This bloody country...
#41
So assembling a mass demonstration in the middle of a pandemic which has already killed 40,000 people is the right way to go. Throwing bicycles at police horses is the right way to go, chucking a statue in the river is the right way to go. There is a time and a place and this is not it.
Reply
#42
(06-08-2020, 09:22 AM)boingingjim Wrote:
(06-08-2020, 09:11 AM)Squid Wrote: People have asked for years for the Colston statue to come down and for Colston hall to be renamed. I recall reading in the NME about renaming the latter back in the 90s.

As for the comments about violence against protesters, I am baffled as to why you would want such a thing. We are the largest country on earth (by population) to have an unarmed police force (NI excepted) and that is something we should be very proud of.

But you are okay with the violence against the unarmed police?  A police officer is in a hospital bed with multiple injuries as a direct result of a protesters behaviour. 

Also having large gatherings at this point of the virus fightback is in itself insane.

I would imagine he's saying that as the protest is closely monitored by the police, you pinpoint the criminals and you round them up later. Why would you put the police in a dangerous position facing thousands of protesters when only a handful are causing serious problems? They do exactly the same thing every weekend in mass brawls. That's how they would rather deal with them. They're the experts.

Remember last years protests?  Can't even remember what they were protesting about any more. G7, environment? Remember that guy who dropped a brick from the top of a building? They got him later. (Thinking about it, I remember more police got injured in both of those protests.)

As for the virus, I don't think we should give the message that any government can do what they want without repercussions because of it. We also shouldn't be surprised that young people who are at negligible risk to themselves should act 'selfishly'. It's always been that way. To be honest, I think the youth have been remarkably law abiding throughout this virus. I know we would have had underground parties in every disused warehouse going.

If you're really that concerned about spreading the virus have a look at where most outbreaks come from. But if you did that, you would have to make serious changes in your lifestyle. Giving up meat for one....
Reply
#43
(06-08-2020, 09:10 AM)fuzzbox Wrote: Statues getting defaced is pretty standard too and usually with a lot less justification than this one. (I would bet big money the council won't pay or even allow it to be put back up. I'll bet even bigger money certain 'political' groups launch a  fund to re-instate the statue - with no intention of actually doing it, just for the publicity)
The mayor of Bristol (a man of mixed race) said this morning on breakfast TV that the statue would stay in the dock until the council had sufficient funds to rescue it and it would then probably end up in a museum. He condemned the people who had pulled it down and said its removal should have been done through democratic channels. But others have said attempts to have it removed have been going on for years, so maybe this action, though I also disagree with it, will make the democratic process focus on the issue a bit more intently now.
Reply
#44
(06-08-2020, 09:11 AM)Squid Wrote: People have asked for years for the Colston statue to come down and for Colston hall to be renamed. I recall reading in the NME about renaming the latter back in the 90s.

As for the comments about violence against protesters, I am baffled as to why you would want such a thing. We are the largest country on earth (by population) to have an unarmed police force (NI excepted) and that is something we should be very proud of.

How many people have asked for the statue to come down and the hall to be renamed though? I would imagine in a city of half a million, probably only a few hundred. Most probably walk past and don`t give it a second thought. Slavery was obviously abhorrent, yes, this country profited, but was also the first to abolish it, and, use our naval power to stop slavery.
As for us having the largest unarmed Police Force, yes, on the face of it. My wifes relative was a Police officer for 30 years, he reckons there are far more armed Police than we realise, not just the ones at airports. The way things are going now, guns, knives etc, this may have to change. On my local estate, a bloke and his wife run a small shop selling greetings cards, balloons etc. He told me that one evening , 5 or 6 teenagers were outside, being obnoxious and started throwing stones at his windows. The Police came, 2 0fficers, and told these 15 / 16 year olds to clear off, go home etc. The kids told the Police to clear off,or they would kick their heads in.
Reply
#45
(06-08-2020, 09:46 AM)Ministry Of Silly Signings Wrote:
(06-08-2020, 09:11 AM)Squid Wrote: People have asked for years for the Colston statue to come down and for Colston hall to be renamed. I recall reading in the NME about renaming the latter back in the 90s.

As for the comments about violence against protesters, I am baffled as to why you would want such a thing. We are the largest country on earth (by population) to have an unarmed police force (NI excepted) and that is something we should be very proud of.

How many people have asked for the statue to come down and the hall to be renamed though? I would imagine in a city of half a million, probably only a few hundred. Most probably walk past and don`t give it a second thought. Slavery was obviously abhorrent, yes, this country profited, but was also the first to abolish it, and, use our naval power to stop slavery.
As for us having the largest unarmed Police Force, yes, on the face of it. My wifes relative was a Police officer for 30 years, he reckons there are far more armed Police than we realise, not just the ones at airports. The way things are going now, guns, knives etc, this may have to change. On my local estate, a bloke and his wife run a small shop selling greetings cards, balloons etc. He told me that one evening , 5 or 6 teenagers were outside, being obnoxious and started throwing stones at his windows. The Police came, 2 0fficers, and told these 15 / 16 year olds to clear off, go home etc. The kids told the Police to clear off,or they would kick their heads in.

And did they?
Reply
#46
(06-08-2020, 08:23 AM)PeakBaggie Wrote:
(06-08-2020, 08:10 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: Please explain to me how the actions of the people in Bristol that removed the statue was lawful

I cant, but then i cant explain how the statue of a slavetrader is allowed to be in place
In a City with a large community of black people in 2020 or any other City to be honest.

It should have been taken down and moved years ago

It will have received planning permission to be erected, and approved by the council.

Who approved it's removal??

This isn't about the statue, I agree it shouldn't be there. It's about a lawless mob taking matters into their own hands. This isn't democracy.
Reply
#47
(06-08-2020, 09:53 AM)Brentbaggie Wrote:
(06-08-2020, 09:46 AM)Ministry Of Silly Signings Wrote:
(06-08-2020, 09:11 AM)Squid Wrote: People have asked for years for the Colston statue to come down and for Colston hall to be renamed. I recall reading in the NME about renaming the latter back in the 90s.

As for the comments about violence against protesters, I am baffled as to why you would want such a thing. We are the largest country on earth (by population) to have an unarmed police force (NI excepted) and that is something we should be very proud of.

How many people have asked for the statue to come down and the hall to be renamed though? I would imagine in a city of half a million, probably only a few hundred. Most probably walk past and don`t give it a second thought. Slavery was obviously abhorrent, yes, this country profited, but was also the first to abolish it, and, use our naval power to stop slavery.
As for us having the largest unarmed Police Force, yes, on the face of it. My wifes relative was a Police officer for 30 years, he reckons there are far more armed Police than we realise, not just the ones at airports. The way things are going now, guns, knives etc, this may have to change. On my local estate, a bloke and his wife run a small shop selling greetings cards, balloons etc. He told me that one evening , 5 or 6 teenagers were outside, being obnoxious and started throwing stones at his windows. The Police came, 2 0fficers, and told these 15 / 16 year olds to clear off, go home etc. The kids told the Police to clear off,or they would kick their heads in.

And did they?
Yes, a young Police man and a WPC got back in the car and left, apparently.
Reply
#48
(06-08-2020, 09:46 AM)Ministry Of Silly Signings Wrote:
(06-08-2020, 09:11 AM)Squid Wrote: People have asked for years for the Colston statue to come down and for Colston hall to be renamed. I recall reading in the NME about renaming the latter back in the 90s.

As for the comments about violence against protesters, I am baffled as to why you would want such a thing. We are the largest country on earth (by population) to have an unarmed police force (NI excepted) and that is something we should be very proud of.

How many people have asked for the statue to come down and the hall to be renamed though? I would imagine in a city of half a million, probably only a few hundred. Most probably walk past and don`t give it a second thought. Slavery was obviously abhorrent, yes, this country profited, but was also the first to abolish it, and, use our naval power to stop slavery.
As for us having the largest unarmed Police Force, yes, on the face of it. My wifes relative was a Police officer for 30 years, he reckons there are far more armed Police than we realise, not just the ones at airports. The way things are going now, guns, knives etc, this may have to change. On my local estate, a bloke and his wife run a small shop selling greetings cards, balloons etc. He told me that one evening , 5 or 6 teenagers were outside, being obnoxious and started throwing stones at his windows. The Police came, 2 0fficers, and told these 15 / 16 year olds to clear off, go home etc. The kids told the Police to clear off,or they would kick their heads in.

Actually, it's been an ongoing campaign for at least 20 years that I know of, so a fair few more than a few hundred.

But is that really the point? If it's wrong, it's wrong and shouldn't be celebrated

Yes the country did profit, but I would argue that not all of it's citizens did. Only a few did, there was little taxation, so much of the wealth was kept in the hands of a few. Most of us were living in squalour.

Like most countries, we have a glorious and inglorious history. After the US, 'we' made the most money out of slavery. That's obviously bad, but you're right, in a way, it should make us even more proud that we were one of the first to abolish slavery (not the first) and we were one of the first to abolish the transport of slaves (again not the first). We did police the seas, but like the US now, it wasn't for totally altruistic reasons.

So would you be happy if we replaced the names and statues of slavers with anti-slavery advocates? Even less politically charged, what about replacing them with other great men or women from this country who had nothing to do with racial issues, but who furthered the development of the human race? We've 'spawned' plenty of them, maybe even more than most. Surely that would be better if national pride was important? It would seem like a win-win to me.
Reply
#49
(06-08-2020, 09:59 AM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(06-08-2020, 09:46 AM)Ministry Of Silly Signings Wrote:
(06-08-2020, 09:11 AM)Squid Wrote: People have asked for years for the Colston statue to come down and for Colston hall to be renamed. I recall reading in the NME about renaming the latter back in the 90s.

As for the comments about violence against protesters, I am baffled as to why you would want such a thing. We are the largest country on earth (by population) to have an unarmed police force (NI excepted) and that is something we should be very proud of.

How many people have asked for the statue to come down and the hall to be renamed though? I would imagine in a city of half a million, probably only a few hundred. Most probably walk past and don`t give it a second thought. Slavery was obviously abhorrent, yes, this country profited, but was also the first to abolish it, and, use our naval power to stop slavery.
As for us having the largest unarmed Police Force, yes, on the face of it. My wifes relative was a Police officer for 30 years, he reckons there are far more armed Police than we realise, not just the ones at airports. The way things are going now, guns, knives etc, this may have to change. On my local estate, a bloke and his wife run a small shop selling greetings cards, balloons etc. He told me that one evening , 5 or 6 teenagers were outside, being obnoxious and started throwing stones at his windows. The Police came, 2 0fficers, and told these 15 / 16 year olds to clear off, go home etc. The kids told the Police to clear off,or they would kick their heads in.

Actually, it's been an ongoing campaign for at least 20 years that I know of, so a fair few more than a few hundred.

But is that really the point? If it's wrong, it's wrong and shouldn't be celebrated

Yes the country did profit, but I would argue that not all of it's citizens did. Only a few did, there was little taxation, so much of the wealth was kept in the hands of a few. Most of us were living in squalour.

Like most countries, we have a glorious and inglorious history. After the US, 'we' made the most money out of slavery. That's obviously bad, but you're right, in a way, it should make us even more proud that we were one of the first to abolish slavery (not the first) and we were one of the first to abolish the transport of slaves (again not the first). We did police the seas, but like the US now, it wasn't for totally altruistic reasons.

So would you be happy if we replaced the names and statues of slavers with anti-slavery advocates? Even less politically charged, what about replacing them with other great men or women from this country who had nothing to do with racial issues, but who furthered the development of the human race? We've 'spawned' plenty of them, maybe even more than most. Surely that would be better if national pride was important? It would seem like a win-win to me.

Good argument, I agree.

Who gave the mob authority to remove the statue?
Reply
#50
(06-08-2020, 10:14 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(06-08-2020, 09:59 AM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(06-08-2020, 09:46 AM)Ministry Of Silly Signings Wrote:
(06-08-2020, 09:11 AM)Squid Wrote: People have asked for years for the Colston statue to come down and for Colston hall to be renamed. I recall reading in the NME about renaming the latter back in the 90s.

As for the comments about violence against protesters, I am baffled as to why you would want such a thing. We are the largest country on earth (by population) to have an unarmed police force (NI excepted) and that is something we should be very proud of.

How many people have asked for the statue to come down and the hall to be renamed though? I would imagine in a city of half a million, probably only a few hundred. Most probably walk past and don`t give it a second thought. Slavery was obviously abhorrent, yes, this country profited, but was also the first to abolish it, and, use our naval power to stop slavery.
As for us having the largest unarmed Police Force, yes, on the face of it. My wifes relative was a Police officer for 30 years, he reckons there are far more armed Police than we realise, not just the ones at airports. The way things are going now, guns, knives etc, this may have to change. On my local estate, a bloke and his wife run a small shop selling greetings cards, balloons etc. He told me that one evening , 5 or 6 teenagers were outside, being obnoxious and started throwing stones at his windows. The Police came, 2 0fficers, and told these 15 / 16 year olds to clear off, go home etc. The kids told the Police to clear off,or they would kick their heads in.

Actually, it's been an ongoing campaign for at least 20 years that I know of, so a fair few more than a few hundred.

But is that really the point? If it's wrong, it's wrong and shouldn't be celebrated

Yes the country did profit, but I would argue that not all of it's citizens did. Only a few did, there was little taxation, so much of the wealth was kept in the hands of a few. Most of us were living in squalour.

Like most countries, we have a glorious and inglorious history. After the US, 'we' made the most money out of slavery. That's obviously bad, but you're right, in a way, it should make us even more proud that we were one of the first to abolish slavery (not the first) and we were one of the first to abolish the transport of slaves (again not the first). We did police the seas, but like the US now, it wasn't for totally altruistic reasons.

So would you be happy if we replaced the names and statues of slavers with anti-slavery advocates? Even less politically charged, what about replacing them with other great men or women from this country who had nothing to do with racial issues, but who furthered the development of the human race? We've 'spawned' plenty of them, maybe even more than most. Surely that would be better if national pride was important? It would seem like a win-win to me.

Good argument, I agree.

Who gave the mob authority to remove the statue?

The council did when they ignored all the campaigns to remove it.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: