Posts: 19,719
Threads: 2,734
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
49
(06-09-2020, 03:41 PM)ColliersWoodBaggie Wrote: Oh dear, the right wing snowflakes are upset; there should be a debate about this, as statues publicly glorify an individual and all they have done/achieved etc. Colston's statue had to go; and efforts by Bristol Council to either get it in a slavery museum, removed or to get the plaque altered were hindered by Bristol's Merchant Venturers an unelected cabal of businessmen who control many of the city's instiutions. There was an attempt to whitewash (no pun intended) Colston's own history by ignoring the fact he gained wealth through the subjugation and murder of Africans, albeit he was indirectly involved with their throwing overboard).. Would you object to a Stalin or Hitler statue? Did you get upset when Saddam was pulled down? They also have a school named after him - not for the non elite, either. On the other point, let me tell you that the people who voted for Boris and Trump are in the minority.
As for Colston's statue, well, it should be in a museum, but considering 19,000 of his 'cargo' was jettisoned overboard into the Atlantic, it could be argued it is in the right place. IMO a slavery museum in the City where he made his fortune and was an MP should be a fitting place for it.
As for Drake, I've read a fair bit about him and he was a slaver (along with his cousin, John Hawkins), but the 16th Century is a bit different in historical terms to the 18th. By Colston's time and later, the Atlantic Slave TRade was propping up the British Economy and driving the Industrial Revolution (Lassez Faire economics). Drake was a pirate and slaver, and was trying to muscle in on the Spanish and Portuguese Slave Trade. But it took 100 years, before Britain was transporting slaves on an industrial level.
As for the other statues, are you sure it isn't some conspiracy cooked up by the right. They usually spark trouble at times like these.
Cool post dude.
I went to school with a John Hawkins. From memory there's a good chance he was involved in the slave trade.
Posts: 3,109
Threads: 184
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
(06-09-2020, 04:09 PM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote: Why are we using 21st century morals to judge historic characters? The Prophet Muhamned bought, sold, captured, and owned slaves. Should we knock down all mosques?
Because we are in the 21st Century.
Posts: 1,712
Threads: 20
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
18
06-09-2020, 04:16 PM
(This post was last modified: 06-09-2020, 04:20 PM by fuzzbox.)
(06-09-2020, 04:09 PM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote: Why are we using 21st century morals to judge historic characters? The Prophet Muhamned bought, sold, captured, and owned slaves. Should we knock down all mosques?
Do it! I'll be right behind you (about 100 miles!)
In all seriousness, I think all these are valid points. This has to be taken into account.
The simplistic nature of the debate is depressing. It's not just about white people being bad and black people being victims
Of course you don't celebrate a slaver, it's nothing to be proud of. But how did that trade evolve? Why black people? How was it operated? How was it justified ? Why did it keep on happening throughout history?
These are the lessons that need to be learnt. Black good white bad helps no-one and I'm concerned that is the way of this debate. Nobody likes to be labelled and it's just not true. The whole West African economy was also based on slavery, not just white Europe and the US
But yes, get rid of the Bristol Statue. I bet the council are grateful, anyway.
Posts: 669
Threads: 36
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
2
(06-09-2020, 03:57 PM)fuzzbox Wrote: I always wonder why nobody mentions the African leaders who actually went out and captured the overwhelming majority of African slaved
and the North Africans that captured at least 1.5million white people
and the Arabs that captured millions of East African Black Slaves
and the black West Africans that bought Arab Slave girls
All done around the same time.
Lets face it, as a species we've always been a bit shit. No race can claim the higher morals
But back to the point, the statues won't come down. 20 people waving a placard doesn't mean we're all out to get your precious statues. It's just a way for newspapers to make money. They know how stories like this make you mad and start clicking those l Atrocities still go on in Africa, Africans against Africans. Unless there is an economic value like oil (e,g Syria etc) there no one will care, whether you are black or white.
What went on the weekend has taken us back a step, pulling down the statue has educated us to what it stood for (but angered many) but defacing Churchills and trying to set fire to a flag on a war memorial angers me.
This country may have a past, but has done much since and is slowly improving in my 40 years. The British attitude to everything is that it wont be forced it has to be educated .
If we keep judging every statue and ripping it down we will have no history and nothing to remind us how far we have come.
Posts: 13,017
Threads: 1,260
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
(06-09-2020, 04:13 PM)ColliersWoodBaggie Wrote: (06-09-2020, 04:09 PM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote: Why are we using 21st century morals to judge historic characters? The Prophet Muhamned bought, sold, captured, and owned slaves. Should we knock down all mosques?
Because we are in the 21st Century.
There won't be many statues, monuments, mosques, churches, temples left then. Marx and Engels from the left both expressed racist views at times. Religious leaders certainly did.
Posts: 3,109
Threads: 184
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
06-09-2020, 04:20 PM
(This post was last modified: 06-09-2020, 04:50 PM by ColliersWoodBaggie.)
(06-09-2020, 04:05 PM)fuzzbox Wrote: (06-09-2020, 03:59 PM)ColliersWoodBaggie Wrote: That's gaslighting. This debate is about Slavery and the statues which commemorate those involved in the Slave Trade of the 18th Century, I'm noy sure when Morrocans enslaved "whites", either.
There were Africans enslaved by Egyptians and Arabs in earlier centuries and the Romans enslaved Jews, Africans and other Europeans, but that is irrelvant to the questions now being asked.
It's true. There's plenty of evidence. The Americans declared war on them for it and the European states paid tributes to stop them doing it.
Not sure I said Moroccans. Did that country exist then? I wasn't totally gaslighting, but you can't just ignore 'inconvenient truths'.
I did press submit before i finished, though!
I guess you meant Barbary Pirates.Yes, they were pretty ruthless and enslaved Europeans who they captured. However, it isn't comparable to the Slave Trade and the effect it has on people today. And the debate is not just about historical characters is it - it is about institutional racism in Britain today. Keeping statues of Colston, Rhodes, etc. up appear to cement that very racism in our society.
(06-09-2020, 04:18 PM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote: (06-09-2020, 04:13 PM)ColliersWoodBaggie Wrote: (06-09-2020, 04:09 PM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote: Why are we using 21st century morals to judge historic characters? The Prophet Muhamned bought, sold, captured, and owned slaves. Should we knock down all mosques?
Because we are in the 21st Century.
There won't be many statues, monuments, mosques, churches, temples left then. Marx and Engels from the left both expressed racist views at times. Religious leaders certainly did.
Marx's memorial (in a cemetery in Highgate) is often vandalised. However, no one is saying take all of the statues down. Or mosques, churches etc. But we need to be aware - or we cease to be civilised and educated.
It is up to historians to tell a balanced truth about the historical past. Whether they do or not is up to the reader. Read books on these characters, but do not stick celebratory statues/monuments to them. They stink of bias - Colston's statue was political of its time - Victorian Civic pride and a wealthy individual who spent money on the city which was gained at the hands of human suffering. However, history never stands still and the shedding of these monuments deserves a place in history alongside the monuments or the people they represent. That's democracy.
(06-09-2020, 04:16 PM)fuzzbox Wrote: (06-09-2020, 04:09 PM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote: Why are we using 21st century morals to judge historic characters? The Prophet Muhamned bought, sold, captured, and owned slaves. Should we knock down all mosques?
Do it! I'll be right behind you (about 100 miles!)
In all seriousness, I think all these are valid points. This has to be taken into account.
The simplistic nature of the debate is depressing. It's not just about white people being bad and black people being victims
Of course you don't celebrate a slaver, it's nothing to be proud of. But how did that trade evolve? Why black people? How was it operated? How was it justified ? Why did it keep on happening throughout history?
These are the lessons that need to be learnt. Black good white bad helps no-one and I'm concerned that is the way of this debate. Nobody likes to be labelled and it's just not true. The whole West African economy was also based on slavery, not just white Europe and the US
But yes, get rid of the Bristol Statue. I bet the council are grateful, anyway.
I agree with a lot of this.
(06-09-2020, 04:17 PM)coxy134 Wrote: (06-09-2020, 03:57 PM)fuzzbox Wrote: I always wonder why nobody mentions the African leaders who actually went out and captured the overwhelming majority of African slaved
and the North Africans that captured at least 1.5million white people
and the Arabs that captured millions of East African Black Slaves
and the black West Africans that bought Arab Slave girls
All done around the same time.
Lets face it, as a species we've always been a bit shit. No race can claim the higher morals
But back to the point, the statues won't come down. 20 people waving a placard doesn't mean we're all out to get your precious statues. It's just a way for newspapers to make money. They know how stories like this make you mad and start clicking those l Atrocities still go on in Africa, Africans against Africans. Unless there is an economic value like oil (e,g Syria etc) there no one will care, whether you are black or white.
What went on the weekend has taken us back a step, pulling down the statue has educated us to what it stood for (but angered many) but defacing Churchills and trying to set fire to a flag on a war memorial angers me.
This country may have a past, but has done much since and is slowly improving in my 40 years. The British attitude to everything is that it wont be forced it has to be educated .
If we keep judging every statue and ripping it down we will have no history and nothing to remind us how far we have come.
Things have improved but in the last 6/7 years, they have threatened to go backwards.
I know what people say about statues, but they are a (mainly) Victorian and Edwardian celebration of certain individuals and are not ', history', but are very political and also reflect society at the time it was erected. History is in documents, not marble, concrete, bronze, iron or copper. Interpretations are by historians and that is upto the reader to decide what is good, bad, indifferent, biased, balanced etc. Statues are not history in that sense, they just reflect an aspect of it. That is why Colston's should be in a Slavery Museum, preferably in Bristol.
As for Churchill, he was responsible for the deaths of thousands of Boers in concentration camps. Yes, white Afrikaans. Like it matters, but he is hardly a national hero to many. Tories, will be horrified, of course, but he was booted out two months after the War was over by the voters.
But let's not forget that actions themselves make history and that is what is happening now. History is fluid , not static.
Posts: 2,953
Threads: 67
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
12
Interesting and well informed debate. And no-one name calling! Blimey!
The Churchill thing is interesting.
He's hated by many for his actions in Ireland, S Wales , and India.
During WW1, I read, a British inspired famine (we were taking their grain for our use. Because we could) led to tens of thousands of Indians starving to death.
On being informed, Churchill, the responsible minister, merely replied "Is Gandhi dead yet?".
But he's a hero to many of us, and not only Tories.
It's certainly not a black and white issue....
Posts: 1,712
Threads: 20
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
18
06-09-2020, 05:13 PM
(This post was last modified: 06-09-2020, 06:06 PM by fuzzbox.)
(06-09-2020, 04:20 PM)ColliersWoodBaggie Wrote: (06-09-2020, 04:05 PM)fuzzbox Wrote: (06-09-2020, 03:59 PM)ColliersWoodBaggie Wrote: That's gaslighting. This debate is about Slavery and the statues which commemorate those involved in the Slave Trade of the 18th Century, I'm noy sure when Morrocans enslaved "whites", either.
There were Africans enslaved by Egyptians and Arabs in earlier centuries and the Romans enslaved Jews, Africans and other Europeans, but that is irrelvant to the questions now being asked.
It's true. There's plenty of evidence. The Americans declared war on them for it and the European states paid tributes to stop them doing it.
Not sure I said Moroccans. Did that country exist then? I wasn't totally gaslighting, but you can't just ignore 'inconvenient truths'.
I did press submit before i finished, though!
I guess you meant Barbary Pirates.Yes, they were pretty ruthless and enslaved Europeans who they captured. However, it isn't comparable to the Slave Trade and the effect it has on people today. And the debate is not just about historical characters is it - it is about institutional racism in Britain today. Keeping statues of Colston, Rhodes, etc. up appear to cement that very racism in our society.
Yes because they were North African, which is what I said. Of course calling them pirates rather than legitimate rulers is a European derogatory term (possibly racist?  ) They didn't call themselves that.
Why isn't it 'comparable'? It was the same human motivations and the same human behaviour. By missing this out you're missing out one of the fundamental issues of slavery. It's not a race issue, it goes deeper than that.
You're right it doesn't have the same affect on people today. I would say that is exactly the reason why slavery throughout the ages should be studied. All races have been subjugated (important all races and the supremacists realise this), all races were involved in it. Unfortunately, it's a base part of out nature that has been repeated throughout our history. In lesser forms, it still goes on today.
I can only speak from my experience, but when I was young I took comfort from that reasoning. I didn't want to feel a victim and I didn't want to feel all white people were persecutors. Sometimes that wasn't easy, but I think it was the right choice - for me, anyway.
As an example. Churchill was he really racist? It's easy to say yes. I suspect he wasn't at least not in the traditional sense. He just believed his social class were better than the rest. It didn't matter if you were an Indian, Irishman, a coal miner in Durham. He was a ruthless man who thought he was better than all of them. That was his upbringing. It works great in backs against the wall fight, not so great in run of the mill politics. Which, funnily enough, is what most people also thought of him at the time. People were grateful, but they didn't forget his shortcomings and they voted him out after the war.
Does it make him worse or better than 'just' a racist? I don't know.
Posts: 4,261
Threads: 263
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
(06-09-2020, 02:59 PM)cornishbaggie Wrote: https://www.plymouthherald.co.uk/news/pl...is-4204163
Many's the unsuspecting sailor who sneaked through the Straits of Magellan and got blown back through Drake's Passage.
Posts: 18,398
Threads: 256
Joined: Jan 2019
They should erect a statue of Enoch Powell in Wolverhampton South West.
Given that he changed sides in the complete immigration debate, then everyone could enjoy ripping it down, and tossing it in the cut.
|