St Pauli - an interesting read.
#11
(06-23-2020, 09:53 AM)Old Stroller Wrote: Back in 1991 the organisers of St Pauli's fan clubs, high up in the clubs hierarchy, came over to the UK for a cultural exchange visit, in an attempt to marry up their ethos with like minded clubs over here. I was involved as I had connections with both Albion and St Pauli, and invited them to a game at The Hawthorns.

I tried to explain to their fans our role in integrating black players into our team in the late 70s, and asked the club if I could show them around the ground but received no reply.

This was in the days of third tier football and Barmy Bobby, and the contrast to what was going on at the Millerntor couldn't have been more stark. We stood on a half filled terrace where the atmosphere was as toxic as the football on the pitch, and watched an instantly forgettable draw with Bradford City. Even though they were too polite to say so, it was clear they weren't too impressed at what we had to offer.

They carried on their mini tour, and forged a link with Celtic which has endured to this day. Their brief affiliation with Albion, alas, lasted just the one weekend.

That's interesting. Talk about bad timing.
What a pity, and I wonder what would have happened if a similar situation occurred now.
Having said that I can't fathom out the enduring appeal of Celtic -  other than "passion" - or am I missing something?
Reply
#12
(06-23-2020, 09:12 PM)Llandudno Baggie Wrote:
(06-23-2020, 09:53 AM)Old Stroller Wrote: Back in 1991 the organisers of St Pauli's fan clubs, high up in the clubs hierarchy, came over to the UK for a cultural exchange visit, in an attempt to marry up their ethos with like minded clubs over here. I was involved as I had connections with both Albion and St Pauli, and invited them to a game at The Hawthorns.

I tried to explain to their fans our role in integrating black players into our team in the late 70s, and asked the club if I could show them around the ground but received no reply.

This was in the days of third tier football and Barmy Bobby, and the contrast to what was going on at the Millerntor couldn't have been more stark. We stood on a half filled terrace where the atmosphere was as toxic as the football on the pitch, and watched an instantly forgettable draw with Bradford City. Even though they were too polite to say so, it was clear they weren't too impressed at what we had to offer.

They carried on their mini tour, and forged a link with Celtic which has endured to this day. Their brief affiliation with Albion, alas, lasted just the one weekend.

That's interesting. Talk about bad timing.
What a pity, and I wonder what would have happened if a similar situation occurred now.
Having said that I can't fathom out the enduring appeal of Celtic -  other than "passion" - or am I missing something?

Having sat in the Celtic end at the Wembley Cup 4 team tournament a few years ago neither can I
Reply
#13
(06-23-2020, 09:53 AM)Old Stroller Wrote: Back in 1991 the organisers of St Pauli's fan clubs, high up in the clubs hierarchy, came over to the UK for a cultural exchange visit, in an attempt to marry up their ethos with like minded clubs over here. I was involved as I had connections with both Albion and St Pauli, and invited them to a game at The Hawthorns.

I tried to explain to their fans our role in integrating black players into our team in the late 70s, and asked the club if I could show them around the ground but received no reply.

This was in the days of third tier football and Barmy Bobby, and the contrast to what was going on at the Millerntor couldn't have been more stark. We stood on a half filled terrace where the atmosphere was as toxic as the football on the pitch, and watched an instantly forgettable draw with Bradford City. Even though they were too polite to say so, it was clear they weren't too impressed at what we had to offer.

They carried on their mini tour, and forged a link with Celtic which has endured to this day. Their brief affiliation with Albion, alas, lasted just the one weekend.

I'm not surprised Stroller. This isn't intended as criticism: I'd describe our 'core' fanbase as being rather more to the right than the left on social issues and more nationalist than internationalist in outlook. And as I say, really not intended as a criticism, just a general observation which I think would make us incompatabile with Sankt Pauli.

Celtic are, to an extent, traditionally more anti-establishment. Whether you agree with them or not. Rangers and the protestant faith were, historically, firmly part of the establushment in Scotland.

I also wouldn't understate the impact of some of Celtic's fanbase being supportive of the IRA. To a lot of people outside Britain there is a rather romantic view of the IRA as freedom fighters against imperial opression and a core of the IRA in the post war period were also marxists - so a left wing link again
Reply
#14
Which clubs do you regard as having a "left leaning" fanbase?
Reply
#15
(06-24-2020, 10:30 AM)UCEbaggie Wrote: I'm not surprised Stroller. This isn't intended as criticism: I'd describe our 'core' fanbase as being rather more to the right than the left on social issues and more nationalist than internationalist in outlook. And as I say, really not intended as a criticism, just a general observation which I think would make us incompatabile with Sankt Pauli.

Celtic are, to an extent, traditionally more anti-establishment. Whether you agree with them or not. Rangers and the protestant faith were, historically, firmly part of the establushment in Scotland.

I also wouldn't understate the impact of some of Celtic's fanbase being supportive of the IRA. To a lot of people outside Britain there is a rather romantic view of the IRA as freedom fighters against imperial opression and a core of the IRA in the post war period were also marxists - so a left wing link again


I'd agree with all of that. Most of our support back then, and probably now, are conservative with a small c, and as you say it was always unlikely that they would find common ground with their more radical approach. I managed to at least get them to check us out in preference to the other local teams, which was a small victory, as I'd have been gutted if they had ended up affiliating themselves with Villa or Wolves.
Reply
#16
(06-23-2020, 09:08 AM)FenlandBoing Wrote: Great article and the stand photo!!!

Needs a second tier FFSs, they sell out every week !!
Reply
#17
(06-24-2020, 12:29 PM)Old Stroller Wrote:
(06-24-2020, 10:30 AM)UCEbaggie Wrote: I'm not surprised Stroller. This isn't intended as criticism: I'd describe our 'core' fanbase as being rather more to the right than the left on social issues and more nationalist than internationalist in outlook. And as I say, really not intended as a criticism, just a general observation which I think would make us incompatabile with Sankt Pauli.

Celtic are, to an extent, traditionally more anti-establishment. Whether you agree with them or not. Rangers and the protestant faith were, historically, firmly part of the establushment in Scotland.

I also wouldn't understate the impact of some of Celtic's fanbase being supportive of the IRA. To a lot of people outside Britain there is a rather romantic view of the IRA as freedom fighters against imperial opression and a core of the IRA in the post war period were also marxists - so a left wing link again


I'd agree with all of that. Most of our support back then, and probably now, are conservative with a small c, and as you say it was always unlikely that they would find common ground with their more radical approach. I managed to at least get them to check us out in preference to the other local teams, which was a small victory, as I'd have been gutted if they had ended up affiliating themselves with Villa or Wolves.
This is true but surprisingly (to me anyway), a few years ago the results of a "who's your second team" survey at Albion had Celtic comfortably as the winners. Actually they genuinely were my second team as a kid, Catholic school and all that, but I find the overt politics of Celtic fans a proper turn off and can't be bothered with them now. Obviously my second team these days is  wolves.
(One part of this post is a lie).
Reply
#18
Loads of St Pauli stickers along the canal in Tipton. Bizarre!
Reply
#19
(06-24-2020, 06:54 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(06-24-2020, 12:29 PM)Old Stroller Wrote:
(06-24-2020, 10:30 AM)UCEbaggie Wrote: I'm not surprised Stroller. This isn't intended as criticism: I'd describe our 'core' fanbase as being rather more to the right than the left on social issues and more nationalist than internationalist in outlook. And as I say, really not intended as a criticism, just a general observation which I think would make us incompatabile with Sankt Pauli.

Celtic are, to an extent, traditionally more anti-establishment. Whether you agree with them or not. Rangers and the protestant faith were, historically, firmly part of the establushment in Scotland.

I also wouldn't understate the impact of some of Celtic's fanbase being supportive of the IRA. To a lot of people outside Britain there is a rather romantic view of the IRA as freedom fighters against imperial opression and a core of the IRA in the post war period were also marxists - so a left wing link again


I'd agree with all of that. Most of our support back then, and probably now, are conservative with a small c, and as you say it was always unlikely that they would find common ground with their more radical approach. I managed to at least get them to check us out in preference to the other local teams, which was a small victory, as I'd have been gutted if they had ended up affiliating themselves with Villa or Wolves.
This is true but surprisingly (to me anyway), a few years ago the results of a "who's your second team" survey at Albion had Celtic comfortably as the winners. 

I think you must have dreamed that Tom, we all know our second team is Villa judging by the amount of posts on here about them.
Reply
#20
(06-24-2020, 12:16 PM)Gzbaggy Wrote: Which clubs do you regard as having a "left leaning" fanbase?

Liverpool and Everton, Celtic. 

Can't think of any others off the top of my head sadly.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: