This bloody country...
(06-08-2020, 10:14 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(06-08-2020, 09:59 AM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(06-08-2020, 09:46 AM)Ministry Of Silly Signings Wrote:
(06-08-2020, 09:11 AM)Squid Wrote: People have asked for years for the Colston statue to come down and for Colston hall to be renamed. I recall reading in the NME about renaming the latter back in the 90s.

As for the comments about violence against protesters, I am baffled as to why you would want such a thing. We are the largest country on earth (by population) to have an unarmed police force (NI excepted) and that is something we should be very proud of.

How many people have asked for the statue to come down and the hall to be renamed though? I would imagine in a city of half a million, probably only a few hundred. Most probably walk past and don`t give it a second thought. Slavery was obviously abhorrent, yes, this country profited, but was also the first to abolish it, and, use our naval power to stop slavery.
As for us having the largest unarmed Police Force, yes, on the face of it. My wifes relative was a Police officer for 30 years, he reckons there are far more armed Police than we realise, not just the ones at airports. The way things are going now, guns, knives etc, this may have to change. On my local estate, a bloke and his wife run a small shop selling greetings cards, balloons etc. He told me that one evening , 5 or 6 teenagers were outside, being obnoxious and started throwing stones at his windows. The Police came, 2 0fficers, and told these 15 / 16 year olds to clear off, go home etc. The kids told the Police to clear off,or they would kick their heads in.

Actually, it's been an ongoing campaign for at least 20 years that I know of, so a fair few more than a few hundred.

But is that really the point? If it's wrong, it's wrong and shouldn't be celebrated

Yes the country did profit, but I would argue that not all of it's citizens did. Only a few did, there was little taxation, so much of the wealth was kept in the hands of a few. Most of us were living in squalour.

Like most countries, we have a glorious and inglorious history. After the US, 'we' made the most money out of slavery. That's obviously bad, but you're right, in a way, it should make us even more proud that we were one of the first to abolish slavery (not the first) and we were one of the first to abolish the transport of slaves (again not the first). We did police the seas, but like the US now, it wasn't for totally altruistic reasons.

So would you be happy if we replaced the names and statues of slavers with anti-slavery advocates? Even less politically charged, what about replacing them with other great men or women from this country who had nothing to do with racial issues, but who furthered the development of the human race? We've 'spawned' plenty of them, maybe even more than most. Surely that would be better if national pride was important? It would seem like a win-win to me.

Good argument, I agree.

Who gave the mob authority to remove the statue?

If they removed the statue as it reminded them of slavery then why not dismantle Bristol docks where the slaves were shipped to and from, I mean where do you draw the line, you can't change history it Reminds us of things that must never happen again, this issue is about law and order you can't just pick and choose what laws to obey as you may not like some you live by them all or not at all. Someone said on here that most of our freedoms were won by civil disobedience, think you'll find our freedoms were won by brave young men and women giving their lives in two world wars fighting against tyrany and evil. Protesting by rioting looting and beating and killing  shop owners and police officers is not the way to get the change and equality  your after it totally undermines your cause and looses any credibility it had.
Reply
(06-08-2020, 01:50 PM)TETLEY74 Wrote: If they removed the statue as it reminded them of slavery then why not dismantle Bristol docks where the slaves were shipped to and from, I mean where do you draw the line, you can't change history it Reminds us of things that must never happen again, this issue is about law and order you can't just pick and choose what laws to obey as you may not like some you live by them all or not at all. Someone said on here that most of our freedoms were won by civil disobedience, think you'll find our freedoms were won by brave young men and women giving their lives in two world wars fighting against tyrany and evil. Protesting by rioting looting and beating and killing  shop owners and police officers is not the way to get the change and equality  your after it totally undermines your cause and looses any credibility it had.

If there was a man who sold your ancestors into slavery would you want there to be a statue of them in your city? Do you think it's a good idea to have statues venerating slavers? Even if you can't see that, are you that attached to them you want to keep them up, even if it offends others? For what logical reason?

Remind me. What was the tyranny and evil we were fighting against in WWI? Most historians agree that it was an ultimately pointless war that could have and should have been avoided. Ironically, one of the things that ended it were mass mutinies (civil disobedience?) by soldiers who were treated like cannon fodder and animals by their 'masters'.

WWII enabled us to KEEP our freedoms. They were WON at home, they weren't just given up by an enlightened despot!! In what world has that EVER happened? - You would have to be reading the fairyland version of history to believe that was even possible!

Has there been rioting and killing of shop owners in this country?

"dismantle Bristol docks where the slaves were shipped to and from"
That's not how the slave trade worked. It was a triangle.

"I mean where do you draw the line, you can't change history"
Your post proves you can and people do.
Reply
Colston held the most senior position of Deputy Governor of the Royal African Company while it expanded it's slave trade operations from the West African coast to the colonies and is directly liable for the appalling conditions on the ships. The money he invested in Bristol was sourced from these abhorrent practices, he does not deserve a statue. I think the means that the statue was brought down was not appropriate but I do have sympathy with respect to the anger of some of the residents feel towards it still being there despite continued petitions and the decisions of the Society of Merchant Venturers to block even the mentioning of the Atlantic slave trade alongside his name. Regarding history, statues represent commemoration more than they do history. Museums and books preserve history. The fact that the statue was put up decades after the slave trade was banned makes it all the more bizarre as surely the late Victorians knew about the impact of the transatlantic slave trade, especially given that West Indian immigration was hardly rare at the time, especially in a major port city, albeit not as commonplace as it was in the 1960s.

Defacing Churchill's statue in London and trying to burn the flags on the Cenotaph is unbelievably stupid and indefensible though.
Reply
(06-08-2020, 04:12 PM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote: Colston held the most senior position of Deputy Governor of the Royal African Company while it expanded it's slave trade operations from the West African coast to the colonies and is directly liable for the appalling conditions on the ships. The money he invested in Bristol was sourced from these abhorrent practices, he does not deserve a statue. I think the means that the statue was brought down was not appropriate but I do have sympathy with respect to the anger of some of the residents feel towards it still being there despite continued petitions and the decisions of the Society of Merchant Venturers to block even the mentioning of the Atlantic slave trade alongside his name. Regarding history, statues represent commemoration more than they do history. Museums and books preserve history. The fact that the statue was put up decades after the slave trade was banned makes it all the more bizarre as surely the late Victorians knew about the impact of the transatlantic slave trade, especially given that West Indian immigration was hardly rare at the time, especially in a major port city, albeit not as commonplace as it was in the 1960s.

Defacing Churchill's statue in London and trying to burn the flags on the Cenotaph is unbelievably stupid and indefensible though.

I don't know for sure - I'm only making a guess based on similar 'contentious' statues in the USA, but maybe even though the argument against slavery was won on a national level, it's very possible that those in power on a local level in a city that had made their family money from slavery may not have been as 'enlightened' so quickly.

Churchill - marginally defensible, but definitely unbelievably stupid
Reply
(06-08-2020, 04:12 PM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote: Colston held the most senior position of Deputy Governor of the Royal African Company while it expanded it's slave trade operations from the West African coast to the colonies and is directly liable for the appalling conditions on the ships. The money he invested in Bristol was sourced from these abhorrent practices, he does not deserve a statue. I think the means that the statue was brought down was not appropriate but I do have sympathy with respect to the anger of some of the residents feel towards it still being there despite continued petitions and the decisions of the Society of Merchant Venturers to block even the mentioning of the Atlantic slave trade alongside his name. Regarding history, statues represent commemoration more than they do history. Museums and books preserve history. The fact that the statue was put up decades after the slave trade was banned makes it all the more bizarre as surely the late Victorians knew about the impact of the transatlantic slave trade, especially given that West Indian immigration was hardly rare at the time, especially in a major port city, albeit not as commonplace as it was in the 1960s.

Defacing Churchill's statue in London and trying to burn the flags on the Cenotaph is unbelievably stupid and indefensible though.

Really good point.  Statues are a form of commemoration (typically a celebration) of an individual or group, providing little or no contextualisation to historical events.  In this case, although the Victorians were relatively enlightened, this particular statue was erected in the final decade of the nineteenth century, when Britain was losing its Imperial strength and, indeed, its Empire.  This was the act of a country on the defence, desperately clinging onto to a manufactured form of superiority.  At local level, Bristol's role as a major port was also on the wane. Such a mindset contributed to the outbreak of WWI.

I'm an advocate of history from below; a move away from biographical or institutional histories of political leaders and parties, or monarchs.  Whilst I don't support vandalising Churchill's statue, I'm aware of his background and as a political elite what he stood for, and can therefore see why he is often a target of the left.

I can't in any way advocate attacking the cenotaph which, as is well documented, commemorates the lives of the proletariat, the Tommy, the ordinary working-class hero.  Their lives should be remembered and honoured more than any King, Queen, general, Prime Minister or industrialist/merchant/slave owner.
Reply
Statues also represent bad.

For example, and a great one, the shoes in front of the Parliament building on the bank of the Danube in Budapest.

It's a reminder of evil acts.
Reply
(06-08-2020, 11:39 AM)BeijingBaggie Wrote: That hose pipe ban eh?

Big Grin

Are they protesting in Beijing?
Reply
(06-08-2020, 05:07 PM)SausEggBaton Wrote:
(06-08-2020, 11:39 AM)BeijingBaggie Wrote: That hose pipe ban eh?

Big Grin

Are they protesting in Beijing?


I bet you never expected this to go 12 pages Saus?   Big Grin
Reply
(06-08-2020, 08:41 AM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: interesting how the protesters can be labelled a lawless mob who should be attacked with rubber bullets (that have caused several innocent people to lose eyes in recent days) based on the actions of a small percentage of them but when it comes to the police its always "a few bad apples" and "we can't judge all of them based on the actions of a few".

Anyway, as Duffers says pretty much every right and freedom we enjoy in this country was hard-won through civil disobedience. Some on here would still be tilling the fields for their masters if it was up to them, Christ.
tHIS.

(06-08-2020, 01:14 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(06-08-2020, 01:02 AM)SausEggBaton Wrote: ... announce a potential hose pipe ban, consequently its been pissing it down for days since and the foreseeable future. Purely self centred, but I love firing up the barbie.

Muppets in supermarkets that don't understand one way system arrows, the cnuts. Unfortunately it's our elder generation that are unable to comprehend this simple well signed instruction. 

Any others?

Youngsters wanting to protest, without maintaining social distancing - because they are unlikely to die from it. Fuck everyone else they come into contact with, or spread to, including their own family.

Others that believe Democracy is dead, and take the law into their own hands, chucking monuments into the water.

Cunts.

Protest all you like when it is safe to do so, and don't break any laws. How would we feel if the Wolves fans pulled down Bomber's statue?? The protesters  had absolutely no mandate to remove the Colston statue. (and I understand why they want it removed, but demolishing it is not the way).

I don't agree with what he stood for, but I hope all of the law breakers have a knock on the door in the morning. You can't create anarchy without expecting the consequences. Law and Order has to preside.
Correct e if I'm wrong, but Bomber was never responsible for the displacement of 84,000 Africans or the death of 19,000 of them.
Reply
As was said earlier, there has been a long campaign to remove the statue. It was even on Radio 4 a month or two ago. The local council could and should have solved this long ago. Remove the statue to a museum where it can be displayed next to a huge plaque explaining how Colston's philanthropy was a result of wealth acquired dubiously. How times were different back then, how we can learn from mistakes. In other words, doing what museums should do.
As an aside, many locals from that area were shanghaied into slavery in Barbados. In fact there are traces of the West Country accent that (until recent times, anyway) could be heard in Bajan speak. Poor sods sunburned to red and were known as the "Ecky Peckys". I know it's nowt to do with the thread but I'll never get another chance to use that fact.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)