Rooney's Law
#31
(06-09-2020, 10:24 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(06-09-2020, 10:20 AM)OmarLittle Wrote:
(06-09-2020, 06:42 AM)steviedm Wrote:
(06-08-2020, 11:02 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: All over the back pages that former players such as Sol Campbell aren't getting Manager's jobs  due to institutional racism.

I think the likes of Sol Csmpbell aren't getting jobs because they aren't very good, and his track record suggests that. I dont think Pardew will have another major job because he has been proven to be poor. The fact he is white is a coincidence.

When Darren was sacked last year, it was because the wheels were falling off, not because he was black. WBA gave him the job in the first place, but the likes of TalkSportShite called it racism. I was proud when DM was appointed, and I wanted it to work, but sadly it didnt work out. I'm pleased it is going well for him, and I dont give two fucks for the white man Graham Jones who I blame for last year.

If you are good enough, you will succeed in the face of adversity. It's not easy for non-white people, but many have failed in management, like Paul Ince, John Barnes and Carlton Palmer because they weren't very good. Just as many, if not more white managers have been sacked for being crap.

All absolutely correct, but it misses the point entirely. It's not about whether managers who are black happen to be good or not or whether they are sacked because of the colour of their skin, it's about the structural inequalities that make it more difficult for black people to get jobs in football management in the first place. I don't have any figures to hand but I can guarantee you that there will be a complete mismatch between the percentage of BAME players and the percentage of BAME coaches/managers. This is because there is an inherent, largely unconscious, bias towards white managers/coaches and people who are not white find it much more difficult to obtain jobs even when there is no difference in terms of experience/previous achievement. If you look at the data, I am sure you will find that, relative to the number of jobs applied for, black people are far less successful than white people in obtaining roles in football management. This isn't necessarily about racism per se (in some cases it is), but it's difficult to deny there is an issue in the recruitment of BAME managers and coaches and those who do deny it demonstrate a lack of understanding of how privilege works.

+1. Absolutely nail on head. Hard to fathom why some find this so hard to get their head around.

If I go to a job interview, they recruit me having assessed how good I will be at the job. I have worked with many people of differing ethinticity. Some were great others should never have been recruited - across the complete colour spectrum.

Colour doesn't come into it; unless you think that being a person of colour will give you an unfair advantage. I don't see too many white waiters in my local Indian restaurant.

And presuming you were the most suitable candidate, you still would be hired with something akin to the Rooney Rule in place. 

It’s about widening the recruitment process to include more diversity within the candidate pool, not making a hiring decision based on race.

Your Indian restaurant comparison is interesting, I imagine you think that not a lot of white people work at your local place because they think that it wouldn’t be worth applying in the first place and therein lies the problem.
Reply
#32
(06-09-2020, 10:40 AM)billybassett Wrote:
(06-09-2020, 10:24 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(06-09-2020, 10:20 AM)OmarLittle Wrote:
(06-09-2020, 06:42 AM)steviedm Wrote:
(06-08-2020, 11:02 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: All over the back pages that former players such as Sol Campbell aren't getting Manager's jobs  due to institutional racism.

I think the likes of Sol Csmpbell aren't getting jobs because they aren't very good, and his track record suggests that. I dont think Pardew will have another major job because he has been proven to be poor. The fact he is white is a coincidence.

When Darren was sacked last year, it was because the wheels were falling off, not because he was black. WBA gave him the job in the first place, but the likes of TalkSportShite called it racism. I was proud when DM was appointed, and I wanted it to work, but sadly it didnt work out. I'm pleased it is going well for him, and I dont give two fucks for the white man Graham Jones who I blame for last year.

If you are good enough, you will succeed in the face of adversity. It's not easy for non-white people, but many have failed in management, like Paul Ince, John Barnes and Carlton Palmer because they weren't very good. Just as many, if not more white managers have been sacked for being crap.

All absolutely correct, but it misses the point entirely. It's not about whether managers who are black happen to be good or not or whether they are sacked because of the colour of their skin, it's about the structural inequalities that make it more difficult for black people to get jobs in football management in the first place. I don't have any figures to hand but I can guarantee you that there will be a complete mismatch between the percentage of BAME players and the percentage of BAME coaches/managers. This is because there is an inherent, largely unconscious, bias towards white managers/coaches and people who are not white find it much more difficult to obtain jobs even when there is no difference in terms of experience/previous achievement. If you look at the data, I am sure you will find that, relative to the number of jobs applied for, black people are far less successful than white people in obtaining roles in football management. This isn't necessarily about racism per se (in some cases it is), but it's difficult to deny there is an issue in the recruitment of BAME managers and coaches and those who do deny it demonstrate a lack of understanding of how privilege works.

+1. Absolutely nail on head. Hard to fathom why some find this so hard to get their head around.

If I go to a job interview, they recruit me having assessed how good I will be at the job. I have worked with many people of differing ethinticity. Some were great others should never have been recruited - across the complete colour spectrum.

Colour doesn't come into it; unless you think that being a person of colour will give you an unfair advantage. I don't see too many white waiters in my local Indian restaurant.

Think this is at best very naïve and the following sentence ridiculous.

If you really think all people do behind an interview desk is recruit based on how good you will be at a job then you don't understand recruitment at all. The institutional biases we all have, that are different dependent on your age, your experiences, your gender, your upbringing, your social circle etc are all in play. People who are relatively good people, and I'm classing myself as one, work hard to try and leave those biases at the door but ultimately it's impossible to leave the full accumulated weight of your institutionalisation at the door - we are all human.

I've recently recruited two people of Indian heritage, a Romanian, a Sardinian, a Covvo and a local lad to me. I interviewed many more across a wide spectrum of races and countries. I believe I recruited them all because they were best at the job  - and I think most are - but you can guarantee the sub conscious was also at work. For example - we all like people like ourselves...

Plenty of others who sit in seats similar to mine ensure their bias applies that's for sure so best for job maybe, but best for that person's view of life definitely.

I've been recruiting for 20 years, and many times on a panel basis. A competency based interview does not score anyone on colour.

(06-09-2020, 10:44 AM)OmarLittle Wrote:
(06-09-2020, 10:24 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(06-09-2020, 10:20 AM)OmarLittle Wrote:
(06-09-2020, 06:42 AM)steviedm Wrote:
(06-08-2020, 11:02 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: All over the back pages that former players such as Sol Campbell aren't getting Manager's jobs  due to institutional racism.

I think the likes of Sol Csmpbell aren't getting jobs because they aren't very good, and his track record suggests that. I dont think Pardew will have another major job because he has been proven to be poor. The fact he is white is a coincidence.

When Darren was sacked last year, it was because the wheels were falling off, not because he was black. WBA gave him the job in the first place, but the likes of TalkSportShite called it racism. I was proud when DM was appointed, and I wanted it to work, but sadly it didnt work out. I'm pleased it is going well for him, and I dont give two fucks for the white man Graham Jones who I blame for last year.

If you are good enough, you will succeed in the face of adversity. It's not easy for non-white people, but many have failed in management, like Paul Ince, John Barnes and Carlton Palmer because they weren't very good. Just as many, if not more white managers have been sacked for being crap.

All absolutely correct, but it misses the point entirely. It's not about whether managers who are black happen to be good or not or whether they are sacked because of the colour of their skin, it's about the structural inequalities that make it more difficult for black people to get jobs in football management in the first place. I don't have any figures to hand but I can guarantee you that there will be a complete mismatch between the percentage of BAME players and the percentage of BAME coaches/managers. This is because there is an inherent, largely unconscious, bias towards white managers/coaches and people who are not white find it much more difficult to obtain jobs even when there is no difference in terms of experience/previous achievement. If you look at the data, I am sure you will find that, relative to the number of jobs applied for, black people are far less successful than white people in obtaining roles in football management. This isn't necessarily about racism per se (in some cases it is), but it's difficult to deny there is an issue in the recruitment of BAME managers and coaches and those who do deny it demonstrate a lack of understanding of how privilege works.

+1. Absolutely nail on head. Hard to fathom why some find this so hard to get their head around.

If I go to a job interview, they recruit me having assessed how good I will be at the job. I have worked with many people of differing ethinticity. Some were great others should never have been recruited - across the complete colour spectrum.

Colour doesn't come into it; unless you think that being a person of colour will give you an unfair advantage. I don't see too many white waiters in my local Indian restaurant.

And presuming you were the most suitable candidate, you still would be hired with something akin to the Rooney Rule in place. 

It’s about widening the recruitment process to include more diversity within the candidate pool, not making a hiring decision based on race.

Your Indian restaurant comparison is interesting, I imagine you think that not a lot of white people work at your local place because they think that it wouldn’t be worth applying in the first place and therein lies the problem.

No, I don't think I've ever seen them advertise for staff. 

Their recruitment policy is biased to exclude white people, who can wait tables just as well as any other race.
Reply
#33
Thought Sterling made a strange comment yesterday when he said "only" a third of professional footballers were black. Given the black population of the UK is 3% then to have a 33% as pro footballers means football is a shining light when it comes to ending racism.
Reply
#34
(06-09-2020, 11:39 AM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote: Thought Sterling made a strange comment yesterday when he said "only" a third of professional footballers were black. Given the black population of the UK is 3% then to have a 33% as pro footballers means football is a shining light when it comes to ending racism.

Very true. Also, how many U.K. professional footballers are Indian or Pakistani? 1? None? They make up a much larger part of the U.K. population too.
Reply
#35
(06-09-2020, 10:32 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(06-09-2020, 10:29 AM)WWHO Wrote:
(06-09-2020, 10:24 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(06-09-2020, 10:20 AM)OmarLittle Wrote:
(06-09-2020, 06:42 AM)steviedm Wrote: All absolutely correct, but it misses the point entirely. It's not about whether managers who are black happen to be good or not or whether they are sacked because of the colour of their skin, it's about the structural inequalities that make it more difficult for black people to get jobs in football management in the first place. I don't have any figures to hand but I can guarantee you that there will be a complete mismatch between the percentage of BAME players and the percentage of BAME coaches/managers. This is because there is an inherent, largely unconscious, bias towards white managers/coaches and people who are not white find it much more difficult to obtain jobs even when there is no difference in terms of experience/previous achievement. If you look at the data, I am sure you will find that, relative to the number of jobs applied for, black people are far less successful than white people in obtaining roles in football management. This isn't necessarily about racism per se (in some cases it is), but it's difficult to deny there is an issue in the recruitment of BAME managers and coaches and those who do deny it demonstrate a lack of understanding of how privilege works.

+1. Absolutely nail on head. Hard to fathom why some find this so hard to get their head around.

If I go to a job interview, they recruit me having assessed how good I will be at the job. I have worked with many people of differing ethinticity. Some were great others should never have been recruited - across the complete colour spectrum.

Colour doesn't come into it; unless you think that being a person of colour will give you an unfair advantage. I don't see too many white waiters in my local Indian restaurant.

They should probably see a doctor about that.

My bad. Should have spell checked  Angry

Arrrrrrr, you should have  Wink
Reply
#36
(06-09-2020, 11:49 AM)Ampadu\s Left Boot Wrote:
(06-09-2020, 11:39 AM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote: Thought Sterling made a strange comment yesterday when he said "only" a third of professional footballers were black. Given the black population of the UK is 3% then to have a 33% as pro footballers means football is a shining light when it comes to ending racism.

Very true. Also, how many U.K. professional footballers are Indian or Pakistani? 1? None? They make up a much larger part of the U.K. population too.

They should be encouraged to play, but when you look at the ranking of their national teams, it would suggest there is a skills deficiency. If the next Messi was Indian, everyone would be rushing to sign him. Adil Nabi wasn't great, though.

Same applies to China and the USA.
Reply
#37
If I go to a job interview, they recruit me having assessed how good I will be at the job. I have worked with many people of differing ethinticity. Some were great others should never have been recruited - across the complete colour spectrum.

Colour doesn't come into it; unless you think that being a person of colour will give you an unfair advantage. I don't see too many white waiters in my local Indian restaurant.

Think this is at best very naïve and the following sentence ridiculous.

If you really think all people do behind an interview desk is recruit based on how good you will be at a job then you don't understand recruitment at all. The institutional biases we all have, that are different dependent on your age, your experiences, your gender, your upbringing, your social circle etc are all in play. People who are relatively good people, and I'm classing myself as one, work hard to try and leave those biases at the door but ultimately it's impossible to leave the full accumulated weight of your institutionalisation at the door - we are all human.
KKC

I've recently recruited two people of Indian heritage, a Romanian, a Sardinian, a Covvo and a local lad to me. I interviewed many more across a wide spectrum of races and countries. I believe I recruited them all because they were best at the job  - and I think most are - but you can guarantee the sub conscious was also at work. For example - we all like people like ourselves...

Plenty of others who sit in seats similar to mine ensure their bias applies that's for sure so best for job maybe, but best for that person's view of life definitely.


I've been recruiting for 20 years, and many times on a panel basis. A competency based interview does not score anyone on colour.


That's quite plainly not the point of this conversation. In a just and equal world a competency based interview will be just that. But it's not that world and unfortunately many racists, bigots, misognyists sit behind the same desks you have for 20 years and sifted out the unsuitables before interview or at interview just given them short shrift (but it makes the bame quota nrs work...)
Reply
#38
Colour doesn't come into it? Really?

It's not just in football, btw. There are the same sorts of disparities within the NHS. 1 in 5 staff members are BAME, yet in NHS England, only five chief executives, 37 medical directors and seven directors of nursing are BAME. Just as in football, those numbers don't stack up.

Last week, a report on the NHS Transfusion service in London found that BAME staff were discouraged from going for promotion and even when they did, people with fewer qualifications were getting jobs ahead of them:

https://www.standard.co.uk/news/london/l...63406.html

I would support a Rooney rule in football, btw.
Reply
#39
Interesting extra fact is that there hasn’t been a BAME referee in the top flight since Uriah Rennie - and he retired 12 years ago.
Reply
#40
(06-10-2020, 08:19 AM)Duffers Wrote: Interesting extra fact is that there hasn’t been a BAME referee in the top flight since Uriah Rennie - and he retired 12 years ago.

Hadn`t realised that. To be fair, I saw Rennie several times and thought he was lousy. He seemed to think the crowd had come to see him, a bit like Graham Poll, David Elleray etc. I remember years back, I used to watch Kiddy quite a lot. One game they had an Asian ref, Gurdam Singh, I think, excellent ref who should have gone far higher.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)