us. Linked the ball up well, looked fresh and hungry, settled nerves with the early goal we needed. Starts again Weds for me even if he only lasts 45 Mins or so. 
Grosicki - 8.5 - Wonderful finish and could have had more. Would have been higher but was greedy when a pass would have seen us score more.

Townsend - 7 - we looked more solid after he came on. 
Brunt - 7.5 - invaluable nous, use the ball very well and got us over the line 
Livermore - 7 - added the bite in the middle we were lacking, the right sub at the right time 
HRK - 6 - not sure he did an awful lot with the ball but his runs opened up space.
Diangana - 7.5 - lovely finish, and a bag of tricks. Looked a lot sharper.

EDIT- thought Townsend game on sooner than he did!
Basically my thoughts too. Hard for me to give high ratings to the defence considering we gave up 2 goals to Hull at home, and were under pressure numerous other times

Not completely the defence’s fault tbf. Had no cover from the midfield until Livermore and Brunt came on.

Agree. Livermore and in particular Brunt made a huge difference.
Reply
#14
(07-05-2020, 05:33 PM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote:
(07-05-2020, 05:24 PM)Dumbo Wrote:
(07-05-2020, 05:18 PM)scotbaggie Wrote:
(07-05-2020, 04:10 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: What an odd side we are... we’ve looked solid as a rock at the back for the last 7 or 8 games, yet have struggled going forward, whereas today some of our attacking play was sublime but our defending shambolic... still fair play to the lads, Brentford again laid down the gauntlet but we didn’t panic and put the points in the board.

Johnstone - 6 - not to blame for either goal but failed to inspire any confidence. Hull targeted that space just in front of him with every dead ball.

OShea - 7.5 - Improves every time I see him, looked better going forward and isn’t afraid to take a man on or have a pop.
Bartley - 6 - Couple wobbles, but did OK in a game where few players come out well at the back.
Hegazi - 7 - cracking header for the goal and saved a certain goal... silly booking got him sent off but otherwise solid. Comes back in after his suspension.
Gibbs - 6 - good delivery, good attacking outlet but we looked better at the back after his injury, at fault for their second.

Sawyers - 5 - needs a rest... has looked sloppy since restart and today probably his worst game since joining. To blame for the opener and let them in several times. Toral  must have been gutted to see him go off. 
Harper - 6.5 - Better than Sawyers, but part of the problem in midfield that saw us get overrun too easily. Should have scored.
Krov - 7 - linked the play well, was at the heat of most of our good work going forward.

Periera - 10 - 3 assists and a constant thorn in their side. Quite what this lad is worth I’ve no idea. 
Austin - 8.5 - one of his best games for us. Linked the ball up well, looked fresh and hungry, settled nerves with the early goal we needed. Starts again Weds for me even if he only lasts 45 Mins or so. 
Grosicki - 8.5 - Wonderful finish and could have had more. Would have been higher but was greedy when a pass would have seen us score more.

Townsend - 7 - we looked more solid after he came on. 
Brunt - 7.5 - invaluable nous, use the ball very well and got us over the line 
Livermore - 7 - added the bite in the middle we were lacking, the right sub at the right time 
HRK - 6 - not sure he did an awful lot with the ball but his runs opened up space.
Diangana - 7.5 - lovely finish, and a bag of tricks. Looked a lot sharper.

EDIT- thought Townsend game on sooner than he did!
Basically my thoughts too. Hard for me to give high ratings to the defence considering we gave up 2 goals to Hull at home, and were under pressure numerous other times

Not completely the defence’s fault tbf. Had no cover from the midfield until Livermore and Brunt came on.

Agree. Livermore and in particular Brunt made a huge difference.
Agreed. I was mentally including Sawyers and Harper in the "defence", hence agreeing with their low scores above
Reply
#15
(07-05-2020, 04:45 PM)Cuzer Wrote: Johnson 5 Just doesn’t display and confidence and clearly the centre halves have none in him, every corner is just under the crossbar or whipped into the six yard box and it’s a calamity in there

OnShea 8 Very good again, crossing is improving massively and excellent defensive work

Gibbs 6 Why did he start him? Probably lost him for the run in now, needed to sit this one out, shame

Hegazi 8 Thought the second yellow was farcical, been our best player since lockdown, a real shame to lose him for what is a huge game Wednesday

Bartley 6 Looked shakey today, some sloppy mistakes we’ve all become accustomed to

Sawyers 4 I’m losing patience, he was my MOM v Blues so no agenda but I would throttle him if he played in front of me, does less than nothing out of possession and in fact gives the opposition chances. The amount of times he fails to put a basic header in and lets the ball bounce or refuses to put a foot in when the opposition is breaking on us. He’s a great footballer and passer of the ball but you must have more to your game playing centre midfield, gave Hull 3 or 4 breakaway chances today due to his inability to put his body on the line, better sides will hurt us

Harper 6 Some good stuff but again need to do more and really should have scored, again often lightweight and bullied at times

Krovinovic 7 Started sloppily but improved and after a couple of sighters texted the keeper from range on a couple of occasions

Pereira 9* Great display, his ball to Krosicki was sublime and everything good we did as usual seemed to go through him, such a talent

Krosicki 8 A constant threat, always seems to either create or score, made little sense why he was overlooked for the first two games and his displays since has shown he should always be around the 11

Austin 7 Good finish for goal, hold up play seems to have improved somewhat, good chance in 2nd half he may have fancied to do better with

Subs

Townsend 7 Started really well and used the ball superbly, a little susceptible at times defensively as slow off the mark but likely to play the remaining 5 so needs to step up

Livermore 6 Gave some much needed steel in the middle of the park and should be back in for the remainder as Harper and Sawyers are too lightweight to start together IMO

HRK 6 Put himself about but the ball didn’t stick as well as it normally does

Brunt 8 What a great cameo, used the ball superbly and was incisive with his passing, great to see him back on the pitch

Diangana 8 A real live wire and took his goal well, probably best coming from bench to run at a tiring defense

Big 3 points which was needed but we looked way too easy to play against I thought without Livermore in there, defensively from set pieces that was back to the Alan Buckley days where every corner for them seemed to lead to a gift edged chance, clearly the players are feeling the pressure which is understandable. Can’t help feeling we will need to raise our levels for the remaining games to get the job done

Cuzer

Now I maybe in a minority here but I just don't get the hype with Sawyers at all yes he keeps and passes the ball well but it's always sidewards or back wards has little or no goal threat and just doesn't know how to tackle and for a central midfielder(unless your blessed like Pirlo, Platini, or inesta) you have to at very least be able to put a foot in or block runners off he does neither how many times do opposition players just waltz passed him with the ball, for me Krov could play that position better, keeps the ball uses it well and always looks to get us moving forward and not afraid to put a shot in thought he did well today, Grosicki great game again his pace and directness will be a big asset for the run in and Pereira well what can you say the man's a genius, on a sad note pity about Gibbs again but think his best for us has been and gone once your hamstrings go this often and easily your more or less finished just like Michael Owen and many others shame as he is/was one of the best left backs we've seen up here for many many years.
Reply
#16
(07-05-2020, 05:33 PM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote:
(07-05-2020, 05:24 PM)Dumbo Wrote:
(07-05-2020, 05:18 PM)scotbaggie Wrote:
(07-05-2020, 04:10 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: What an odd side we are... we’ve looked solid as a rock at the back for the last 7 or 8 games, yet have struggled going forward, whereas today some of our attacking play was sublime but our defending shambolic... still fair play to the lads, Brentford again laid down the gauntlet but we didn’t panic and put the points in the board.

Johnstone - 6 - not to blame for either goal but failed to inspire any confidence. Hull targeted that space just in front of him with every dead ball.

OShea - 7.5 - Improves every time I see him, looked better going forward and isn’t afraid to take a man on or have a pop.
Bartley - 6 - Couple wobbles, but did OK in a game where few players come out well at the back.
Hegazi - 7 - cracking header for the goal and saved a certain goal... silly booking got him sent off but otherwise solid. Comes back in after his suspension.
Gibbs - 6 - good delivery, good attacking outlet but we looked better at the back after his injury, at fault for their second.

Sawyers - 5 - needs a rest... has looked sloppy since restart and today probably his worst game since joining. To blame for the opener and let them in several times. Toral  must have been gutted to see him go off. 
Harper - 6.5 - Better than Sawyers, but part of the problem in midfield that saw us get overrun too easily. Should have scored.
Krov - 7 - linked the play well, was at the heat of most of our good work going forward.

Periera - 10 - 3 assists and a constant thorn in their side. Quite what this lad is worth I’ve no idea. 
Austin - 8.5 - one of his best games for us. Linked the ball up well, looked fresh and hungry, settled nerves with the early goal we needed. Starts again Weds for me even if he only lasts 45 Mins or so. 
Grosicki - 8.5 - Wonderful finish and could have had more. Would have been higher but was greedy when a pass would have seen us score more.

Townsend - 7 - we looked more solid after he came on. 
Brunt - 7.5 - invaluable nous, use the ball very well and got us over the line 
Livermore - 7 - added the bite in the middle we were lacking, the right sub at the right time 
HRK - 6 - not sure he did an awful lot with the ball but his runs opened up space.
Diangana - 7.5 - lovely finish, and a bag of tricks. Looked a lot sharper.

EDIT- thought Townsend game on sooner than he did!
Basically my thoughts too. Hard for me to give high ratings to the defence considering we gave up 2 goals to Hull at home, and were under pressure numerous other times

Not completely the defence’s fault tbf. Had no cover from the midfield until Livermore and Brunt came on.

Agree. Livermore and in particular Brunt made a huge difference.

In fairness to Slav I think he went with the line up he did today with the knowledge we’d probably not be at our most solid but having seen us labour against Blues and Brentford expected we’d be able to score goals
Reply
#17
(07-05-2020, 05:15 PM)Cuzer Wrote: Sorry 13, you can’t give him a bloody 8 after that

The first goal he punched it away 5 yards and they scored, every set piece he’s found in no mans land

He’s our best keeper, no doubt, but he’s got to do better than he did today, just look at the CH’s reactions every time they have a set piece, they have no faith in him at all, shame as he does so many facets well but a keeper than can’t command his area will always be a liability

Cuzer

The best one was when Hegazi happened to be on the line and hacked it away. That ball was 7ft in the air just 2yds from goal and he was stood there like a rabbit in the headlights. He made one excellent reaction save second half that kept it 3-2 so maybe you can call it quits but the first goal was his fault and it was as you say mayhem in there every time. If....we do go up we need a big commanding keeper, conceding goals at set pieces will kill a team in the Prem as it will be so much harder to score.

O'Shea was excellent. Thought Townsend was excellent too - added an attacking threat. Austin did what he can do - got a couple of chances and put one away. That's why he's better than Kanu.

We went a bit more gung ho which is what was required to get the goals but left some massive gaps in front of the back 4. In the end though that's what this division is about. If it's a sluggiing match we've got more knock out blows than anyone in the division.
Reply
#18
(07-05-2020, 05:12 PM)wba13 Wrote: Leave SJ alone as Andy Johnson said  a excellent keeper and that save at 3 2 was brilliant but all you lot see are negatives that aren’t there. Excellent today 8

It's pointless making Gordon Banks saves, if you deal with crosses like Korky the Cat.
Reply
#19
(07-05-2020, 05:12 PM)wba13 Wrote: Leave SJ alone as Andy Johnson said  a excellent keeper and that save at 3 2 was brilliant but all you lot see are negatives that aren’t there. Excellent today 8

I'm assuming this is a wind-up?
Reply
#20
(07-05-2020, 04:10 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Johnstone - 6 - not to blame for either goal but failed to inspire any confidence. Hull targeted that space just in front of him with every dead ball.

I'm usually one of Sam's more ardent supporters but he was deffo at fault for that first one. If coaching keepers to punch rather than catch is the modern way, then fine, I can accept that, but if Sam is coached to punch he really does have to do better. Credit to Hull, they did their homework and bombarded the six yard area - hopefully not too many more have spotted this weakness. Fortunately, he's a far better shot-stopper.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)