Franny has to go now
#1
https://www.plymouthherald.co.uk/news/pl...is-4204163
Reply
#2
Fucking saft.
Reply
#3
This is why people vote for Boris and Trump.
Reply
#4
It’s not going to end there I’m afraid, there’s talk of Clive of India statue in Shropshire and even Nelsons column, let’s see em try and put that in a museum
Reply
#5
Oh dear, the right wing snowflakes are upset; there should be a debate about this, as statues publicly glorify an individual and all they have done/achieved etc. Colston's statue had to go; and efforts by Bristol Council to either get it in a slavery museum, removed or to get the plaque altered were hindered by Bristol's Merchant Venturers an unelected cabal of businessmen who control many of the city's instiutions. There was an attempt to whitewash (no pun intended) Colston's own history by ignoring the fact he gained wealth through the subjugation and murder of Africans, albeit he was indirectly involved with their throwing overboard).. Would you object to a Stalin or Hitler statue? Did you get upset when Saddam was pulled down? They also have a school named after him - not for the non elite, either. On the other point, let me tell you that the people who voted for Boris and Trump are in the minority.

As for Colston's statue, well, it should be in a museum, but considering 19,000 of his 'cargo' was jettisoned overboard into the Atlantic, it could be argued it is in the right place. IMO a slavery museum in the City where he made his fortune and was an MP should be a fitting place for it.

As for Drake, I've read a fair bit about him and he was a slaver (along with his cousin, John Hawkins), but the 16th Century is a bit different in historical terms to the 18th. By Colston's time and later, the Atlantic Slave TRade was propping up the British Economy and driving the Industrial Revolution (Lassez Faire economics). Drake was a pirate and slaver, and was trying to muscle in on the Spanish and Portuguese Slave Trade. But it took 100 years, before Britain was transporting slaves on an industrial level.

As for the other statues, are you sure it isn't some conspiracy cooked up by the right. They usually spark trouble at times like these.
Reply
#6
The Queen Victoria statue in what is currently called Victoria Square in Birmingham is to be melted down, apparently.
Reply
#7
I always wonder why nobody mentions the African leaders who actually went out and captured the overwhelming majority of African slaved
and the North Africans that captured at least 1.5million white people
and the Arabs that captured millions of East African Black Slaves
and the black West Africans that bought Arab Slave girls

All done around the same time.

Lets face it, as a species we've always been a bit shit. No race can claim the higher morals

But back to the point, the statues won't come down. 20 people waving a placard doesn't mean we're all out to get your precious statues. It's just a way for newspapers to make money. They know how stories like this make you mad and start clicking those links!
Reply
#8
(06-09-2020, 03:57 PM)fuzzbox Wrote: I always wonder why nobody mentions the African leaders who actually went out and captured the overwhelming majority of African slaved
and the North Africans that captured at least 1.5million white people
and the Arabs that captured millions of East African Black Slaves
and the black West Africans that bought Arab Slave girls

All done around the same time.

Lets face it, as a species we've always been a bit shit. No race can claim the higher morals

That's gaslighting. This debate is about Slavery and the statues which commemorate those involved in the Slave Trade of the 18th Century, I'm noy sure when Morrocans enslaved "whites", either.

There were Africans enslaved by Egyptians and Arabs in earlier centuries and the Romans enslaved Jews, Africans and other Europeans, but that is irrelvant to the questions now being asked.
Reply
#9
(06-09-2020, 03:59 PM)ColliersWoodBaggie Wrote: That's gaslighting. This debate is about Slavery and the statues which commemorate those involved in the Slave Trade of the 18th Century, I'm noy sure when Morrocans enslaved "whites", either.

There were Africans enslaved by Egyptians and Arabs in earlier centuries and the Romans enslaved Jews, Africans and other Europeans, but that is irrelvant to the questions now being asked.

It's true. There's plenty of evidence. The Americans declared war on them for it and the European states paid tributes to stop them doing it.

Not sure I said Moroccans. Did that country exist then? I wasn't totally gaslighting, but you can't just ignore 'inconvenient truths'.

I did press submit before i finished, though!
Reply
#10
Why are we using 21st century morals to judge historic characters? The Prophet Muhamned bought, sold, captured, and owned slaves. Should we knock down all mosques? 
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: